Is Oatmeal bad for the weight?
graelwyn
Posts: 1,340 Member
Some seem to swear by it for breakfast and keeping their weight down, others seem to think it adds to weight gain, so which is correct?
0
Replies
-
No its not, especially if you get the whole grain oats.0
-
nothing is bad for weight gain, assuming it fits in your daily limits. for example, last night, I had room for a cadburry creme egg. it fit. so it wasn't bad for weight loss. also, it was delicious.0
-
I like steel-cut oats, but Quaker plain rolled oats will do just as well. Water + stove/microwave + flavoring (I don't add sweeteners, but I do like to add almond milk, cinnamon, and chopped fruit or nuts) = awesome breakfast. I'm full until three o'clock in the afternoon, and I don't believe it's ever made me gain weight.0
-
Some seem to swear by it for breakfast and keeping their weight down, others seem to think it adds to weight gain, so which is correct?
Excess calories lead to weight gain not individual foods.
It's perfectly fine on a diet, as is basically any other food0 -
Hmm I ate a whole box of oatmeal monday, 3-4 packets yesterday, and 5 packets today, I LOVE oatmeal.
<---- still lean.
Its healthy, yummy, and filling. Win!0 -
Hmm I ate a whole box of oatmeal monday, 3-4 packets yesterday, and 5 packets today, I LOVE oatmeal.
<---- still lean.
Its healthy, yummy, and filling. Win!
Nice photoshop, everyone knows carbs and only carbs make you fat ;p0 -
I eat oatmeal EVERYDAY. I love oatmeal. I am not gaining weight. If its fits in your calories I have no idea why someone would be gaining from it...0
-
I love your thinking! I had a bag of Chiccarrones (deep fried pork skins) today and stil stayed under my calories and fats for the day!0
-
The food is really irrelevant I used to be huge on oatmeal for breakfast but specific foods don't cause you to gain weight just eating them at an excess to the point where you're exceeding your caloric limit causes you to gain weight. Some claim the whole grains keep you fuller longer but I'm not sure I buy into all that.0
-
Oats are SO SO SO good for you. I eat them every day, sometimes more than once. They fill you up, give you loads of fibre and have vitamins and minerals. Low in calories as well. I do measure my oats though as it’s easy to eat double the amount you think you are consuming in calories.0
-
Thanks for the input guys, I might try having them for breakfast somedays, as long as they wont slow down my cycling. Heard that having anything too heavy before exercise can be detrimental.0
-
NO!
Too many calories are. That is all.
I eat porridge every single day and love it!!0 -
Only if you over eat it.
A.C.E. Certified Personal & Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
I wonder if the people that say it bad are meaning the packets with the added sugar and stuff. As others have said, under calories and you are good.
I'm actually going to go back to oatmeal with a scoop of whey protein in it. I think it kept me full longer, and therefore decreased my eating later on.0 -
Thanks for the input guys, I might try having them for breakfast somedays, as long as they wont slow down my cycling. Heard that having anything too heavy before exercise can be detrimental.
Porridge is a well know fuel for cyclists0 -
I eat a cut almost every day in the morning, along with a piece of fruit and egg whites. Its a good whole grain complex carb with a low glycemic index and good fiber.0
-
No, it's not. That being said, neither is double chocolate fudge ice cream if it fits into your calories. Oatmeal is good for you.0
-
WHAT you eat is irrelevant. HOW MUCH you eat as well as your macros is all that matters. calories in, calories out.
If two Big Mac's a day fits in your calorie and macro goals then you can eat it and still reach your goal weight. you may not feel great or be healthy but you wont gain weight as long as your calorie goal is set for losing weight or staying at maintenance. this is why the point system for Weight Watchers works. no matter what you eat as long as you stay within your points you will lose weight. you really can eat a Snickers bar and lose weight. The down side of that is that Snickers bar has so many calories that you will have to sacrifice at other meals to stay within your calorie and macro goal. For me I would much rather eat a filling meal (like oatmeal) with fewer calories so I can eat more all day. A candy bar isnt worth starving all day for.
losing weight is much more simple than people make it out to be. if you eat less than you are burning (without going way too low) then you will lose weight. just remember it's how much not what.
By the way oatmeal has carbs so eating that before your workout is a great idea. Carbs provide the energy you need to work out hard.0 -
I've never heard it's bad. Actually, quite the opposite - I've heard it's a super food.
I might be biased though because it was my go to breakfast throughout my journey. I love the stuff.0 -
I add oatmeal to a lot of my recipes. By itself, I will add a scoop of whey protein. If I need extra calories, I will add a 1/2 cup to a protein smoothie. Instead of bread crumbs, I will put oatmeal in my burgers.
As some other folks have mentioned already, overeating oatmeal causing you to exceed your calories would only make it bad.0 -
I add it to my protein shake. A great breakfast!0
-
nothing is bad for weight gain, assuming it fits in your daily limits. for example, last night, I had room for a cadburry creme egg. it fit. so it wasn't bad for weight loss. also, it was delicious.
I looooooove cremé eggs. Just sayin' :-D0 -
i dont eat oats for two reasons, one is because i have celiac and theres a huge potential fo cross contamination and its ridiculously expensive for gluten free oats. and the other reason is because i dont eat any grain products as they dont react well with my body, as in, if i eat them i get fat. lol0
-
I've never heard it's bad. Actually, quite the opposite - I've heard it's a super food.
I might be biased though because it was my go to breakfast throughout my journey. I love the stuff.
Corn and peanuts are the only true super foods. I mean, what else can you eat twice??0 -
I've never heard it's bad. Actually, quite the opposite - I've heard it's a super food.
I might be biased though because it was my go to breakfast throughout my journey. I love the stuff.
Corn and peanuts are the only true super foods. I mean, what else can you eat twice??
:noway: ewww0 -
Some seem to swear by it for breakfast and keeping their weight down, others seem to think it adds to weight gain, so which is correct?
I have eaten oatmeal every single day for the past 3 years or so. In my opinion, it is truly one of thebest breakfast foods besides eggs I buy weight control and mix in flaxseed. Plus it is something I could eat 20 times a day ha!0 -
I buy the Quaker High Fiber Instant Oatmeal - Cinnamon Swirl... Not sure it's the BEST that I can do, but makes breakfast quick and easy and definitely better than some of the other alternatives that I could be having. 1 packet is more than adequate to fill me up!
160 calories, 2 grams fat (.5 saturated), no cholesterol, 220 sodium, 34 carbs, 10 fiber, 7 sugar
I know people seem to be a little bit averse to the instant, but I did look and the first ingredient is 'Whole grain rolled oats'... It's pretty tasty though!0 -
I buy the Quaker High Fiber Instant Oatmeal - Cinnamon Swirl... Not sure it's the BEST that I can do, but makes breakfast quick and easy and definitely better than some of the other alternatives that I could be having. 1 packet is more than adequate to fill me up!
160 calories, 2 grams fat (.5 saturated), no cholesterol, 220 sodium, 34 carbs, 10 fiber, 7 sugar
I know people seem to be a little bit averse to the instant, but I did look and the first ingredient is 'Whole grain rolled oats'... It's pretty tasty though!
I eat instant also and believe it's fine. I LOVE LOVE LOVE it!0 -
i dont eat oats for two reasons, one is because i have celiac and theres a huge potential fo cross contamination and its ridiculously expensive for gluten free oats. and the other reason is because i dont eat any grain products as they dont react well with my body, as in, if i eat them i get fat. lol
I don't think they make you fat. May cause immune response and inflammation but wouldn't make you fat per se. You still need excess calories to make you fat.0 -
oatmeal is fantastic and an excellent source of fibre. I don't eat it daily, but I do plan on having a big bowl of it tomorrow for breakfast! I've never had any problem losing weight while eating oats or any other grain. I eat grains several times a day, and as long as I don't cheat, I am always down the next morning.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions