Is anybody having 2-3 meals instead of 5-6 and still fit?

MashaSK
MashaSK Posts: 142 Member
edited December 18 in Food and Nutrition
It's just harder to find a balance with food for me then exercise. I try to eat 5 times a day small amount of food, mostly meat/vegetables fruits and nuts. But I hate it! I am not hungry till 11 am at least every day and torture myself with breakfast at 5 am, and it's hard to snack in office healthy (people think you are an idiot while you eat a carrot or a cucumber)
«1

Replies

  • jaysonhijinx
    jaysonhijinx Posts: 663 Member
    I'm not fit right now but I'm working my *kitten* off to get there with 3-4 days of strength training and usually 3-4 days of basketball and soccer to cover my cardio with the odd run or fast paced walk.

    I eat 3 meals a day but will have a morning and afternoon snack if I'm hungry. My 3 meals are proper sized meals that fill me up and usually consist of fresh or steamed veggies, eggs, meat & fish. Stuff I snack on usually take the form of more veggies, greek yoghurt, nuts, tuna, bread and peanut butter.

    Everyone is going to be different and have their own personal preference, this is just what works for me. Shake things up, see what works for you.
  • MashaSK
    MashaSK Posts: 142 Member
    ehh basically 7 days a week of excercises You are a HERO! ufff I'll try to steal something from your diary too, very bored with my food already
  • 01divey
    01divey Posts: 50 Member
    On a small cut at the moment of around 1lb a week average, aiming for 8lb fat loss total (3lb down already)
    3 days Full body workout per week, No cardio as yet as my diet is almost perfect. Im literally eating to fuel my worouts, no treats.
    Take a look at my food diary, you really dont have to eat carrot sticks alone. All about calories in calories out.
    Keep protein high, fat relatively high, carbs moderate, plenty of water, pretty much what 90% of people on here advise!
    Give it time, you dont actually need cardio as it can be detrimental to fat loss. What i mean is, if your diet is almost spot on and your strength training, then you'll want your calories to repair/rebuild. why waste calories on the treadmill? just eat sensibly.
    I feel that maybe people hit the cardio as they feel it justifies the fact that they can eat more and get away with it?
    I've personally lost more weight on a cut when eating right, little or no cardio and consistent strength training, rather than hours on the treadmill!
    Good luck.
  • Helloitsdan
    Helloitsdan Posts: 5,564 Member
    Feeding frequency has nothing to do with weight loss.
    Try not to consume more than 40% of your calories in 1 sitting and youll be fine.

    I eat 2-3 meals daily.
    My last meal is at 10pm and my first for the day is at 2pm the next day.

    Sometimes if you are cutting extreme calories, its easier to adopt a smaller eating window so your food becomes more filling.
    Macronutrients will play a huge key role in this as their settings are what decides how satiated you are throughout the day.


    On a small cut at the moment of around 1lb a week average, aiming for 8lb fat loss total (3lb down already)
    3 days Full body workout per week, No cardio as yet as my diet is almost perfect. Im literally eating to fuel my worouts, no treats.
    Take a look at my food diary, you really dont have to eat carrot sticks alone.

    Truth!
    All about calories in calories out.

    Your hormones dont agree.
    Keep protein high, fat relatively high, carbs moderate, plenty of water, pretty much what 90% of people on here advise!
    Give it time, you dont actually need cardio as it can be detrimental to fat loss. What i mean is, if your diet is almost spot on and your strength training, then you'll want your calories to repair/rebuild. why waste calories on the treadmill? just eat sensibly.
    I feel that maybe people hit the cardio as they feel it justifies the fact that they can eat more and get away with it?
    I've personally lost more weight on a cut when eating right, little or no cardio and consistent strength training, rather than hours on the treadmill!
    Good luck.

    Best advice ive seen today.
  • beccah88
    beccah88 Posts: 57 Member
    I eat 3 meals a day, with 1 or 2 snacks depending on what they are. I tried eating more small meals instead of 3 but like you I hated it. It's worked for me so far, I've lost about 7 inches all round and I'm probably fitter than I've been in a long time.
  • MashaSK
    MashaSK Posts: 142 Member
    and how long do you do strength training per day?
  • beccah88
    beccah88 Posts: 57 Member
    On a small cut at the moment of around 1lb a week average, aiming for 8lb fat loss total (3lb down already)
    3 days Full body workout per week, No cardio as yet as my diet is almost perfect. Im literally eating to fuel my worouts, no treats.
    Take a look at my food diary, you really dont have to eat carrot sticks alone. All about calories in calories out.
    Keep protein high, fat relatively high, carbs moderate, plenty of water, pretty much what 90% of people on here advise!
    Give it time, you dont actually need cardio as it can be detrimental to fat loss. What i mean is, if your diet is almost spot on and your strength training, then you'll want your calories to repair/rebuild. why waste calories on the treadmill? just eat sensibly.
    I feel that maybe people hit the cardio as they feel it justifies the fact that they can eat more and get away with it?
    I've personally lost more weight on a cut when eating right, little or no cardio and consistent strength training, rather than hours on the treadmill!
    Good luck.

    Best advice I've seen. I wish I'd had someone tell me this years ago. I've had better results with doing very little cardio, with strength training instead than I ever did with doing cardio almost everyday.
  • 01divey
    01divey Posts: 50 Member
    You have to work out whats best for you, if you dont like cardio, dont do it although it could be beneficial for your heart/respiratory system, it can be detrimental to fat loss.
    I wish i had known this years ago, but thats the joys of working out and experimenting as i have found a way that suits me, and it feels like a great achievement on its own!
    i never believed diet was so important until i followed it consistently and saw the results for myself.
    i switched from brown rice, pasta, bagels etc to salad, fruit, vegetables and that switch alone made a huge difference after two weeks of how and where have water retention. The bloated feeling disappeared after around a week.
    Im very happy with my results of the last month, and i wish you all well.
    Remember, diet is key.
  • 01divey
    01divey Posts: 50 Member
    @ Mashenka85

    I strength train mon, wed, fri, in general but may switch to tues, thurs, sunday some weeks. i do it when i feel im ready and have sufficiently recovered from the last workout otherwise i wont be working out as well as i could and could actually be slowing down my progress. I know i dont HAVE to do it JUST BECAUSE its a monday or a wednesday. Thats why people find it hard to be consistent. as they feel they have to do it, and its a routine so it gets boring.
    I workout for an average of 45-60 mins 3 times a week, short rest periods, Full Body compound based movements @ approx 80% maximum.
    Rest is very important.
  • kennie2
    kennie2 Posts: 1,170 Member
    having small meals just stops you binging and endlessly snacking
    but if youre fine having 2-3 thats awesome and doesnt have any benefits or withdraws on weight loss
  • Zichu
    Zichu Posts: 542 Member
    I usually have about 3 meals a day with snacks. Depending on what I have for breakfast will determine whether or not I have a second meal a few hours later. If I am only have Ready Brek and fruit, I tend to be really hungry a few hours later so I had turkey sausage, eggs and sugar and salt reduced baked beans.

    My snacks tend to be around 200 to 300 calories at times. I'm currently eating 2121 calories a day, so my meals are usually split up into 500 to 600 calories which leaves me 170 for my protein shake and fruit for the remaining 150 calories. At times though, if I have reached my protein goal for the day before a protein shake, I tend to go for more fruit instead of going for a protein shake.


    If you aren't hungry at 5am, don't force yourself to eat... No good comes from forcing yourself to eat if you feel uncomfortable or even nauseous... I wish I were like you, when I get up at 5:30am I am hungry pretty much instantly, but I only have like 5 or 10 minutes to get out of the house which is mainly getting dressed, comb hair and off we go. I'm only out till 7:10am though, but I still wait it out a bit till everyone has gone to school or work before I cook something up. I would just get in peoples way if I were to start cooking up sausage, egg and beans while people are getting ready lol.

    Also, don't be worried about what people think if you snack on carrot or cucumber sticks. If you enjoy it, just do it. They will most likely be jealous that you are able to sustain a healthy diet while they snack on there biscuits, cakes and chocolate lol.
  • laddyboy
    laddyboy Posts: 1,565 Member
    Bump to read later.
  • Anonymou5
    Anonymou5 Posts: 92
    I don't understand why doesnt cardio work for losing fat?

    Is it not just calories out - calories in?!
  • rsward
    rsward Posts: 45
    bump
  • anoroc751
    anoroc751 Posts: 57 Member
    I think people confuse what 5 meals per day means. Snacks count. It only meant to eat so that you are never super hungry. It will help increase your metabolism and help keep you from overeating througout the day. Meals are meals, regardless of the food or the time of day you it them.

    As for cardio. I do agree that many will benefit from a good weightlifting program alone. This increases your metabolism throughout the day. Too much cardio without enough calories can eat away at your muscles.

    On the other hand a good ballance is good if that's what you want. I like to do 5ks, warrior dashes and I am training for a tough mudder. I want to have a strong cardio side to help me get through it.

    I know several people at the gym who look good and only weight lift but they readily admit they have poor cardio strength. To each his own just do what is best for you.

    Good luck and keep moving.
  • 01divey
    01divey Posts: 50 Member
    @ Samuel Gray

    Dont get me wrong, doing cardio doesnt mean you WONT lose weight. I just meant that you dont have too. I dont like cardio particuarly, unless im playing sport or doing something fun for example.
    You can lose weight, and feel bettery by following a good solid balanced diet, and following a consistent strength training program.
    I was simply offering a glimmer of hope of an alternative to all those people that hate cardo :)
  • 01divey
    01divey Posts: 50 Member
    * better
  • Anonymou5
    Anonymou5 Posts: 92
    Oh , right. I happen to love cardio! So anyone out there who likes cardio don't just give up your cardio workouts as I believe you can lose weight with a purely cardio program. (No disrespect to strength programmes as I know alot of people who enjoy them)
  • jetabear10
    jetabear10 Posts: 375 Member
    I don't have meals per se...I just eat all day long. I do have "lunch" and "dinner"

    Every couple of hours or so, I am eating something. During the day I feel like I don't stop eating! lol
  • JenaePavlak
    JenaePavlak Posts: 350 Member
    i eat 5-7 times a day... A typical day:

    5am: Protien Powder w/1 cup milk
    8am: 3 whole scrambled eggs w/2 cups broccoli, onions, green &red peppers & Chobani Greek yogurt
    11am: Detour Lean Protein Bar
    1pm: Chicken & Mixed veggies or chicken breast & salad
    3pm: (Depending on if I'm hungry) chicken and/or veggies
    5pm: Detour Lean Protein Bar
    7pm: Chicken or Ham wrap or a previously made hotdish (basically beef, egg noodles, veggies, & cream of chicken...) maybe chick w/veggies and brown rice...

    I do the protein drink right away in the morning (tastes just like choc. milk) to stop the fasting process because that is when your body is most likely to use your lean muscle for fuel instead of fat.
  • Anonymou5
    Anonymou5 Posts: 92
    With regards to meals I usually have:

    6:00am - 400ml natural yoghurt + coffee w/milk
    6:30 - 8am - training
    8:30am - Porridge w/protein powder and milk
    12:00pm - jacket potato w/chicken, salad, tuna
    3:00pm - porridge w/milk
    4:00pm-5:15pm - training
    5:45 - 4/6 eggs
    7:30pm - tea (meat protein + non refined carbs)

    This is based on my training program though
  • Cocochickdeleted
    Cocochickdeleted Posts: 342 Member
    I just skimmed the replies, but here is my 'unscientific' take on things; this is what worked for me and my husband. I have lost about 30 pounds and he's lost almost 50. We eat only when we are hungry. I tend to eat 3 or 4 times a day. I hate eating breakfast, but I started when all the 'wiser' people said it was the only way to lose weight. I stopped after joining the intermittent fasting group. I only eat breakfast IF I'm hungry. I grew up with the three-meal-a-day mentality, and that is what I'm comfortable with, but for those who prefer to eat more often, there is nothing wrong with that. As long as you stay in your calorie range, you will lose weight.

    As far as exercising goes, hubby and I love to walk. We started out walking about two miles and day and gradually bumped up to walking at least 3 1/2 miles almost every day. When we first started, I hated getting out of my chair to do it, but I forced myself. Then, in January, I bought a Fitbit, and it did wonders for motivating me to walk. Now, if I don't get at least 10K steps, I feel like I cheated myself. Those who say that cardio isn't necessary to lose weight are correct, but cardio will speed the loss. It's a calorie burn. Strength training also burns calories, and muscle mass does speed up the metabolism, but it takes a long time to build substantial muscle mass, so the benefits aren't going to come overnight.

    On another personal note, I now love cardio so much that I started running, and I recently signed up for my first 5K. So, for those of you who hate cardio; if you make time to do it, and continue to do it for about a month, chances are that you will begin to enjoy it. I think I'm addicted to the endorphins.
  • MizCJ84
    MizCJ84 Posts: 335 Member
    Are you serious? I eat healthy snacks all day long in my office because I care way more about my health than how my snacking effects the rest of the world. You are already in great shape, so I would say keep doing what you are doing anyway.
  • joejccva71
    joejccva71 Posts: 2,985 Member
    You can eat 5-6 meals a day or 2-3. It doesn't matter. Meal timing is irrelevant. It's all personal preference.
  • raiderrodney
    raiderrodney Posts: 617 Member
    You can eat 5-6 meals a day or 2-3. It doesn't matter. Meal timing is irrelevant. It's all personal preference.

    This is the truth! I used to stress over getting 5-6 small meals in for years and it's all bs.

    Stay under your calorie goals...period. It's more important than exercise, when you eat, what you eat, cardio, weights, and on and on. NOTHING works better than simply staying under your calorie goal ;)
  • Mollydolly10
    Mollydolly10 Posts: 431 Member
    I eat 6-7 times a day. I also workout 5-6 days a week (alternating running and strength training). I find I get hungry about every 2-3 hours!

    Breakfast (7:30am)
    Snack (10am)
    Lunch (12pm)
    Snack (2pm)
    Snack (4pm)
    Dinner (6:30pm)
    [Dessert or late snack (9pm)]

    I manage to stay under calories, it works for me! :-) but the key is not letting yourself get to the point where you are STARVING and would eat anything, haha. If that means 2-3 meals or 7 meals, whatever works, it's the calories (and content) that counts!
  • hpsnickers1
    hpsnickers1 Posts: 2,783 Member
    Sometimes I eat only one BIG meal. When I was trying to eat 5-6 times a day my entire day revolved around food.

    I usually have 2 meals. Unless you count coffee with cream and/or coconut oil a meal. I guess that could be.

    I've even gone 40 hours without food. True hunger is an amazing feeling. Almost euphoric. My energy levels increase. And my digestive system gets a rest. It's exhausting to the body when you are digesting food all day (takes about 5-6 hours for the digestion process to complete). And if there is no food in your system - what does your body do? Uses its own "resources" (fat!!) for fuel.

    If you aren't hungry then don't eat. If you are hungry then eat. Listen to your body. It will tell you the right thing to do.

    My general view is our ancestors probably just did some "grazing" here and there throughout the day and had the biggest meal of the day in the evening after "hunting and gathering" all day. They didn't worry about getting food immediately upon waking because "breakfast is the most important meal of the day".
  • kdiamond
    kdiamond Posts: 3,329 Member
    Yes.

    Some days I only have 1 meal.
  • TheBraveryLover
    TheBraveryLover Posts: 1,217 Member
    A lot of the people who do intermittent fasting do 2 meals a day. I used to do it (IF) before my current work schedule so my body got used to the 2 meals and I'm still eating like that. 1 moderate meal before work/after workout and a huge meal for my second meal. This is usually only 5 days a week and on my off days I tend to eat more times since I go out for drinks, but I tend to stick with it during my work week. I'll sometimes have snacks but that's only if I haven't met my protein goal.
  • JenMull44
    JenMull44 Posts: 226 Member
    I work two jobs and do not have time to eat 5-6 times a day. I feel happy and full with three miles. I also run four days a week and have a snack imbetween my three meals. I think 5-6 is alright if you are burning that many calories.
This discussion has been closed.