my knees creak - can I do JM 30 day shred?

Options
mccollumse
mccollumse Posts: 84 Member
in Fitness and Exercise
I have been reading comments about the video and am tempted to get it. My current routine is 30 minutes of treadmill (3 miles) and 30 minutes of eliptical. I need to tone A LOT. I am 5'8" and 127lbs. I've lost ~50 lbs and look ok in clothes.....but have a lot of "flab". Classic, skinny fat. Would like to lose about 4 more lbs.

Anyhow, my knees aren't the best. I avoid doing squats because it doesn't feel good (not horrible, but I don't like it). My knees pop and grind when I go up steps.

For those that have the 30day shred, how hard is it on the knees?

Also, where is the best place to buy it?

Thanks!!!!
«1

Replies

  • mccollumse
    mccollumse Posts: 84 Member
    Options
    anyone?
  • katscoots
    katscoots Posts: 255 Member
    Options
    It's not that bad and she gives you pointers on how to NOT hurt yourself. My whole body creaks, but it's a great workout

    I ordered my DVDs from Amazon.com
  • BeeElMarvin
    BeeElMarvin Posts: 2,086 Member
    Options
    You can usually find it at Walmart or any other department store. And yes, I believe that you should be able to do it. I'm 52 with bad knees, bad shoulders etc. and I do it.
  • echandle12
    echandle12 Posts: 82
    Options
    #1- 30 DS has lots of squats and lunges. I have bad knees too but I did it.
    #2 try investing in some glucosamine. It has helped me a ton and I have no more pain. I do squats and lunges daily and it used to hurt just to sit down and stand up. Took about 3 weeks to kick in, but it helped
  • entropy83
    entropy83 Posts: 172 Member
    Options
    I have joints that crack and pop. You just have to see for yourself. If high impact moves kill you, I would suggest you either go for a longer workout and just do strength training at your own pace. I have attempted twice and both times my knees hated me, which is not functional as I a pedestrian in Chicago. I think some people say parts of it are on youtube. I bought the video and am holding out that after dropping more weight my knees will be more prepared. Good luck!
  • sarah120906
    sarah120906 Posts: 69 Member
    Options
    I've had knee pain in the begining both times of doing the Shred. It eventually went away for me though. Both times were after long absences of hard work-outs (post baby.) If you already work-out on a regular basis it may not bother you much.
  • sel254
    sel254 Posts: 273 Member
    Options
    My knees have actually gotten much better since I started doing 30 Day Shred. One of the girls in the video does modified moves which are easier, so you only have to go as far as you feel comfortable. Definitely recommend it ;)
  • militarydreams
    militarydreams Posts: 198 Member
    Options
    Yeah just avoid things like insanity and plyometrics in general.
  • hmcminton
    hmcminton Posts: 49 Member
    Options
    i would recommend 30DS - i lost a lot of weight doing it and have arthritis in my right knee, which makes exercising very painful at first. now i have virtually no knee pain and can run up and down stairs without thinking about it. the great thing about Jillian is that she gives tips on how to modify... also, once you become familiar with her workouts, you can substitute other moves that work the same muscles but might cause you less discomfort. good luck!
  • tigerlily8045
    tigerlily8045 Posts: 415 Member
    Options
    I myself am having trouble with my knees doing the 30 DS. I have gotten a knee support and it seems to help while doing the lunge/squats.
  • MinnieInMaine
    MinnieInMaine Posts: 6,400 Member
    Options
    For me, it's not so much the squatting and lunging as it is the jumping around - jumping jacks, butt kicks, etc that cause knee issues while doing 30DS. And the higher you go up in the levels, the more jumping you do as she incorporates more plyometric type moves.

    As far as resolving your issues, may I recommend trying to cut dairy out of your diet to see if that might be the source of knee issues. I know it sounds weird but a friend of mine did a "detox" (no soy, dairy, gluten for 30 days) and discovered that dairy caused all kinds of issues for her, including her knee creakiness. Just a thought...
  • Lleldiranne
    Lleldiranne Posts: 5,516 Member
    Options
    I would say yes. My knees pop as well, and so do my hips, ankles, shoulders …. (thanks to gymnastics as a kid/younger teen). I don't think it's any harder on my knees than running a 10 minute mile is.

    When you do squats and lunges, start gentle (JM always has a modifier example that is for beginners). Also listen to her when she talks about form! The big thing is that your knees stay over your ankles. It's when you let them go over your foot that you start risking injury.

    ETA: Check at your local library for the DVD. I checked it out there a couple of times before deciding not to buy it (and then I checked out other JM, and ended up buying some of them; I just didn't care for 30 DS). That way, if you love it you can keep it for a few weeks, with renewal, and decide if you want to buy it, and if you hate it you can take it back with no money lost.
  • wiggywompus
    wiggywompus Posts: 65 Member
    Options
    My knees creak and I avoid squats but since starting 30DS my knees are stronger and don't creak so much. I started off only going down a little and gradually increased built up muscle in legs/knees which helped. Good luck it is certainly a good routine
  • Charismasme2
    Charismasme2 Posts: 118 Member
    Options
    I also have VERY bad knee's, and have been doing it for awhile now. The one thing is to modify. Listen to what she says, and follow the girl that modify's especially the lunges and squats...at least until you feel comfortable. But it's a very nice workout!!! I love it.
  • jadedbutterfly71
    jadedbutterfly71 Posts: 83 Member
    Options
    #1- 30 DS has lots of squats and lunges. I have bad knees too but I did it.
    #2 try investing in some glucosamine. It has helped me a ton and I have no more pain. I do squats and lunges daily and it used to hurt just to sit down and stand up. Took about 3 weeks to kick in, but it helped


    ^^^^^ This. Glucosamine saved me :happy:
    I got my dvd from Amazon
  • janalayn
    janalayn Posts: 510 Member
    Options
    My knees crack and hurt too. I did it and just adjusted the things I couldn't do (like jumping jacks) ... although by the end I could actually do some (not all) of the jumping jacks. Good luck - it is a killer workout but you can really see a difference at the end.
  • pamelak5
    pamelak5 Posts: 327 Member
    Options
    Yes, but only if you have really, really good form at squats. Your knee will get worse if you don't have good form, but if you have good form it will help tons. I love workout videos but the limitation is that you don't have anyone to watch you to tell you whether you're doing it right. I had knee problems and squatted them away. I would actually recommend The Firm videos - they have terrific modifications and even with modifications are a great workout. JM doesn't provide modifications for things like jumping jacks, because everyone should be able to use them.
  • Michelle_Nicole
    Michelle_Nicole Posts: 95 Member
    Options
    I also have really bad knees yet was able to do her 30 day shred dvd with no problem. I would just not go as far down with your squats or lunges if it hurts and go easy on any jumping moves. Its really all on how you feel, if you can do the moves with little pain then go for it, but if it hurst just lessen the intensity a bit and you should be fine! Good luck!
  • jjblogs
    jjblogs Posts: 327 Member
    Options
    I have knee issues and the 30ds was hard on them until I started doing it barefoot. It made a huge difference. You might try that if you have trouble once you get started.
  • ber3023
    ber3023 Posts: 146 Member
    Options
    I would say it's all about just how bad your knees are. There is quite a bit of impact; jumping around, squats and lunges. There is a girl on the vid to follow to do less impact, which even as I'm in much better shape and could manage more impact, my knees sometimes can't in the higher levels so I have to stick to the lower impact stuff. I have still had great results with it though.

Categories