Difficulty losing weight caused by Vitamin D Deficiency
CourtKeyWest
Posts: 1 Member
Vitamin D deficiency may be preventing you from losing weight. Few people (your trainer, Doctor, et. al.) are aware of this relationship. Educate yourself.
http://www.vitamindcouncil.org/
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/25/health/25brody.html?_r=2
http://www.womentowomen.com/healthynutrition/vitamind.aspx
http://www.drweil.com/drw/u/QAA400683/Vitamin-D-Deficient.html
http://www.vitaminddeficiencysymptomsguide.com/vitamin-d-and-weight-loss/
Here’s my story.
I am very fit 42-year- old, Caucasian female who over three years, while working out religiously and intensely, grew to be 40lbs overweight; all my numbers other than my weight, were and remain fantastic, BP excellent, cholesterol excellent, RHR 46 ... all good. I have extremely healthy workout and eating habits. In fact, in the three years that I gained this weight my cholesterol levels dropped slightly as I improved my eating habits in an effort to lose weight.
I tried everything to lose weight without being able to get more than a few lbs off. The only unusual things I noticed in this time was that I began to have INTENSE sugar cravings and I seemed to fatigue easily and have greatly decreased energy. Things I used to love doing simply exhausted me much sooner or I got tired just thinking about doing them. I just seemed to be slowing down, but it was very subtle and when I mentioned it to people they attributed it to "you're getting older". I felt like it was more than that, but it was so subtle, I couldn’t pin it down.
I am an ACSM certified personal trainer and trained and have lost weight successfully in the past, so I know how hard it can be, but the more I worked out the LESS I lost. I had my metabolism tested, nothing there. I moved to a new town where I walked and biked everywhere (didn’t even own a car) and I signed on with reputable personal trainer 3x weekly . I lost body fat but over 6 months of training, the scale did not budge more than 5 lbs. Neither I nor my trainer could understand what was wrong, so I started going to Doctors. I went to my OBGYN, General Practitioner and finally and Endocrinologist.
They ruled out all the usual culprits, Thyroid, adrenal issues, PCOS, Cushing's syndrome, pre-diabetes, etc. at this point, I was losing my mind because in addition to the frustration of dieting religiously and working out with a personal trainer and own my own nothing was happening and the doctors really did not seem interested in getting to the bottom of it and it was pretty clear they assumed I was simply not working hard enough, so they weren't motivated to dig deeper.
I resigned myself to the fact that no one believed me and because I had no “real” health issues, everyone thought it was some failure on my part. The last Dr. I saw was an endocrinologist who, reluctantly, ran some tests, although she told me point blank "it could be anything" and didn't seem to care. She called me with my test results said everything was normal - no explanation for my weight gain and inability to lose weight. In passing she mentioned, that my Vitamin D was low 24 ng/mL. She said the range was 30 ng/mL -80. She advised me to take a supplement of 1000 IU of D3 per day.
She did not correlate this deficiency to my weight problems. I did some research on my own. There is a high correlation between obesity and Vitamin D deficiency and the ranges are being raised to redefine normal as being between 50-80 ng/mL, not 30-80 ng/mL as the Dr. noted. When my problems began, I had just moved to a state where you get NO vitamin D from the sun in the winter -- If you live north of the latitude of Atlanta, Georgia, the sun is not high enough in the sky half of the year to stimulate vitamin D production in the skin. And if you do, be aware that absorption if VitD and it is blocked by sunscreen, so with the increase in skin cancer awareness and prevention, people are often blocking the Vitamin D they might otherwise get.
Because I was quite deficient based on the 50-80 scale, I started taking 7000 UI of D3 (not D2). The effect was immediate and positive, my energy levels immediately rose and I started dropping weight off my hips and stomach where is would not BUDGE for three years.
There are few if any experts in this area, but you can get tested and do your own research. Some of the basic guidelines are that it’s safe to take 1000 IU per 25lbs of body weight and do not take more than 10,000 IU per day it can cause toxicity of you take too much. Don’t expect your doctor to know much about this issue, educate yourself on reputable websites and elsewhere. Three out of 4 people are Vitamin D deficient and over time this can contribute to heart disease, depression, fatigue and is Vit D is important calcium absorption, so it is also contributing to rickets in children and osteoporosis in adults. Some theorize that Vitamin D deficiency may be contributing to the obesity epidemic in the US.
I am not an expert this is just my experience and I hope it is useful and will shorten the duration of someone else who is experiencing the same intense frustration I did for several years.
http://www.vitamindcouncil.org/
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/25/health/25brody.html?_r=2
http://www.womentowomen.com/healthynutrition/vitamind.aspx
http://www.drweil.com/drw/u/QAA400683/Vitamin-D-Deficient.html
http://www.vitaminddeficiencysymptomsguide.com/vitamin-d-and-weight-loss/
Here’s my story.
I am very fit 42-year- old, Caucasian female who over three years, while working out religiously and intensely, grew to be 40lbs overweight; all my numbers other than my weight, were and remain fantastic, BP excellent, cholesterol excellent, RHR 46 ... all good. I have extremely healthy workout and eating habits. In fact, in the three years that I gained this weight my cholesterol levels dropped slightly as I improved my eating habits in an effort to lose weight.
I tried everything to lose weight without being able to get more than a few lbs off. The only unusual things I noticed in this time was that I began to have INTENSE sugar cravings and I seemed to fatigue easily and have greatly decreased energy. Things I used to love doing simply exhausted me much sooner or I got tired just thinking about doing them. I just seemed to be slowing down, but it was very subtle and when I mentioned it to people they attributed it to "you're getting older". I felt like it was more than that, but it was so subtle, I couldn’t pin it down.
I am an ACSM certified personal trainer and trained and have lost weight successfully in the past, so I know how hard it can be, but the more I worked out the LESS I lost. I had my metabolism tested, nothing there. I moved to a new town where I walked and biked everywhere (didn’t even own a car) and I signed on with reputable personal trainer 3x weekly . I lost body fat but over 6 months of training, the scale did not budge more than 5 lbs. Neither I nor my trainer could understand what was wrong, so I started going to Doctors. I went to my OBGYN, General Practitioner and finally and Endocrinologist.
They ruled out all the usual culprits, Thyroid, adrenal issues, PCOS, Cushing's syndrome, pre-diabetes, etc. at this point, I was losing my mind because in addition to the frustration of dieting religiously and working out with a personal trainer and own my own nothing was happening and the doctors really did not seem interested in getting to the bottom of it and it was pretty clear they assumed I was simply not working hard enough, so they weren't motivated to dig deeper.
I resigned myself to the fact that no one believed me and because I had no “real” health issues, everyone thought it was some failure on my part. The last Dr. I saw was an endocrinologist who, reluctantly, ran some tests, although she told me point blank "it could be anything" and didn't seem to care. She called me with my test results said everything was normal - no explanation for my weight gain and inability to lose weight. In passing she mentioned, that my Vitamin D was low 24 ng/mL. She said the range was 30 ng/mL -80. She advised me to take a supplement of 1000 IU of D3 per day.
She did not correlate this deficiency to my weight problems. I did some research on my own. There is a high correlation between obesity and Vitamin D deficiency and the ranges are being raised to redefine normal as being between 50-80 ng/mL, not 30-80 ng/mL as the Dr. noted. When my problems began, I had just moved to a state where you get NO vitamin D from the sun in the winter -- If you live north of the latitude of Atlanta, Georgia, the sun is not high enough in the sky half of the year to stimulate vitamin D production in the skin. And if you do, be aware that absorption if VitD and it is blocked by sunscreen, so with the increase in skin cancer awareness and prevention, people are often blocking the Vitamin D they might otherwise get.
Because I was quite deficient based on the 50-80 scale, I started taking 7000 UI of D3 (not D2). The effect was immediate and positive, my energy levels immediately rose and I started dropping weight off my hips and stomach where is would not BUDGE for three years.
There are few if any experts in this area, but you can get tested and do your own research. Some of the basic guidelines are that it’s safe to take 1000 IU per 25lbs of body weight and do not take more than 10,000 IU per day it can cause toxicity of you take too much. Don’t expect your doctor to know much about this issue, educate yourself on reputable websites and elsewhere. Three out of 4 people are Vitamin D deficient and over time this can contribute to heart disease, depression, fatigue and is Vit D is important calcium absorption, so it is also contributing to rickets in children and osteoporosis in adults. Some theorize that Vitamin D deficiency may be contributing to the obesity epidemic in the US.
I am not an expert this is just my experience and I hope it is useful and will shorten the duration of someone else who is experiencing the same intense frustration I did for several years.
0
Replies
-
I just wanted to thank you for sharing your experience. It is most helpful!0
-
This post was so helpful.0
-
I know a lot of people on here think Dr. Mercola is a fraud. But one thing he always emphasizes in getting enough Vit. D. He claims Vit. D. deficiency contributes to developing numerous diseases and I'm sure obesity is on the list.0
-
very interesting! i think i'll start taking some vitamin D. I burn so easily i avoid the sun as much as possible, so getting enough naturally is hard, especially in the winter.0
-
This information has answered so many issues I have been having. Thank you!!0
-
Thank you for this post.0
-
Very useful! Thanks.
Stef.0 -
I was tested and shown to have vitamin d deficiency. My level was at 20.6. My dr has me on a prescription dose of 50,000 iu's once a week. I'm just wondering if it would be more beneficial to do a certain amount a day rather than a large dose because I've been taking it for almost 3 months and haven't lost any weight and still seem to be tired. Not as much as I was but still not "normal".0
-
I did some research on my own.do your own research.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19321573
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24622804
There's currently no compelling evidence that vitamin D plays a role with weight loss.0 -
From all the primary literature studies I have read, vitamin d3 doesn't cause weight loss. There is a big question of 'does vitamin D deficiency cause chronic illness or do chronic conditions cause the deficiency'. Like CourtKeyWest, my experience has been pretty pointed. I gained weight for no reason that I could come up with. I was constantly cold at work, often feeling brain-dead around 1pm. My bones and muscles ached, often waking me up at night. I thought my thyroid was messed up, I thought maybe I had arthritis. Lyme (because that is prevalent where I live). It got so bad that even yoga was painful. Walking was all I could do. A full checkup which included a blood panel, showed nothing wrong except my Vitamin D level was at a 9. After a week of taking a 5000 supplement daily, my life has made a complete change. Most of the bone aches have gone, I am not freezing any more, i have no more afternoon lows and my energy is slowly returning. I have a ways to go to lose the 30 pounds I gained over the past 4 months. But it seems like I am already losing. So it's benefitting me. D3 is the only supplement I take. I take no other meds. So if it helps with my energy and joint/muscle aches, then it seems like my weight loss will be supported just because I am healthier.0
-
Vitamin D has also recently been indicated in studies to have some protective effect on memory as we age. I've started taking a supplement because I have Alzheimer's heavily on both sides of my family.0
-
I echo these stories...I thought at 35 years old in 10 years I'd be too fat and in too much pain to walk, and be one of those fat people in a scooter. I had chronic debilitating pain, and was eating nothing and gaining about 15 pounds a year. Once adding the Vitamin D3 supplement with in a week my pain started to subside, and two weeks I was loosing weight. (My Doctor had no clue and told me to exercise more, gee thanks!)
Vitamin D isn't a miracle weight loss drug, but having a deficiency can certainly effect your weight, and your health.
Now 2 months later I'm down 20+ pounds, walking 5km a day, swimming and starting lifting!
Get your levels checked out people!!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions