TDEE method vs MFP
Replies
-
DeguelloTex wrote: »
It includes it upfront though, right? I like earning through my fitbit and seeing the count go up throughout the day.
TDEE does factor exercise as part of the equation0 -
Like I said, you don't have to use it if another way is better for you. Personally, I don't want to wait until I do my evening 4.5 miles to have those calories "available."DeguelloTex wrote: »
It includes it upfront though, right? I like earning through my fitbit and seeing the count go up throughout the day.
But, yes, TDEE includes exercise up front.
ETA: Also, I think pre-logging meals is greatness, so TDEE is a much better fit for me.
0 -
DeguelloTex wrote: »
Like I said, you don't have to use it if another way is better for you. Personally, I don't want to wait until I do my evening 4.5 miles to have those calories "available."DeguelloTex wrote: »
It includes it upfront though, right? I like earning through my fitbit and seeing the count go up throughout the day.
But, yes, TDEE includes exercise up front.
ETA: Also, I think pre-logging meals is greatness, so TDEE is a much better fit for me.
Definitely makes sense and I will likely try it at some point. I never know how my day is going to go and I base what I'm going to eat on my ongoing activity. I don't pre-log, I eat as I go. Maybe not the cleanest way to do things, but it's woking out ok so far.0 -
If your days aren't consistent, you're definitely doing it the right way. As long as you can hit your calorie goals, the method you use comes down to personal preference. It's cool that you're having success.DeguelloTex wrote: »
Like I said, you don't have to use it if another way is better for you. Personally, I don't want to wait until I do my evening 4.5 miles to have those calories "available."DeguelloTex wrote: »
It includes it upfront though, right? I like earning through my fitbit and seeing the count go up throughout the day.
But, yes, TDEE includes exercise up front.
ETA: Also, I think pre-logging meals is greatness, so TDEE is a much better fit for me.
Definitely makes sense and I will likely try it at some point. I never know how my day is going to go and I base what I'm going to eat on my ongoing activity. I don't pre-log, I eat as I go. Maybe not the cleanest way to do things, but it's woking out ok so far.
0 -
Sorry folks but I gotta ask, what is the TDEE method?
I've lost 46 pounds using MFP, so far. I thought your daily calorie limit was based on a deficit from your TDEE.
I know what TDEE stands for, just unaware of any method.0 -
Much prefer the MFP method myself. If I used TDEE I would be a lot less motivated to push exercise on any particular day.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
echmainfit619 wrote: »Sorry folks but I gotta ask, what is the TDEE method?
I've lost 46 pounds using MFP, so far. I thought your daily calorie limit was based on a deficit from your TDEE.
I know what TDEE stands for, just unaware of any method.
The normal MFP method is based on figuring out your NEAT (which is a fancy way of saying your maintenance if you don't do any intentional exercise), subtracting 250 calories for each .5 lb you mean to lose in a week (but never more than 1000 calories), and then getting a pre-exercise calorie goal. After that, when you actually exercise you log it and have it added to your exercise goal. It's a particularly good way to go for someone who has just started exercising or is otherwise not consistent in their exercise, and also for someone who prefers eating more on days with more exercise.
The TDEE method that people are talking about is really TDEE averaged over the week. You figure out your average TDEE (in other words maintenance including the exercise that you normally do averaged over a week) and then subtract off either a percentage or sometimes 250 calories for each .5 lb you plan to lose (without being too aggressive). And that's that--no need to add back or eat back exercise. It's a good approach if you like having the same goal every day and are consistent in your exercise.0 -
I agree both methods work, I just question the MFP method for it's accuracy. Using that method, you're relying on two things, ONE: That MFP accurately estimated the calories you need to eat on a daily basis for your goal. I've found that to be off. And, TWO: You're relying on a calories burned estimator, to help you guess how many exercise calories you can eat back. For me, TDEE is more cut and dry. Trial and error for a few weeks will give you a good understanding of your average caloric needs for your goals, and then you can make adjustments as needed, without the hassle of recording your calories burned each day. That just seems like an added step, to me.0
-
sjohnson__1 wrote: »I agree both methods work, I just question the MFP method for it's accuracy. Using that method, you're relying on two things, ONE: That MFP accurately estimated the calories you need to eat on a daily basis for your goal. I've found that to be off. And, TWO: You're relying on a calories burned estimator, to help you guess how many exercise calories you can eat back. For me, TDEE is more cut and dry. Trial and error for a few weeks will give you a good understanding of your average caloric needs for your goals, and then you can make adjustments as needed, without the hassle of recording your calories burned each day. That just seems like an added step, to me.
Yes, I'm with you. The "MFP" method introduces more sources of potential error. The TDEE way does require a moderately consistent activity level, though - but that's something that should be happening anyway.0 -
Thanks everyone I'm definately choosing right for myself then. I've been cutting cals in one way or other for years now and found this is the best way for me. I'm consistent every week with my exercise and I did find I struggled on non exercise days with mfp. So the extra cals I get on tdee every day prevent me from sabotaging. Nice to know everyone's perspective0
-
To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol0 -
-
christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks LOL, maybe others following TDEE method are same as me?? Each to their own and whatever works
Fitbit stops me from having any lazy days full stop, even my so called rest day is an active day with 14k minimum...recently I had a chest infection and thought it was awful that I only managed 10k! oh what a changed person I am LOL0 -
RunRutheeRun wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks LOL, maybe others following TDEE method are same as me?? Each to their own and whatever works
Fitbit stops me from having any lazy days full stop, even my so called rest day is an active day with 14k minimum...recently I had a chest infection and thought it was awful that I only managed 10k! oh what a changed person I am LOL
this ^ i never have lazy weeks if im physically ill, then ill naturally eat less anyway however i havent experienced that yet so time will tell i guess ha0 -
@leahcollett1
well I've been having active rest days and pushing myself more and more the rest of the time and still going strong after 2+ years ...in fact I used to get sick more before I got fit, now (touch wood!) I'm as healthy as a trout!
(where the heck did that saying come from lol, but you know what I mean hopefully ) 0 -
RunRutheeRun wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks LOL, maybe others following TDEE method are same as me?? Each to their own and whatever works
Fitbit stops me from having any lazy days full stop, even my so called rest day is an active day with 14k minimum...recently I had a chest infection and thought it was awful that I only managed 10k! oh what a changed person I am LOL
one of the reasons I asked is because we went away for 3 days last week, and I pretty much sat on my butt the whole time. We were staying with aquaintances and I couldn't just disappear to go do my exercises. I think 6000 steps was the most I did in one day whilst there.
0 -
@christinev297 when we work out our TDEE we can factor in if we only do for example 3 days of exercise, our overall TDEE will be lower accordingly...
On a day IF I did lower steps I'd just TRY to eat less...try being the operative word LOL, when you're used to eating 2000+ cals a day its really hard to go lower....0 -
christinev297 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks LOL, maybe others following TDEE method are same as me?? Each to their own and whatever works
Fitbit stops me from having any lazy days full stop, even my so called rest day is an active day with 14k minimum...recently I had a chest infection and thought it was awful that I only managed 10k! oh what a changed person I am LOL
one of the reasons I asked is because we went away for 3 days last week, and I pretty much sat on my butt the whole time. We were staying with aquaintances and I couldn't just disappear to go do my exercises. I think 6000 steps was the most I did in one day whilst there.
ahh yes, i had this dilema two weeks ago i went on holiday didnt train, ate over calories too. so i gained 4lbs, which came off last week thank god when i got striaght back to it
@runrutheerun, yea i try and get a coupld of walks in on my rest days today is the first actual do nothing day im doing as tomorrow im getting weighed and ive done body combat twice, zumba once and walked 2.5 mils yeatersday!"0 -
Thanks guys. I'm probably waaay over thinking it...0
-
I did the MFP method for weightloss, but now do TDEE for maintenance.0
-
my TDEE from scoody workshop gives me 1750 calores every day to play with, this is incoporating 1-3 hours a week of light exercise,0
-
HappyCampr1 wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks LOL, maybe others following TDEE method are same as me?? Each to their own and whatever works
Fitbit stops me from having any lazy days full stop, even my so called rest day is an active day with 14k minimum...recently I had a chest infection and thought it was awful that I only managed 10k! oh what a changed person I am LOL
one of the reasons I asked is because we went away for 3 days last week, and I pretty much sat on my butt the whole time. We were staying with aquaintances and I couldn't just disappear to go do my exercises. I think 6000 steps was the most I did in one day whilst there.
When I go away on vacation, I don't track at all, so no worries here about whether my TDEE was affected, lol.
I only work out three times a week, so there's not usually an issue with getting that amount of exercise in. Most of my TDEE is made up of my job, so that would be the same anyway. I guess I just figure that if I'm less active one week, it won't make much difference. If I were less active consistently, then the scale would tell me and I'll make adjustments then. So long as I stay in my range, I figure it must be working. On Wed. I skipped the cardio portion of my workout because I got off work two hours late. I did the strength training and went home to cook dinner. I'm not worried about that affecting my TDEE. I mean, I'm sure if I did it every workout it would matter, but once? Not too worried.
have you been successful on TDEE? @HappyCampr10 -
I don't have lazy weeks.christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
If I'm sick and can't exercise, I'll naturally eat less.
If something comes up for a couple of days, my goal is to maintain within a range, not at a particular weight, and it's exceedingly unlikely that such a scenario would push me out of that range.
It's not immense pressure; it's motivation.
0 -
I've done both, and for the most part, it works out about the same for me. But my appetite doesn't always sync with my calorie burn. Sometimes I'm hungrier on a rest day, and have to almost force myself to eat after a long run.
MFP method is good for me when my exercise isn't very consistent and my calorie burns are fairly low, like when I was first starting out, and when I was returning to exercise and logging after an injury. But now, I'm training for a half marathon and strength training. Using MFP methods, my calories would be all over the place, low on lifting or rest days, crazy high on running days. It's a lot easier to just go by an average of what my weekly burns would be.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This is my first week using the TDEE method. I have been using the MFP method since April and have lost about 8 lbs. (8 more to go). The MFP method has been a little stressful for me because I would obsess over fitting in exercise each day just so that I could have more calories to eat. Using the TDEE method this week, I feel much more relaxed knowing that I have the whole week to fit in my 1-3 hours of exercise, which is usually not an issue because I'm pretty active and enjoy the gym. The only thing I miss about the MFP method is on Fridays and Saturdays, I would do a longer work out so that I could have more calories to spend on dinner/drinks out. Now, I'm not so sure how I do that with TDEE . . . ? If I exceed my 1700 calories, I guess I'll just do a longer workout this weekend?
Anyways, I think it does just come down to personal preference and it's largely psychological which one a person prefers. Good luck!!0 -
christinev297 wrote: »To those of you who follow the TDEE method. What happens if you have a lazy week or are sick and can't exercise, do you lower your calories or still eat the same?
My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
I don't have lazy weeks. I have a training plan and I stick to it.
TDEE - X% calories that I eat are a little under my sedentary maintenance, so I'm not going to gain if I eat that amount without exercise. So if I'm sick and still eat my calories, I'd still lose slowly, just slower. If I miss a day of exercising because whatever excuse (I try to fit it in no matter what, so this rarely happens), I might not lose my projected amount that week, but I'd still lose.
When I'm truly on vacation, I don't count calories and just stay active. I always aim for at least 10,000 steps a day no matter what unless I'm seriously bed ridden. When I'm on vacation, we walk a lot. I usually get at least 15,000 steps on vacation plus extra activity (swimming, biking, etc).0 -
This for me too!My impression of tdee is there would be immense pressure to keep to the same exercise levels each and every day.
It's giving me nervous hives just thinking about it lol
And also this!The MFP method has been a little stressful for me because I would obsess over fitting in exercise each day just so that I could have more calories to eat.
0 -
GuitarJerry wrote: »I can't stand the fluctuations exercise causes. I use TDEE. In my opinion, it's a superior method because you learn more about how many calories it takes to lose, gain, and maintain. Having that knowledge is valuable. But, for me, there is no question about exercise. I don't need any motivation to do that.
well said 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions