1000 cals a day??
hellohoney86
Posts: 21
I've been reading and I KNOW that even 1200 cals a day is considered low. I bought the 10 minute trainer program (Tony Horton) and included is a 10 day diet to "jump start" -lose a pants size in 10 days.
It's got lots of good, healthful foods, tonnes of protein & veggies but averages out to 1000 cals a day. I know better, but I want to do it anyways.....
It's only 10 days. I'll continue eating healthy afterwards and up my cals back to 1200-1500. I know some of what I drop may come right back, but I'd like to give it a shot regardless.
Is 10 days of tight food restriction like that enough to throw your body into "starvation mode"?
It's got lots of good, healthful foods, tonnes of protein & veggies but averages out to 1000 cals a day. I know better, but I want to do it anyways.....
It's only 10 days. I'll continue eating healthy afterwards and up my cals back to 1200-1500. I know some of what I drop may come right back, but I'd like to give it a shot regardless.
Is 10 days of tight food restriction like that enough to throw your body into "starvation mode"?
0
Replies
-
Just a bump - I'd love to get some feedback from the knowledgeable folks!0
-
unless you are about 4'6" 1000 cals a day is not going to cut it. you are going to be starving your body and at that rate you aren't going to be losing long term fat. You need to ensure you have a healthy load of fat and protein in your diet if you want to lose weight correctly, and 1000 cals just isn't going to cut it.0
-
I personally wouldn't do it. It just sounds like a detox to me.0
-
Why would try and apply a diet which takes no consideration of your weight, height, activity levels and current BF%?!?!?
Work out your own macros and follow them!!!!!0 -
Ah, **** - moment of weakness. I really do know better. The allure of dropping a pants size in 10 days though...... it's freaking tempting.
I'll be smart and follow what's been working so far (
eta - thanks for the feedback!0 -
You can drop a pant size or two in 30 days by doing the 30 Day Shred, and eating well.
Sounds much better to me, IMO.0 -
too many 10's in there...good luck with whatever you decide, but I wouldn't do it just because I personally would be a cranky ***** for 10 days.0
-
You could just add 200 or 400 more calories to the plan in healthy foods.0
-
You can drop a pant size or two in 30 days by doing the 30 Day Shred, and eating well.
Sounds much better to me, IMO.
This^ I dropped more than one pants size in a month and i eat WAY more than 1k cals / day. WAY more! LOLz0 -
You in a hurry to get fit? Then don't waste any time doing Stupid Diet Things. Starting eating right and exercising today.0
-
yeah i wouldn't do that....loosing weight that fast is not healthy a slow steady loss is what is best for anyone trying to loose weight....0
-
I survived on less than 800 calories for over 2 weeks. I had no energy, I was always tired and very cranky. But that's just me. I'm interested to hear some more feedback on this.0
-
Do it anyway.... In that time frame unless your body is thin already you aint going to drop into starvation mode by a long shot...
Heck people have maintained significant weight loss by water fasting 2 x 30 days with a break in-between... and they have kept it off...
It really depends how you EXIT the lower amount, your body will adapt slightly to that amount, so need to increase by about 10% a day afterwards only until back up to normal. Just to be on safe side anyway....
Also 10 days is reasonable time anyway... I see people here that lose maybe what? 60pounds in about 1 year maybe 1 and half? I'm almost there and only been doing since Jan.. No side effects so far except sore legs from training for marathon....
Then again, I am 5 ft tall... or short? So yea, maybe that why to me it doesn't sound so bad... either way the fasting on water part truth still stands, possible and can work long term if medically supervised....0 -
Why jumpstart?....
Learn to eat healthy for your whole life... that takes some practice... eat in a way that you can keep up indefinitely.
I don't think that 10-days of harsh stress on your body will do you any good in the long run.
I tracked for a couple of weeks before I worried about losing.
(although seeing what I was eating I couldn't help but rein back a bit)
Then I saw where I could make small changes on things that weren't that important to me.
(Don't even think of taking chocolate out of my diet!!!)
--Reducing quantities where I won't notice it so much
--Swapping out things instead of eliminating them.
Then every couple of weeks I check where I can make another couple of small changes.
If you completely revamp your diet, it's way easy to revert to old ways in times of stress.
If you make a series of small changes, food still offers you some sense of comfort.
sort of a comfort continuum, and after a while the first small changes will seem comforting in themselves.0 -
if you do exersice as well then your body will not go into starvation made in that short a time x0
-
I doubt you'll be thrown into starvation mode unless you go over 3 days without eating. The whole Starvation Mode craze has taken on a life of it's own. You'll be fine. Hungry? Yes. But you won't be literally starving.0
-
Depending on how tall you are, 1000 cal a day might work for you. I'm likely not in the majority, but that's my typical daily goal. I'm also only 5'0. The way I look at it, you could eat a LOT of veggies (20 cal items) with a 1000 cal limit so it certainly doesn't mean you have to starve yourself!
Good luck to you! :happy:0 -
Is 10 days of tight food restriction like that enough to throw your body into "starvation mode"?
No, it's not. You'll probably be hungry and miserable, but it's unlikely to do any damage.0 -
You can drop a pant size or two in 30 days by doing the 30 Day Shred, and eating well.
Sounds much better to me, IMO.
Agreed.0 -
If you lose that much weight in such a short period of time, there's no way it's going to be all fat. When you starve yourself like that, your body will actually break down your muscle for energy because protein is easier to break down than fat is.
Sure, you'll lose 10 lbs in 2 weeks, but once you go back to a more normal routine, it'll be hard not to put the weight back on as fat.
Not only will it be fat, but it'll be visceral fat. Visceral fat is the fat underneath your muscles in your abdomen - the dangerous stuff. It'll put more pressure on your internal organs which will increase the risk of weight-related problems.
My suggestion? Don't do it. Or if you do that 10-day thing, eat all your regular calories + the calories you burned off from working out, minus enough to lose 1lb/week. Then you'll build lean muscles, burn off fat, and you'll be able to keep it off! You won't lose as much weight as quickly, but muscles weigh more than fat, and bigger muscles burn more calories to do the same work!0 -
1000 calories for 10 days is fine.
I did it!!!
. My doctor recommended it after having my metabolism tested. Eating 1000 calories simply creates a caloric deficet. Allowing your metabolism to gear up into overdrive.
I lost 15 over a 2 month period. Then increased calories to 1200 and lost another 10. Now I'm eating 1500 and simply exercising 2/3x a week to maintain the 30 lb loss. At a year now, and its still off. :-) Hope that helps!!!0 -
I honestly don't think that it would be a problem...I eat about that many calories a day anyway, and I've never had an issue. However, ignoring what the fear-mongers on MFP say about slowing down your metabolism (which takes MONTHS to do, I might add, and months like closer to a year than two or three) you may just want to talk to your doctor about it.0
-
I did the 10 min trainer and the 10 day diet....didnt work...I actually gained weight-=( and until I started eating my 1200 cals then I started losing again....also unless u do all 3 videos a day (30 min instead of 10) i wouldnt recommend eating back ur excersise cals...good luck!!!0
-
yeah i wouldn't do that....loosing weight that fast is not healthy a slow steady loss is what is best for anyone trying to loose weight....
lose, not loose0 -
It was just the jump start my body needed. :-)0
-
I think those 10 day diets are worthless IMHO. why eat only 1000 to lose some weight and then eat 1200-1500 in 10 days? all you are doing is having a higher calorie deficit which make you lose weight but I would see that you gain it back. i dont see a point in putting your body in such a strain remember 3500 calories is a pound so to me not worth it.0
-
All I have to say is that it will probably...absolutely jump start your weight loss...because your body well go wtf and immediately deplete your glycogen. I'm willing to bet the initial pounds will not be fat. I'm willing to bet your glycogen will come back when you start eating again.
Therefore, pointless.0 -
Ah, **** - moment of weakness. I really do know better. The allure of dropping a pants size in 10 days though...... it's freaking tempting.
Yes, it is. And you can do it. But the long-term impact is that you'll have to start eating more at some point, and your metabolism will be so suppressed after the 10 day period that a lot of it will come back on again as soon as you start eating.
If you have some specific reason why you need to be a pant size lower in ten days, and you don't care about your pant size in 15 days, then it's probably not harmful to you at all.
But slow and steady is the way to go for the long haul.0 -
I doubt you'll be thrown into starvation mode unless you go over 3 days without eating. The whole Starvation Mode craze has taken on a life of it's own. You'll be fine. Hungry? Yes. But you won't be literally starving.
I agree. I am 5'1, but for me to lose weight, I have to keep my calories around 1,000-1200. It is important to make sure that what you are eating counts. I try to eat 40% carbs, 40% protein, and 20% fat. It keeps me from getting hungry.
I think the key is "listen to your body." If you are hungry, give yourself permission to eat something healthy. The reason 1200 calories is important is to achieve well-rounded nutrition. I don't think a supplement overcomes the insufficiencies when your diet isn't well-rounded. Supplements don't seem to provide the same benefits as the nutrients in whole foods.
Another way to "listen to your body" is if you are losing more than 2 pounds a week. Don't lose sight of a long term goal for a short term "solution".0 -
I really appreciate all of the varied feedback! It's interesting to hear the many different thought processes on this one.
I've been reading and researching and I'm going to go for it. It's 10 days, from what I've read it won't harm my body for such a short term. Tonnes of protein/veggies, lots of water and we'll see what happens. If I drop a few pounds and it comes back on after I go back to my 1200-1500/day, I'm not really any farther behind than I would have been at the rate my loss is going so far anyways
)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions