Low carb tips/suggestions
JimieLou
Posts: 273 Member
Ugh. Between period and carb overload yesterday I feel so icky and bloated. Any way to make it better/go away? I work at the bar today so I will be drinking a LOT of water. Tomorrow is our Thanksgiving and then Monday I'm going to try low carb until Christmas. If successful I will try to make it my lifestyle. Gonna have to read labels way more diligently Any tips/suggestions?
0
Replies
-
Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.0 -
Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain 5LBS water weight"? It makes no sense
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting). Anyone, including the MFP set, who diets, loses weights and then returns to their old ways of eating (which were obviously above maintenance in the first place) will regain the weight.
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
0 -
OP If you want to try low carb, and want advice on that, go here: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-group
if you want to debate the pros and cons of low carb as a lifestyle, stay here. You'll get plenty of discussion.
If you go low carb until christmas, and then return to a SAD, yes, prepare for the scale to go up about 5LBS once you re-introduce the Standard American Diet. That will be water weight.
You do need to find something that works for YOU. Good luck!0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
0 -
Eating crap also affects water weight. And how one feels. But we don't say that to the CICO crowd.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
Why couldn't one overshoot by 5LBS on low carb. Or, hell, just inform them.
Seriously, it makes NO SENSE to single out low carb diets as "you have to do it for life".
Any long term weight loss will only be maintained if someone makes a plan "for life".
I wonder, every day, when folks join MFP, do we say to each of them: Don't bother. If you don't plan on weighing, counting, measuring and logging for life you'll gain it all back, and then some"?
No, we don't. We hope that while they're here, they'll learn. About food, about nutrition, about their own bodies, about fitness, about their own minds... and that after they've lost the weight, they'll have the tools (and I'm not talking about a smart phone) they need to be part of the 10% that succeeds long term.
Granted, low (lower) carb "for life" can be a damned healthy and satisfying way to live, from what I can tell.
and no: one doesn't need to omit a food group for life because they did so in deficit. Think on that one...0 -
Try "Good Carbs" like brown rice, whole wheat bread, oats, almonds (basically nuts since they have healthy fats which, in studies, proved to not make you gain fat or bloatness no matter the amount, that is, if you within your caloric goal), fish (preferably tuna), Almond drinks, and any green vegetables.
Stay away from white bread, white rice, pasta/noodles, greecy meat (burgers are one hell of a carbo-bomb), fast foods, and too many sweets (you can have a Bueno every week or so, just as long as you've earned the privilege by eating right).
To minimize bloating, on your MFP app, keep track of your "SODIUM" count on the "NUTRITION" section of the app. Make sure you're under 2300 mg of SODIUM. Drink plenty of water (I drink 7-9 cups of water a day and am 5 ' 6 ft, for your reference). The bloating should only happen before you sleep. You'll wake up the next morning "looking" 4 lbs thinner, if you're doing it right.
Hope I helped some!0 -
I suppose I should clarify a few things.
I simply said christmas because that's about a months time and I want to see if it works for me. Am I looking for a quick fix? No! I've been using this app for years now and have been successful and then fallen off the wagon. When I do eat rice or pasta my portions are measured and I use brown rice and brown bread.
I was looking for some tips or suggestions. I watched my mom become obsessive over carbs 3 years ago and lose a ton of weight and then she started eating normal and gained it all back. I would like to have her success which I fully understand means that I'm not a lifer so to speak but it will always be something I need to be conscious of.
To those of you who gave me some links thank you!0 -
Reduce sodium--it's SUCH a sneaky thing and in almost everything. You can go low-carb without going high fat. I generally eat a lot of soy and have at least one protein shake a day.
Normally, I try to stick with veggies, beans and fruits for my carbs. Sometimes whole wheat pasta. Not much bread/rice, etc. Though this is the season for Trader Joe's Pumpkin Pop Tarts!
0 -
Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. {/quote]
ana3067 couldn't be more wrong. First, drinking lots of water ALWAYS helps, regardless of whether you are following a low carb diet, or not following any regimen at all. Caffeine is a diuretic and makes your body lose water. Your body needs that water.
Second, check out South Beach Diet recipes. They are low carb and low fat. The fats that are included are heart healthy fats, like from nuts, fish, olive oil, etc. Generally, I recommend avoiding processed foods. They tend to be higher in sodium and higher in sugar. Eat lots of vegetables and lean meats/proteins. There's no reason you can't have room in your life for some of the things you love. You'll just have to limit the really unhealthy ones.0 -
ana3067 couldn't be more wrong. First, drinking lots of water ALWAYS helps, regardless of whether you are following a low carb diet, or not following any regimen at all. Caffeine is a diuretic and makes your body lose water. Your body needs that water.Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat.
Second, check out South Beach Diet recipes. They are low carb and low fat. The fats that are included are heart healthy fats, like from nuts, fish, olive oil, etc. Generally, I recommend avoiding processed foods. They tend to be higher in sodium and higher in sugar. Eat lots of vegetables and lean meats/proteins. There's no reason you can't have room in your life for some of the things you love. You'll just have to limit the really unhealthy ones.0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
Eating crap also affects water weight. And how one feels. But we don't say that to the CICO crowd.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
Why couldn't one overshoot by 5LBS on low carb. Or, hell, just inform them.
Seriously, it makes NO SENSE to single out low carb diets as "you have to do it for life".
Any long term weight loss will only be maintained if someone makes a plan "for life".
I wonder, every day, when folks join MFP, do we say to each of them: Don't bother. If you don't plan on weighing, counting, measuring and logging for life you'll gain it all back, and then some"?
No, we don't. We hope that while they're here, they'll learn. About food, about nutrition, about their own bodies, about fitness, about their own minds... and that after they've lost the weight, they'll have the tools (and I'm not talking about a smart phone) they need to be part of the 10% that succeeds long term.
Granted, low (lower) carb "for life" can be a damned healthy and satisfying way to live, from what I can tell.
and no: one doesn't need to omit a food group for life because they did so in deficit. Think on that one...
Precisely.
All kinds of people do versions of low-carb only to change it up in maintenance to plain calorie counting at maintenance level. I've done keto and will do so until I'm a little below my goal weight, then increase my carb-count some. I'll still be lower carb, but it will be more "slow-carb." I don't have to do keto my whole life just because I used that tool to lose the weight. On the other hand, I could totally choose to do so if I wanted. You aren't locked in for life to whatever plan you used to lose. It's less HOW you maintain, and more that you DO maintain. If it's all calorie deficit, who cares which foods you fill your calories with, as long as it is healthy for you?-1 -
Ugh. Between period and carb overload yesterday I feel so icky and bloated. Any way to make it better/go away? I work at the bar today so I will be drinking a LOT of water. Tomorrow is our Thanksgiving and then Monday I'm going to try low carb until Christmas. If successful I will try to make it my lifestyle. Gonna have to read labels way more diligently Any tips/suggestions?
I cut out grains a little while back to see if it would help with an autoimmune disorder (since then I have tweaked things and I now eat oatmeal), so not necessarily low carb since I do eat fruits and vegetables. Two major changes helped for me in order to feel satiated at meal time: 1) I increased my vegetable intake at meals and at snacks; 2) I drastically increased my healthy fats. I still counted calories, but weight loss was not my goal in this case (but I did lose weight because I was eating at a deficit). That's what worked for me and I still eat this way, aside from eating a bowl of oatmeal now almost every morning.0 -
I suppose I should clarify a few things.
I simply said christmas because that's about a months time and I want to see if it works for me. Am I looking for a quick fix? No! I've been using this app for years now and have been successful and then fallen off the wagon. When I do eat rice or pasta my portions are measured and I use brown rice and brown bread.
I was looking for some tips or suggestions. I watched my mom become obsessive over carbs 3 years ago and lose a ton of weight and then she started eating normal and gained it all back. I would like to have her success which I fully understand means that I'm not a lifer so to speak but it will always be something I need to be conscious of.
To those of you who gave me some links thank you!
Here are some recipe links.
http://www.genaw.com/lowcarb/index.html
http://alldayidreamaboutfood.com/ (she's gluten-free but you could modify the recipes)
Or you could go to the Atkins site to surf their recipes. There are dozens of low-carb recipe sites.
Or just find ways to cut added sugar, and high starch foods from your fave dishes and replace them with slow-carb versions.
And also...don't be afraid of fat. It's not a villain. You don't have to go crazy on it, but there's no reason whatsoever to hide from it. In fact, low-carb and low-fat do not mesh.
Good luck in finding the formula, whether that be low-carb or not, that works best for you.
0 -
for me, a low carb and high fat diet is giving me great benefits. For advice and encouragement, the MFP forums are probably your last resort. there are a few here (in this thread actually) who will remain sane about it, but overall, the MFP crowd does not stay sane about low carb. ignore the warnings that you MUST do it for the rest of your life and beyond. Do it for a week or a month or a year.....or for the rest of your life. Try it....read about it (elsewhere) and experiment. Good Luck.0
-
I suppose I should clarify a few things.
I simply said christmas because that's about a months time and I want to see if it works for me. Am I looking for a quick fix? No! I've been using this app for years now and have been successful and then fallen off the wagon. When I do eat rice or pasta my portions are measured and I use brown rice and brown bread.
I was looking for some tips or suggestions. I watched my mom become obsessive over carbs 3 years ago and lose a ton of weight and then she started eating normal and gained it all back. I would like to have her success which I fully understand means that I'm not a lifer so to speak but it will always be something I need to be conscious of.
To those of you who gave me some links thank you!
Define "normal". Did you mom eat "normal" or as she did before losing weight?0 -
ana3067 couldn't be more wrong. First, drinking lots of water ALWAYS helps, regardless of whether you are following a low carb diet, or not following any regimen at all. Caffeine is a diuretic and makes your body lose water. Your body needs that water.Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat.
Second, check out South Beach Diet recipes. They are low carb and low fat. The fats that are included are heart healthy fats, like from nuts, fish, olive oil, etc. Generally, I recommend avoiding processed foods. They tend to be higher in sodium and higher in sugar. Eat lots of vegetables and lean meats/proteins. There's no reason you can't have room in your life for some of the things you love. You'll just have to limit the really unhealthy ones.
Most south beach recipes aren't really low carb, they are lower than the SAD, sure, and they are healthier carbs, sure, but not really "low" carb. I'm not sure I would qualify them as low fat either.
That said: South Beach recipes and eating plan is damned healthy as a basis for building a diet.0 -
Dave198lbs wrote: »for me, a low carb and high fat diet is giving me great benefits. For advice and encouragement, the MFP forums are probably your last resort. there are a few here (in this thread actually) who will remain sane about it, but overall, the MFP crowd does not stay sane about low carb. ignore the warnings that you MUST do it for the rest of your life and beyond. Do it for a week or a month or a year.....or for the rest of your life. Try it....read about it (elsewhere) and experiment. Good Luck.
An example for you OP would be the low carber group in terms of advice and encouragement. Hopefully you find what works for you and stay flexible in diet and options for you.
0 -
baconslave wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
Eating crap also affects water weight. And how one feels. But we don't say that to the CICO crowd.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
Why couldn't one overshoot by 5LBS on low carb. Or, hell, just inform them.
Seriously, it makes NO SENSE to single out low carb diets as "you have to do it for life".
Any long term weight loss will only be maintained if someone makes a plan "for life".
I wonder, every day, when folks join MFP, do we say to each of them: Don't bother. If you don't plan on weighing, counting, measuring and logging for life you'll gain it all back, and then some"?
No, we don't. We hope that while they're here, they'll learn. About food, about nutrition, about their own bodies, about fitness, about their own minds... and that after they've lost the weight, they'll have the tools (and I'm not talking about a smart phone) they need to be part of the 10% that succeeds long term.
Granted, low (lower) carb "for life" can be a damned healthy and satisfying way to live, from what I can tell.
and no: one doesn't need to omit a food group for life because they did so in deficit. Think on that one...
Precisely.
All kinds of people do versions of low-carb only to change it up in maintenance to plain calorie counting at maintenance level. I've done keto and will do so until I'm a little below my goal weight, then increase my carb-count some. I'll still be lower carb, but it will be more "slow-carb." I don't have to do keto my whole life just because I used that tool to lose the weight. On the other hand, I could totally choose to do so if I wanted. You aren't locked in for life to whatever plan you used to lose. It's less HOW you maintain, and more that you DO maintain. If it's all calorie deficit, who cares which foods you fill your calories with, as long as it is healthy for you?
And in fact, one could, hypothetically, give up grains to create a deficit, then add them back with some common sense at maintenance and be fine.
I've known folks who, say, gave up their netflix account til the visa bill was paid off, or cut starbucks down to twice a week until the new car was paid off. That does not automatically suggest those folks will be back in debt the minute they reintroduce movies into their life. People make choices.
Someone could easily decide: grains are the thing I give up (as a way to create a deficit). Or sweets, or cream in coffee, or beer.... as long as one has a plan for what to do after.
The goal is to LEARN while here to avoid being overweight again... Learn some healthy habits. Learn what the true caloric and health cost of certain foods is.... and learn what better options you have.
0 -
Reduce sodium--it's SUCH a sneaky thing and in almost everything. You can go low-carb without going high fat. I generally eat a lot of soy and have at least one protein shake a day.
Normally, I try to stick with veggies, beans and fruits for my carbs. Sometimes whole wheat pasta. Not much bread/rice, etc. Though this is the season for Trader Joe's Pumpkin Pop Tarts!
How much of each per day? That doesn't sound all that low carb. Slow carb sure, and damned healthy!0 -
I suppose I should clarify a few things.
I simply said christmas because that's about a months time and I want to see if it works for me. Am I looking for a quick fix? No! I've been using this app for years now and have been successful and then fallen off the wagon. When I do eat rice or pasta my portions are measured and I use brown rice and brown bread.
I was looking for some tips or suggestions. I watched my mom become obsessive over carbs 3 years ago and lose a ton of weight and then she started eating normal and gained it all back. I would like to have her success which I fully understand means that I'm not a lifer so to speak but it will always be something I need to be conscious of.
To those of you who gave me some links thank you!
Thanks for clarifying... you may be someone who'd like South Beach. Healthy carbs are a staple of South Beach (I'm avoiding the "g-word" as it makes people crazy).0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
Eating crap also affects water weight. And how one feels. But we don't say that to the CICO crowd.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
Why couldn't one overshoot by 5LBS on low carb. Or, hell, just inform them.
Seriously, it makes NO SENSE to single out low carb diets as "you have to do it for life".
Any long term weight loss will only be maintained if someone makes a plan "for life".
I wonder, every day, when folks join MFP, do we say to each of them: Don't bother. If you don't plan on weighing, counting, measuring and logging for life you'll gain it all back, and then some"?
No, we don't. We hope that while they're here, they'll learn. About food, about nutrition, about their own bodies, about fitness, about their own minds... and that after they've lost the weight, they'll have the tools (and I'm not talking about a smart phone) they need to be part of the 10% that succeeds long term.
Granted, low (lower) carb "for life" can be a damned healthy and satisfying way to live, from what I can tell.
and no: one doesn't need to omit a food group for life because they did so in deficit. Think on that one...
"eating crap" usually means eating a lot of carbs. I eat crap all the time, but because I aim to eat 150g of protein every day and I like eating fat, I don't just eat a full day of junk food. Because I'm not cutting out junk food and I still eat carbs, I'm not dealing with losing significant amounts of water weight that would easily come back once I start eating those things again.
But really, losing weight is about making lifestyle changes. Which is yet another reason people say that if you choose to do low-carb it should be a life-long choice.
As you said, plenty of people don't plan on logging for life. So if they choose to eat low-carb, then they will most likely maintain success by doing low-carb for life because they will not have to re-learn proper caloric intake based on the new foods they are eating. It's just like how I lost and mostly maintained while "eating clean" but gained once I stopped eating clean. I ate similar portions but my caloric intake was much higher due to eating more calorie-dense foods.
Elimination diets, if done for weight loss, are generally not geared towards maintenance unless they are, you know, maintained while in weight maintenance. This is one of the reason fad diets don't work - not just because they are usually way low cal, but because people go back to "old" ways of eating. Hence different/too high calorie.
0 -
ana3067 couldn't be more wrong. First, drinking lots of water ALWAYS helps, regardless of whether you are following a low carb diet, or not following any regimen at all. Caffeine is a diuretic and makes your body lose water. Your body needs that water.
Second, check out South Beach Diet recipes. They are low carb and low fat. The fats that are included are heart healthy fats, like from nuts, fish, olive oil, etc. Generally, I recommend avoiding processed foods. They tend to be higher in sodium and higher in sugar. Eat lots of vegetables and lean meats/proteins. There's no reason you can't have room in your life for some of the things you love. You'll just have to limit the really unhealthy ones.
Drinking way too much water can lead to someone feeling gross and bloated. Drinking water is important, just not in excess.
Also, caffeine may help reduce bloat, which is often caused by water retention. This may not work for everyone, it has definitely worked for me for helping to more quickly reduce bloating for me without me having consumed plain water with it (just a cup of black tea and within 20 minutes I needed to pee and felt much better and less bloated).
You really don't need to limit unhealthy food if it fits into your macros for the day. You can eat unhealthy food every day if you want, I have without ill effect. I've even done so with the results being less bloat than other periods. Just happened to be that certain variables lined up to allow me to be less bloated.
As far as low carb and low fat, no. Pretty much everyone here who does low-carb diet also does high fat. This is necessary for satiety. LCHF. And eating high fat within her calories will not affect her weight.
Processed foods are also just fine.
Seriously, all foods are fine in moderation. Which is one reason I do not advocate elimination diets done for purposes other than health (e.g. diabetes and low-carb, or allergies/digestion issues). Nothing wrong withi sugar either.0 -
Here's my advice:
- Do your homework. Read something by Atkins, or Taubes. There are others, but I'm not familiar with them. Don't just focus on the rules, try to understand how low-carb diets work. Don't just rely on advice from random people on forums, get the whole story. There are some good articles online about low-carb. But I find the ones written by those who are truly well-informed assume that you've already read a book, and merely provide clarification and supplemental tips. This is something you can do between now and when you plan to start your diet.
- You're going to find all kinds of advice about how low to go. The lowest I've seen is 20 g/day. I've been up to 80 g/day and still in ketosis. But I started at 20 g, and worked my way up until I found a comfortable level where I could eat plenty of vegetables and still have room for other variety of carb sources (50 g/day for me). I fell off the wagon over the summer. I got back on by starting at 75 g/day and working down to 50.
- If you've never done low-carb before, you probably want to start low. I think Atkins calls this the induction phase.
- You still have to eat at a calorie deficit to lose weight. Low-carb just makes this easier because you won't be as hungry as you are now.
- Figure out how much protein you need, and don't over do it. I've heard 0.7 g/lb of lean body weight as a minimum. As a maximum, I've heard no more than 35% of your calories.
- Find a good list of fat sources, and make sure you have several on hand. You'll need to eat a lot of fat.
- Don't skimp on the vegetables. The lowest-carb advice I've read (which was for 20 g/day) recommends (as a minimum) 2 cups of leafy greens and 1 cup of other vegetables every day. Combine fat with all your vegetables. This is because fat without something to put it on is kinda nasty. Add butter or oil to your veggies.
- Manage your expectations. You may lose 5-10 lbs right off the bat, but that's just water. The rest will come off at the same rate as any low-calorie diet. If you have a lot of weight to lose, it's going to take a long time. If you have not a lot of weight to lose (like 20 lbs) it's still going to take a long time, because it's harder to lose when you're closer to your goal.
- Also in the manage your expectations category: You've only got a month between Thanksgiving and Christmas. If you're anything like me, you're going to just be getting used to it in time for Christmas.
- As for water: Drink when you're thirsty, don't overthink it. One common side effect of low-carb is dehydration. So you will know if you need more water. Listen to your body, it knows better than anybody on MFP.
- Another listen to your body rule: during the first few weeks, you might be really, really hungry. I don't worry about my calorie count during this time (I count, I just don't worry if I go over). Just eat when you're hungry, stop when you're full, but stick to your carb limit. The transition is tough.0 -
I'm kind of over the perception that low carb has to be a "lifestyle" for everyone that does it.
I eat low carb (70g or less) the majority of the time, but if I have the ocassional day where I just want to eat bread and rice and sugar, I do. I choose to eat low carb as my standard diet because it means I get adequate protein and fat while staying under a calorie limit, and helps me eliminate unnecessary snacking. It is not an unchangeable lifestyle for everyone, and that's fine.0 -
Chaotic_Weevil wrote: »I'm kind of over the perception that low carb has to be a "lifestyle" for everyone that does it.
I eat low carb (70g or less) the majority of the time, but if I have the ocassional day where I just want to eat bread and rice and sugar, I do. I choose to eat low carb as my standard diet because it means I get adequate protein and fat while staying under a calorie limit, and helps me eliminate unnecessary snacking. It is not an unchangeable lifestyle for everyone, and that's fine.
Totally agree. I find the longer I've been doing low-carb, having a high-carb day every now and then has less impact.0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
Eating crap also affects water weight. And how one feels. But we don't say that to the CICO crowd.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »Don't over-do it on water, caffeine can help.
If you want to make low-carb your lifestyle then that means high fat. So if you don't enjoy high fat foods atm, then don't bother with it. But it's also something you'd need to maintain for LIFE if you want to avoid putting on the water weight you'll have lost. So.. if you can see yourself eating this way for at least a few decades, then go for it?
Personally I only recommend elimination diets like this w hen it's for medical purposes. E.g. I eat gluten-free because otherwise I have painful gas and bloating. If I were allergic to something I'd eliminate it. But I won't eliminate carbs or lower them because it might help me debloat more than if I kept them in my diet. That is not enough incentive for me to omit foods I love from my life.
If one stops low carb one adds, what 5-10 pounds of water AT MOST? Why would they need to do low carb for life? Ie if someone wants to lose 100 pounds....why would they need to do low carb for life "because they'll regain water weight".
(though most of the time folks say "you'll regain it all and then some", which is true for 90+% of dieters including those using MFP for calorie counting)
I'm not picking, just that I see this edict about being low carb "for life" on every post and it makes no sense to single low carb out.
For some people, that 5-10lb gain would make them feel really horrible. But aside from the scale weight gained, there is a BIG effect in terms of how the body looks when considering the extra water retention.
But mostly, if someone plans on not tracking calories for life, if they omit an entire food group then they pretty much need to keep omitting it to help retain a mostly stable caloric intake.
If someone chooses to be low fat or low protein for life it doesn't affect water weight and probably minimally for the appearance of the body. Other than of course protein being required to help sustain lean body mass. So for instance, I eat a moderate protein diet (150g). In order to help ensure my body retains the composition I am trying to build, I'm going to have to maintain a moderate protein intake for life. Because the incentive for this dietary approach is high, it's something I am easily able to do. If I did NOT so badly want my dream body composition, I'd say "eff it" and just eat way more carbs and fats.
Why couldn't one overshoot by 5LBS on low carb. Or, hell, just inform them.
Seriously, it makes NO SENSE to single out low carb diets as "you have to do it for life".
Any long term weight loss will only be maintained if someone makes a plan "for life".
I wonder, every day, when folks join MFP, do we say to each of them: Don't bother. If you don't plan on weighing, counting, measuring and logging for life you'll gain it all back, and then some"?
No, we don't. We hope that while they're here, they'll learn. About food, about nutrition, about their own bodies, about fitness, about their own minds... and that after they've lost the weight, they'll have the tools (and I'm not talking about a smart phone) they need to be part of the 10% that succeeds long term.
Granted, low (lower) carb "for life" can be a damned healthy and satisfying way to live, from what I can tell.
and no: one doesn't need to omit a food group for life because they did so in deficit. Think on that one...
"eating crap" usually means eating a lot of carbs. I eat crap all the time, but because I aim to eat 150g of protein every day and I like eating fat, I don't just eat a full day of junk food. Because I'm not cutting out junk food and I still eat carbs, I'm not dealing with losing significant amounts of water weight that would easily come back once I start eating those things again.
But really, losing weight is about making lifestyle changes. Which is yet another reason people say that if you choose to do low-carb it should be a life-long choice.
As you said, plenty of people don't plan on logging for life. So if they choose to eat low-carb, then they will most likely maintain success by doing low-carb for life because they will not have to re-learn proper caloric intake based on the new foods they are eating. It's just like how I lost and mostly maintained while "eating clean" but gained once I stopped eating clean. I ate similar portions but my caloric intake was much higher due to eating more calorie-dense foods.
Elimination diets, if done for weight loss, are generally not geared towards maintenance unless they are, you know, maintained while in weight maintenance. This is one of the reason fad diets don't work - not just because they are usually way low cal, but because people go back to "old" ways of eating. Hence different/too high calorie.
Most diets aren't geared toward maintenance. And those that are (south beach, atkins etc.) are generally ignored. Most people start a formal diet because their friend/officemate etc. starts one and shares a "foods list". They've often not read the principles of the diet, nor do they ever follow through with the maintenance phase. They lose weight. Stop, repeat.
most folks regain. You know that. Each of us, individually, needs to figure out what works for us. It's not one size (yours, apparently) fits all.
Best of luck on your journey.0 -
Drinking way too much water can lead to someone feeling gross and bloated. Drinking water is important, just not in excess.
Also, caffeine may help reduce bloat, which is often caused by water retention. This may not work for everyone, it has definitely worked for me for helping to more quickly reduce bloating for me without me having consumed plain water with it (just a cup of black tea and within 20 minutes I needed to pee and felt much better and less bloated).
You, apparently, have not tried a low-carb diet. If you had, you would know that one very common side affect is dehydration. Bloating, on the other hand: not so common.0 -
A low carb diet isn't an "elimination" diet. Some of the others suggested doing research on the low carb lifestyle, and I will suggest that as well. The concept of diets like Atkins, LCHF, etc is to lower your carb intake and get your body to switch from using carbs/sugar for energy to using fat for energy. Going from burning glucose to burning ketones. The Atkins website has great little lessons on each phase of their program. This goes to demolish the idea that the entire Atkins diet is within Phase 1 "Induction" where you only eat 20 grams of carbs per day. The point is to find your ideal carb intake, how many carbs you can have per day to continue to lose weight, and how many you can have to maintain, etc. Most people only use the first phase of the Atkins low carb lifestyle to quickly lose the weight and automatically go back to their old habits. There is a plethora of low carb information out there and a lot of motivation from people that have made keto a true lifestyle. I don't follow exactly the Atkins plan, but it did help me understand the concept initially. Dr. Peter Attia has some excellent information on his blog: http://eatingacademy.com/ as well as his own motivational story. It is truly a process to find what works for us as individuals, but definitely worth all the work and patience when we figure it out! Good luck!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions