why french women don't get fat
vpsmith14
Posts: 71
I've been reading some books on this lately and it is all so very interesting. I have no particular question, only what do you all think about the idea?
I'd like to add my two cents quick. For over a year I have been calorie counting, losing at first, but of course always going back up. Like a yo-yo but I'm not purposely eating, not eating, eating, etc. Only sticking to my calories and working out while zig-zagging my calories making sure I stay in a deficit so I can lose. THAT SAID. Right before Thanksgiving I did great. So for 5 weeks straight I was nearly perfect with my calories. Gained a pound. AGAIN. So, since July, faithfully exercising and watching calories I've put back on 9lbs.
The last 3 weeks or so, over the holidays I might add I took it upon myself to eat like a French woman. Go figure, I've lost 3 lbs. Without trying, but of course with continued exercising.
Any thoughts? I gotta go grab another bowl of Breyer's ice cream
I'd like to add my two cents quick. For over a year I have been calorie counting, losing at first, but of course always going back up. Like a yo-yo but I'm not purposely eating, not eating, eating, etc. Only sticking to my calories and working out while zig-zagging my calories making sure I stay in a deficit so I can lose. THAT SAID. Right before Thanksgiving I did great. So for 5 weeks straight I was nearly perfect with my calories. Gained a pound. AGAIN. So, since July, faithfully exercising and watching calories I've put back on 9lbs.
The last 3 weeks or so, over the holidays I might add I took it upon myself to eat like a French woman. Go figure, I've lost 3 lbs. Without trying, but of course with continued exercising.
Any thoughts? I gotta go grab another bowl of Breyer's ice cream
0
Replies
-
I read a a little bit of the book called "Why French Women Don't Get Fat" or something like that... maybe it was "Why French Women Stay Skinny." Either way, I think the idea is to be conscious of what you are eating without stressing about it. There are simple rules in the book I read like "Don't eat seconds" "Take your time eating" "Enjoy your food" etc... which can be applied to anybody. Sometimes focusing too much on what you are eating can backfire. If you don't listen to your body you can end up eating more than it needs... even when you are counting calories and excercising. Not worrying about what you are eating and relaxing might have helped you lose weight.
It's an interesting book to peruse but nothing to take too seriously, because it's just another label of a fad diet: "I'm eating like a French woman."0 -
-
Perhaps you have been eating too few calories, and when you lightened up on yourself, you ate correctly and lost.
Here's an interesting read about staying obese while eating only 700 calories a day:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/3047-700-calories-a-day-and-not-losing0 -
Haha! Thanks love that.0 -
I spent three weeks in Egypt last year....and all the food there is fatty and fried. They fry everything! They deep fry vegetables. And they only drink sugar laden juices and soda. I think I saw one overweight person the entire time I was there. I couldn't believe it. The only thing I can figure is that they really do not snack (they just eat really heavy fat/fried full meals)...and most people do not drive and do a lot of walking.0
-
Coffee, cigarettes, and anorexia.0
-
Coffee, cigarettes, and anorexia.
Ummm.. why? Is it so hard to believe that someone can stay slim without the above?0 -
have you BEEN to France?0
-
I mostly French, and I got fat! LOL!0
-
Sour grapes.0
-
I have that book and the author is right on target but.... it all depends upon YOU and your dedication to staying with YOUR program, one meal at a time, one day at a time. You are the only one in charge of what you know works for you. There is no quick fix, no magic cure and no easy way.0
-
fyi ... I am half French.0
-
Sex? no dont hate me for saying it. Some says that its a good calorie burner.
I have browsed that book. I think its because they savor their meal. They take their time to enjoy every bite. They dont just gulp They chew it well. Wine drinking i guess helps too0 -
cigarettes, and anorexia.
i've been there twice (once for a month) and i didn't get that impression at all. i stayed with 3 different host families and spent a good deal of time with them and their friends, as well as observing the general population. interesting.0 -
I was! and now I'm fat.0
-
Ennui, bitterness, Gauloises cigarettes, and multiple lovers..0
-
oh, how I miss the Gauloises.
the multiple lovers are still health-friendly, though.0 -
There is no Hydrogenation oil in Europe's food, its' actually band from europe. We North Americans have have foods full of this poison... This is the culprit. Take this completely out of your diet, read the labels oh what you buy and you will be amazed at how much weight you will lose.
http://www.purica.com/holistic_living/healthy_lifestyle/diet_and_nutrition/hydrogenated_oils.htm0 -
I've read all of Mireille Guiliano's books- including the one about women and business!
I think the food plan is quite smart, and actually what most of us are doing every day- trying to eat a healthy calorie count, making sure we get more of the good stuff and less of the bad stuff, and have good portion control.
The difference is that Guiliano claims that French women have been better trained at feeling their way safely through what for most Americans is an absolute minefield of potentially hazardous food choices.
If someone was interested in the philosophy put forward in the books- I would recommend MyFitnessPal and tell them to log. It's a little more work, kind of like learning to drive a manual before an automatic, but the truth is that until you see the numbers of calories in, calories out, you won't believe what you're eating.
Now that I'm logging regularly I can see that I'm eating (very carefully) just as Guiliano recommends- smaller portions, healthier choices, occasional naughty foods. If I know I'm going out for pasta and wine- I plan for it. I have smaller meals earlier, get in a bit of exercise, and practice good portion control. But unfortunately for me, not being born with this natural French insight, I have to log it all... or else I'm flying blind.0 -
fyi ... I am half French.
So you're an anorexic smoker who drink's coffee?
Just because you're half French, doesn't mean you are living like a French woman. I am half Parisian French and half Canandian French, but I was raised in the U.S. So I adapted the eating habits of Americans.0 -
The French government is concerned about a coming obesity epidemic in France. Google it.
Le grand secret dévoilé: French women tend not to get fat because they don't eat and they smoke.
They also live in a society even more sexist than the U.S.0 -
Now that I'm logging regularly I can see that I'm eating (very carefully) just as Guiliano recommends- smaller portions, healthier choices, occasional naughty foods. If I know I'm going out for pasta and wine- I plan for it. I have smaller meals earlier, get in a bit of exercise, and practice good portion control. But unfortunately for me, not being born with this natural French insight, I have to log it all... or else I'm flying blind.
Some of us figured this out without being French. The idea that French women have some secret method est complètement ridicule.0 -
Coffee, cigarettes, and anorexia.
HA tell that to the many skinny girls I know, some of whom are trying to GAIN weight because they are so skinny and who do none of the above. That explains some people but definitely not most.0 -
Coffee, cigarettes, and anorexia.
I know this was an old post but hilarious! Boo on people for not having a sense of humor. (And I agree with you.)0 -
I guess this applies to anyone regardless of their nationality or ethnicity. Its just happens that French women usually gets the stereotype as the most "skinny" people in the West but they're no different from other Mediterranean people. There are also overweight French women.0
-
Speaking as a french woman I can assure you it's all crap. Sex is also a better cardio exercise for men than it is women. Don't get me wrong, I like being an active participant, its just I've always felt men have to exert more energy than women when it comes to sex.0
-
I'm french, we have fat people just as you, LESS, because :
- we don't have a McDonald every 2 meters
- serving sizes are not the same
- we have a gastronomical culture that promotes healthy meals
appart that, there are a lot of fat people :-)0 -
I concur there are plenty of overweight people in France, just look at René Artois0
-
It's like the idea that French women all have perfect skin. It is a country hugely obsessed with women's appearance. In general they spend a vast amount of time getting treatments, for instance it is quite normal after giving birth to go to a thalassotherapy spa for a week (without the baby) to kick start the weight loss. It is quite normal to use lunch hours having anti ageing treatments too. How many English or American women do that?
Also having a culture of eating well, don't mean eating a lot. It is expected that on a date, women don't eat much and just pick at their food daintily. French (and Italian for that matter) men don't particularly like women putting away as much as they can.0 -
There is no Hydrogenation oil in Europe's food, its' actually band from europe. We North Americans have have foods full of this poison... This is the culprit. Take this completely out of your diet, read the labels oh what you buy and you will be amazed at how much weight you will lose.
http://www.purica.com/holistic_living/healthy_lifestyle/diet_and_nutrition/hydrogenated_oils.htm
^^^^^^^ YES!! eat clean your body will thank you for it, no preservatives, artificial crap, dyes! If you can't pronounce it then it probably isn't good for you. And....stay away from bleached flours bad bad bad. Whole wheat is the way to go.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions