Cutting carbs
Replies
-
I would suggest switching your fat and protein macros if you are trying to go low carb, especially if you don't eat a lot of meat. You only need adequate protein, not high protein, and the fat is what keeps the hunger and cravings away. And I agree about coming to the low carb group. There are a lot of people with a lot of experience who completely disprove the "not sustainable" theory.
*perfectly* well said! :-)
Come hang with us.0 -
Springfield1970 wrote: »baconslave wrote: »If low-carbing is suicide, I'm taking a d*mn long time to die...
I've had enough time to lose 84lbs, get healthy, and run 3 times a week. Oh, and lift twice weekly. But certainly us low-carbers will all drop dead any minute now. I'm sure there'll be a party. Make sure there's bacon-wrapped cheese, ok. That's my death-bed request.
Go on, you nearly typed bacon sandwich, admit it!!
No, I meant bacon-wrapped cheese. It's a thing.
But now I'm thinking of a bacon sandwich, with two pieces of carne asada as the bread, with avocado mayo, bacon, and melted cheddar inside.
So, yeah, I change my mind. When the grim reaper, wearing his bad-*ss black cloak, comes calling, in...well...about 50-odd years, that's what I want at my wake. To go with the bacon-wrapped cheese sticks.0 -
Playing with your macros a little at a time should be fine but making long term or drastic changes I would say it would be prudent to contact your doctor and/or a dietitian and discuss it with them.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Exactly this!Let's see how many pages this goes until the OP comes back if at all. My just be baiting. But if it's not then how about we get the questions below answered. All this nonsense and who knows, based on just 1 profile picture maybe the OP needs to lose like 2 pounds, or 20 or maybe she's trying to be underweight. Who knows. Might be a good idea to actually ask for more information before people give out thoughtless advice just to be supportive.You will need to find other sources of protein to hit minimums which should be between .6.87g per lb of bodyweight.
If you say you were eating at the caloric intake it takes to be in a deficit and lose weight but you were not losing weight then you were eating too much and not in a deficit.
How tall are you?
How much do you weigh?
Do you weigh and log all your food?
What's your training like?
0 -
Let's see how many pages this goes until the OP comes back if at all. My just be baiting. But if it's not then how about we get the questions below answered. All this nonsense and who knows, based on just 1 profile picture maybe the OP needs to lose like 2 pounds, or 20 or maybe she's trying to be underweight. Who knows. Might be a good idea to actually ask for more information before people give out thoughtless advice just to be supportive.You will need to find other sources of protein to hit minimums which should be between .6.87g per lb of bodyweight.
If you say you were eating at the caloric intake it takes to be in a deficit and lose weight but you were not losing weight then you were eating too much and not in a deficit.
How tall are you?
How much do you weigh?
Do you weigh and log all your food?
What's your training like?
Just curious, which was the thoughtless advice - the one suggesting a website with low carb vegetarian protein sources, or the one suggesting OP was doing something akin to suicide?0 -
If OP returns, what is the goal? Doe she consume 5,000 calories a day?0
-
The most common diet of restricting carbs is know as the Atkins diet. It has a pretty strong record as many really obese people have been put on it by doctors to reduce their weight often for surgery. One major draw back is that it is really restrictive on carbs, but the users do in fact lose weight. It might be worth checking out if you are sure you want to try this route.
http://www.atkins.com/0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Ok so I've decided to play around with my macro. Before this I would just eat my daily allowance of calories but I'm at a stand still and want to try something different to see if it works for my body. I don't eat a lot of meat, just chicken and fish once in a while so it's hard for me to get in protein without the carbs. Right now I've decided on 15% carbs, 30% fat and 55% protein. Any suggestions on what to eat... Normally I've been eating around 100-120g carbs per day so this should be a challenge...
I agree with those who said that 55% protein is kind of extreme, especially if you struggle to get in the low MFP recommendation, and probably unnecessary.
I tend to eat a lot of protein, basically around my body weight in grams (125), and that's more like 30%. Granted, my goal could be much higher than yours, but I would find 55% protein a huge challenge and I really like meat, eggs, and dairy, and normally eat a lot of them, plus somewhat regular protein bars. (Significant protein sources other than meat and eggs tend to have carbs, also, as with beans.)
What I would do to figure out what to eat if I wanted to modify my macros to eat more protein and fat and less carbs would simply be to look at my meals and figure out how to up the protein and reduce the carbs--for example, replace a starch/grains course with a larger serving of whatever the protein course was plus some non-starchy vegetables and reduce the other high-carb food servings across the board. The trick, though, is that you will need to replace the calories with fat or protein, rather than just reduce carbs alone. (And I also agree with those who have suggested that 30% fat with 15% carbs probably doesn't make that much sense--normally when people cut carbs that much they increase fat as that will be your basic energy source and there's no need for all that extra protein.)0 -
Why don't you try the Keto diet0
-
Here is serious advice. As specific as it could be given what little info we have.
OP, and anyone else interested.- Stay below your desired carb level. Whether that be 15%, or whatever. Focus on green leafy veggies and other non-starchy veggies that grow above ground. Have some low-carb dairy (if you can tolerate it). Nuts are yummy, too.
- Reach your protein limit. The minimum should be approximately 1.2g of protein per kg of ideal body weight.
- Fill the rest of your intake in fat.
- Determine an estimate of how many cals you should be taking in based upon your, height, weight, and activity level using a TDEE calc. Scooby's is a good one. Remember though that it is only an estimate. You may have to raise or lower a suggested calorie deficit to suit your personal needs.
- If you have a medical condition, you can certainly read our advice, but run it by your Dr before listening to us interweb big mouths.
- Drink enough water and watch your electrolytes.
- Perform the search suggested by DAM5412 on page 1 on vegetarian protein sources.
- Go to the Low-Carber group linked above.
- Exercise a little. It isn't necessary to lose weight, but physical fitness can help a lot of other things. Like mood or being able to escape zombies.
Good luck.
0 -
Start with five serves of vegetables per day. Plenty of bulk and nutrients. Pull it back to basics and build from there. 0
-
cwolfman13 wrote: »Let's see how many pages this goes until the OP comes back if at all. My just be baiting. But if it's not then how about we get the questions below answered. All this nonsense and who knows, based on just 1 profile picture maybe the OP needs to lose like 2 pounds, or 20 or maybe she's trying to be underweight. Who knows. Might be a good idea to actually ask for more information before people give out thoughtless advice just to be supportive.You will need to find other sources of protein to hit minimums which should be between .6.87g per lb of bodyweight.
If you say you were eating at the caloric intake it takes to be in a deficit and lose weight but you were not losing weight then you were eating too much and not in a deficit.
How tall are you?
How much do you weigh?
Do you weigh and log all your food?
What's your training like?
Just curious, which was the thoughtless advice - the one suggesting a website with low carb vegetarian protein sources, or the one suggesting OP was doing something akin to suicide?
Ironically, the "suicide" comment was made by a fellow low carber who was telling the OP how all of the non low carbers will compare it to suicide...which nobody did...*kitten* hilarious.
Um....no
Try againso- asking which bridge I should jump off of is okay- but don't you dare tell me jumping off a bridge is a good idea or not.
Got it.
I wasn't making a parallel to low carb = suicide.
I was making a parallel about how one could/can/should give advice. it has nothing to do with low carb = suicide.
I was going to extremes to point out how one can offer advise when one is asking about making potentially poor decisions- and the answer isn't always "she didn't ask for that advice- she asked for this instead."
What makes her decision potentially poor? I found your analogy to be poor taste.
I would say the fact that she said she didn't really like eating meat but stated she wanted to low carb and do 55% protein...0 -
This content has been removed.
-
cwolfman13 wrote: »cwolfman13 wrote: »Let's see how many pages this goes until the OP comes back if at all. My just be baiting. But if it's not then how about we get the questions below answered. All this nonsense and who knows, based on just 1 profile picture maybe the OP needs to lose like 2 pounds, or 20 or maybe she's trying to be underweight. Who knows. Might be a good idea to actually ask for more information before people give out thoughtless advice just to be supportive.You will need to find other sources of protein to hit minimums which should be between .6.87g per lb of bodyweight.
If you say you were eating at the caloric intake it takes to be in a deficit and lose weight but you were not losing weight then you were eating too much and not in a deficit.
How tall are you?
How much do you weigh?
Do you weigh and log all your food?
What's your training like?
Just curious, which was the thoughtless advice - the one suggesting a website with low carb vegetarian protein sources, or the one suggesting OP was doing something akin to suicide?
Ironically, the "suicide" comment was made by a fellow low carber who was telling the OP how all of the non low carbers will compare it to suicide...which nobody did...*kitten* hilarious.
Um....no
Try againso- asking which bridge I should jump off of is okay- but don't you dare tell me jumping off a bridge is a good idea or not.
Got it.
I wasn't making a parallel to low carb = suicide.
I was making a parallel about how one could/can/should give advice. it has nothing to do with low carb = suicide.
I was going to extremes to point out how one can offer advise when one is asking about making potentially poor decisions- and the answer isn't always "she didn't ask for that advice- she asked for this instead."
What makes her decision potentially poor? I found your analogy to be poor taste.
I would say the fact that she said she didn't really like eating meat but stated she wanted to low carb and do 55% protein...
Plethora of reasons- I certainly wasn't going to explain seeing as how the rest of the conversation was going. Just a waste of energy.0 -
herrspoons wrote: »Holy nutballs!
No one cares if anyone got butthurt over some text on the internet. No one will ever care. Well unless they're a weepotron from the plant of the hand wringers, and no one cares about them.
Move on. Cheese wrapped in bacon is far more worthy of discussion than 'dem feels'.
Yes...let's discuss this further....0 -
What type of cheese? Are we using double smoked bacon? Pig Bacon Lard Balls?!? Wilbur Balls?!? Piggy Balls?!?0
-
Polite Reminder
Dear Posters,
Please be sure to keep all replies in good nature, attacking other members is against the community guidelines and just as importantly creates an atmosphere within an awesome community that doesn't need creating.
If you disagree with a discussion or reply, you are always best moving on to one in which you agree with or feel to be able to make a positive contribution to.
If you feel another member is in breach of our community guidelines then please use the 'report' feature found on each discussion topic and each reply so that the moderation team can look and take appropriate action where necessary.
Have an awesome day/evening!
Adam, MyFitnessPal Moderator0 -
Ah, even the mod has resorted to cat gifs
. 0 -
OP I will just say this …if you are not losing right now, then you are not in a calorie deficit. So if you switch to low carb and are not in a deficit then you will not lose weight. Low carb does not defy the basic laws of math and physics…
0 -
Thanks to those who gave advice. I'm new at looking at my macros rather than just soley my calories and unfortunately im new at MFP... Didn't realize I was in the wrong "group discussion" just needed some honest/ good advice from the fitness community. Whether you are trying to loose, gain, maintain, etc good luck to all you on your journey!0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Are you going to tell us how tall you are, how much you weigh and how many calories you eat per day?Thanks to those who gave advice. I'm new at looking at my macros rather than just soley my calories and unfortunately im new at MFP... Didn't realize I was in the wrong "group discussion" just needed some honest/ good advice from the fitness community. Whether you are trying to loose, gain, maintain, etc good luck to all you on your journey!
I think that would be a bridge too far. . .
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
_Terrapin_ wrote: »
Are you going to tell us how tall you are, how much you weigh and how many calories you eat per day?Thanks to those who gave advice. I'm new at looking at my macros rather than just soley my calories and unfortunately im new at MFP... Didn't realize I was in the wrong "group discussion" just needed some honest/ good advice from the fitness community. Whether you are trying to loose, gain, maintain, etc good luck to all you on your journey!
I think that would be a bridge too far. . .
RETREAT RETREAT RETREAT!!!!0 -
OP, there's no need to go to extremes like drastically reducing carbs. We need every food group in moderate amounts, and drastic cutting like this can be terrible for your health. I think it's healthier and more pleasant to enjoy a full variety of foods (unless there's a good reason to monitor carbs, of course)0
-
FunkenWagnel wrote: »OP, there's no need to go to extremes like drastically reducing carbs. We need every food group in moderate amounts, and drastic cutting like this can be terrible for your health. I think it's healthier and more pleasant to enjoy a full variety of foods (unless there's a good reason to monitor carbs, of course)
No, we don't need to consume carbs. Please name the disease state that will befall you if you exclude carbohydrates from your diet. Wait...I'll save you the trouble from looking - there isn't one.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
FunkenWagnel wrote: »OP, there's no need to go to extremes like drastically reducing carbs. We need every food group in moderate amounts, and drastic cutting like this can be terrible for your health. I think it's healthier and more pleasant to enjoy a full variety of foods (unless there's a good reason to monitor carbs, of course)
No, we don't need to consume carbs. Please name the disease state that will befall you if you exclude carbohydrates from your diet. Wait...I'll save you the trouble from looking - there isn't one.
No problem!
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14672862
http://healthyeating.sfgate.com/negative-results-eating-carbs-4182.html
http://www.bmj.com/content/344/bmj.e4026
http://islet.org/forum026/messages/23446.htm
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions