Six Small Meals

hthrld
hthrld Posts: 125 Member
edited December 19 in Food and Nutrition
Any tips on eating several small meals a day? I am so clueless on when/what to eat. Help.

Replies

  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,337 Member
    No tips as I don't do it. I did it for the first six months of my weight loss, hated every minute of it as I was never satisfied with my meal size. Then I discovered there is no benefit to doing it unless it is an eating pattern that works for you. Here is a good write up on meal frequency http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/529002-a-compliation-on-meal-frequency

    For me 3 meals a day is ideal. If you prefer six go for it. But, if you are simply going to six because many people say you have to, the reality is you don't. There is no difference in weight loss or metabolism between many small meals or few big ones as long at the total calories eaten remains the same.
  • melsinct
    melsinct Posts: 3,512 Member
    Agreed, there is zero benefit unless it is just how you like to eat. You won't get any thinner, faster. I prefer three bigger meals plus a snack or two thrown in. 6 small meals would be very unsatisfying for me.
  • myfitnessnmhoy
    myfitnessnmhoy Posts: 2,105 Member
    There is zero caloric benefit, but that's how I eat. If I don't, I get more hungry between "meals". So I have a very small breakfast and eat my bagged lunch over the course of about 7 hours (10-5), then when I get home I have a sensible dinner and a bedtime snack/dessert.

    This is the most effective way I've found to stay within my caloric budget, and it's the only reason I do it - my blood sugar stays more steady-state and I'm less hungry. In fact, I often find myself skipping parts of my lunch and having to make up the difference at supper.

    Here's what I pack:
    - One small turkey-and-cheese wrap in a wheat tortilla, cut in half.
    - One quart bag about half to 3/4 full of various raw veggies I like.
    - One each Apple, Banana, Clementine ("cutie").
    - One of the teeny little tupperware containers with almonds, walnuts, and sunflower seeds.
    - One large thermos hot coffee.

    My general schedule:
    - Drink the coffee when I get to work, sipping it and making it last until about 10-11.
    - When I start getting a bit peckish, eat half the wrap.
    - An hour later, eat the other half. This usually keeps me full until my workout at about 1-2PM
    - After the workout: Eat the banana and, if I'm hungry for it, the nuts (always eat the nuts if I've been doing any weights for the protein).
    - About 4-4:30, if I'm hungry for them, eat the apple and/or clementine.

    I usually end up taking 1-2 things home. If I skip my workout, I won't eat the nuts and one of the pieces of fruit to save calories for a decent supper.

    But, as several people have already said, there is really no health benefit to this. I just find it an effective tool to keep me from getting hungry, and eating this way has allowed me to be satisfied with much smaller meals, for example when I go out to eat - the concept of eating what I used to in one sitting is too much. So it's a tool I use to maintain better control over my overall caloric intake, not based on some mythical timing of calories being somehow beneficial.
  • SwimKitty
    SwimKitty Posts: 122 Member
    First figure out what your normal tendency is - do you like to eat small meals often? Or do you prefer a larger, more filling meal 2 to 3 times a day?

    I did lose quite a bit of weight (35 pounds) eating 5 to 6 times a day. Problem was, this is not my preferred method of eating, so I burned out eventually and couldn't keep it up. I like real food and felt like I was in the kitchen all day, cooking. Plus, I was NEVER a breakfast eater - I'm happy with just coffee.

    This time around, I don't eat breakfast (intermittent fasting), have a big late lunch, moderate dinner, and a depending on hunger, a pretty good bedtime snack. I am much more satisfied, compliant, and have gone down 3 pants sizes. I have lots of energy and can exercise much better in the morning on an empty stomach, too.

    I eat all my calories (1800+ depending on activity), with a minimum of 120 grams of protein, 60 grams of fat, and the rest good carb choices.

    Best to listen to your body in this regard - you'll be much happier and more compliant with your plan.

    Good luck :)
  • randa_behnam
    randa_behnam Posts: 488 Member
    I eat three main meals a day and enjoy them thoroughly, my snacks if I want them are fruit and the odd biscuit with my tea :) more than satisfied!
  • karinefitness
    karinefitness Posts: 336 Member
    I eat all the time!

    I have breakfast around 7am, then I snack at 10, eat lunch at noon, snack again at 3 and have dinner at 6-7 pm. I will also have a protein shake at night after my workout.

    If I don't eat 6 times a day, I get hungry and I get (carbs/sugar) cravings. But that's just me... I know it doesn't apply to everyone.

    My meals are regular meals like turkey chili, fish with some veggies (and sometimes brown rice or quinoa), tuna salad, etc. As for snacks, I like greek yogurt with berries, string cheese, almonds, turkey/tuna, protein bars (homemade or not when I am lazy), etc.
  • Flixie00
    Flixie00 Posts: 1,195 Member
    I eat small meals throughout the day, and like the above poster, this stops me from feeling hungry. My diary is open if you want to browse. I will warn you though, its far from perfect.
  • deniseearheart
    deniseearheart Posts: 919 Member
    I eat two main meals and snacks... not going to eat anymore than I am hungry for or less.. the weight is coming off but slowly
  • zgdsmith
    zgdsmith Posts: 114 Member
    I eat 3 meals & at least 3 snacks a day. Although, my snacks and meals are usually around the same amount of calories. I've tried eating just 3 meals a day and i find that i'm constantly feeling hungry if i don't eat every 3 hours. I also don't feel as tired if i eat somethign small more often. I also try and eat lots of protein.

    Feel free to add me as a friend.
  • Kissybiz
    Kissybiz Posts: 361 Member
    I generally eat three meals with three snacks if I want them.. my meals usually always include a balance of carbs, fats and protein. So far I've been losing steadily. I eat when I'm hungry...

    Love this site.. I don't diet anymore, I just track what I eat and stop before I get to my food limit. Exercise more if I go over. Works for me.
  • Emancipated_Tai
    Emancipated_Tai Posts: 751 Member
    I eat about 5 meals a day. Feel free to check my diary. No real rules, just stay within my allotment. I'm set at 1700, but I'm usually more close to 1800-1900. I don't mind going over since I usually burn between 800-900 calories thru exercise. Plus I'm under my TDEE. I like eating this way becuase just when im getting hungry its time to eat again! I space my meals starting at 8am - 8pm every 2 1/2 to 3 hours.
  • dlwyatt82
    dlwyatt82 Posts: 1,077 Member
    I'm not sure about eating 6 actual "meals"; my plan involves 3 meals and 3 "snacks", spaced about 2-3 hours apart. For the snacks, I target 150 calories each and eat either some baby carrots and hummus, or a granola bar, that kind of thing.
  • SandyAnnP
    SandyAnnP Posts: 252 Member
    I prefer 3 decent meals a day with a couple of healthy snacks if I am really hungry or if my meal is going to be later for some reason. I try to choose for snacks, non fat/ low sugar yoghurt, a piece of fruit, a low calorie muesli type bar, or homemade low fat sweet or savory muffin. This has worked for me so far and I have lost over 26 lbs since February, and I have eaten out quite a bit as well, but try to cut back the next day as in, perhaps just fruit for lunch and veg soup and a roll for dinner but I NEVER miss a meal.
  • misticache
    misticache Posts: 364 Member
    I am just starting to get the hang of eating all day long and while I don't lose quickly I'm more satisfied and happy. I lose about a pound a week so this is a slow and steady race. I am still working on eliminating a few bad habits (damn cookies) but I'm getting there. This is how my day went:

    6:30am small coffee
    7:00am Cream of wheat
    9:00am Hard boiled egg
    12:00 Chicken Salad Wrap, Fresh cut veggies, tbsp peanut butter, string cheese
    3:00pm 1 small avocado
    4:30 Hard Boiled Egg
    5:30 Corn on Cob with spray butter, and a Hamburger (no bun)

    8 -10 glasses of water all day long

    My total calorie intake will be just under 1200 so I will probably eat an apple at 7:00pm

    I don't get hungry as much and just about when I start getting hungry it's only minutes away from meal time so I think I have finally trained my mind.
  • Shock_Wave
    Shock_Wave Posts: 1,573 Member
    I also eat kinda small/er meals just because I do not like to cram in huge meals all at once because I get that aweful feeling of food coma and it makes me to lethargic for hours afterwards which can make it almost impossible to work out for me, so no thank you.

    Breakfast
    Shake
    Lunch
    Shake
    Snack <--optional
    Dinner

    Edit: A guide line what to eat in can be in your macros, Protein/Carbs/Fat. Input food as you intake food and you can figure out what you can and cannot have. It can be kind of fun to play around with.
  • Inebriated
    Inebriated Posts: 271
    Agreed, there is zero benefit unless it is just how you like to eat. You won't get any thinner, faster. I prefer three bigger meals plus a snack or two thrown in. 6 small meals would be very unsatisfying for me.
  • I think there are so many resources about nutrition it can be really confusing.

    I personally enjoy eating 6 small meals, but that's hard to maintain on the weekends. I've been following the Venice Nutrition guideline by Mark McDonald where each meal is approximately 1/3 Fat, 1/3 Protein, 1/3 Carb.

    I try to keep each meal around 250 calories. Eating this way keeps me from feeling hunger pains, it's curbed sugar and carb cravings. I'm also saving money because all of my meals are pre-planned. However, I can't say much about any weight loss (I blame my weekend binges). All I know is my calories are a lot less than what they used to be, I have a TON of energy (I need less sleep and I exercise a lot harder), and I'm not hungry (therefore not fantasizing about food). I'm sure the weight loss will happen for me, so I'm going to be patient with it.
  • hthrld
    hthrld Posts: 125 Member
    Thanks to everyone for their input. This was suggested to me by my trainer. I tried it today, and I found when I ate more frequently, it took less to satisfy me. I also ate less calories throughout the day. I found before I was really craving carbs and sugar. I would also get so hungry between meals that I would eat whatever I could get my hands on to satisfy me. I didn't experience this today. I think I will try this for a while. :)
  • buttzy237
    buttzy237 Posts: 3
    Another good idea with eating 6 meals a day is varying your daily recommended carb intake. So for example reduce your daily

    carb intake by half, the next day increase your daily carb intake by a half... repeat this day in and out but have one day where you

    eat just your daily recommended carb intake...this helps keep your metabolism burning (body guessing) so you store less and

    use more.....
  • simplysassi
    simplysassi Posts: 137 Member
    I have eaten six meals a day for many years. In reality it isn't 6 full meals, more like 6 half meals. It works for me because I prefer not to eat until I'm full/stuffed because then I just feel awful and don't want to move. (That is not to say that there aren't days that I definitely do that, but they are usually few and far between).

    Usually the in between meals are more like snacks/fruit, veggies or maybe a half a cheese sandwich or just something light that will get me through the next couple hours. I find that eating this way helps keep me energized.

    It requires some forethought and planning though for times when you're planning to be out and about. I often keep a softside lunch tote (with ice packs) in the car with me so I can take along some fruits, veggies, cereal, breakfast bar, piece of cheese etc
  • ladyace2078
    ladyace2078 Posts: 460 Member
    My diary is open so you can see what my eating habits look like. I just get too hungry to go longer than 2-3 hours without eating.
This discussion has been closed.