Help needed - How to measure body fat?
000WhiteRose000
Posts: 266 Member
I have Accu-Measure calipers but not sure I'm measuring correctly.
The results I'm getting don't seem right (too low).
Does anyone know a good site / method for females?
The results I'm getting don't seem right (too low).
Does anyone know a good site / method for females?
0
Replies
-
Calipers will only be accurate when someone trained in using them measures you. It is near imposible to het a food reading measuring yourself. And even then not 100%. The more sites on your body you measure the more axcurate, min 3 site reading preferablu 5.0
-
the scales at my gym measure body fat % so you could look out for some, they have hadles at the side to grip to measure your body fat0
-
I recommend this site.
http://www.calculator.net/body-type-calculator.html?bustsize=90&bustsizeunit=centimeter&waistsize=70&waistsizeunit=centimeter&hipsize=90&hipsizeunit=centimeter&x=103&y=11
I would argue that it's pretty accurate. In comparison to the scale at my local gym there's only a 0.2% difference.0 -
My scales do it for me - most accurate method I've found, and they weren't too expensive either!0
-
I recommend this site.
http://www.calculator.net/body-type-calculator.html?bustsize=90&bustsizeunit=centimeter&waistsize=70&waistsizeunit=centimeter&hipsize=90&hipsizeunit=centimeter&x=103&y=11
I would argue that it's pretty accurate. In comparison to the scale at my local gym there's only a 0.2% difference.
hmmm 18.3% ? I dunno. wish it involved caliper measurement . My caliper one measurement (Around the navel) is 24.5 %.0 -
I have Accu-Measure calipers but not sure I'm measuring correctly.
The results I'm getting don't seem right (too low).
Does anyone know a good site / method for females?
If it's a one off measurement you are looking for to put your mind at rest then you could try a Bodpod. It costs about £30 - £50 depending on where you go in England (not sure about Scotland though.) A number of Universities / hospitals have them (if you go to a private company it will cost a lot more.)
You get a pretty groovy report at the end tell you your fat mass / fat free mass.0 -
I have Accu-Measure calipers but not sure I'm measuring correctly.
The results I'm getting don't seem right (too low).
Does anyone know a good site / method for females?
If it's a one off measurement you are looking for to put your mind at rest then you could try a Bodpod. It costs about £30 - £50 depending on where you go in England (not sure about Scotland though.) A number of Universities / hospitals have them (if you go to a private company it will cost a lot more.)
You get a pretty groovy report at the end tell you your fat mass / fat free mass.
This would be very interesting, but I'm looking to measure every week.0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!0 -
Get yourself a skin calliper. You dont need to be a rocket scientist to use one! Just make sure your grabbing with thumb and forefinger as much skin/fat/muscle (it should hurt a little) then put the calliper about an 1 cm from here. Plug your measurements into this calculator: http://scoobysworkshop.com/body-fat-calculator/0
-
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
This is spot on for me0 -
Get yourself a skin calliper. You dont need to be a rocket scientist to use one! Just make sure your grabbing with thumb and forefinger as much skin/fat/muscle (it should hurt a little) then put the calliper about an 1 cm from here. Plug your measurements into this calculator: http://scoobysworkshop.com/body-fat-calculator/
Hmmm I said I have a calliper?0 -
Get yourself a skin calliper. You dont need to be a rocket scientist to use one! Just make sure your grabbing with thumb and forefinger as much skin/fat/muscle (it should hurt a little) then put the calliper about an 1 cm from here. Plug your measurements into this calculator: http://scoobysworkshop.com/body-fat-calculator/
AND this site is only for males, already checked it.0 -
here you go: http://www.nerdfitness.com/blog/2012/07/02/body-fat-percentage/ Enjoy!!0
-
0
-
Buy a scale that measures bodyfat %! They are not too expensive, you can get one that also measures %water, muscle (lean body weight) in pounds and bone mass. I bought mine a few years ago, the Tanita "Ironman" Inner Scan Body Composition Monitor.0
-
Have a look at these pics and you should be able to tell if you are in the right ball park.
http://www.leighpeele.com/body-fat-pictures-and-percentages0 -
If you want to just track differences/improvements, but don't really care about HOW much you really are you can just buy a tanita scale. They aren't super accurate but it can help you figure out if you've dropped or not. If you want a better result and are ok with paying a bit, I recommend doing a bod pod. Its the least invasive of the accurate tests, and from what I hear aren't too expensive.0
-
I use AccuMeasure calipers. First thing, get somebody to help you do it the first time or two -- or use a mirror (so you don't have to look down. Second you should be measuring one inch above the hip bone (about where your lower abdomen would begin to fold over if you sat down). Pinch the skin, fat away from your body as much as possible (should be discomfort), place calipers around the pinched flesh until you hear the click.
My husband and I measure each other -- we're accurate using that method (as he gets his body fat measured annually for insurance). Take a lot of practice.0 -
calipers can be wildly inaccurate depending on the method (number of sites), if the tester uses the correct protocol for each test site, and is consistent in technique. commonly used numbers for calipers (caveat is with a trained tester and a good caliper, versus one of the cheapo $2 from gnc). I will also note that its easier to test and far more accurate for thinner subjects, you will note that the its very difficult or impossible to test an obese person with calipers.
Another method you may want to try is the circumference tests (look for the "army" test) that uses a formula to input a few key measurements for men or women, and will give you an estimate. all tests performed with a simple measuring tape.
Many still consider water testing (aka hydrostatic) to be the gold standard, and it does still have a high accuracy with the caveat that it is not suitable for people that are water phobic, or claustrophobic One of the common causes for error is if the subject has not completely emptied their lungs, creating additional buoyancy.
I feel the most accurate, and one of the easiest to use is the DEXA (also called DXA) body scanner. availability might be one of the biggest challenges, but I was able to find one in a relatively small town (I live in Little Rock, Arkansas). the cost was also attractive, at $50 for the first test and $25 for additional tests. I will note that the facility i use (hospital lab) will only allow you to get a test every 6 months.
the hand held or other bio-impedance tests are ok, as a ball park measurement but pretty inaccurate as far as the actual number. I used a pretty high end bio-impedance scale at a corporate exercise facility, at the company that manufactures that scale and a ton of other medical imaging equipment, a DEXA scan, and a $30 hand held bio-impedance tester within a few days of each other. the fancy bio-impedance tester was 5% off of the DEXA result and the cheap tester was 10% off.
what works for me is to identify an available "gold standard" test, that will probably have to pay for. could be DEXA, or hydrostatic (only ones i would call gold standards). try to take another test as close to your gold test as possible (calipers or home quality bio-impedance tester). you can do the home quality test weekly/monthly and have the gold standard test backing it up ever X number of months. Over time you should see patterns and get a better understanding of how much the home test varies from the more accurate test methods.
just my 2 cents.0 -
I recommend this site.
http://www.calculator.net/body-type-calculator.html?bustsize=90&bustsizeunit=centimeter&waistsize=70&waistsizeunit=centimeter&hipsize=90&hipsizeunit=centimeter&x=103&y=11
I would argue that it's pretty accurate. In comparison to the scale at my local gym there's only a 0.2% difference.
hmmm 18.3% ? I dunno. wish it involved caliper measurement . My caliper one measurement (Around the navel) is 24.5 %.
This site was very innacurate for me. I had in Inbody test at the gym and I have 27% body fat but this site says I have 37%!
I am not sure if they do Inbody tests where you are but this was a very good test for me x0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
This was innacturate for me as well.0 -
Buy a scale that measures bodyfat %! They are not too expensive, you can get one that also measures %water, muscle (lean body weight) in pounds and bone mass. I bought mine a few years ago, the Tanita "Ironman" Inner Scan Body Composition Monitor.
I have this too and I'm not sure how accurate it is because my bf% does bounce around from day to day but it's usually within 1%and it gives me a good idea.0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
Done and DONE thanks!!!0 -
fat2fitradio.com
Click on all calculators. Then click on the Military Body Fat calculator. It is accurate to + or - 2%.0 -
I recommend this site.
http://www.calculator.net/body-type-calculator.html?bustsize=90&bustsizeunit=centimeter&waistsize=70&waistsizeunit=centimeter&hipsize=90&hipsizeunit=centimeter&x=103&y=11
I would argue that it's pretty accurate. In comparison to the scale at my local gym there's only a 0.2% difference.
hmmm 18.3% ? I dunno. wish it involved caliper measurement . My caliper one measurement (Around the navel) is 24.5 %.
This site was very innacurate for me. I had in Inbody test at the gym and I have 27% body fat but this site says I have 37%!
I am not sure if they do Inbody tests where you are but this was a very good test for me x
This site was also grossly inaccurate for me. First at 36-28-36 (I'm only 5'3)I had a banana of straight shape, then it told me I had 19% body fat and I know with little doubt I am more at 27%0 -
I just did the military one and it had me at 21% which seems about right, but below it listed military requirements for bf% and for a woman my age to join the military I would only need to be at 32% or below! If I remember correctly over 30% is considered obese??
Maybe I'm thinking of BMI but 32% still seems high for an elite type of training.0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
This was innacturate for me as well.
If you want to really know, go pay the money.
Who cares?
Any way to get a consistent result, go for it.
And if you like a certain body fat number to brag about, just lie to people. That works as well as the scale in addition to the man in the mirror.
If you are goal oriented and into just gauging results, this one works just fine - even if it tells you something you may not like hearing.0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
This was innacturate for me as well.
If you want to really know, go pay the money.
Who cares?
Any way to get a consistent result, go for it.
And if you like a certain body fat number to brag about, just lie to people. That works as well as the scale in addition to the man in the mirror.
If you are goal oriented and into just gauging results, this one works just fine - even if it tells you something you may not like hearing.
Actually accuracy kind of matters a bit more than that though. I get what you're saying about getting a baseline and working from that and if you know you have a lot of body fat to lose your method would work great for a while, but if you're a ridiculously high or low number -- that would affect your routine, no? That calculator tells me my body fat is at 22%, which is very close to my goal of 21%, I know my body fat is closer to 27-28%. Same thing with calculators that give higher results -- if your body fat is actually lower, you end up working longer for a goal you've maybe already achieved.0 -
I use simple body measurements - here for free:
http://www.scientificpsychic.com/fitness/diet.html
This method give you good, consistent results you can use tracking progress.
Good Luck!
This is spot on for me
This is the site I use as well, it provides all kinds of beneficial measurements, not just body fat
I also advise using a Myo Tape, as I have found it so much easier to use with the anchor tab and circular retraction. It is accurate to a T as long as you position correctly.0 -
Here is the site I use. It has several methods you can try based on your own preferences, and pretty good video instructions on how to take each measurement. I've used it for years and it as proven accurate for me.
http://www.linear-software.com/online.html0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions