cant fuction on the calories recommended

swatkins1c
swatkins1c Posts: 48 Member
edited December 17 in Food and Nutrition
Hello i weigh 145 and ive been eating better for a week now the food recomends 1200 calories daily but i am starving if i only eat that much. i seem to be satisfied with about 400 more than that. And its real hunger not cravings. what should i do?
«1

Replies

  • sl1ngsh0t
    sl1ngsh0t Posts: 326 Member
    I'm at 143 and also supposed to be at 1200 calories. I am having the same struggle you are.

    I'm trying to drink a LOT of water and eat every four hours-b-fast, lunch, dinner. I have one snack 2 hrs. after lunch.

    It's hard, I know!

    Also, be sure you're eating clean-no GMO's, no artificial sweeteners, HFCS!
  • seanwebster
    seanwebster Posts: 83 Member
    Do you have it set for 1 lb/week weight loss, or something higher? You could try changing your goal to slower weight loss, even just temporarily. I eased myself down and it's worked so far.

    Just a thought, I'm not a nutritionist, but your hunger might be related to nutrient requirements. Might be you're not getting enough fat, or protein, or too much sugar, not enough iron, etc.

    Or maybe it's just that 1200 isn't enough and you need to eat more. Above all listen to your body, it knows what it needs.
  • chrisb75
    chrisb75 Posts: 395 Member
    Two questions:

    1) What are you eating?
    2) How much to do you exercise?
  • n_r_d
    n_r_d Posts: 1
    On 1200 calories you have to make sure you are eating back whatever calories you burn during the day. When I was at 1290 I was getting muscle aches and was very spacey. I also stalled on my weight loss, so I decided to move up to 1500 calories a day and i feel SO much better and I can exercise harder.
  • gemiwing
    gemiwing Posts: 1,525 Member
    What's your TDEE? Figure that out- take 15-20% off and the calories left will be what you should eat every day. With this plan- unless your workout takes you below your BMR, do not eat exercise calories back.

    An alternate plan- readjust your settings in MFP. Set for 1lb or .5lbs a week loss, select an activity level that more closely represents your life (most chose sedentary when they truly aren't). Do not eat below your BMR. Your BMR can be found under the Tools tab here on MFP. With this plan- eat your exercise calories back.

    Hope this helps :)
  • Drastiic
    Drastiic Posts: 322 Member
    A safe area to be in would be 20-35% less of your TDEE to lose weight.

    Here's a simple calculation.
    Estimated TDEE = Multiply your weight in lbs x 15.
    To lose weight = Subtract 20-35%
    Follow plan for 3 weeks.
    Adjust accordingly.

    Example:
    Assuming you're 143 lbs.
    Estimated TDEE = 143 x 15 = 2145
    20% of 2145 = 429 --> 2145-429=1716 (0.86 lbs per week)
    35% of 2145 = 751 --> 2145-751=1394 (1.50 lbs per week)
    In this example to lose weight, eat between 1400-1715 calories.

    MFP doesn't use percentages. They base their loss by lbs per week.
    3500 calories = 1 lb. 3500/7 = 500 calories per day
    7000 calories = 2 lb. 7000/7 = 1000 calories per day
    2145-500 = 1645
    2145-1000 = 1145
    As you can tell, using poundages for a person with such a low TDEE wouldn't be a great idea, because a 2 lb loss per week is detrimental for a person with such a low TDEE.

    If you had a higher TDEE of 2700, it would be fine to subtract 500-1000 calories per day.
    2700-500=2200
    2700-1000=1700

    But a better way, would still be to use the 20-35%.
    20% of 2700 = 540 --> 2700-540=2160 (0.72 lbs per week)
    35% of 2700 = 945 --> 2700-945=1755 (1.25 lbs per week)
    In this example to lose weight, eat between 1750-2150 calories.

    ****The important thing with all of these calculations is they are estimates.
    ****It doesn't really matter what numbers you pick.
    ****Pick a number and stick with it for 3 weeks.
    ****Based off your RESULTS, either increase or decrease.

    ****If after 3 weeks, your average weekly fat loss was:
    --Less than 1 lb/wk -->Reduce your calories by 10%
    --1-1.5 lbs/wk --> No Change
    --2+ lbs/wk -->Is there performance loss?-->No (no change), Yes (Increase calories by 10%)
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    Hello i weigh 145 and ive been eating better for a week now the food recomends 1200 calories daily but i am starving if i only eat that much. i seem to be satisfied with about 400 more than that. And its real hunger not cravings. what should i do?

    Eat more. Make sure you log exercise and eat the extra calories.
  • ChelleDJM
    ChelleDJM Posts: 161
    I weigh more than double you and am close to that daily (I am seeing a nutritionist a doctor and printing journals for them so no bashing the big gal eating low calories please). I am doing this for 6 months at least based on what they have told me. But my food choices are all mine. My diary is open if you want to look. I log every bite and drink.
  • I'm just staring week 3 and I sometimes have the same trouble, but I trust my body more than I trust numbers in a program. Some days it's as simple as eating a tablespoon of raisins, or a few peanuts or almonds. Other days I need a sandwich to feel satisfied. Experiment with your diet and find what works for you! It might be good to also take a look at what you're eating and make sure you're hitting all of the nutritional bases.
  • swatkins1c
    swatkins1c Posts: 48 Member
    Thanks for all the responses! i eat healthy bran flakes fruits veggies nuts ect i try and exersize alot but i sit down at least half the day do you think since im new to exersizing its just my body wanting to not lose the weight?
  • fteale
    fteale Posts: 5,310 Member
    I started out at 154 lbs, and on 1200 cals a week to lose just under a lb a week. And I was starving. Properly, miserably starving. I don't know how people do it long term. I went up to 1360 cals a day after a couple of months and was a lot happier.
  • Sharonks
    Sharonks Posts: 884 Member
    You should open your diary when asking for help.

    Eat back your exercise cals.
    Eat lots of veggies.
    Increase fat &/or protein.
    Drink water.
    Eat whole grain starches.
    Eat nuts.
    are you truly hungry or wanting to munch out of habit?
  • fteale
    fteale Posts: 5,310 Member
    You should open your diary when asking for help.

    Eat back your exercise cals.
    Eat lots of veggies.
    Increase fat &/or protein.
    Drink water.
    Eat whole grain starches.
    Eat nuts.
    are you truly hungry or wanting to munch out of habit?

    I think on 1200 cals, most people are properly hungry. Not wanting to eat from habit.
  • swatkins1c
    swatkins1c Posts: 48 Member
    idk how to open my diary and i found that soup helps a bit and is low enough cal
  • chevvy53
    chevvy53 Posts: 35 Member
    to open your diary go into your privacy settings on your account plus i have been doing mfp since january although it looks like less as I did not log when I was away due to no comp' however I started at losing half a pound a week and it worked I was on 1700 odd calories a day and I have lost so far slowly and have now changed over the last couple weeks to a pound a week . Stay strong it is one of the best places to lose the weight especially with the support all the best
  • mccarol1956
    mccarol1956 Posts: 422 Member

    I second using this!
  • swatkins1c
    swatkins1c Posts: 48 Member
    diary open only three days in it though cuz im new but i think im gunna add 250 extra and work my way down
  • bizco
    bizco Posts: 1,949 Member
    Thanks for all the responses! i eat healthy bran flakes fruits veggies nuts ect i try and exersize alot but i sit down at least half the day do you think since im new to exersizing its just my body wanting to not lose the weight?
    No.
  • chrisb75
    chrisb75 Posts: 395 Member
    diary open only three days in it though cuz im new but i think im gunna add 250 extra and work my way down

    You are eating high calorie low nutrient foods all the time. For example:

    Lean Cuisine - Pepperoni Pizza, 1 Pizza (170g)
    Replace with:
    1 Whole Wheat Pita, 1/4 C Mozzerella, 1/4c Pizza Sauce, 2c of veggies

    Pbj - Pbj, 1 Sandwich
    Replace with:
    Apple and 2tbs Peanut Butter with 1tbs Water (PB and Water for 30 Seconds).
  • fatboypup
    fatboypup Posts: 1,873 Member
    yup you gotta find 1200 cals of good filling foods
  • All_Mimsy
    All_Mimsy Posts: 49 Member
    When I set my weekly weight loss goal too high (1 lb or more per week), MFP also recommended around 1200 net calories per day. I was miserable and I could tell my body needed more fuel, so I upped my daily net goal to 1450. Because I exercise a lot, I actually end up eating a total of 1650-2000 calories per day, but I try to net at least 1450. I'm still losing weight at a rapid pace, but I feel so much better. Don't be afraid to increase your caloric intake until you find something that feels "right" for you. You're not in a race to meet your goal weight! You're much more likely to be successful if you have a plan that you can sustain.
  • maillemaker
    maillemaker Posts: 1,253 Member
    Eat less carbs. When you eat carbs, it jacks your blood sugar level up and when it crashes, you feel hungry. If you eat less carbs, you will have a more stable blood sugar level and you won't get so hungry.

    Being "filling" is somewhat of a misnomer. What makes you hungry isn't the physical size of your stomach organ, it's your blood sugar level.

    You don't want to eat "filling" food, you want food that stabilizes your BSL.
  • husker_gal
    husker_gal Posts: 462 Member
    MFP recommends that I only eat 1200 per day too. I couldn't function on it and found that I don't lose very much when I eat only 1200 so I upped my calories to a variable between 1500 and 1800 per day. I do not eat my exercise calories back though unless my NET calories are below 1200. Try for a few weeks with like 1500 calories and see how you do. You may be surprised at how it works =)
  • CristlNothem
    CristlNothem Posts: 54 Member
    its always hard in the beginning. I felt like i was always hungry, but that is because my body was used to eating so many more calories and a whole lot of crap. It took a little while to become accustomed to it and no longer be hungry. I have found that eating just a little bit of beef jerky in between meals (when i am at work) has helped me to feel more full.
  • SuffolkSally
    SuffolkSally Posts: 964 Member
    You haven't got many days filled in yet, but what there is says you're not eating well. I'd cut out the ready meals - you'll find homemade food without all the additives a lot more filling and you'll be able to have more of it. Try and get your protein intake up. And as others have said, you need to do the maths around your BMR and TDEE. You sound like you're more active than just sedentary and I doubt 1200 is enough - I'm losing on 1700 + eating back exercise calories, although I'm tall
  • TinkrBelz
    TinkrBelz Posts: 866 Member
    MFP recommends that I only eat 1200 per day too. I couldn't function on it and found that I don't lose very much when I eat only 1200 so I upped my calories to a variable between 1500 and 1800 per day. I do not eat my exercise calories back though unless my NET calories are below 1200. Try for a few weeks with like 1500 calories and see how you do. You may be surprised at how it works =)

    This!!

    I actually set MFP at maintenance. Then let my workout be my deficit. I think it is a lot easier to keep up with. So, some days I may only be a 200 calorie defect and other days I am a 500 calorie deficit. But, to think that I can only eat 1200 is not enough!!

    I eat 1600-1900 calories per day.
  • mystic_elegance
    mystic_elegance Posts: 258 Member
    I would recommend three things.
    1. Make sure your drinking at least 8 glasses of water daily, and try to drink one before a meal.
    2. Add to every meal some vegetables, try to avoid butter or dressings if you can. Vegetables are a great source of nutrients, can make you feel Fuller without the excessive calories. Or do a veggie salad with every meal with fat free very low calorie dressing, you can usually find these at your local grocery store in a spray bottle.
    3. If you want to eat more, then do it. Just make sure you burn off the extra calories before the end of the day.
    Good luck :)
  • AlsDonkBoxSquat
    AlsDonkBoxSquat Posts: 6,128 Member
    Looking at what you've eaten over the past few days I have little wonder why you're having such a difficult time. You're eating a lot of prepackaged foods, you're not showing it but I'm assuming that your sodium is off the charts too (if I get too much sodium in my diet I get really hungry and start craving sweets on top).

    The biggest trick I learned when I was on 1200 calories is that steamed and raw veggies go a long long way, and so do exercise calories. I found it incredibly difficult to survive on 1200 calories, so I would exercise my *kitten* off and earn enough calories to satisfy. On days where I can't exercise I load up on the steamed veg and super lean meats. Up your protein goal, and eat foods high in fiber.

    I'm not the "cleanest" eater in the world, but I would suggest cucking the velveta for better cheeses too . . . get a nice block of cheddar.
  • Short and simple. Exercise more and you'll be able to eat more and still lose weight.
This discussion has been closed.