Who are you? A Trekie, or a Whovie. The ultimate debate.

13

Replies

  • Scubanana7
    Scubanana7 Posts: 361 Member
    Star Trek -- original. then Voyager....loved the female captain! then all the other Start Treks....ALLL movies. Then came Battelstar Gallatica. Only loved original Star Wars. then they got kinda dumb....then the whole first isn't first, go back before crap just annoyed me so never watched the later episodes. if they were first, they shoulda been first.....lol

    still miss Battlestar.....and Voyager (seen it three times...)

    what's next? where is my new space scifi. hubby loves Walkin Dead...but I NEED SPACE---
  • demondj0220
    demondj0220 Posts: 1
    Whovie. Matt Smith.
  • fletchilicious
    fletchilicious Posts: 6
    The ultimate debate? Where? England? Certainly not in the US.
  • Le_Joy
    Le_Joy Posts: 549 Member
    I was 12 years old when I went to my first Dr. Who convention. I bought a Tom Baker poster, button and the pattern for how to make that nifty scarf he wore! :)

    Yay! Someone else who knows Dr. Who from a long time ago! David Tennant is hottest, but I liked Tom Baker.
  • FatUncleRob
    FatUncleRob Posts: 341
    I like both Star Trek and Dr. Who.

    Started watching Dr Who about 40 years ago. :glasses: Tom Baker was my favorite Doctor.
  • ConstableOdo
    ConstableOdo Posts: 104
    I like both equally and for different reasons.
  • patchesgizmo
    patchesgizmo Posts: 244 Member
    oh my Honey you are so young. I am both. I watched Star Trek the original back in the 70's and Dr Who every week on PBS for our half hour episode back in the 70's also. Tom Baker is the my favorite Doctor Who. It would be so hilarious for Dr Who to land on the Enterprise.
  • shmiracles
    shmiracles Posts: 105 Member
    i love this thread!
    Doctor Who
    Star Trek
    Firefly
    Sherlock
    Misfits
    i love this thread!

    the 9th Doctor will always be my first.

    i have nothing useful to add hah
  • tappae
    tappae Posts: 568 Member
    img-thing.jpg

    Tai-kong suo-yo duh shing-chiouh doh sai-jin wuh duh pee-goo!
  • Canuck_TriFit
    Canuck_TriFit Posts: 97 Member
    Star Trek Original series.
    Captain Kirk... is my favorite acting... captain... The way.... he takes forever... to get a sentence out! Also.... the way he totally.... ignored.... the prime.... directive!
  • Fit_Canuck
    Fit_Canuck Posts: 788 Member
    Star Trek Original series.
    Captain Kirk... is my favorite acting... captain... The way.... he takes forever... to get a sentence out! Also.... the way he totally.... ignored.... the prime.... directive!

    Great nickname and well said!
  • EJand94
    EJand94 Posts: 55 Member
    You're all posers....I've been watching Doctor Who since 1975.....Tom Baker IS my Doctor. That was when it was a toss up to who was hotter....Sarah Jane Smith or Romana II

    Of course Ace was pretty hot during the Sylvester McCoy years...

    This is true. For someone who has watched it since tom baker, i am indeed a poser. But I was born in the '90s, and wasn't exposed to Sci Fi until I got to high school. I thought it was lame. Now, it is the coolest thing since sliced bread.
  • EJand94
    EJand94 Posts: 55 Member
    Trekkie. Old school. Get off my lawn.

    DOCTOR WHO STARTED IN 1963!!!! Star Trek didn't start till 1966!!!! WHich was when the doctor who movie came out. Star trek also has it's longevity based off of spin offs. Doctor who is one show :)
  • EJand94
    EJand94 Posts: 55 Member
    Oh, and Sarah Jane Smith, Romana 2, Rose, and Rory are my favorite companions. And let's not forget, Jack Harkness. Face of Boe, ftw.
  • stepherzzzzz
    stepherzzzzz Posts: 469 Member
    Ick, neither. I'm more of an X-Files kind of girl.
  • mamamudbug
    mamamudbug Posts: 572 Member
    what's next? where is my new space scifi. hubby loves Walkin Dead...but I NEED SPACE---

    You and me, both, sister!

    Out of the two in the op, Star Trek takes the edge only because I've been watching them longer. I love them both, though.
  • SteffieMark
    SteffieMark Posts: 1,719 Member
    I choose both and more!
  • McBully4
    McBully4 Posts: 1,270 Member
    No love for Stargate?

    I nerd out on some Stargate
  • kaymarie78
    kaymarie78 Posts: 104
    Total Whovian all the way!
  • mamamudbug
    mamamudbug Posts: 572 Member
    No love for Stargate?

    I nerd out on some Stargate

    Love Stargate
  • BrienJD
    BrienJD Posts: 541 Member
    The Doctor always had the cutest companions. I had a crush on Sarah Jane, Romana (I was happy but heartbroken when she married Tom Baker.) and Leela! Rawr!!!
  • Jain
    Jain Posts: 861 Member
    I started watching Dr Who way back in the dark ages (1971) and Tom Baker is 'my' Dr. Star Treck was fun, but Dr Who had the best monsters.:laugh:

    But no love here for Babylon5?
  • Mctree20
    Mctree20 Posts: 137
    Tom Baker will always be Dr Who for me.

    But definitely Red Dwarf FTW!!
  • Loopylu84
    Loopylu84 Posts: 28 Member
    So totally both, every series of star trek since I was little and doctor who since it came back on a few years ago.
    I'm such a geek :)
  • peles_fire
    peles_fire Posts: 501
    Neither, I am a Jedi like my father...
  • joehempel
    joehempel Posts: 1,543 Member
    No love for Stargate?

    No. LOL
  • caraiselite
    caraiselite Posts: 2,631 Member
    tennant fangirl!
    i make all my friends watch doctor who. if they don't like it.. then we don't stay friends ;)
    i'd like matt smith more if he didn't look similar to my ex.. they even act the same. it's mildly annoying.
    baker is so wonky, it's amusing.

    never even watched star trek.

    i like star wars, firefly, and bsg too.
  • tonybreyal
    tonybreyal Posts: 3 Member
    Sylvester McCoy (soon to be seen playing Radagast the Brown in The Hobbit) was my Doctor when I was a kid of 3 or 4 years old and still is to a certain degree. Second place goes to Tennant.
  • livingrose
    livingrose Posts: 16
    Oh, both!

    Star Trek was the only program my family could watch together when I was a kid (my dad worked away a lot and when he was home, he'd just want to watch football and mum was all about detective programs) and I have fond memories of getting up early on a Saturday morning and watching Dr Who with my mum while I ate my cereal.

    It's no surprise I grew up to be a sci-fi geek. Christopher Eccleston will always be my Doctor, but there is something deliciously dark about David Tennant's Doctor.

    As for the modern Star Trek reboot, I love it and not just for the fact that Karl Urban (swoon!) is a wonderful Dr McCoy.
  • dad106
    dad106 Posts: 4,868 Member
    Considering I've never heard of Dr.Who.. It has to be Star Trek.

    I watched TNG and Voyager.. Some deep space 9 and none of the new episodes.

    Love the movies too.. and loved Warf/Data!

Categories