How long did it take you to stop craving junk food ?
Buttercupmcgee
Posts: 95 Member
I've heard said that after a certain amount of time, the cravings for burgers and fries (or whatever your favorite may be) dissipate, and people actually start longing for greens and whole foods.
Now, I like healthy food. I eat a whole foods diet about 70% of the time. But I'd be full of ---- if I said I don't also love a big old milkshake or a bag of chips. It's that other 30% that lead me to MFP--it seems I can only eat so many healthy meals before I want something "comforting" and crappy.
The longest I've gone without indulging in junk food is a few months, and I was *definitely* thinking about it the entire time. After three months, I was still unable to re-wire my brain to stop desiring the foods I'd indulged in frequently for so long. I was eating two to three cheat meals a week at the time, so I wasn't 100% restrictive. But I never reached that place of moderation where a few squares of dark chocolate satisfied me, and the rest of the time I craved quinoa--a mythical place where my "cheats" are reasonable, and don't exceed 1,000 calories.
Does anyone have any experience with this? How long did it take your brain and behavioral patterns to truly transform, and how did you manage to not give up before you got there?
Now, I like healthy food. I eat a whole foods diet about 70% of the time. But I'd be full of ---- if I said I don't also love a big old milkshake or a bag of chips. It's that other 30% that lead me to MFP--it seems I can only eat so many healthy meals before I want something "comforting" and crappy.
The longest I've gone without indulging in junk food is a few months, and I was *definitely* thinking about it the entire time. After three months, I was still unable to re-wire my brain to stop desiring the foods I'd indulged in frequently for so long. I was eating two to three cheat meals a week at the time, so I wasn't 100% restrictive. But I never reached that place of moderation where a few squares of dark chocolate satisfied me, and the rest of the time I craved quinoa--a mythical place where my "cheats" are reasonable, and don't exceed 1,000 calories.
Does anyone have any experience with this? How long did it take your brain and behavioral patterns to truly transform, and how did you manage to not give up before you got there?
0
Replies
-
Sorry to tell you I still want it. Yesterday I read a post about Chick Fil A and that's all I could think about. So I had it. But what I did differently was check out how many calories I had left for the day, check out their website for nutritional values and eat accordingly. Instead of a 12 piece nugget, I ate 8, instead of a large shake, I had a small. I came in under calories for the day and was quite content. Today I'll drink a ton of water, eat my giant salad with protein for lunch and eat my normal snacks and dinner. For me the key is to have it occasionally, make it fit in my calories for the day and move on. If not, that's all I can think about. I'm in the moderation camp for sure.0
-
Hasn't happened yet, and I would cry if it did.0
-
I have no idea. I don't think it ever completely goes away, but I have noticed it's really diminished. I've been at this almost a year. It's been diminished for a while, so I'll guess it took around 6 months or so.
For me though, I don't deny myself anything specifically. If I can fit it in my daily goals, great. If not, I wait for a cheat day and have it then LOL. Keeps me sane.0 -
I'm not exactly past craving it, but having it is less satisfying. I can draw a connection between poor performance working out and having eaten some junk.
I lived out of my normal environment for a year and got adjusted to healthier food. I really didn't crave it because it was futile. Once I got back to my normal environment junk food tasted horrible. But, I persisted, and finally I could eat junk food again0 -
WHAT??????
N E V E R0 -
I'm not sure if I believe in the whole "your body stops cravinf junk food" idea. It seems to me that it is more along the lines of once you start making a choice to eat healthier, you become accustomed to eating those healthy foods INSTEAD of junk foods. It's just like any other habit that you break. It's all about will power and choices that you make. I am with you that I will always want or crave junk food. It tastes good!! But now that I have changed my eating habits, it has become a treat for me to eat junk instead of something I consume on a daily basis (which I was!). An example for me would have been before I would always say I could never live without cheese!! I ate cheese everyday (in fairly large quantity) and that wasn't good. Now I eat cheese maybe once or twice a week in normal quantities because that is a concious choice I am making.
One thing I will add is that when I do indulge in "junk food" it tastes soooo much better than it ever did before simply because I am not used to eating it all the time all the time all the time now. It's easy to fall back into "bad habits" but only if it is something you allow yourself to do. I have had the most success with attampting weight loss this time simply because I have changed my eating habits. I don't look at it as being a diet. It is a lifelong change.0 -
For the most part, you won't stop craving certain things. However, there is no reason you should make your food choices too restrictive. If you are able to eat a cheeseburger and fries and stay with in your calorie/carbs/proteins/fat limits, then you should eat it.
Too restrictive, for most people, becomes cumbersome and they eventually stop trying to lose weight.0 -
I would never give up junk food or cheeseburgers, so I don't know anything about how long it might take to stop craving them.0
-
In a week to 2 weeks of eating healthy, my cravings are greatly diminished. They never go away because TOM always bring them back!0
-
It stops as soon as I get a burger, a small fry and a soda. I still indulge in all my favorites, I just don't order it in the old quantities. Pretty simple.0
-
Still want it.
I don't know if the craving will ever go away. It makes me happy.0 -
It never goes away and when I think I have it kicked I have a small taste and want even more. If I could get my hands on one of those bunny's that lay the cadburry eggs i'd be in heaven. Damn bunny! CMON Willy Wonka0
-
It stops as soon as I get a burger, a small fry and a soda. I still indulge in all my favorites, I just don't order it in the old quantities. Pretty simple.
Hmmm, you seem to be indicating that food you enjoy can be fit into your diet. Details, please.0 -
A burger and fries does not sound good at all to me anymore. I really can't believe I used to eat that so much. I do still crave chocolate and cake and all though. I still have it here and there. no biggie.0
-
I dont know if you will ever quit craving junk food but the other night I was craving a Big Mac Meal and I only took a couple bites and it was DISGUSTING!!! Thank God for that!!!0
-
Eight months and 55 pounds after I started, I *still* love junk food! It's true that your body DOES start craving healthy food, too, which is good - healthy foods that are high in protein and fiber fill you up so you're less *hungry* for junk food, but how many of us really grab a candy bar because we're hungry? If you presented me with a tray of celery and a tray of chocolate, I'd still prefer the chocolate, and would wager that anyone who said differently is a liar. It's never as simple as not wanting the "junk" - it's about learning how to eat a balanced diet so we're eating less junk and plenty of good stuff, too.0
-
I'll let you know if I ever stop craving it. :P I just allow myself to eat a little junk here and there.0
-
I don't think I'll ever stop craving junk food, but I would say it took me about a month of slowly replacing one junky thing a day with a healthy thing before I was at least able to resist most cravings.0
-
I crave it all the time but I finally realize how it affects my performance at the gym. So when I do have junk food I will now eat much smaller portions, just enough to satisfy the craving.0
-
the strong craving for me stopped about a month and a half after i started. I still eat junk food occasionally but my cravings feel different. Now sometimes chips or a burger sound good, unlike before where i felt like i just had to have whatever i was craving.0
-
Holy crap, Sharie. Is it only 34 pounds of weight loss between those two photos in your profile pic? The difference is incredible!0
-
Eight months and 55 pounds after I started, I *still* love junk food! It's true that your body DOES start craving healthy food, too, which is good - healthy foods that are high in protein and fiber fill you up so you're less *hungry* for junk food, but how many of us really grab a candy bar because we're hungry? If you presented me with a tray of celery and a tray of chocolate, I'd still prefer the chocolate, and would wager that anyone who said differently is a liar. It's never as simple as not wanting the "junk" - it's about learning how to eat a balanced diet so we're eating less junk and plenty of good stuff, too.
Well said.0 -
I'm not exactly past craving it, but having it is less satisfying. I can draw a connection between poor performance working out and having eaten some junk.
I lived out of my normal environment for a year and got adjusted to healthier food. I really didn't crave it because it was futile. Once I got back to my normal environment junk food tasted horrible. But, I persisted, and finally I could eat junk food again
Haha, you beat that nasty junk food aversion, good for you! This gave me a much needed giggle.0 -
I'm not sure if I believe in the whole "your body stops cravinf junk food" idea. It seems to me that it is more along the lines of once you start making a choice to eat healthier, you become accustomed to eating those healthy foods INSTEAD of junk foods. It's just like any other habit that you break. It's all about will power and choices that you make. I am with you that I will always want or crave junk food. It tastes good!! But now that I have changed my eating habits, it has become a treat for me to eat junk instead of something I consume on a daily basis (which I was!). An example for me would have been before I would always say I could never live without cheese!! I ate cheese everyday (in fairly large quantity) and that wasn't good. Now I eat cheese maybe once or twice a week in normal quantities because that is a concious choice I am making.
One thing I will add is that when I do indulge in "junk food" it tastes soooo much better than it ever did before simply because I am not used to eating it all the time all the time all the time now. It's easy to fall back into "bad habits" but only if it is something you allow yourself to do. I have had the most success with attampting weight loss this time simply because I have changed my eating habits. I don't look at it as being a diet. It is a lifelong change.
That's very true about the actual treat factor going up as you don't make it a daily thing. This helps it to feel less "all or nothing"--the idea that it's there when we want it, and it will be delicious!0 -
It's inspiring to me how many of you have taken on the attitude of junk food being fun and pleasurable. I tend to begin associating those foods with guilt almost immediately when I decide to revamp my eating. I'm going to see about viewing them differently--as a necessary treat, just not a daily one.0
-
Still crave it, and at random times and random very specific items. Sometimes I decide it's my body telling me I need some protein or carbs and find a healthy alternative. Every now and then (maybe once a month or so) I'll just eat the cheeseburger or twix bar or whatever.0
-
I still crave chips, chocolate, cookies and I EAT them but never going over my calorie goal and if I do go over a little I don't lose sleep over it! Just so you know I eat Pringles low fat chips and Nips everyday...works for me lol0
-
304 lbs down in 34 months and I still have craving for certain things. But there is also alot of those things that just don't do anything for me anymore. I use to be a Doritoes freak (ate 2 large bags a week) and now I don't even like them anymore. I have control of those cravings now and don't give into them. I have 2 spike meals a week (cheat meals) and normally eat whatever I want so I use those meals to include those foods I normally don't eat during the week. The rest of the time I stick to my healthy choices and it keeps me focused knowing I have those meals to look forward too...0
-
I think after about a two weeks I was able to not be pulled by the magical persuasive powers of junk food. Plus the fact that I gave it all away to people and got it out of my house really helped as well.0
-
I've never stopped wanting it, but that's because I never cut it out of my diet. It's interesting, though, because there have been changes. My family eats at a particularly greasy and high calorie restaurant at least once, sometimes twice a week. I haven't eaten there in five weeks. Although I want a fry, I'm now ok to just sit with them as they stuff down burgers and ribs, while I eat tuna salad or something. Of course, they also get pieces of chocolate cake and eat those in front of me, too. =( That's the hardest part.
In general though, when people aren't eating delicious greasy foods in front of me, I don't feel like I have to have them.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions