Can You Lose By Simply Eating Less of The Stuff You Eat Now?

2»

Replies

  • Meaganandcheese
    Meaganandcheese Posts: 525 Member
    I think when you're first starting you, you pick your battles. A calorie deficit is critical, and exercise is good for you (also allows you to eat more). You can't really flub on that part and expect to lose.

    Now, in terms of what you're eating - I think that's an evolution. If soda is a priority for you to keep in your diet, you might have to trade some other things to balance it out (or workout more to earn it). In my personal experience, I started out by still eating a lot of junky things (in moderation), but I've slowly moved towards my diet consisting mainly of cleaner, more nutritionally dense things. I've realized the quality of the calories are just as important as the quantity. I still eat those foods, just not as frequently. I would say the 80/20 rule is my happy place - I lose consistently and still live my life without feeling restricted. It's something I know I can sustain, because I arrived at that place almost unconsciously over time.

    Sometimes it's about baby steps, and that is ok. This is your journey. If cutting out soda is unrealistic right now, you can start by cutting back this week. Next week, add another goal (maybe cutting back on what you're calling junk). And you build it up from there.
  • rininger85
    rininger85 Posts: 131
    Less is always better but also what you eat is more important. Some tips from my trainer: Cardio in the morning before you eat. Eat a healthy and large breakfast. It should be the largest meal of the day. Eat a snack only if you are hungry. Eat a moderately sized lunch. Eat a light dinner. Do strength training in the evening. Don't eat after 9 pm. Get 7 - 8 hours rest. Repeat.

    Well, honestly, doesn't matter when you work out. Doesn't matter how late you eat
    Doesn't matter how big your meals are. Doesn't matter how often you eat.

    what the trainer is getting at is if you do cardio in the morning before you eat it helps "jump start" your metabolism from being inactive (sleeping). So you will burn more calories while eating breakfast if you jump start your metabolism first rather than just sitting down and eating breakfast. And the strength training at night is because strength training takes a big toll on your muscles which need to be able to repair themselves, so by strength training at night it allows your body to repair muscles while you are sleeping. Strength training also burns calories for a longer period of time than cardio (regardless of when you do it) because it takes calories to repair the muscles, but doing the strength training at night allows you to continue burning more calories in your sleep. The same concept goes for not eating late at night, you aren't as active at night/when you are sleeping so your metabolism slows down, thats why they say don't eat late at night... you don't have to follow those guidelines, but you will see better results if you do follow them.

    As far as what you eat - I agree with the above posts, you can still continue to eat whatever you want as long as you control your portion size. You will have better results if you choose to eat healthier and are less likely to regain the weight if you change your diet to healthier foods, but I lost 30 pounds in 3 months mostly by decreasing my portion size... I still ate chinese buffet and/or boneless hot wings on average once a week or more, but I ate smaller portions (I also increased my exercise as well)... then I quit working out and slowly put all of the weight back on and then more because I quit tracking my food when I quit working out so I slowly allowed myself to eat bigger and bigger portion sizes until I was right back where I was (plus 10 additional pounds)... if you choose to eat healthier you are probably less likely to regain the weight than just changing portion sizes... but I'm back at it again and shooting to lose 50+lbs this time around and maintain it this time (while still eating the same foods just smaller sizes, so now that I found MFP and have it on my cell phone I'll hopefully continue tracking my food even after I hit my goal whereas before I had a hand written paper that I kept track of my foods on which wasn't convenient so I quit tracking....)
  • jrupe47371
    jrupe47371 Posts: 3 Member
    I had great luck switching from soda to unsweetened iced tea. It literally costs pennies to brew a pitcher of tea at home and I still get my caffeine. Plus, there are the added benefits of antioxidants. If I'm in a pinch most convenience stores have fresh brewed tea available for 69-79 cents a glass or a large tea at McDonald's is only $1.
  • jfields42
    jfields42 Posts: 27
    Hi J Fields....Sorry you are having a rough go of it right now....I hope things change soon..
    Have you tried things like beans and legumes...Chillies, stews etc....Look them up on the net...Get ideas for very nutritious recipes..

    Thanks. Hopefully, I pass the bar exam and get a job soon!!!

    I love chili, but never had legumes(may have to try them). Might have to try a turkey chili(is that healthier?)

    "Sprite Zero tastes just like regular to me!"

    really? gonna def have to try that.
  • channa007
    channa007 Posts: 419 Member
    Yes you need a deficit in calories. It doesn't matter what you eat. Do this and you'll lose weight even without exercise.
  • luvjsmile
    luvjsmile Posts: 1 Member
    I totally agree! instead of a eating the whole pizza only eat a cpl slices. But I have a cheat day where I eat what I want. Or if I have a strong craving I just go ahead and take care of it, cause if I dont, I will it eat:smile: up everything plus what I originally wanted. Eating healthy doesnt have to be expensive. I am unemployed and I still manage.I buy whatever fruit on sale for the week, I pretty much eat chicken legs everyday, wether its baked many different ways, or boiled and shredded into some steamed frozen veggies. I think ppl find ways to lose weight regardless of how Broke we are if you really wanna change!!
  • thechubner
    thechubner Posts: 94 Member
    Yes it's all about calories in vs calories out, but keeping your body properly nourished during the process is important too. The good news is that most veggies are cheap and you can munch on them whenever you want w/o much consequence to your food diary. So go ahead and eat mom's lasagna, but if you have 2 cups of raw spinach w/ it it's only going to add 15 calories, but lots of vitimins. Good Luck
  • jemachharo
    jemachharo Posts: 144 Member
    Many people are able to lose simply by eating less of what they normally eat. If you are one of those people, you are blessed. For others, like me, WHAT I eat is actually more important than the number of calories I consume. I have an intolerance to gluten which screws up my body and actually makes me gain weight. I have similar issues with other starches. I have found I can eat over 2000 calories of lean proteins, fruit and veggies every day and easily lose weight. I can eat 1200 calories including starches and processed food and gain weight. All food is NOT created equal for me. Definitely start by cutting out sodas and junk food and see how your body reacts. If you find you still have issues, try cutting out processed foods and see what it does for you.

    Eating healthy does not have to be expensive. Our grocery bill is actually lower now since I cut out buying processed foods and buy everything fresh.
  • Sarahbara76
    Sarahbara76 Posts: 601 Member
    I lost 30 pounds 9 years ago by simply cutting my portions down to half the size I would normally eat. I still eat the same amount my stomach shrunk. These last 5-6 pounds are vanity pounds that help my running time if I shed them. Good luck!
  • Drawberry
    Drawberry Posts: 104 Member
    I know it sounds simple and I'm sure the answer is yes...but, will the results be good. I'm staying with the rents to study for the upcoming bar exam in late July.

    I plan to workout and try to lose some weight during this period. Problem is that I am broke and do not plan to work during this time. This means that I won't be as able to buy healthy foods. If I just workout/cardio and portion control can I still lose a pound per week? I really want to get down to 217-220 before my birthday in mid July,

    I mean right now I drink so much soda and eat junk food. I would imagine simply cutting those out would do wonders?

    If you cut out calories you'll lose weight even without exercise.

    Example.
    Say it takes you 2000 calories to maintain your current weight and for the sake of argument say you live a mostly sedentary lifestyle. Take away 500 calories to get 1500 calories for what you should be maintaining to lose weight even if you stay mostly sedentary.


    At the very simplest of things to lose weight you need to burn more then you consume.
  • Flab2fitfi
    Flab2fitfi Posts: 1,349 Member
    I've cut out my really bad snacks and eating late at night but the rest of my diet is the same - I just serve up a smaller portion or look for a lower calorie version eg slightly less mince in my spag bol. As i see it this is a change in my eating habits not a diet so its something I have to be able to live with. The other reason is that I cook the main meal for six of us and doing something different is not an option especially as we already have enough issues with food intolerances and a child with autism who is fussy.
  • raayfrancy
    raayfrancy Posts: 100
    If you cut off soda, alone, that will help tremendously in the long-run (: ... like the wise say, "don't drink your calories!"

    I wish you the best! Any effort towards losing weight at all helps - one step at a time.
  • jfields42
    jfields42 Posts: 27
    this is actually the hard part for me. When I'm not stressed over deadlines for school(I am a stress eater), I usually am very active. I have trouble knowing how many calories I burn during these activities.
  • tammisr32
    tammisr32 Posts: 38 Member
    Here is what I read that helps me say no to soda.... hope it helps. It can make a huge difference :drinker: If you cut one and not the other, I would cut out the soda, it makes you crave more sugary things anyway. Who knows, maybe if you cut out one, the other will follow without you even thinking about it.

    They contribute to obesity as well as diabetes, tooth decay and weakened bones. They have also been linked to depleting the body of vitamin A, calcium and magnesium--all nutrients needed for healthy weight loss. Consuming soda also has a profound effect on the taste buds. Some research suggests that soda, even diet soda, can actually make you feel hungrier given the artificial sweeteners that signal the brain to crave extra food. This can make losing weight a lot more difficult. In addition, according to a study by the University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio, diet soda actually enhances weight gain by as much as 41 percent.
    Estimates show that two cans or glasses of soda per day adds approximately 24 to 35 pounds of fat per year, depending on body size, age, habits, etc.. Some people (weighing in at 140 pounds) have reported that by giving up two cans of soda per day, without exercise, they lost 20 pounds in six months. Add in exercise, reduce other sugar intake, eat more fruits and vegetables, add high water consumption and you could possibly be ready to fit into those jeans within six weeks. But if cutting out soda altogether is too difficult, you could replace one soda per day with water. Cutting down from two per day to one can yields about a 16 pound yearly loss.
  • christyd4
    christyd4 Posts: 191
    most people have said it ...it's all about portion control.and more calories out than in....maybe instead of 4 a day start with 1 a day and see if you can move to 1 every other day. I don't deprive myself but I try to eat healthly 90 percent of the time. That is my personal choice. as for working out. Maybe download C25K and run during that time. If you have a smart phone the app is free and it costs nothting to run.
  • 2FattyXFatty4
    2FattyXFatty4 Posts: 215 Member
    I know it sounds simple and I'm sure the answer is yes...but, will the results be good. I'm staying with the rents to study for the upcoming bar exam in late July.

    I plan to workout and try to lose some weight during this period. Problem is that I am broke and do not plan to work during this time. This means that I won't be as able to buy healthy foods. If I just workout/cardio and portion control can I still lose a pound per week? I really want to get down to 217-220 before my birthday in mid July,

    I mean right now I drink so much soda and eat junk food. I would imagine simply cutting those out would do wonders?

    Yup, you can. Check out the "Eat This, Not That" series of books and the accompaniment website. This is basically the concept of replacing what you eat now with lower calorie portions of the same foods.
  • ariant23
    ariant23 Posts: 161 Member
    i might have to be a smidge snarky here... i'm fairly certain you've consumed legumes before. it's the botanical term for all beans / peas, including peanuts. (where did you go to law school??? c'mon, vocabulary is of tantamount importance).

    But in all seriousness, good luck on the Bar. :heart:

    and in theory turkey chili is "better" than beef chili because the leaner turkey would have less calories. but you can just use very lean beef and obtain the same thing (with more taste, and manly red meat, my husband despises things like "turkey" chili).

    ETA: people have talked about "calorie/nutritionally dense" things... some of that can be misleading when your concern is not starving and feeling deprived all day. I personally worry about my "calories to bites ratio (C2BR)" I like it to be as LOW as possible... ie, lots of bites, few calories. most fresh veggies will do that for you. beans, while yummy and good for you, have a high-ish C2BR as they are a starchy protein i've always loved seaweed salad, and just found it at my local costco in the deli area, and it's totally low C2BR :-).
    Hi J Fields....Sorry you are having a rough go of it right now....I hope things change soon..
    Have you tried things like beans and legumes...Chillies, stews etc....Look them up on the net...Get ideas for very nutritious recipes..

    Thanks. Hopefully, I pass the bar exam and get a job soon!!!

    I love chili, but never had legumes(may have to try them). Might have to try a turkey chili(is that healthier?)

    "Sprite Zero tastes just like regular to me!"

    really? gonna def have to try that.
  • 2FattyXFatty4
    2FattyXFatty4 Posts: 215 Member
    ... and cut out the Lakers and you will see a difference :wink: :laugh:

    Clever. LOL!
  • jfields42
    jfields42 Posts: 27
    i might have to be a smidge snarky here... i'm fairly certain you've consumed legumes before. it's the botanical term for all beans / peas, including peanuts. (where did you go to law school??? c'mon, vocabulary is of tantamount importance).

    But in all seriousness, good luck on the Bar. :heart:

    and in theory turkey chili is "better" than beef chili because the leaner turkey would have less calories. but you can just use very lean beef and obtain the same thing (with more taste, and manly red meat, my husband despises things like "turkey" chili).
    Hi J Fields....Sorry you are having a rough go of it right now....I hope things change soon..
    Have you tried things like beans and legumes...Chillies, stews etc....Look them up on the net...Get ideas for very nutritious recipes..

    Thanks. Hopefully, I pass the bar exam and get a job soon!!!

    I love chili, but never had legumes(may have to try them). Might have to try a turkey chili(is that healthier?)

    "Sprite Zero tastes just like regular to me!"

    really? gonna def have to try that.

    law school? obviously somewhere that would be ashamed of my vocabulary :laugh: .
    ... and cut out the Lakers and you will see a difference :wink: :laugh:

    Clever. LOL!

    ohh...can't cut out the greatest sports franchise of all time!!
  • tsh0ck
    tsh0ck Posts: 1,970 Member
    Less is always better but also what you eat is more important. Some tips from my trainer: Cardio in the morning before you eat. Eat a healthy and large breakfast. It should be the largest meal of the day. Eat a snack only if you are hungry. Eat a moderately sized lunch. Eat a light dinner. Do strength training in the evening. Don't eat after 9 pm. Get 7 - 8 hours rest. Repeat.

    Well, honestly, doesn't matter when you work out. Doesn't matter how late you eat
    Doesn't matter how big your meals are. Doesn't matter how often you eat.

    what the trainer is getting at is if you do cardio in the morning before you eat it helps "jump start" your metabolism from being inactive (sleeping). So you will burn more calories while eating breakfast if you jump start your metabolism first rather than just sitting down and eating breakfast. And the strength training at night is because strength training takes a big toll on your muscles which need to be able to repair themselves, so by strength training at night it allows your body to repair muscles while you are sleeping. Strength training also burns calories for a longer period of time than cardio (regardless of when you do it) because it takes calories to repair the muscles, but doing the strength training at night allows you to continue burning more calories in your sleep. The same concept goes for not eating late at night, you aren't as active at night/when you are sleeping so your metabolism slows down, thats why they say don't eat late at night... you don't have to follow those guidelines, but you will see better results if you do follow them.

    sorry. incorrect, dated info here.
  • crazysexykoo
    crazysexykoo Posts: 129 Member
    no need...they're doing it to themselves.... #byebyeLakers LOL! :)
This discussion has been closed.