Anyone on 1200kcals a day?
Warley_x
Posts: 62
Hi Everyone! I am 5'4 and currently weight 137lbs, looking to get to 126lbs for my holiday in July (profile pic is my inspiration).
My question is, how many of you out there are on 1200kcals a day and how are you finding it? Many people on here say it's unhealthy and your body is in "starvation mode" etc but I feel fine and often go under my goal for the day.
I currently don't do any exercise (other than walking, cleaning etc) and when I do start to exercise I plan to increase my kcals just like everyone says to do on here. The one day I worked out and ate my 1200kcals plus a bit more for the exercise I put on 2lbs so I dont understand how it works!? All I know is it obviously doesnt work for me eating slightly more and exercising. Am I alone here?!
Confused
x
My question is, how many of you out there are on 1200kcals a day and how are you finding it? Many people on here say it's unhealthy and your body is in "starvation mode" etc but I feel fine and often go under my goal for the day.
I currently don't do any exercise (other than walking, cleaning etc) and when I do start to exercise I plan to increase my kcals just like everyone says to do on here. The one day I worked out and ate my 1200kcals plus a bit more for the exercise I put on 2lbs so I dont understand how it works!? All I know is it obviously doesnt work for me eating slightly more and exercising. Am I alone here?!
Confused
x 0
Replies
-
I'm a bit less than that, unless the alcohol gets involved.
I don't do any formal exercise either, occasionally I'll walk for 30 mins or maybe an hour. Being a bit of a geek I read lots of science etc and aerobic exercise doesn't have a fantastic track record for increasing fat loss.0 -
I assume that girl in your photo isn't you. If it is you, you don't need to change a thing! If it's more an inspiration photo, think about this: that girl works out. Probably a lot. She lifts weights and does other strength exercises in addition to cardio. And she likely eats more than 1200 calories a day to fuel it.
When I first joined (different profile), I ate 1200 calories a day. And you know what, I felt all right. I lost weight, I didn't feel bad, whatever. But eventually I raised my calorie goal. I'm short, so my BMR is pretty low, so I still dont' eat as much as some folks here. But raising that calorie goal helped me feel even better, and I still lost weight. It didn't slow my loss one bit. And I have always eaten all my exercise calories, even the ones from cleaning the house. And sometimes I even eat half a pizza for dinner, and blow my cals right out of the water. And that's ok too. Raising my calorie goal enabled me to get more good nutrition from my food, which in turn gives me more energy for living. That's a wonderful thing.
I'm not saying you absolutely have to eat more than 1200 calories. It's your body, it's your life, you do what you want to do. But I would suggest doing some more research, and looking around the site at the calorie goals of the people who have reached their goals. Check out users like CoryIda, who lost a lot of weight and looks fantastic, and eats more than 1200 calories. Most of the people who are at their goals eat significantly more than 1200, and did all along their journey. Because 1200 calories really isn't that much to fuel your body. Remember, those calories get burned just by living -- they keep your heart beating, your lungs breathing, your eyes blinking, your brain working, your muscles holding you up while you sit in your chair or walk across the room. And they're burning 24 hours a day. So when you move, you're burning even more. You need calories to survive, and if you want to do anything on top of just barely surviving, you need to eat more calories to fuel those body functions.
Above all else, experiment. If this is working for you now, great! But if you feel like you need a change, then try increasing them for a while. Think of this as a flexible process. What works right now might not work as you get closer to your goal weight, and that is normal. Just keep an open mind.0 -
I'm on 1200 but I exercise every weekday for 40 mins - 1 hr. I don't think I'd be able to do it without my exercise as I need those exercise calories to not feel hungry.
I find weekends really difficult as that's when my boyfriend comes over so I don't have time to exercise and end up going out for dinner and going over my calories. I've asked him if he'd like to go on dates to the gym at weekends but he's surprisingly never very enthusiastic...0 -
You are not alone, and, quite simply, science is still struggling to understand this.
Anyone who gives you any strong, immediate opinions on this - is probably just uninformed.
I strongly recommend you read "Good Calories, Bad Calories" by Gary Taubes, otherwise you're just shooting in the dark.
My opinions:
(1) it is all in the kitchen. don't even bother about exercise. you're now in "advanced" weight loss for your last few kilos, so it's all in the kitchen
Whatever you do, DO NOT " ' eat back your exercise calories ' " if you exercise. At your stage of weight loss it is inconceivable you could take that approach (unless you're a marathon runner), so forget that. Read the book, get actual science on your side.
(MFP laughably includes the concept of "eating back your exercise calories" - just ignore it. They'll remove this feature in future versions.)
(2) carbohydrates will be key. you must find an exact intake per day - what about 65 grams per day - of carbohydrates which will make you lose the last few pounds
(3) you should have NO PROBLEM eating only 1200 calories in a day, at your height. Anyone who tells you otherwise is uninformed. I typically eat 1400 cals (I'm also losing the "last few pounds", but I am 6' tall) and I feel stuffed all the time, I can barely eat that much. I experimented with 1200 a day for a couple weeks, and it was perhaps a hair low, I'd feel a little peckish. At your height it should be no problem at all, as long as your pancreas is in good condition.
you'll only feel HUNGRY, like you're not getting enough food, if you eat too much carbs. if you were eating say 125 grams a day of carbs, and only 1200 calories overall, your body would be starving itself, and psychologically you would be bitterly hungry all the time. in contrast if you are eating 70 g of carbs per day, and 1200 calories overall, your body will be stuffed with all the wonderful food it needs, and you will feel fantastic, energetic and full all the time.
(4) eating a good amount of FAT is key to FEELING FULL. FAT makes you feel full, CARBS make you feel hungry, and PROTEIN builds and repairs your body. FAT is also key to the health and beauty of your skin. A good source is something like pure, absolutely well-made Greek Yoghourt (made from full cream mlik). carefully included that type of fat with each meal for that really satisfied, stuffed feeling.
(5) EXPERIMENT and LISTEN TO YOUR BODY. If you feel good eating 1200 a day - great! Try it CAREFULLY for a week. If you feel too peckish at 1200, try a different amount of carbs and a different level.
Some thoughts.0 -
I'm on 1200 and I'm finding it just fine. I cut sugar and white flour out of my diet and I find that I don't get terribly hungry. I don't formally eat my exercise calories back, but I think a few glasses of wine when I go out / at the weekend probably takes care of them. After the initial two weeks of high losses, I've settled into a 1lb a week which is about right if I do my BMR / TDEE numbers.
Isn't the girl in the pic Kate Moss? I don't imagine she's lifted anything heavier than a champagne glass in her life.0 -
First, I'd change my inspiration to something or someone that's not airbrushed. I'm on 1200 calories too and it's not easy but is very do-able with good choices. Some days I go over just a bit but then exercise (walking) to counter the calories so it all balances out at the end of the day. 0
-
You are not alone, and, quite simply, science is still struggling to understand this.
Anyone who gives you any strong, immediate opinions on this - is probably just uninformed.
I strongly recommend you read "Good Calories, Bad Calories" by Gary Taubes, otherwise you're just shooting in the dark.
My opinions:
(1) it is all in the kitchen. don't even bother about exercise. you're now in "advanced" weight loss for your last few kilos, so it's all in the kitchen
Whatever you do, DO NOT " ' eat back your exercise calories ' " if you exercise. At your stage of weight loss it is inconceivable you could take that approach (unless you're a marathon runner), so forget that. Read the book, get actual science on your side.
(MFP laughably includes the concept of "eating back your exercise calories" - just ignore it. They'll remove this feature in future versions.)
(2) carbohydrates will be key. you must find an exact intake per day - what about 65 grams per day - of carbohydrates which will make you lose the last few pounds
(3) you should have NO PROBLEM eating only 1200 calories in a day, at your height. Anyone who tells you otherwise is uninformed. I typically eat 1400 cals (I'm also losing the "last few pounds", but I am 6' tall) and I feel stuffed all the time, I can barely eat that much. I experimented with 1200 a day for a couple weeks, and it was perhaps a hair low, I'd feel a little peckish. At your height it should be no problem at all, as long as your pancreas is in good condition.
you'll only feel HUNGRY, like you're not getting enough food, if you eat too much carbs. if you were eating say 125 grams a day of carbs, and only 1200 calories overall, your body would be starving itself, and psychologically you would be bitterly hungry all the time. in contrast if you are eating 70 g of carbs per day, and 1200 calories overall, your body will be stuffed with all the wonderful food it needs, and you will feel fantastic, energetic and full all the time.
(4) eating a good amount of FAT is key to FEELING FULL. FAT makes you feel full, CARBS make you feel hungry, and PROTEIN builds and repairs your body. FAT is also key to the health and beauty of your skin. A good source is something like pure, absolutely well-made Greek Yoghourt (made from full cream mlik). carefully included that type of fat with each meal for that really satisfied, stuffed feeling.
(5) EXPERIMENT and LISTEN TO YOUR BODY. If you feel good eating 1200 a day - great! Try it CAREFULLY for a week. If you feel too peckish at 1200, try a different amount of carbs and a different level.
Some thoughts.
Thank you, this is some great advice and I will have to check out that book. Like you said, for my height I feel that 1200kcals is more than enough. I think the protein is what I need to look into a bit more and less carbs to shed these last 10lbs.
Good luck in losing your last bit too x 0 -
Hi, thank you for your quick reply! No the girl isnt me (I wish it was!), the photo is my inspiration body and I'm not really sure who she is or how she has got to that point.
Did you lose weight more quickly by having your lower amount of kcals or by upping them and exercising? xI assume that girl in your photo isn't you. If it is you, you don't need to change a thing! If it's more an inspiration photo, think about this: that girl works out. Probably a lot. She lifts weights and does other strength exercises in addition to cardio. And she likely eats more than 1200 calories a day to fuel it.
When I first joined (different profile), I ate 1200 calories a day. And you know what, I felt all right. I lost weight, I didn't feel bad, whatever. But eventually I raised my calorie goal. I'm short, so my BMR is pretty low, so I still dont' eat as much as some folks here. But raising that calorie goal helped me feel even better, and I still lost weight. It didn't slow my loss one bit. And I have always eaten all my exercise calories, even the ones from cleaning the house. And sometimes I even eat half a pizza for dinner, and blow my cals right out of the water. And that's ok too. Raising my calorie goal enabled me to get more good nutrition from my food, which in turn gives me more energy for living. That's a wonderful thing.
I'm not saying you absolutely have to eat more than 1200 calories. It's your body, it's your life, you do what you want to do. But I would suggest doing some more research, and looking around the site at the calorie goals of the people who have reached their goals. Check out users like CoryIda, who lost a lot of weight and looks fantastic, and eats more than 1200 calories. Most of the people who are at their goals eat significantly more than 1200, and did all along their journey. Because 1200 calories really isn't that much to fuel your body. Remember, those calories get burned just by living -- they keep your heart beating, your lungs breathing, your eyes blinking, your brain working, your muscles holding you up while you sit in your chair or walk across the room. And they're burning 24 hours a day. So when you move, you're burning even more. You need calories to survive, and if you want to do anything on top of just barely surviving, you need to eat more calories to fuel those body functions.
Above all else, experiment. If this is working for you now, great! But if you feel like you need a change, then try increasing them for a while. Think of this as a flexible process. What works right now might not work as you get closer to your goal weight, and that is normal. Just keep an open mind.0 -
Thanks Kat. I have other motivation pics, that's just my fav! How much have you been able to lose being on 1200kcals and walking?0
-
Hi, thank you for your quick reply! No the girl isnt me (I wish it was!), the photo is my inspiration body and I'm not really sure who she is or how she has got to that point.
Did you lose weight more quickly by having your lower amount of kcals or by upping them and exercising? x
Thinking about it, I don't really recall any difference in the speed of my weight loss. I did notice that I dropped inches more quickly when I increased my calories and exercised, but I don't think it sped up my actual weight loss. I have noticed that the more I eat, the less sleep I require. Which for me is a HUGE deal, because I've always been a 12-hours-of-sleep kind of girl, and I have a little boy who likes to wake at 5:30 every morning. :laugh: I feel better in the mornings when I eat more the day before.0 -
I'm on the 1200 calories diet...for a meal :laugh:0
-
Hi Everyone, :flowerforyou: I've just joined tonight! I'm on roughly 1500cals/day but over the past few days this week I haven't been able to reach that, sitting around 1200. I'm from Australia, Far North Queensland and finding this site a little difficult to complete my exercise plans using miles instead of klms, and consistently converting pounds to kilos. But I'm persisting! Anyone else in the same boat?0
-
I am on 1200 a day but I am always under...to be honest i am afraid to get to 1200 or even go over a little.
I'm walking aprx 60 mins a day and doing about 10 mins of "light exercises" total0 -
My name is Daniela
The best thing to do if you love to eat is, eat 5 -6 small meals a day , i never tried it .
So i decided what the hell let me give it a try , i started 2 weeks ago and already lost
its amazing and its so much fun , check out my blog i found that it keeps me motivated posting my meal plans and recipes everything is so good and low in calorie and very healthy
especially if you love peanut butter i found this amazing peanut butter for 2 tbsp only 45 calories , 1.5 fat amazing and so goooddd !!!!!!!!!!!
let me know what you think , and also message me with any questions
im still new at this blogging stuff but i want to help everyone who struggles with weight loss , ive struggled and it wasn't easy but it is possible
Happy Healthiness everyone
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MY BLOG ---> http://healthy--happiness.tumblr.com/0 -
I would like to be between 1200-1500/day. I exercise 4 mornings a week, 2 cardio and 2 weight training. I am very motivated and wondering if I am going to slow down the weight loss process if I don't eat the required amount of cals that I'm suppose to. 0
-
I am on 1200 cals a day, and let me say it can be a bit tough. I have to make sure that I cut out all the little things, like putting creamer in my coffee.. etc. and portion out my foods correctly. Like one lady said, sometimes I go over too, but then I will exercise to balance it back out. I am currently just walking, but about to start building muscle mass, for a more tone look. You can do it, but I would def. recommend that you work out as well.0
-
I'm also from Australia! But Perth
My advice would be, if it's working for you, then it's right.
If you're losing weight, feeling good etc on 1200 cals a day, keep at it!
If you're not getting the results you want, try upping your cals a bit.
Just play around until you figure out what works best for you
Good luck!:flowerforyou:0 -
hI, mfp has set me to 1200 a day and I feel this is more than doable by cutting out the high calorie snacks. I do excersise, at least an hours walking a day,a nd I do karate training 90mins x3 a week, plus light training and practice at home including warm ups and downs of sit ups/press ups and stretches etc
Ive only just started this journey so no idea what realisitc daily calories I will need, also breast feeding, so think i should be adding calories in for that, but we'll see how we go!
Good luck with your weight loss journey x0 -
I'm on 1200 cal a day. I workout 6-7 days a week for at least an hour a day. I do the stationary bike, or the treadmill for an hour and some lifting. I actually just reached goal this morning!0
-
I agree, I record my daily exercise depending on if its circuit training, walking or running. WIthout a daily something I'd be very hungry on the 1200 calories I've been allocated. The only problem is that I get a little light headed but herbal teas and water are a good way to satisfy a hunger pang sometimes Try a 300 breakfast, 300 lunch then something nice for dinner with all the rest of the calories, then you dont go to bed hungry.
Even a short walk will give you some extra calories 0 -
I think it's different for everybody and how their bodies work. What I do is I try to eat a 1200 calorie diet. It was really hard in the beginning but now it's hard to even reach the 1200 which scares me a lot because I'm afraid to go into starvation mode. Here is what I do. I eat around 1000-1200 a day with at least an hour of exercise a day. I don't eat my exercise calories as I just leave them behind. I heard not to do that as it doesn't help BUT I have been averaging a weight loss of 1.5-3 pounds a week.....Now when I get closer to my goal it might not still work like that. On the other hand I know people who have done this exact thing and they gain weight because they aren't eating enough. I think you have to keep trying different things until you see which one your body reacts to....then go for it :-) Good Luck!!!0
-
I am on 1200 a day and I usually only eat around 700 to 800 a day. I am not excersizing per say. I eat 3 meals and 2 snacks a day. I have not had a problem at all doing this and sometimes have a hard time eatting over 700 cal a day. I am being very strict with myself at this point though.I am sure I will have to ajust everything at some point.0
-
We are on 1200kcal. Weight has come off consistently every week, yes to eating back but that is my choice and it has worked. Diary is open to see.0
-
I eat 1200 calories a day, and i try to keep as close to it as i possbly can without going over my fat and carb limit. I do 1 or 2 classes a day, or 1 class and strengh training (i wouldnt say lift heavy yet) 3 or 4 times a day. I try to stick to the 1200 calories on those days too, but if im hungry ill eat a little bit more, and i do mean a little bit. Ive been losing steadily 2 lbs a week. ive also lost a few inches bust, waist and thighs.0
-
Thanks everyone for your replies, these all great pieces of advices. I'm going to focus on 1500cals and if I go under, so what! I exercise and still have a glass of red wine occasionally. So with 20kgs to loose it will be a long haul, but I'm pumped and motivated to do this - logged my food diary today and put in my exercise plan too. Bit hard when it's all in miles and pounds though. Anyway thanks again and see ya later.:flowerforyou:0
-
This is me minus the boyfriend add hubby with hubby waiting on me to complete my exercise routine so we can commence to partake of a few "drinks" :drinker: and there goes my caloriesI'm on 1200 but I exercise every weekday for 40 mins - 1 hr. I don't think I'd be able to do it without my exercise as I need those exercise calories to not feel hungry.
I find weekends really difficult as that's when my boyfriend comes over so I don't have time to exercise and end up going out for dinner and going over my calories. I've asked him if he'd like to go on dates to the gym at weekends but he's surprisingly never very enthusiastic...
I had to go to 1200 per day in order to lose. I exercise 6 days/week but I quit eating my exercise calories and am finally losing. I have devised a plan that I plan to initiate this weekend in which I will allow myself 1600 calories/day on either fri sat or sat sun or fri sun....but only for 2 days....I am doing this because I usually blow all my hard work during the week by consumming WAY too many calories on the weekend. So I figured if I give myself some extra then I won't feel deprived :happy:
Good luck to you :flowerforyou:0 -
Oh yeah and I have to REALLY watch my sodium....or I can gain 5 lbs over night!!!:sad:0
-
That's actually a great idea!0
-
What foods do you find the most sodium in? I havent heard of watching this before so maybe it's something I can look in to.Oh yeah and I have to REALLY watch my sodium....or I can gain 5 lbs over night!!!:sad:0
-
hey.. im on 1200cals a day... i havnt done any exercise for some time and havent lost any weight at 1200 cals.. when i going gym before 3-4times a week i lost weight at the same cals and sometimes ate some back too.. im trying to get back into the gym routine and hopefully will start losing again.. for me the food alone doesnt work as much.. i have to exercize.. i've lost 5kg so far and have 8-10kg to go.. and im 5''8.. xx0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions