Do people respect you more if you're not overweight?
WAM777
Posts: 15 Member
I've lost 45 pounds since January 6th and that 45 pounds is fairly noticeable. What I have noticed is that people in general (mostly strangers) seem to give me more respect. At the very least, people are more friendly towards me. Is this because people have a natural repulsion to overweight people? Or am I projecting more confidence and perceiving something that's not really there?
What have your experience been? Anyone else have similar experiences?
What have your experience been? Anyone else have similar experiences?
0
Replies
-
I noticed that also. Perfect strangers are now starting up conversations with me, where it rarely happened before. I think it's because people find overweight people repulsive.0
-
For me, the short answer is yes.0
-
I have been overweight most of my life and I have a different story. I have always had men open doors to me and strangers talk to me all the time. I think it has to do with confidence, a smile and making eye contact.
I have noticed that overweight women do not seem to do these things. I think it is more likely a confidence issue.0 -
A little from column A, a little from column B.0
-
I'd have to say they do...and the worst thing is, it was friends that i hadn't seen in years when my weight had piled on. they constantly mocked me and made jokes that really hurt. a year later at the next reunion, I was 60 lbs lighter and things were TOTALLY different.
sad,pathetic,i know..but thats just the way people are. even now, they still make fun of me, but it pretty much stops when i get more attention than they do when were out and about..0 -
People tend to treat me like crap either way.0
-
I go to school in Southern California (at a VERY shallow school) and when I lost the weight, people were NICER to me when I lost the weight. It disgusted me, I didn't change just my body. While I am healthier, my personality is the same! It made me angry. I see people around here treat the few overweight people like they have the plague. It makes me want to cry because I was once overweight.0
-
When I was in High school, I ran track, played sports and swam. I was very muscular and weighed in all 4 years at about 98 to 115 lbs. I was told by a long time family friend, that I was fat. This broke my heart. So I used to go on starvation diets from age 17 to age 23. That's when I had my baby, (at 23) and didn't care anymore. topped out at 135 for years.
So then I topped out at 260 after the birth and lost it all and stayed at about 135 and the miserable 14 married years, then, I bounded to 289.
So I started losing and got from 289 to 190 and felt so good, but it was never enough. I got passed up, passed by and held back. And yet, a few told me, well, you have a few more to lose. Really?
So now I was at 245 and went to 235 and now 231. My initial weight loss was 65 lbs from 2010 to 2011. So now I have started over.
So yes, there is a big diff in the way we are treated for being fat.
I am going through so many changes. Weight loss, finally, breast reduction and a full hysterectomy all in 3 years. and no matter how much weight a person looses, some will forever be butt heads. It's a sad harsh reality. but look at the model world. No one can think for them selves, only read this crap and believe fat is ugly.
I say, just be happy and do what you need to do to be healthy and forget the crap around you.0 -
It took my 5 years or so to gain 50 lbs and ive lost most of it in a year or so.... I know that I AM more confident now that I again
1 ..Dont care what people think about me or how i look because I am ok with what i Look like NOW and
2 ..That has given me the confidence to MAKE eye contact with people where as before i wouldnt.
But i still think people get friendlier as I get thinner:))0 -
I've lost 45 pounds since January 6th and that 45 pounds is fairly noticeable. What I have noticed is that people in general (mostly strangers) seem to give me more respect. At the very least, people are more friendly towards me. Is this because people have a natural repulsion to overweight people? Or am I projecting more confidence and perceiving something that's not really there?
What have your experience been? Anyone else have similar experiences?
I'd say it's some of both most likely.0 -
I think people do give you more respect when you are not overweight. However, I don't think they are repulsed by someone who is overweight. I wonder if it's an issue of perception. If you are overweight, people might think you don't have respect for yourself, so therefore they tend not to respect you.
I've been overweight at various times in my life (high school as well as middle age) and have noticed that people tend to be more helpful and receptive to me when I've been at my goal weight. Not fair at all but it's just what I've experienced.0 -
YES
But what makes me laugh is the way I get more respect now for things I know nothing about than I did 100lb ago in things I'm knowledgeable0 -
I don't know which it is, but I am finding more men who are strangers are saying hello and greeting me as if we've met or know each other.0
-
First of all congrats on your awesome weight loss!:happy: :happy: After losing 45 pounds in such a short time must leave you feeling better and feeling happier. Therefore, I would think that you have a "happy glow" about you. When people smile and are polite, It's contagious. Try this: Put on a genuine happy face and smile at people ~ There will be a lot of return smiles!0
-
I think it is a bit of both... people treat me different now than they did 50lbs ago, but they still do not treat me like they do my more normal size counterparts. (I lost a lot of weight before finding this site) I have always been the "biggest" of my friends.. I was never the size 0 or size 4.. I was the size 7 or 9 in school... I was consistently made fun of and passed over. Now I also have no confidence either... so people do play on that as well. I am a smart and wonderful person.. I also happen to be overweight. I think it is a bit of both, but with society always saying the thinner you are the more beautiful you are, I think society has made everyone a bit more shallow and therefore there is less respect and tolerance for people who are overweight. Confidence may have a little bearing, but I really believe that people are negative and mean based mostly on look. Just my two cents however..0
-
Go read the fat fitness instructor thread to get your answer.0
-
Yes... I've noticed it too. I'm 5'4" and I've lived being 206 pounds and 120 pounds, and there is a difference.
And theres a difference when job hunting & whether you are hired or not too. Its sad but true. You would think this world would be different by now. Especially because so many people can relate to weight issues these days.0 -
I think a lot of it is attitude/self confidence. I'm fat, that hasn't changed anytime recently, but if I'm in a good mood (happy, self confident), people will randomly talk to me when I'm out & about. If I'm not in a good mood (upset, pissy), people seem to just ignore me. I really believe it's how you project yourself0
-
I think it's a little of both but I have to admit I do not feel more confident but I work in a tipping industry & since I have lost 25+lbs & have clothes that fit me & show my body off I have started making more money! I think people have an unawareness of wanting to please someone who is attractive. You are on your best behavior on a 1st date because you want to attract them & our society places great emphases on being fit & we reward people for doing so-regardless if we realize it or not.0
-
I cannot answer your question because I am still overweight. Check back with me when I am no longer obese. My experience is that people have disrespected me. Was it because of my weight? I do not know. All I know is that I did not care. That has now changed. I now care whether people disrespect me. However, I cannot expect people to respect me if I do not respect myself.0
-
I've noticed this as well. People will hold open doors and randomly strike up conversations with me.0
-
I think it has to do with what type of attitude and energy you're projecting. I'm very overweight (obese) and people talk to me and guys are nice to me.0
-
No. I've always felt respected. People smile and wave at me, guys hit on me, open doors for me, random people strike up convos with me on the metro. I think I just appear friendly and I'm pretty outgoing and confident. When I was a skinny kid/teen I got a lot less respect and that was the reason why I packed on the weight. I fear that when I lose the weight I'll get less respect from the ladies and possibly too much attention from males. I know that when some women sense "competition" or intimidation they get catty and nasty. As an attractive big girl, I don't deal with it as much because they don't see me as competition. Though, I must say, when the weight comes off I know I'm gonna be a bombshell so I guess I'll just have to deal with it lol.0
-
I lost 60 pounds in 5 months a few years ago (85 in all). It's amazing how differently I am treated. Disgustingly amazing.
Edit: And I mean by the people who knew me before I gained the weight in the first place. It's like they went from treating me one way, to ignoring me, and back to being interested. Needless to say, most of those people aren't in my life anymore.0 -
I think it's a resounding "Yes"-- which is unfortunate. Maybe it's just perception, though! (Let's hope...)0
-
I mean this in the least mean way possible. People are overweight because of the choices they make and what they put into their bodies. Some call it hereditary but, it still comes down to wanting a change and you have to make it if you don't want to be obese. But if you are content with that then fine. So I say its all about how you carry yourself. If you feel confident with yourself then people can see that. If you feel disgusted by yourself people see that as well!0
-
There are actually studies on this. Psychology refers to it as the 'halo effect'. It's been proven that good looking people (and overweight is something that society today classes as unattractive) are generally assumed to be nicer, more likeable, and better people upon first sight. It is only a perception and that can be changed when someone gets to know you properly, but unfortunately when it comes to initial sight, appearance and character are intertwined in people's minds.0
-
Generally, yes. Two years ago I applied for several jobs, all requiring me to do extensive physical work both in the store and in the back and I was denied each one despite having the qualifications. I thought perhaps it was my lack of previous work until I went in one place I had applied to as a customer and saw the assistant manager training a very thin, very stupid (I'm not joking, this one was a chicken short of a 12 pack of eggs) guy. I thought it was weird he hired a guy for what was really more suited for women, but I learned later the guy was gay and had hired eye candy that, months later, were all fired because they couldn't do their jobs. Another job told me I obviously wouldn't have been able to lift inventory boxes, which I could but I guess they were trying to avoid a lawsuit.
I'm also an actor, though not professional. When I was in high school I did a lot of work with the children's theater since they allowed you to audition until you turned 18. The community theater, linked with the children's theater, has never given me callbacks even with someone I've worked with before being a judge. And really that's theater, they don't have much use for fat people unless you're an older guy or you're putting on the musical Hairspray.
And stupidly enough I'm not respected as an artist (which is sedentary) because of my weight. Just yesterday I was talking to a gentleman and when I mentioned what I did, the first thing he did was look me up and down, focusing on my stomach. It wasn't until I pulled up my work on my phone that he believed me. Several others have the same reaction, especially when I used to attend figure drawing classes. The teacher was a thin hippie type and all her students were thin "artsy-fartsy" girls who thought as long as they were cute and drank wine their work was good. And that is the artist stereotype here. I've learned to carry my portfolio in the car because it's not a matter of people wanting to see, they want to know if I'm lying.
My mother, back when she still worked, had a hard time finding work after Hurricane Katrina because she too is overweight and companies see it as an increase in medical bill expenses or having to modify something so they'll fit through the door or whatever.0 -
I agree with you Sunflower. I think it has to do with confidence. I've also been overweight my whole life, but usually have a friendly smile and make eye contact, so the same happens for me (open doors, friendly gestures), unless of course the person is an oaf. :-)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions