Low carb diet
Replies
-
PeculiarLou wrote: »Consider joining the MFP subgroup, the Low Carber Daily. Everyone there is low carb from almost no carbs to 150 g or so of carbs per day. Most are very happy to share their diaries and their months or years of advice. A nice group.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
My main pieces of advice when going low carb would be:- Increase your fats. Many have a hard time accepting that fats don't make you fat. Replacing carbs with fats is healthy and tasty for most people, and a good way to make sure your caloric deficit is not too low.
- Eat carbs but restrict the type. Most of us find it easiest, and healthiest to reduce carbs in this order: sugar and food with added sugars (candy, baked goods, soda, syrups, honey, and even salad dressings with sugar in it- go full fat), grains and flours (rice, corn, quinoa, wheat flours, baked goods except for some made with coconut or almond flours), starchy root vegetables (potatoes, yams, turnips, onion and carrots are reduced), and finally fruit (grapes, tropical fruits like bananas and mangos are high in sugar and usually avoided, apples, oranges and pears are moderated, and berries are eaten the most often... Usually).
- Eat green leafy veggies freely.
- Increase your sodium, and possibly potassium and magnesium. Reducing carbs causes water loss which lowers your electrolytes. This can makes you feel headachy, tired, sore, sick and nauseated. If you drink salty bullion/broth once or twice a day, salt your food, or even add a teaspoon of salt to your water you will be able to avoid the keto flu - usually just a low electrolyte flu. Often 3000-5000mg is often recommended.
Good luck.
This ^
Most people that follow low carb/keto see it as a lifestyle change and not just a diet. Especially those that follow it for brain function benefits.
Brain function benefits!
What the what now?
Please ...give us at least one credible source for "brain function benefits" ...that would be excellent to read
Look on PubMed if you are that interested, read a book: Grain Brain, Keto Clarity, The art of low carbohydrate living. Sorry I don´t have time to search out articles for you. If you are generally interested do some research on it...0 -
stevencloser wrote: »Yep, probably one of the most useless charts I've seen him post so far.
Oh ye of little imagination.
Here I thought scientific charts should not be up to your imagination. Silly me.0 -
Found a crossover of obese men and overweight/borderline obese women. Both on 500 cal deficit, men for 50 days women for 28 (one cycle). Starting with keto then switching to low fat so going from baseline to ~30 to ~200 g/day of carbs :-
ok ?..no source so no idea of the parameters of these diets or dieters? Provided or self-reported? Or any other factor that could be taken into consideration
Also unclear if 28 days in total or 28 days each dietary approach nor numbers men/ women...ages ...unusual timeframe when bringing into play the obvious hormonal fluctuations
On the surface, although there's really no point in looking at that kind of chart without all the relevant information provided, that possibly demonstrates that removing carbs then reintroducing them causes swings in water weight as there appear to be only 3 weight points and Linear mapping between
Points are start, end of low carb, end of low fat.
Lines are individual subjects.
Duration as specified, same for both diets. 28 days on each for women etc.
Carbs as specified.
No 5kg+ rebound on reintroducing carbs.
But I realise you're only feigning interest. Over to you to produce evidence of this alleged massive water regain.
Losing fat and regaining water weight, hmmm. Initial weight - what you keep losing + what you regain = ???0 -
If glucose is so beneficial, why does your body get rid of it as fast as possible?0 -
If glucose is so beneficial, why does your body get rid of it as fast as possible?
If your body wanted to get rid of it as fast as possible why does it keep making more if you don't eat enough?0 -
Found a crossover of obese men and overweight/borderline obese women. Both on 500 cal deficit, men for 50 days women for 28 (one cycle). Starting with keto then switching to low fat so going from baseline to ~30 to ~200 g/day of carbs :-
ok ?..no source so no idea of the parameters of these diets or dieters? Provided or self-reported? Or any other factor that could be taken into consideration
Also unclear if 28 days in total or 28 days each dietary approach nor numbers men/ women...ages ...unusual timeframe when bringing into play the obvious hormonal fluctuations
On the surface, although there's really no point in looking at that kind of chart without all the relevant information provided, that possibly demonstrates that removing carbs then reintroducing them causes swings in water weight as there appear to be only 3 weight points and Linear mapping between
Points are start, end of low carb, end of low fat.
Lines are individual subjects.
Duration as specified, same for both diets. 28 days on each for women etc.
Carbs as specified.
No 5kg+ rebound on reintroducing carbs.
But I realise you're only feigning interest. Over to you to produce evidence of this alleged massive water regain.
Hm, most of the women didn't lose weight at all.0 -
PeculiarLou wrote: »Consider joining the MFP subgroup, the Low Carber Daily. Everyone there is low carb from almost no carbs to 150 g or so of carbs per day. Most are very happy to share their diaries and their months or years of advice. A nice group.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
My main pieces of advice when going low carb would be:- Increase your fats. Many have a hard time accepting that fats don't make you fat. Replacing carbs with fats is healthy and tasty for most people, and a good way to make sure your caloric deficit is not too low.
- Eat carbs but restrict the type. Most of us find it easiest, and healthiest to reduce carbs in this order: sugar and food with added sugars (candy, baked goods, soda, syrups, honey, and even salad dressings with sugar in it- go full fat), grains and flours (rice, corn, quinoa, wheat flours, baked goods except for some made with coconut or almond flours), starchy root vegetables (potatoes, yams, turnips, onion and carrots are reduced), and finally fruit (grapes, tropical fruits like bananas and mangos are high in sugar and usually avoided, apples, oranges and pears are moderated, and berries are eaten the most often... Usually).
- Eat green leafy veggies freely.
- Increase your sodium, and possibly potassium and magnesium. Reducing carbs causes water loss which lowers your electrolytes. This can makes you feel headachy, tired, sore, sick and nauseated. If you drink salty bullion/broth once or twice a day, salt your food, or even add a teaspoon of salt to your water you will be able to avoid the keto flu - usually just a low electrolyte flu. Often 3000-5000mg is often recommended.
Good luck.
This ^
Most people that follow low carb/keto see it as a lifestyle change and not just a diet. Especially those that follow it for brain function benefits.
Brain function benefits!
What the what now?
Please ...give us at least one credible source for "brain function benefits" ...that would be excellent to read
My frequent headaches went away. Does that count?
I've heard the best way to get rid of a cold is to give it to someone else...0 -
OP, making large changes in your diet is hard at first. Give yourself a couple weeks and see where you're at. If you still don't like it, it's ok to not do a low carb diet. It's not for everyone. Remember, this is something you'll need to do the rest of your life, and if you're not happy with it, you won't stay with it.
There are plenty of people that do better with a low carb diet. And there are plenty of people that do better on a regular or higher carb diet. It's ok if you don't like it. you have to find what works FOR YOU.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions