DEXA Scan Shock
Replies
-
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
This article gives some ranges and pictures of what they look like:
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/0 -
It seems you have some loose skin too, no? I'd put you around 28, from the pictures.0
-
OP, Did the DEXA scan give you a weight?
If not, I'd be looking at weighing on different scales as a check on your's.0 -
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
This is a rough idea. Everyone will feel comfortable in different areas, though:
0 -
The age range is relevant go back to the article and look at the Jackson and pollock tables0
-
-
@Packerjohn, I so get this.
Pet peeve.
"You're in pretty good shape... for a man your age." [grrrrr]0 -
Huh? Sorry, it just seemed to me that the belly was not just fat, but some loose skin as well, so it might change the results, or at least how we perceive it. And from his sides, he just doesn't look like 30%+ to me.
I'm confused about the 'wtf' comment.0 -
Well there is absolutely no sign of any loose skin on either of those pictures and as people tend to be sensitive about things like that it just seemed a weird comment based on the fact that OP has not mentioned any perceived issue with his skin0
-
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
0 -
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
At 18 maybe0 -
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
At 18 maybe
or 38
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/0 -
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
At 18 maybe
or 38
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/
Interestingly in other charts lean is termed "underfat"0 -
1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."0 -
I agree that it might be some loose skin. OP lost his weight really fast, so the skin wouldn't have caught up yet. I don't think he looks as fluffy as most of those 30% pics.
Definitely lift, OP, because the rate of weight loss you have is pretty extreme. It will lose muscle that way. You are probably usually quite more muscular
How does loose skin figure in these scans, btw, y'all? Could it come up as fat if it is in that awkward state right after quick weight loss? When the skin readjusts you lose some skin. I don't know what weight that would total, but I'm just curious, lol.0 -
richardgavel wrote: »Thoughts? Should I get a second opinion with a different form of measurement, like a body pod?
DEXA has a lower margin of error than BodPod. DEXA is pretty much the gold standard for measuring BF%.0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."
Fashion model mebbe
Underwear models need a little more ...stuff
0 -
Huh? Sorry, it just seemed to me that the belly was not just fat, but some loose skin as well, so it might change the results, or at least how we perceive it. And from his sides, he just doesn't look like 30%+ to me.
Dexa scan wouldn't confuse loose skin for fat.
The side picture definitely looks to be near 30% to me (I was only slightly leaner when i started).0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."
Fashion model mebbe
Underwear models need a little more ...stuff
True...either way, much leaner than "fairly slim."0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »
Huh? Sorry, it just seemed to me that the belly was not just fat, but some loose skin as well, so it might change the results, or at least how we perceive it. And from his sides, he just doesn't look like 30%+ to me.
Dexa scan wouldn't confuse loose skin for fat.
The side picture definitely looks to be near 30% to me (I was only slightly leaner when i started).
I agree.
He had damn near the best method that can be done to measure his body fat. According to his pictures AND dexa, i'd say there's no reason to question it.0 -
Is there some reason why you don't lift weights?0
-
I was reading up on body fat measuring the other day, the article I was reading suggested that none of the available methods are highly accurate for a given individual (although averaged across many individuals they can be very accurate). Still, DEXA does seem to be the best of the bunch.
http://weightology.net/weightologyweekly/index.php/free-content/free-content/volume-1-issue-5-the-pitfalls-of-body-fat-measurement-parts-5-and-6-skinfolds-and-dual-energy-x-ray-absorptiometry-dexa/the-pitfalls-of-body-fat-measurement-part-6-dexa/0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."
UK Female Olympic cyclist 14% BF aged 30 ? My neighbour aka Mrs Whippet also a pro cyclist is a bit skeletal but I daren't ask her stats, not least as she's failing to conceive.0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."
UK Female Olympic cyclist 14% BF aged 30 ? My neighbour aka Mrs Whippet also a pro cyclist is a bit skeletal but I daren't ask her stats, not least as she's failing to conceive.
Low BF can completely screw up hormones
http://www.builtlean.com/2012/09/24/body-fat-percentage-men-women/
Body Fat Percentage Women 15-17%
This is still considered a very low body fat for women, which is similar to the 6-7% body fat for range men. Many bikini and fitness models will reach this body fat level and some may not be able to menstruate. Muscle definition in the abs, legs, arms, and shoulders is apparent, there is some vascularity and some separation between muscles. Hips, buttocks, and thighs generally have a little less shape because of the low body fat.0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »1961dublin wrote: »What % should BF actually be? My BMI is around 22.5 and I am a 54 year old woman. I have not got a clue about what my BF% should be and I would love to know....
A fairly slim woman will be about 20% BF.
Fairly slim?
More like "underwear model lean."
UK Female Olympic cyclist 14% BF aged 30 ? My neighbour aka Mrs Whippet also a pro cyclist is a bit skeletal but I daren't ask her stats, not least as she's failing to conceive.
Offering an example of an extremely lean Olympic endurance athlete doesn't negate the fact that "fairly slim" is a strong understatement when describing a female with 20% body fat.0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »Is there some reason why you don't lift weights?
No reason in particular. But when I got started in this round of weight loss, I wanted to focus on exercises that I would be highly motivated to do, and that's swim/bike/run because I enjoy them. Now I wish I had a dexa scan from when I started. Hate to think what BF I had 50 lbs ago.0 -
richardgavel wrote: »azulvioleta6 wrote: »Is there some reason why you don't lift weights?
No reason in particular. But when I got started in this round of weight loss, I wanted to focus on exercises that I would be highly motivated to do, and that's swim/bike/run because I enjoy them. Now I wish I had a dexa scan from when I started. Hate to think what BF I had 50 lbs ago.
That makes sense.
I tend to think about fitness as strength, endurance and flexibility. So, if your program is missing one of those things, keep doing what you enjoy and just add in a couple of days a week of the thing you are missing. When you have a running rest day, do a couple of weight circuits.
Worrying about the past or thinking about BF as a defining characteristic isn't going to help you...just keep moving forward. You have already made great progress.0 -
I'm at about 18% which is not low for me but normal. I'm not underweight at this point so I wouldn't say super slim.. And I got heavier on purpose trying to build muscle so it's def not too low for me or many other active females. I think the averages are based on the average population a lot of the times..not necessarily recommendations.0
-
azulvioleta6 wrote: »richardgavel wrote: »azulvioleta6 wrote: »Is there some reason why you don't lift weights?
No reason in particular. But when I got started in this round of weight loss, I wanted to focus on exercises that I would be highly motivated to do, and that's swim/bike/run because I enjoy them. Now I wish I had a dexa scan from when I started. Hate to think what BF I had 50 lbs ago.
That makes sense.
I tend to think about fitness as strength, endurance and flexibility. So, if your program is missing one of those things, keep doing what you enjoy and just add in a couple of days a week of the thing you are missing. When you have a running rest day, do a couple of weight circuits.
Worrying about the past or thinking about BF as a defining characteristic isn't going to help you...just keep moving forward. You have already made great progress.
Cosigned.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions