Is it Really Exercise or Am I Cheating?

24

Replies

  • deannakittygirl
    deannakittygirl Posts: 228 Member
    i have light active set also and don't count anything except actual workouts. I did count lawn mowing before but don't anymore.
  • thebigcb
    thebigcb Posts: 2,210 Member
    I think its can be either

    Did you but on weight when you where doing the cleaning in the first place? Then its a cheat. If it was something you never did previously to joining MFP, then its not a cheat.
  • NoAdditives
    NoAdditives Posts: 4,251 Member
    If you are set as light active you should only count "exercise" as exercise, if you were set to sedentary then some of the stuff could be logged as exercise.

    I agree. I'm a stay at home mom with three kids under 4 years old. I'm set to lightly active, so all the cleaning, laundry, walking, etc. I do on a regular basis is already accounted for. I only log actual exercise
  • tadpole242
    tadpole242 Posts: 507 Member
    No I wouldn't bother, especially if you already have lightly active in your settings. You don't burn calories unless your heartrate is increased.. I think by adding them, you are allowing yourself eat more when you're not really burning the calories you think you are
    You burn calories just by being alive – when you are lying down, or doing nothing...
  • TXGirl821
    TXGirl821 Posts: 115
    MFP is very...let's say OPTIMISTIC about how many calories an activity burns. I burn 460 on the elliptical, MFP tells me I burned almost 800. Haha, I wish!

    If you're working up a sweat cleaning and such, and if you're doing a big clean of your house then it's definitely work, log it. But you might want to slash the calories MFP said you burned in half just to be on the safe side. :)
  • Kara_xxx
    Kara_xxx Posts: 635 Member
    The database includes some crazy stuff...

    "sitting in boat - fishing" 8 hours = 1506 calories. :huh: :huh: :huh:
  • surromom2010
    surromom2010 Posts: 457 Member
    I don't log anything that I do that I already did when I was getting fat. If it burned that many calories, I wouldn't have gotten fat in the first place lol. I wouldn't log them if you already have your diary set to lightly active, maybe sedentary, but I'd still feel like it's not so much cheating, but misleading.
  • WaterBunnie
    WaterBunnie Posts: 1,371 Member
    I don't log anything I used to do before joining here, so no to housework and everyday stuff, and I've learnt through wearing a FitBit that even walking to work and back (around 25 mins per day) and around the office and home STILL keeps me within the sedentary settings so if I were you I'd only log specific exercise sessions or longer walks (over and above about 25 mins a day) if you want to be true to yourself. Even sedentary isn't totally idle!
  • SmallMimi
    SmallMimi Posts: 541 Member
    House cleaning and other "daily chores" nope, now the weekly 2-3 hours of lawn mowing yes. I would say your a doubling up.
  • dancingj2
    dancingj2 Posts: 4,572 Member
    I have sedentary as my setting. Normal picking up I do not count but if I spec 1/2 hour cleaning and vacuuming I will input.

    If you have light active I would think you would not count it.
  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    I have my activity level set to sedentary but I only record actual exercise as exercise. That's my "insurance" for potentially under reporting calories consumed (I don't weigh anything) or over reporting calories burned (I trust my HRM but not sure about some of MFP's estimates)
  • surromom2010
    surromom2010 Posts: 457 Member
    No I wouldn't bother, especially if you already have lightly active in your settings. You don't burn calories unless your heartrate is increased.. I think by adding them, you are allowing yourself eat more when you're not really burning the calories you think you are
    You burn calories just by being alive – when you are lying down, or doing nothing...

    You knew the poster meant ADDITIONAL calories, don't be THAT guy....
  • mandyfawn1
    mandyfawn1 Posts: 9
    People have different opinions on this, but I once read in the forums somewhere that "you cleaned when you were fat"...or something to that degree, anyway...so you shouldn't count it when you're trying to lose weight.

    No matter how long I clean or do any other normal chores I don't count it as exercise.

    I don't count normal activities that probably are exercise - running and playing with my lab; vacuuming, sweeping and mopping floors at work - because I did then every day before and still do them every day now. They obviously weren't help me lose weight before, so I don't count them as exercise, even though I sometimes work at them harder than others and get a bit sweaty.

    For me, personally, I only count the "exercise" I do that I wasn't in the habit of doing before. Taking the dog on a 90 minute walk instead of 30 counts for me, or doing 10 loads of laundry instead of 2 because I'm doing more than I normally do.
  • skybird455
    skybird455 Posts: 172 Member
    i log only intentional exercise. Not regular duties of cleaning, washing car etc....the only other thing I would add is mowing, since it burns so many calories with a push mower. Other than that if its not intentional working out, ie your in work out clothes, your serious ;0) then its normal activity, plus if you dont log the cleaning house etc thats just extra calories you burn you dont track that will help you out, but to eat back whats burned for cleaning house....no I would not add it
  • JesterMFP
    JesterMFP Posts: 3,596 Member
    Basically - are you still losing weight at the rate you expect when logging these things as exercise? If so, then maybe you really are "lightly active" regardless of the cleaning etc. If not, then perhaps you're really sedentary, and inadvertently counting these activities twice. Working out exactly how many calories you burn and consume can be an inexact science anyway, so sometimes you just have to experiment and see what works.
  • KMSForLife
    KMSForLife Posts: 577 Member
    I don't add in anything that I was doing when I was fat.

    Exercise activities are the things that you deliberately do in order to change your life and be thinner. You get "points" for positive change, not for things you were already doing before.

    Great answer.
  • whitejessamine
    whitejessamine Posts: 166
    I don't count that stuff even though I've said I'm sedentary. I figure if it's part of my normal activity it doesn't count. If MFP doesn't take it into account and it should, then I'll just be burning more calories then planned and losing weight faster than it says I should! I'd rather not count something I should, than count something I shouldn't and not see the scale go down as quickly as I expected...though that's probably not really noticeable, since I'm not losing quickly anyway...guess I'll stop rambling now. Sorry. lol
  • carreen
    carreen Posts: 175 Member
    WoW!! You guys are awesome. Thanks for the quick response and the advice. I think I'll stop recording it unless it's a major project. Thanks again!
  • SparkleShine
    SparkleShine Posts: 2,001 Member
    Yeah, I agree. I wouldn't log it. For instance I DID log moving boxes yesterday as I was sweating my butt off moving boxes into our new classroom yesterday. MFP had it for over 1,000 calories burned! I logged it as half of that and I think even that was high!
  • chenrytc2
    chenrytc2 Posts: 48
    Depends on the intensity. I would get a Heart Rate Monitor (HRM) to see the amout of calories you are using. It would give you the best number of the calories burned.

    You could be double dipping, that is an unknown. Since you are here on MFP, I would NOT include them to be on the safe side and not put yourself in the situation of eating back too many calories.

    For example, I do an hour on the elliptical machine (M-F). The machine says I burn 700, my HRM says I burn 900, and MFP says I burn 1100. I used the lowest number to be on the safe side. What's the worst that can happen? I lose a little more weight? No problem. I make sure I eat all of my calories and then some. I have averaged about 4 pounds a week with the exception of the last two. The last two I have been eating out due work. So, even the "healthy" stuff is packed with calories.

    I wish you continued success!
  • kcoftx
    kcoftx Posts: 765 Member
    Even sedentary has movement included in the formula.

    BMR X 1.2 (Sedentary Activity Multiplier).

    Thus it assumes you do get out of bed and do some daily stuff.
  • luthage
    luthage Posts: 12 Member
    I don't understand the reasoning of "don't log something you did when you were fat." I thought the point was to eat slightly under the calories you needed based on the amount you burn every day. Just because you clean when you are fat, doesn't mean you don't burn calories now during it.

    I'm set a no activity because I sit at a desk 9-5, during class and doing homework. I log heavy cleaning (scrubbing and floors), the amount I walk (an hour back and forth to work carrying a 15lb bag), as well as kickboxing/yoga/running.

    I think if you have it set to light activity and you sit at a desk all day, then it's cheating. If you work on your feet all day and then add the extra in cleaning, it isn't.
  • tadpole242
    tadpole242 Posts: 507 Member
    No I wouldn't bother, especially if you already have lightly active in your settings. You don't burn calories unless your heartrate is increased.. I think by adding them, you are allowing yourself eat more when you're not really burning the calories you think you are
    You burn calories just by being alive – when you are lying down, or doing nothing...

    You knew the poster meant ADDITIONAL calories, don't be THAT guy....
    When people post Absolutes, and what they say is easy to misunderstand, then Yes I am “that guy” WETFTMs.
    But the poster was both unclear and wrong. You don’t “only” burn calories when your heart rate is raised were that true you’d burn nothing when you sleep. 350 to 400 per night avg
    Driving a car 300 cal per hour
    Chatting on your cell 110 per hour
    Sitting at your desk and playing with you pencil 200 to 300 per day,
    none of which will raise your heart rate much
  • Bobby_Clerici
    Bobby_Clerici Posts: 1,828 Member
    haha - the great debate!
    It's all up to you, and is it working for you?
    Most who log in silly, every day activities defend it in one forum while crying the blues about their lack of progress in another...lol
    Seriously, here is what I do.
    And yes, it works.
    I bought a weighted vest. Mine is 70 lbs - the number of pounds I had lost up to that point.
    A lady might get one about 20 or 30 lbs - whatever.
    When I wear my vest, I count daily activities as exercise. And it is!
    Just my opinion - good luck to you:flowerforyou:
  • SPNLuver83
    SPNLuver83 Posts: 2,050 Member
    Yes, the way you are doing it now is "cheating".

    If you want to log everything like that, you gotta put it as sedentary. If not, keep as is and stop logging the daily stuff.
  • UrbanRunner81
    UrbanRunner81 Posts: 1,207 Member
    you'd be surprised how much you burn by cleaning. I don't know what your daily calories are set at, but I think generally people are more active then they think.

    I wear bodymedia fit and I can burn 2600 in a day just cleaning the house on a rest day. If didn't add it I would only get to eat 1900 calories. This way I eat at least 2400.
  • Jscanland
    Jscanland Posts: 26 Member
    oh ya!!!!!!!!! they all count, my nutritionist says that doing those small things 'with purpose" throughout the day actually help to raise your metabolism. so making those things happen "on purpose" and putting gusto (or a few dance steps) into vacumming can be critical to raising your met.....
  • karylee44
    karylee44 Posts: 892
    i dont add any of that stuff. only thing i might add is gardening.. and by that.. i usually mean heavy work.. moving cement blocks, building walls, etc. not weeding or watering.
  • SuperAmie
    SuperAmie Posts: 307 Member
    My opinion.. cleaning.. maayybbee not unless its crazy scubbing and stuff.. sweaty. But washing the car can be a workout.. if your panting I would.
  • kristen6022
    kristen6022 Posts: 1,923 Member
    I only log honest to goodness exercise. When I purposely put tennis shoes on and take time out to do physical activity. Cleaning doesn't count and I have mine set to sedintary.

Categories