Losing weight too fast?
PrayerofAmity
Posts: 176 Member
I know that it is recommended to lose weight slowly in order to keep it off. I look at my own loss (23 pounds in 30 days) and worry that maybe its coming off too fast. I haven't done anything rediculous, though my change in eating habits has been drastic simply because I was eating so badly before. My job keeps me running so hard without breaks that I found it next to impossible to eat at work, then I would grab fast food (super sized of course) on my way home at 1 am and scarf it down before going to sleep. Then I was sleeping till noon and maybe eating something before I left for work or (again) grabbing some takeout on the way to eat quickly before I started work. The only liquids I ever drank was diet pop and I drank a lot of it (minimum 2 L a day). On May 30 I went cold turkey. I gave up all liquids except water and have had nothing but water ever since (I'm finding I actually like it now and don't miss the pop at all). I am also eating a lot more food now, every two hours no matter what I am doing (I have made a habit of bringing snacks with me everywhere I go). I cut out junk food completely and don't miss that one bit either. I'm finding I am never hungry any more, I'm liking the healthy food a lot more than the junk food and I'm feeling healthier than I have in years.
My question is...if I am eating and feeling great and not craving or hungry ever, is the weight loss still too fast? I want to lose the weight but I also want to be doing it right.
My question is...if I am eating and feeling great and not craving or hungry ever, is the weight loss still too fast? I want to lose the weight but I also want to be doing it right.
0
Replies
-
How many calories are you eating a day?0
-
1300 to 1500 on average and not really exercising at all. My diary is open for all to see if you like.0
-
No, I think this happens especially if you were taking in a ton more calories that is needed. A friend of mine at work, not overweight at all decided to give up soda and lost 10 lbs in a week due to just giving up that one vice.
if you are giving up several and are very heavy than I don't think initially to drop a lot quickly is bad for you, I just wouldn't get discouraged when things start to slow.0 -
No because you are starting out with a massive amount, so it's proportional. If you were starting out at say, 180 pounds and lost 23 pounds in a month, that would be problematic. Have you checked in with your doc?0
-
My doctor is monitoring me very closely and he said he is very happy with my progress. And I really do know it will slow down. I don't care how slow it goes as long as I keep getting healthier.0
-
My doctor is monitoring me very closely and he said he is very happy with my progress. And I really do know it will slow down. I don't care how slow it goes as long as I keep getting healthier.
great attitude!!! Keep up the good work!!0 -
My doctor is monitoring me very closely and he said he is very happy with my progress. And I really do know it will slow down. I don't care how slow it goes as long as I keep getting healthier.
Sounds like you are on the right track then!0 -
I think you're doing great, well done. To be able to turn around your eating habits so drastically and stick to it is very good
Also, your busy/active work hours will make an impact on your calorie burn I should think0 -
I think you are doing great. If your doctor is working with you you should be fine. I agree that slow & steady wins the race but there is also a difference when the amounts to lose in general are more. Someone who only needs to lose 20lbs should be set to 1/2lb a week & slower loss than someone who needs to lose 50lbs & someone to lose 100lbs can lose Ore faster or have larger calorie deficit without a poor affect on overall health.
Just remember to recalculate your #'s as you drop weight & become more active your BMR & TDEE will also change which will change your goals. I think I read every 10lbs you lose re-do your #'s.
Sounds like you are doing great.0 -
It sounds like your doing all the responsible things especially having a doctor follow you closely. Sounds like your body is happy with what your doing and You seem happy too! If you were to incorporate exercise then I would definitely talk with your doctor about a gradual program to be safe. That is a lot of weight to lose in a month but it seems you have a larger goal to lose so your body is going to react differently. The only thing I've ever read about rapid weight loss was your skin's ability to adjust to the rapid weight loss. That's the only thing I would worry about. The skin's ability to snap back from such a rapid loss.
Congrats on your switch to a healthy lifestyle! That's what it's all about.0 -
Keep track of your calories, you should not be eating less that 1,200. and drink water a lot. When I stared the first month I lost 22 Lb, then it level. I am losing 1 to 2 a week. the lower your weight is the less that you lose a week.
but, I will run it by a nutriciones any way. Just be sure that you take vitamins. A get a blod test every 3 months to be sure that all my counts are correct. I stared at 240 and now I am at 208, in 3 months. Like I said the first 20 was the first month. Be careful, sometimes when you do a big change like that, you may give up. I count all my calories and if I have something hight in calories, I reduce the calories in the other meals. Be sure to have check how many grams of protein you need for your weight. good luck0 -
Listen to your doctor. Good for you!!0
-
I didn't look at your diary but I'm thinking if you went from eating tons of fast food to eating healthy you're probly dropping a lot of eater weight too. Fast food is full of sodium which equals water retention! Keep up the good work, you're doing great0
-
As I understand it, safe weight loss is based on a percentage of your body weight - I'm not sure of the exact percentage, but for a lot of people it comes down to between 1/2 and 2 pounds a week. While I can reassure you that this is safe and normal (especially since a lot of your first month's losses are water weight) I hope you understand that as your weight decreases, the amount you lose in a month will decrease as well; don't let this discourage you.0
-
My doctor is monitoring me very closely and he said he is very happy with my progress. And I really do know it will slow down. I don't care how slow it goes as long as I keep getting healthier.
As long as you keep your physician 'in the loop' and he is fine with how things are going, then continue. I wish others would consult with their physicians more often.... I cant tell you how many medical claims come through that I have to attempt to appeal to the insurance companies....and its because the patient never consulted with their doctors... and made things worse for theirselves...
Kudos!!!!!0 -
In 2004 I gave up Soda completely I also started walking at least twice a day. Prior to that I would drink at least 1 can of soda a day maybe 2. I lost 15lbs right away. I think it was from not having all that sugar. There are appox 9-10 tbsp of sugar in one can of soda! Just think of the calories you are no longer taking in. I would chalk most of you loss up to that.0
-
I have looked at research in Obesity Journal and there is no evidence that people who lose weight quickly are less healthy than those who lose slowly, and they put weight back on at a slightly lower rate. Obesity is a pre-disease state so we need to get out of it quickly. I think mfp should modify it's weight loss advise depending on the weight of the person. If I was eating as much as they advise, I would lose weight unbearably slow.0
-
Your rate of loss will slow down as you go, but you may want to consider upping your calories intake a little if you feel concerned about this now. As long as your doctor is monitoring you, you're probably doing fine.0
-
great job on the weight loss, the first so many pounds is easier to lose at the begining, just look to see how many calories you should be having per day and just not go beyond that to lose weight. ,keep it up and dont worry about losing weight so fast.0
-
Congrats on your loss! Two things: You are eating enough so no worries there and 2. You are being monitored by your doctor who agrees that you're on the right track, based on what you posted. You're doing great so keep up the good work!0
-
1300 to 1500 on average and not really exercising at all. My diary is open for all to see if you like.
On the surface without looking too hard, it appears to me that you are probably ok at this point. Here is the deal -- you are morbidly obese... (I have been there ... this in no wise is meant as an offensive statement)... When you are at this level, it is ok (I think) to lose weight rapidly... This is as long as you are consuming enough to maintain your weight at the weight you care to attain... SO if you are let's say 5'4" and want to weigh 130 but are currently let's say 320.. @ 320 lbs your BMR is about 2076 calories per day... BUT at 130 (your goal weight) it is 1215 calories per day... In other words, naturally, your body is burning an extra 1050 calories per day... just to maintain your size... Therefore, you can easily lose weight faster when you first start than you will be able when you get closer to your goal.
Also, you indicated that you have dropped drinking a lot of soda... This may have caused an initial flush of water weight as you first began your life change. As you progress, you will notice that you will have to do more to continue losing weight... You will not maintain this rate of loss as you progress toward your goal.. If you do, then I would think there is a problem somewhere...
Moving forward I would suggest...
1. Begin at least some light aerobic exercise. When you are ready, begin some toning exercises to help build muscle mass and strength. Those of us who have been morbidly obese fight the tendency to have hanging skin... This can be helped by water intake, slower progress moving forward and by weight training. It is less about losing weight and much more about a healthy lifestyle.
2. Do not be discouraged when your progress slows down.. This SHOULD happen and is a good thing. As you approach your goal, you should go to about a 2 lb per week loss then maybe a 1 lb per week loss.. This is normal and a good thing.
3. Eat plenty of protein in your diet to maintain muscle mass.
Best wishes on your journey.. .You are off to a great start. You can do this. Keep up the great work.0 -
you have a lot to lose, so it will come off quicker.0
-
My doctor is monitoring me very closely and he said he is very happy with my progress. And I really do know it will slow down. I don't care how slow it goes as long as I keep getting healthier.
Great job! Right attitude, check. Monitored by Dr., check. Realistic expectations, check. Sounds like all is good in your world!0 -
I know that it is recommended to lose weight slowly in order to keep it off. I look at my own loss (23 pounds in 30 days) and worry that maybe its coming off too fast. I haven't done anything rediculous, though my change in eating habits has been drastic simply because I was eating so badly before. My job keeps me running so hard without breaks that I found it next to impossible to eat at work, then I would grab fast food (super sized of course) on my way home at 1 am and scarf it down before going to sleep. Then I was sleeping till noon and maybe eating something before I left for work or (again) grabbing some takeout on the way to eat quickly before I started work. The only liquids I ever drank was diet pop and I drank a lot of it (minimum 2 L a day). On May 30 I went cold turkey. I gave up all liquids except water and have had nothing but water ever since (I'm finding I actually like it now and don't miss the pop at all). I am also eating a lot more food now, every two hours no matter what I am doing (I have made a habit of bringing snacks with me everywhere I go). I cut out junk food completely and don't miss that one bit either. I'm finding I am never hungry any more, I'm liking the healthy food a lot more than the junk food and I'm feeling healthier than I have in years.
My question is...if I am eating and feeling great and not craving or hungry ever, is the weight loss still too fast? I want to lose the weight but I also want to be doing it right.
____________________________________________________
No, I don't believe it's been too fast. Everything is relative. You started at 345: 23 lbs. is 6.6%. This would be like someone who is 160 lbs. dropping to 150 lbs. in one month. What's more, a lot of that initial weight is water weight because you've cut back on your carbohydrate intake -- sugar, in particular. For each gram of carbohydrates we eat, our bodies retain 3 to 4 grams of water. You're not holding as much water as you did when you were drinking soda and eating lots of carbs which metabolize quickly into glucose.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions