Low Carbers Only
LReneeWalker
Posts: 213 Member
My husband is thinking of starting Atkins. I am just interested in success stories from low carb dieters. I dont care to hear others opinions on just eat less blah blah blah. I am not interested in Nay-Sayers. Just Low Carb Success Stories. Thanks!
0
Replies
-
Sure you don't want to hear a Low Carb Epic Fail story? I know one...0
-
It works, but it doesn't stay off if you don't stick to it. He should get his cholesterol checked first, because it can cause cholesterol to raise. As long as his cholesterol is fine, then he should go for it. His energy level is going to be really low for the first couple of weeks (if he is strict about Atkins).
if he is thinking about doing a modified, low carb diet, he should look into the Cave Man Diet or other low carb options that do allow for fruit and nuts and whole grains. this will keep his energy up and probably help him stay on longer.
Most people arent disciplined enough to commit to Atkins long term.
My aunt lost like 80lbs on Atkins but put it all back on when she started eating carbs again. It just depends on his discipline level.0 -
sure....tell me!Sure you don't want to hear a Low Carb Epic Fail story? I know one...0 -
Never heard of the Caveman diet...thanks I'll tell him!0
-
Never heard of the Caveman diet...thanks I'll tell him!
http://www.webmd.com/diet/features/diet-review-the-caveman-paleo-diet?page=2
Here is a webmd link. I am sure if he talked to a physician about it they would be pretty supportive.0 -
It's not a personal story, but a man I work with was diagnosed with Diabetes about ten years ago. He went on the Atkins diet and has remained committed to it ever since. He lost 60 lbs, has kept it off and is not on any diabetic meds. He is 100% committed and does not cheat. EVER.
My aunt did Atkins for about six months and lost a tremendous amount of weight, but she did gain it back as soon as she re-introduced carbs into her life.0 -
I've been doing a modified South Beach program since January and have lost about 36 pounds. This was based on a recommendation from my doctor.
I use a lot of the Atkins protein bars to fill in some of the blanks calorie-wise and really love most of them.
All of that said, here are a couple of approaches I've taken with what I would call a lower carb way.
I do eat fruit but limit it to one serving a day. When I eat fruit, I try to pair it with a serving of protein. South Beach encourages people to eat fruit with a lower carb load, like berries or cantaloupe, vs. things like apples, which are seriously good for you but have a more carbs. (I do avoid pineapple and watermelon, also, but I will "budget" these in when they are in season.)
I do eat pasta dishes as well as potatoes. Again, though, when I eat them, I also eat protein. The only carb I've really, really given up is white rice.
Keep in mind, too, that the "induction" phases can feel really painful, what helped me was a "focus on today" philosophy. There are going to be lots of different opinions you're hit with--people who think Atkins is evil, people who ascribe to the caveman diet, all of that. You really do have to find what works for you as an individual, and for the very long haul. When I realized that I could live a lower carbohydrate lifestyle and be OK with eating the occasional baked potato or sub roll, things got easier.
I tried Atkins a long time ago and loved it, but it wasn't something I could do for real and forever.0 -
sure....tell me!Sure you don't want to hear a Low Carb Epic Fail story? I know one...
Tried the Protein Power Plan almost 10 years ago, lost over 25 lbs in less than 5 months. I thought I had found the answer, but I never could get my maintenance diet in order. It was very hard to not just go overboard, even after a year of following the plan. I never completely stopped craving certain things...
Long story short, after a year and a half of struggling with low carb eating, I fell off the wagon, gained back the weight plus an extra ten pounds for good measure...
I joined MFP a year ago in April and have lost almost 40 lbs....very slowly and sensibly. I eat what I like, but don't eat mindlessly, everything goes in the diary. I don't feel deprived or tired, just healthier and six sizes smaller! This site has put me in control of my own lifestyle.
There is no quick fix for the rest of your life!0 -
I did a Ketogenic diet (practically no carb) last year and lost 15lbs. Bathroom scale broke and I didn't weigh myself again until about a month ago. Exact same weight as when I ended the diet last year. So no, you don't always gain the weight back.
Granted, I lift weights regularly. But for the most part, this last year I did not watch anything that I ate and kept the weight off. To each his own, I guess.0 -
I went on the atkins when I was 15 and went from 230 to 150. I decided that the atkins was not a good lifestyle just a good way to lose weight fast so I then went on the Fat Smash and that was a pretty good diet to learn portions on. I I did gain weight back but its NOT bc i went on a huge binge on carbs and gained it all back. I just got comfortable with my husband and I gained about 30-40 lbs. Then I found MFP and really learned what portions were and how many calories I should be taking in, but i will Always swear by the low carb diets bc it helped me drastically!0
-
i have had low carb success -- been doing it since Nov 1 and have lost 77 pounds in six months
0 -
LOL Kathy I know your success... I always think you put the anti low carbers in their place!0
-
Hi there..I am low carbing for now..not atkins , south beach or any other fad diet..but my own modification.
I did reference the diets above for ideas on how to modify my own. After playing with the Carb numbers..I found that I could lose about 2 lbs or more weeking by keeping my Carb intake under 80.
Some days I don't even hit the 80..others I may go over by 10 or 20..
I eliminated the processed foods, sugars, white stuff (flour, pasta, potatoes, rice) and increased protein, veggies and fresh fruit.
Good luck to your husband!0 -
Started a lower carb diet in January around 40-50 carbs a day, used it for a month or so to kick things off, then as I added in more and more exercise, I added in carbs to support that additional exercise. I'm down almost 40 lbs since the middle of January.
Im now averaging around 100-120 carbs a day on an 1800 - 2000 cal diet which means I eat a pretty normal diet but exclude most bread, rice, and potatoes. Thats not really 'low carb' but I think its a reasonable balance between feeling satisfied and getting the exercise energy you need. I believe this is maintainable long-term, but ask me again in a year!
Track your potassium if you do this... and make sure you take a good well rounded vitamin.0 -
LOL Kathy I know your success... I always think you put the anti low carbers in their place!
yes and i can guarantee i will gain it back if i go back to eating the way i use to -- just as anyone counting calories will gain it back once they stop counting and start eating crap again. that goes for any diet -- however you lose it.0 -
We follow the Primal Blueprint which has some similiarities to Paleo. We don't eat grains, but there are no restrictions on vegetables and fruit. The first month was hard to follow as we didn't know how to eat without pasta and bread, but now it's really pretty simple. We did suffer in the first couple of weeks with the "carb" flu, but once that passed it was all great. More energy and we don't have stomach issues such as bloating and gas that we see instantly if we splurge on grain laden foods. Also, I don't have to exercise as hard or as long to achieve the same results. It has definitely been something that is sustainable for our family, but I think it would be hard to keep up with if you were the only one in your family that was following it. Check out marksdailyapple.com for more information and for some amazing success stories. Good Luck!0
-
Here's a fail story. I did Atkins back in 2003 to lose weight for my wedding. I lost about 50 pounds and I felt great. After the wedding I went back to eating like I used to and not only gained it all back but added a ton more on top of it. In fact, I ended up weighing 73 pounds heavier than my starting weight (so gained 123 pounds). I gained back the 58 lbs within about a year and half. And then it just kept coming.
I didn't exercise though when I was losing and I was in complete denial when the weight started to return.0 -
I love the somersize diet. I lost a lot of weight @ 70 pounds and it's a much less strict low Carb diet but you can have fruits and vegetables. It's more of when to eat but also eliminate "funky " foods. It's by Susanne somers. I love it but I missed eating whatever I wanted. I gained the weight back but stayed on it while pregnant and didn't gain hardly any weight. Good luck ...low Carb is fantastic if you have a great will to do it.0
-
HI! Keto here! see below VVVVVVV0
-
I am following the primal/caveman type diet..so far, so good.0
-
We are Paleo. I have lost 52lbs and continue to lose consistently, Fiance has gained 25lbs of muscle. I would highly recommend "low" carb to anyone and everyone. I have never felt better in my life, but you have to be prepared to make a full lifestyle change, but trust me that it is most definitely for the better, and will give you the best life and health you can imagine! Cut out the grains and watch your health improve! Keep eating healthy fruits and veggies in moderation, (I eat about 20-30g of carbs on the average day, never more than 50, often much much less) Stock up on healthy fats, good quality protein, cut out the processed crap and you cannot go wrong.0
-
I do the same thing. I try to limit to 90ish Some days I am over, some under. And I control calories with MFP. That is what works for me. In April I lost just under 10 pounds. My first month of low carb I did under 50/day and lost 19 pounds without controlling calories. But it is not a diet I could sustain -so, over the next month, I experimented with the numbers and found I felt GREAT and lost weight with calorie control and lower carbs. When I don't control carbs I could eat 500 calories and still not lose. That is me.0
-
Here's a fail story. I did Atkins back in 2003 to lose weight for my wedding. I lost about 50 pounds and I felt great. After the wedding I went back to eating like I used to and not only gained it all back but added a ton more on top of it. In fact, I ended up weighing 73 pounds heavier than my starting weight (so gained 123 pounds). I gained back the 58 lbs within about a year and half. And then it just kept coming.
I didn't exercise though when I was losing and I was in complete denial when the weight started to return.
That's not a story of low carb failing though. Just as any change, if you don't keep up with it, you will go back.
Definition of Insanity.....Doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.
Check out the Low Carb Group. You'll find great information, lots of support for low carbers, and some fantastic dinner ideas too !
0 -
Here's a fail story. I did Atkins back in 2003 to lose weight for my wedding. I lost about 50 pounds and I felt great. After the wedding I went back to eating like I used to and not only gained it all back but added a ton more on top of it. In fact, I ended up weighing 73 pounds heavier than my starting weight (so gained 123 pounds). I gained back the 58 lbs within about a year and half. And then it just kept coming.
I didn't exercise though when I was losing and I was in complete denial when the weight started to return.
That's not a story of low carb failing though. Just as any change, if you don't keep up with it, you will go back.
Definition of Insanity.....Doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.
Check out the Low Carb Group. You'll find great information, lots of support for low carbers, and some fantastic dinner ideas too !
Agreed...there's many variables in this story that resulted in the "fail"...not the atkins diet alone....It's not for everyone this is for sure...the individual has to make the right decisions that will help him/her reach the goal0 -
Here's a fail story. I did Atkins back in 2003 to lose weight for my wedding. I lost about 50 pounds and I felt great. After the wedding I went back to eating like I used to and not only gained it all back but added a ton more on top of it. In fact, I ended up weighing 73 pounds heavier than my starting weight (so gained 123 pounds). I gained back the 58 lbs within about a year and half. And then it just kept coming.
I didn't exercise though when I was losing and I was in complete denial when the weight started to return.
That's not a story of low carb failing though. Just as any change, if you don't keep up with it, you will go back.
Definition of Insanity.....Doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.
Check out the Low Carb Group. You'll find great information, lots of support for low carbers, and some fantastic dinner ideas too !
Agreed...there's many variables in this story that resulted in the "fail"...not the atkins diet alone....It's not for everyone this is for sure...the individual has to make the right decisions that will help him/her reach the goal
It's definitely of a low-carb failure story. I couldn't keep to a low-carb deprivation for the rest of my life. It resulted in me gaining back all my weight plus some. I suspect many people are unable to stick to a low carb diet for life. Are there people successful doing it? Sure. But I would never do it again. Especially when there is really no reason (for me) to. I'd be insane to do it again.
To each their own... just thought I'd share my experience.0 -
One thing people don't realize when doing low carb is that there is a several pound "bloat" that you will lose when first introducing the diet. If you eat carbs, you will gain that "bloat" back in a day or two of bingeing on carbs. Then when you cut carbs out again, you'll lose the bloat again. You could gain and lose the same 3-8 lbs repeatedly if you don't stick to the diet.
I started ketogenic in January. Lost 8lbs in the first week. I've been a little shoddy lately, with the carb intake and last week I gained and lost the same 3 lbs. But I always get back on that horse and keep plodding along, and the weight keeps falling off when I'm TRULY DEDICATED.
I think the reason a lot of people gain the weight back is because they "reach their goal" and then start eating exactly as they did before they lost the weight. MAINTENANCE is the key.
On a side note: some people have a hard time going through carb withdrawal. For me, cutting out carbs for me was like a blind person seeing for the first time. My mind and body function at a much more efficient level. Keeping that experience forefront in my mind has helped me make MUCH better decisions when it comes to food. Though I have to say, dinners out are still my nemesis....0 -
I'm a low carber! I eat low carb for health reasons and the weight loss is a side benefit. It's cleared up yeast issues and hypoglycemia. I was on a bad path. Diabetes runs in my family and I knew I needed to fix my eating habits. I will eat low carb for life. I used to eat around Atkins induction levels but now I eat around 60-75 grams a day. Weight loss is slower but I'm cool with that.
I wish it wasn't such a heated topic around here. It's not for everyone but it's certainly for me.
Good luck to your husband!0 -
Here's a fail story. I did Atkins back in 2003 to lose weight for my wedding. I lost about 50 pounds and I felt great. After the wedding I went back to eating like I used to and not only gained it all back but added a ton more on top of it. In fact, I ended up weighing 73 pounds heavier than my starting weight (so gained 123 pounds). I gained back the 58 lbs within about a year and half. And then it just kept coming.
I didn't exercise though when I was losing and I was in complete denial when the weight started to return.
That sucks0 -
bump0
-
I started Atkins in March of 2008, that was 100+ pounds ago. I documented the entire journey on my blog...
http://www.theurbanprimate.com
Since 2011 when I started doing long course endurance events (Ironman, etc,) I increased my carb intake. I am hungry all of the time and 10 pounds heavier. I can maintain easily on low-carb with typical 60-90 minute workouts. However, fueling for 3-4+ hour workouts is a challenge.
I would prefer to just stay low-carb because I feel better and generally not as hungry. Having said that, my nutrition plan right now is a work in progress. Trying to balance fueling for endurance events and being careful not to over do it is something I am learning still.
If you look in the upper right hand corner of my blog you will see several links that have the basics of Atkins on it. The key to success is to follow the plan to the letter. The first 3-5 days can be pretty uncomfortable, atkins flu, but it gets better quickly and not craving carby, sugary foods is awesome.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!