Need support from those who struggle with binging..

On a day when I should be relaxed, I am stressed out today about eating. I Really want a sweet. I just can't get a McDonalds McFlurry out of my mind. And, I am meeting my Dad at Bravo's for lunch, and it's my Father In Law's birthday party tonight. You should think I would be relaxed. I have a break from the kids, but I am worrying about overeating too much today! My therapist said I need to stay away from sweets (it will trigger a binge). She told me it's like having an "allergy". I need to stay away! But the book I am reading, "Breaking Free from Emotional Eating" says the opposite,

"When you no longer put foods in a box and call them forbidden, you will no longer feel the urgency to rip the box open and consume what's in it in a frenzied race against the time when you'll slam it shut again. ( Roth, Breaking Free from Emotional Eating, pg. 74)

So, do I let myself have a small sliver of cake tonight at my FIL's birthday? I am leaning towards having a small piece so I don't deprive myself. What would you do? I just want something to take the edge off, but it's so difficult having a food addiction. alcholics and drug addicts don't have to be around their "drug", but we NEED food to live. Anyway...if anyone has any thoughts or suggestions. I am doing so much better with this after getting on Celexa and meeting with a therapist monthly. But, I think it will always be a battle for me. Long for the day when I can keep a box of chocolates in the fridge and forget about them!
«1

Replies

  • secretlobster
    secretlobster Posts: 3,566 Member
    I would probably have a small piece, yes... Being able to moderate yourself and prove that you CAN have any food you want (though not all the time) without binging on it is ultimately more helpful than forbidding yourself.

    Struggled with bulimia for 3 years, it's still hard, but complete deprivation didn't/wouldn't work for me personally.
  • billsica
    billsica Posts: 4,741 Member
    There are worse things in life than cake. Have a piece. track it and make it fit into your calorie goals.

    That that box of chocolates and spray them with windex.
  • Thanks for your feedback, secretlobster. I also struggled with bulimia for years, but stopped after knowing what it does to my body. But, I still have slip ups with the binging. It's a struggle, and you are right. I need to prove to myself I CAN eat a piece a cake in moderation. Gonna enjoy every bite! :) I guess I needed permission...want to get to the point where I can give myself permission without feeling guilty for enjoying a treat once in a while! :)
  • lottycat
    lottycat Posts: 333 Member
    Honestly, I would try your absolute best to not think about it until you are at the party. Really force yourself to chill out about the food. Focus on how nice it will be to spend time with your family, catch up on news and relax without the kids.

    Then just decide once you're there if you want the sweet food. If you do then have a small bit, then move physically away from it. If you end up eating lots you'll feel horrible guilty and bloated. But it's not the end of the world, just pick yourself up and start fresh and happy again tomorrow.

    Good luck x
  • deb_109
    deb_109 Posts: 16
    For me I can't have a piece of cake, I know it will trigger a binge and I know it will get out of control.. It's like I cheated might as well feed the beast.. I'm 65 days binge free I'm staying away from sugar .. I'm hoping one day I can have piece and move on ,but I know I'm not strong enough .I'm getting there one day at a time... Have a low sugar fruit like strawberries and whip cream..
    You must be concern if your already stressed about it so I say don't do it.... Stay in control unil you know your strong enough

    Best of Luck
  • KristyJoy123
    KristyJoy123 Posts: 84 Member
    I can see the validity in both. I struggle with Kit Kat bars. I know, it's weird. But when I'm sitting at work, I KNOW I can go get one out of the vending machine. It becomes an obsession, and if I don't restrict it, I'll probably eat two, so know I'm no longer allowed to have Kit Kat bars. End.

    I think it depends on how you look at food, really.
  • ♥ChUbByCoyLe♥
    ♥ChUbByCoyLe♥ Posts: 267 Member
    I am a ridiculous binge eater. If it was me, i would have a small piece of cake then exercise it off. It's too hard to stick to a healthy eating plan when you deprave yourself of all the things you love.

    Good luck on your weight loss journey x
  • dr_tina
    dr_tina Posts: 225 Member
    it depends on your personality, for some people they have to steer clear and for others it is bettter to learn to have small amounts. The reason your getting different info is because people are different and you need to find out what works for you. I have handled it by having one spike day (Saturday) and it being off limits besides that day. This works for me, but it is not what is best for everyone
  • Amryfal
    Amryfal Posts: 225
    i have trouble with binging too. i can't say not to listen to your therapist. but i have found that when i avoid all the sweets and pastries that i love, my motivation only holds for so long. i manage to *occasionally* get a small package of separately wrapped hundred-calorie-packs of sweets, and then i can control the urge to eat them all. but that was only after many years of trying and failing :(

    what do you honestly think? will the little piece of cake be enough, or will it make you miserable and want more?
  • Dethea
    Dethea Posts: 247 Member
    I would have a piece of cake and try not to stress about it... If you are really worried about it, try eating just the cake and leave most of the frosting on your plate.

    From personal experience, the best thing for me was allowing myself to have a little bit once in awhile, and that helps keep me from overindulging. It takes a long time and a lot of work to really break yourself of the habit (I went months without binging, then after a bad week I had a bad binge last Saturday) so just know, if you do have a binge, it's okay. You will be okay. Don't beat yourself up over it. Try to accept what just happened and move on.

    Stress is a binge trigger for many people. Work on not stressing over your food, and that will help.

    As for your therapist... do you feel like she is really helping? Do you have a connection with her? Is she experienced with eating disorders? Maybe take the book with you to your next session and tell her how you feel about what you read. Your therapist is there to make suggestions, not tell you how to live. You can work on a solution together.
  • Captain_Tightpants
    Captain_Tightpants Posts: 2,215 Member
    I think it depends on you. For some people, avoidance works better. There are some convincing studies out there that show the powerful priming effects a small amount of nutrient-light, high sugar, high fat food combination (such as cake) can have on the psyche. For a decent percentage of us, having that one slice just leads to increased craving for more, rather than satiety. For others, trying to avoid it just leads to a buildup of steam and eventual release in a binge. The trick is figuring out which type of person you are.

    To complicate matters, I've noticed in my own experience, I can be either one of the two types at different times. Depending on my mood and emotional state, sometimes I need to have a little bit of something to win the psychological battle, and sometimes I need to go to extreme lengths to avoid it altogether.

    It comes down to being very honest with yourself. A single slice of cake isn't going to set you back even the tiniest bit on your weight loss journey. At most it will bring your calories up to maintenance for the day. You certainly won't deposit any fat from it. But if you are internally aware that eating the one piece will lead to more, or will lead to a 'throwaway' of the whole day. Then you may be better off avoiding it.
  • LadyAmy20
    LadyAmy20 Posts: 137
    I agree with Lollykat - focus on the other things that will be good about the event, and try to make food an afterthought. That way you can have cake but you won't be obsessing over it so it's less likely you'll binge on it.

    Easier said than done, I know. I also struggled with bulimia and I've come to the conclusion that if I do have a binge, it's not the end of the world - it's better to accept it and move on and maybe try to be a bit healthier the next day, instead of dealing with it in a more stupid, unhealthy and dangerous way.

    I also agree with KristyJoy in that some things set me off and so I have to just never have them. With those things I find it easier once I've decided that I won't be eating them ever, because it takes the decision out of my hands when I'm in a supermarket or whatever. It isn't even an option any more.

    But, I think these things work differently for everyone. Find what works best for you and stick with it.

    Add me as a friend and I'll try and give support/motivation when it's needed :)
  • ishapeme
    ishapeme Posts: 213 Member
    I struggle tremenously with binge eating, especially when I go to my parents house. However, when I know I'm going out to eat, I check the resturant's menu online and choose what I'm going to eat ahead of time then track it. That way you know exactly the calories intake you'll be having. Also, if you really feel like you can't control your portion. Eat a normal portion then honestly, leave the table for a bit. Pretend you have a phone call or somethinhg. I know this is a little OCD, but if it's a serious problem for you, you have to get yourself in the right mindset. I agree, don't deprive yourself. Good luck!

    P.s. Sometimes I call my parents ahead of time and ask what they will be making. That way I can track the calories ahead of time.
  • krisiepoo
    krisiepoo Posts: 710 Member
    You're trying to make a life change and changing your life should not include cutting out things that you want. If you want the piece of cake but are worried about going over your calories hit the gym and build up some extra calories or just go for a long walk.

    I'm obviously not perfect otherwise I wouldn't be 50# overweight, but when I REALLY want to binge, i go to the store and buy ONE thing and LOVE it. SAVOR it. If I buy a box, i will eat whatever is in it but I will NOT deprive myself because the rest of my life will not depend on deprivation :)
  • smjarmon
    smjarmon Posts: 1
    it is much better to have a little than to stress out about it all day. I have a huge problem with binging but in the last couple months I haven't binged once. The only thing I changed was the way I approached "dieting". I eat a peice of chocolate if I want one, or cake, I just have less than I would have before. Stress is bad for you and your diet. Drink a big glass of water before you eat your little peice of cake. If they try and hand you a bigger piece then you think fits your goals, thank them but firmly and kindly tell them that you would like a smaller peice. When you eat it, enjoy it. After you're done, don't punish yourself. Then do something afterward that burns calories but doesn't feel like exercise, like going for a walk, or snuggling with your honey, dancing to a music video, whatever the case may be. But if you stress out about it all day eventually that little voice that sabotages you is gonna say, you deserve that cake, you're just being ridiculous, then you'll eat a huge peice after a large dinner, you'll feel gross and you'll be mad at yourself.
  • SamanthaD23
    SamanthaD23 Posts: 53 Member
    I think most people here have said "don't stress" in one way or another.

    I had a year of therapy and discovered some very deep-set reasons for some of my overeating. I also learned my attitude towards food was described as "petulant" - I CAN have it, so I'm GONNA!

    Anyways, I know it's hard but you need to r-e-l-a-x around food and listen to your body. If you ain't hungry, don't eat it. I got a whole lot of stress-vibes coming just from your post and it sounds like you've wound yourself up about food for a lot of years. Work on that.

    Oh and try and think differently than "I think it will always be a battle for me" ...

    We're either all right there with you mate, or we have been. Good luck.



    p.s. "I might have a bit of cake so I'm not deprived" - you need to think about what you're actually depriving yourself of :)
  • Thanks everyone. I think I am going to enjoy myself and let myself have that piece of cake and just allocate calories to go towards it. I want to become more balanced, and I want to be kind to myself. Glad to know I am not alone in this though. :) The one thing that makes me think I can do this is 1) we have no junk in the house I would like to binge on (so when we come home from the party, I won't get in trouble 2) My husband is very understanding and won't bring any extra cake home with us. My entire family knows of my problems with binging and are very supportive. I couldn't ask for a better support system, and I am thankful to have found MFP to help become healthier mentally and physically while losing weight! :) Thanks!
  • rlmadrid
    rlmadrid Posts: 694 Member
    My first and foremost tip to you is to not keep the chocolates in the fridge. If you want chocolate, leave the house and go get it. You'll be surprised at just how much binging that will stop.

    Second, your therapist makes sense, but not every person is the same. I personally make allowances for cravings as long as they fit into, or don't overly surpass my calorie goal. The way I see it, being OCD about the numbers was driving my anxiety through the roof. I'm healthier this way, and still losing about a pound a week! The secret? Lifestyle change vs diet.

    Restricting yourself to no sweets, no junk, no carb-laden delicacies, will just make those untouchable objects all the more appealing. If you want a slice of cake tonight, have one. But compromise, have a salad with fruit and nuts at lunch. Maybe decide to have a mini McFlurry, (half the size of the full ones they are about 500 cals), or simply choose cake or ice cream. Realize that you are not eliminating sweets for the rest of your life, but you are giving them a smaller role in your daily diet.

    My last piece of advice was something I read on here (I'd credit but I can't remember where I saw it :blushing: )
    "Are you hungry? Do you want some carrot sticks?" If the answer to either question is a no, then you likely don't need to eat. Perhaps between lunch and the party you'll be full enough to not really need a big dinner? You don't have to deprive yourself, just balance your life. Good luck, and have fun tonight!
  • SoozeE512
    SoozeE512 Posts: 439 Member
    I'm glad you've decided to find your balance today to allow for the cake, I would have suggested the same. Don't stress over it, just savor each bite and allow the smile to spread across your face when you do :) I think you'll find it's much more satisfying that way.
  • rhymeswithfox
    rhymeswithfox Posts: 63 Member
    For me I do a couple of things. One I ask myself, what type of person do I want to be today? Everyday is different and new and an opportunity to start fresh with who you want to be. I like sweets and many other unhealthy foods but every time I told myself, "cut it out completely" that same day I would go eat a bunch of it. It's like I was challenging my inner food demons and they always won lol. So now I can eat whatever I want but in moderation and I have to write it down. The best advice for me has honestly been- don't beat yourself up, write everything you eat so you don't cheat, and just take it day and moment at a time. Talk to yourself and ask what you really want, breathe, and work with your demons not against them! So far I've stuck it out for twenty days (longest so far) and have already been seeing exciting results.
  • This is so great to read - you reaching out to the community. Well done for being brave and speaking about this. No matter what addiction we have - drugs, food, we are suppressing some kind of pain. Once we learn to accept ourselves entirely, thats when eating that piece of cake is no sweat, because you can take responsibilty for your action and work it off through healthy eating the next day and a bit of exercise. Don't give food power. Separate your mind from your body - SO much easier said that done!! Your thoughts are perspectives and opinions you've collected and frankly, we do ourselves more harm than good. So thankyou for being brave, and know that you're not indifferent by having this issue to deal with. I hope you find a way to relax and enjoy food and this journey. I have suffered from bullemia for the last few years and what it took for me was a self help book and many personal reminders that I AM work happiness and I can bloody feel good in jeans and look sexy! Why am I sabotaging this body that has been nothing but loyal to me?!?
    Good luck darling, you can do it, just go with what you feel and what your body is telling you versus your emotions.
    Xx
  • LaLouve_RK
    LaLouve_RK Posts: 899 Member
    I don't really have a sweet tooth, even though I get a sugar rage once in a while. My problem is with salty stuff such as chips.
    I say you go with what you feel will work for you. For me, is just staying away from it. It works well.
    My biggest problem is the quantities... I can eat a lot! If anyone has a tip...
  • hpsnickers1
    hpsnickers1 Posts: 2,783 Member
    If you have issues with binging then I would say no. I have Reactive Hypoglycemia (aka "prediabetes". Part hereditary and part a lifetime of a high refined carb diet. My father in on dialysis and my older brother is an obese diabetic.)

    I went Primal in May of last year. I never quite went 100% with getting rid of sugar. I have been battling it the entire time. Those cravings are caused by the jumps/crashes in your blood sugar (you don't have to be diabetic to get them. You don't have to be overweight to get them). If you are craving sweets then you are addicted to them. In a good chunk of people, carbohdrates create an addiction along the same lines as cocoaine, heroin, opium. The only way I can get rid of my cravings is by removing the sweets completely and make sure I eat plenty of calories (I follow a low-carb/high-fat lifestyle so I have to eat quite a bit more calories to maintain my weight then I would have to if I was following a high-carb/low-fat lifestyle. Carbs cause my body to start storing fat (and retaining water) very, very quickly (I've ballooned up 10lbs in less than two weeks on a carb binge)

    I have suffered from anxiety disorder, depression, volatile emotions etc. At the same time I have also suffered from chronic indigestion, hiatal hernia, IBS, constipation/diarrhea, bloat, stomach pains/gas from delayed-stomach emptying, etc. When I removed the majority of carbs from my diet (sugar was turning me diabetic; grains were destroying my gut) and increased my fat intake (I also removed almost all processed foods and now try and eat only real food) to about 65%-70% of my calorie intake all issues went away.

    The sugar cravings come and go but as long as I'm eating enough calories and getting enough natural fats (I eat quite a bit of saturated fat) and protein the sugar cravings stay very, very dim.
    I still can't even eat a piece of fruit or have a sweet potato without the cravings intensifying and I don't like those feelings.
    BUT N=1

    But if you can do it then props to you!!

    Edit: By the way, I'm maintaining my weight now (5'2" at 111lbs). I was never obese. I was close to overweight - but I was very sick and unhealthy. I dropped 10lbs following the low-calorie, low-fat diet. But what I got from going Primal was my mental stability back, my energy levels back, (I got a flat belly for the first time in my life), my evenings back (I don't have to exercise constantly to look good and maintain. I GOT MY HEALTH. I can't say I got that back because I have never been healthy. I had to get to 41 years old to figure it out.
  • oreyna
    oreyna Posts: 88 Member
    It's tough...it's like a slippery slope sometimes. Just gotta be strong and have some self control. I feel that if you avoid the cravings...they only get worse. Just enjoy in moderation...and drink plenty of water.
  • cavewoman15
    cavewoman15 Posts: 278 Member
    <-- binger!! try this: eat a SMALL cookie (or half a big cookie - think 100-150 cals) and a cup of coffee or tea. sometimes this will do it for me for several days, sometimes a week or two. make sure it's a good cookie!!
  • kapspecial
    kapspecial Posts: 67 Member
    Without any in-depth research or study (I'm a non-expert), I think it's hard to live and get healthy with all the pressure we can sometimes put on ourselves. There is no one way to do most things. So you've been craving a sweet for a bit. It seems as if you haven't given in so why not plan to have a sweet at the party. If you decide to have some cake tonite what will help you to have the one small serving you've planned for? Does it help for you to tell your husband and maybe a few friends that you've been struggling and have planned to only have one small piece of cake. Get the small piece of cake and savor each bite. Then when it's gone you're done. Or if after some thought you think the party atmosphere will be too challenging, get your sweet right before the party. Maybe not a McFlurry since it's so high in calorie, but maybe there's a good alternative. But make sure it's a single serving only.

    Believe in yourself and your ability to overcome the habit of binge eating. It's great that you are getting support and help to handle this. Don't stress yourself out. Take some deep breaths, collect your thoughts, create a plan, and implement. Just today, just focus on today. You'll do the right thing!!! I'll keep you in my thoughts.
  • LindaCWy
    LindaCWy Posts: 463 Member
    For me, when I go somewhere surrounded by mounds of people and I am uncomfortable, I usually park myself beside the food and eat, and eat, and eat. Now that I know this I park myself as far away from the food as possible. Eat the cake or else you will be obsessed with the cake and eat something else to fill the void.

    I never had an ED, but I did have a problem stopping myself from eating, it's worse when I'm with my big Italian family, cause they litterally put food in your hand and would shove it down your throat if they could. This past Sunday was one of those days, I wasn't hungry in the least, but I just ate and ate and ate and ate. I realized when it was too late, but didn't punish myself for it. It happens, you grieve and move on.

    Have the cake.
  • LarStar
    LarStar Posts: 102 Member
    Hi debomommyforh, I have struggled with binge eating for most of my life and have had the opportunity to work with some really great doctors who have helped me to become incredibly mindful of where I go in my head while binging. As I look back now at the struggle I had, I know that I went in waves of denying myself everything and then allowing everything. There are different schools of thought and no one right answer. People will often swing along the spectrum of eating disorders, taking on binge eating and bulimic habits or binge eating and then anorexic habits in an effort to undue what they have "done."

    I would usually stop myself from eating any of the cake for example, because I knew that even if I had a piece of it, I would tear myself apart for eating it., even if it was just a little bite. As I started to get better, I started to realize that I could have just one piece. I learned to watch myself think through a binge; often thinking "there won't be any more, so I have to eat it now." Now, I try to be gentle with myself, so if I do decide to have a piece of cake (or whatever) I will talk myself through it and ask myself questions in advance Before: 1. Do I really want this? 2. Why do I want it? 3. Do I feel emotional right now? (If I am emotional, I will usually avid eating for 30 minutes) 4. Will this put me over my calories (if yes, I either won't eat it or if I do decide to eat it, I make sure to exercise it off (I ask myself, "Is it worth 1 hr in the pool for 1/2 a piece of cake?".) There were times when I would eat it and promise myself to exercise and then I woudn't, and ended up feeling terrible about myself, so now I know that if I probably won't be able to work it off, t doesn't go into my mouth.

    While I am eating, I talk to myself: Am I enjoying this? If yes, I try to eat it slowly, putting my fork down between bites and letting the taste sit in my mouth. If no, I throw it out.
    If i was enjoying it, as I start to finish the piece and look towards the rest of the cake that s left, I remind myself that that is not the ONLY cake. If I want cake later, I can go to the store and buy it any time. It is always accessible to me. For now, I don't have to have another piece.

    If I have a party to attend, I will exercise in the morning to 1. give me extra calories incase there is a treat there that I would like to have and 2. to make me think twice if that treat is worth all the hard work I did during the workout earlier that day.

    If I overeat, I usually get sulky and pissy and then just want to eat more, but I force myself to go for a walk or exercise. The problem with food addiction and disordered eating is that most people have issues with it and simply don't realize it. When I think about people who struggle with alcohol addiction and places they often avoid (bars, festivals, sports games, etc) I work to do the same. I avoid buffets, fast food restaurants, and take out. I choose not to buy crappy foods to keep around the house that I know I will binge on. I try to avoid big eating parties or going to other peoples homes for dinner unless I know what will be served. On those family get together's that can't be avoided, I make a point of having 1 plate of food and putting off desert until the very end, knowing that I can have it any time, but am choosing not to. If I do decide to have it, that I am having it because I want it, not because I feel an urge to eat. I will also tell myself, if I skip this and want a different treat later that night, I will let myself do that. I usually end up skipping the cake and then not stopping to get a different treat because then I have to think myself through getting off route on my way home, going into the store, picking out what I want, how much $ it will cost me, and that I will have to buy it from the cashier. If I do stop, I will only buy single servings - 1 ice cream bar from a convenience store or 1 chocolate bar or a small bag of whatever.

    The most important thing to remember is that if you do eat the cake and go over, as soon as your put your fork down, you're still OK! You're still losing weight and you're still on the right track!

    I still wont keep a box of chocolates in the fridge because if I do they will be on my mind until I throw them out or eat them all, and that isn't something I want to do to myself, but I'm getting better and I'm doing a really good job.

    It's great that you are premeditating what tonight will be like so that you can create an "escape route" for yourself.

    You're doing great!!!
  • I struggle with binging and food addiction too. My sister can have sweet stuff in the house and make it last. If I have it, it's gone the first night and then I feel guilty and hate myself. Eat the small piece. I find when I try to have it but limit it to out of the house at parties or special occasions, I do better. If I try to totally abstain, I go crazy and then when I do cave I go overboard and go on a hell-bent free-for-all and then sink to where I started. You have to make guidelines for yourself that you can live with and that work for you. So don't feel guilty of taking a small piece with the others in celebration and make yourself feel better by doing a physical activity that day to compensate a bit. :)
  • Giantess
    Giantess Posts: 213 Member
    To complicate matters, I've noticed in my own experience, I can be either one of the two types at different times. Depending on my mood and emotional state, sometimes I need to have a little bit of something to win the psychological battle, and sometimes I need to go to extreme lengths to avoid it altogether.

    This is me, exactly. Sometimes I can have a little and let it settle my craving. Sometimes a handful of raisins will send me off the deep end of sugar-binge-depravity.

    Ask yourself how YOU feel. Do you think you will downward spiral for a slice of cake? If you have the slice, have an escape plan for not having more. I would tell people around me I am only having one slice, so then I would feel embarrassed if I went for seconds. Crowd accountability, heh. I told my class one year that I wasn't eating sugars, and lo and behold, they became my sugar patrol. Their parents would bring cupcakes, and a nice piece of fruit for the teacher. Kids would come around offering left over treats to teachers, and my class would shoo them away at the door.

    I'm trying to train my fiancee the same way, haha. ; )