Need Urgent Advice Please!
Replies
-
arditarose wrote: »This thread is going to be the death of me. I should have finished my coffee before reading the forums.
I'm wit this.arditarose wrote: »Just stop. Everyone. Meal timing Does Not Matter.
1000% THIS..!!!
Get your calories in check. Use a food scale. Log accurately and don't forget drinks and condiments, especially cooking oil and salad dressings. [/quote]
0 -
arditarose wrote: »This thread is going to be the death of me. I should have finished my coffee before reading the forums.
I'm surprised starvation mode hasn't been mentioned yet.
Don't get me started. My heart just skipped a beat lol.
But seriously, not to derail. Meal timing doesn't matter, shakes don't rev up your metabolism. Eat in a deficit, weigh your food, lose weight. It's that "simple". Also eat when you want-I eat 800 calories right before bed.0 -
PrincessxSoph wrote: »4 Days Ago, Weighed Myself This Morning 2 Pounds Put On, I'll Soon Be Back To Wear I Started
Remember .. weight does fluctuate ... you could be retaining more water, be constipated, be in that time of the month when you are bloated ... etc. Don't be so quick to make changes ... it's always discouraging when you weigh yourself in the morning and you are up instead of down from yesterday morning ... but that doesn't mean it's 'real' weight you have gained unless your body is storing a lot of extra food as energy in your muscles and fat ... and that would have to have been on whopper of a high calorie day and wouldn't show up overnight probably anyway.
corrected spelling0 -
arditarose wrote: »This thread is going to be the death of me. I should have finished my coffee before reading the forums.
Me too.0 -
we're wasting our time until the OP answers the questions posed WAY back in regards to what/how she is logging....if/if not she has adjusted her cal intake for her "current" weight.0
-
Adding certain spices like black pepper to your lunch can really add that extra boost to help you lose weight. Also try eating homemade soups such as lentil soup (high in protein, fibre, magnesium, and iron), which will help you become more full during the day and also boost metabolism. I agree with a lot of the previous statements regarding water consumption as well. Good luck!0
-
Need2Exerc1se wrote: »bruhaha007 wrote: »I believe you need to eat more than one meal. At a minimum try incorporating a couple meal replacement shakes to keep your metabolism going throughout the day.
Nonsense. Our metabolism doesn't shut down if we don't feed it food every couple of hours.
Actually, we do need to spread our caloric intake out throughout the day. This textbook also advocates having at least a light breakfast to maintain homeostasis: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK22414/0 -
If you are accurately logging your food, and meeting or short of your calorie goal, 7 days each week you will lose weight. If you are over on your sodium target you will retain water, masking the weight loss temporarily.0
-
bruhaha007 wrote: »Please show me the research study that reflects what I am saying is inaccurate. I can be swayed but it needs backed.
Show me research that your metabolism stops at any point before death.0 -
All calories are not created equal. Are you consuming sugar or starchy foods that convert into sugar? If you are then your body will use those as energy and store everything else as fat.0
-
letsgosabres2013 wrote: »Adding certain spices like black pepper to your lunch can really add that extra boost to help you lose weight. Also try eating homemade soups such as lentil soup (high in protein, fibre, magnesium, and iron), which will help you become more full during the day and also boost metabolism. I agree with a lot of the previous statements regarding water consumption as well. Good luck!
Oh! I've been doing it wrong. I've just needed to add black pepper to my lunch to help me lose weight. D'oh!0 -
Squeaksfriend wrote: »All calories are not created equal. Are you consuming sugar or starchy foods that convert into sugar? If you are then your body will use those as energy and store everything else as fat.
Oh lordy. Here we go! lol0 -
bruhaha007 wrote: »Please show me the research study that reflects what I am saying is inaccurate. I can be swayed but it needs backed.
your metabolism runs a LOT faster if you don't eat at all for a couple days ...
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10837292
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24057170 -
positivepowers wrote: »Need2Exerc1se wrote: »bruhaha007 wrote: »I believe you need to eat more than one meal. At a minimum try incorporating a couple meal replacement shakes to keep your metabolism going throughout the day.
Nonsense. Our metabolism doesn't shut down if we don't feed it food every couple of hours.
Actually, we do need to spread our caloric intake out throughout the day. This textbook also advocates having at least a light breakfast to maintain homeostasis: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK22414/
What does this have to do with metabolism shutting down?0 -
I'm no rocket scientist, but I believe that unless you have some sort of underlying metabolic disease, you should lose weight if you eat less. Shocking, I know!!0
-
-
fabulousmo wrote: »I'm no rocket scientist, but I believe that unless you have some sort of underlying metabolic disease, you should lose weight if you eat less. Shocking, I know!!
Not just less....but less than you are burning. THEN you lose weight.0 -
Squeaksfriend wrote: »All calories are not created equal. Are you consuming sugar or starchy foods that convert into sugar? If you are then your body will use those as energy and store everything else as fat.
Except for excess protein, which your body will convert to sugar too ...
Your body runs on sugar. Nearly everything you eat needs to be turned into sugar before it is used for fuel.
If you eat fewer calories than you need, your body will begin converting its fat reserves into sugar for fuel.0 -
PrincessxSoph wrote: »Before I Started Work, I Was Losing General 1-2 Pounds Overnight, And All Of A Sudden It's Stop, I'm Seriously Considering To Have Less Calories Than What My Intake Is And Very Small Portions?
If you are expecting to continue losing 1-2 lbs every night, you are going to be very disappointed. That is not a realistic goal unless you've had WLS or something of that sort. I don't think you should ever aim for losing more than 10 lbs a month. Just be patient. Give your body time to adjust. Also try tracking your measurements. Sometimes you will see progress in that department, even when the scales don't budge.0 -
PrincessxSoph wrote: »Before I Started Work, I Was Losing General 1-2 Pounds Overnight, And All Of A Sudden It's Stop, I'm Seriously Considering To Have Less Calories Than What My Intake Is And Very Small Portions?
Yes. Do this.0 -
i am pretty sure you can fit small snacks in throughout your work day so that your dinner isn't so big. is your job such that you can't eat at your desk? or you get NO breaks at all? what are you doing on your lunch time? you could go for a walk outside your office.0
-
Eating One Big Meal At Dinner Won't Affect Your Ability To Lose Weight As Long As Your Overall Calories For The Day Are In Line. If You're Not Losing Weight, Start Accurately Weighing And Measuring Your Food To Make Sure You Are Accurately Logging Your Calories.
This!
I lost nearly 45 lbs eating a small breakfast and lunch and then having a regular sized dinner at 8 pm.
The hard part was the big space between lunch and dinner. I had to fight the urge to eat large snacks.
But other than personal hunger patterns, meal timing won't matter.
0 -
Eating One Big Meal At Dinner Won't Affect Your Ability To Lose Weight As Long As Your Overall Calories For The Day Are In Line. If You're Not Losing Weight, Start Accurately Weighing And Measuring Your Food To Make Sure You Are Accurately Logging Your Calories.
This!
I lost nearly 45 lbs eating a small breakfast and lunch and then having a regular sized dinner at 8 pm.
The hard part was the big space between lunch and dinner. I had to fight the urge to eat large snacks.
But other than personal hunger patterns, meal timing won't matter.
you lost weight cuz you consumed less calories than you burned.0 -
arditarose wrote: »arditarose wrote: »This thread is going to be the death of me. I should have finished my coffee before reading the forums.
I'm surprised starvation mode hasn't been mentioned yet.
Don't get me started. My heart just skipped a beat lol.
But seriously, not to derail. Meal timing doesn't matter, shakes don't rev up your metabolism. Eat in a deficit, weigh your food, lose weight. It's that "simple". Also eat when you want-I eat 800 calories right before bed.
I do love setting aside a significant number of calories for one big meal a day.
0 -
Think of it as filling up your car. You can choose to put in 2 gallons of gas every day, or you can wait until the end of the month when it is almost empty. Either way, your car gets the gas it needs and it performs the same regardless of when you put gas in.
I never understand the mentality of thinking you have to eat at certain times. I eat all of my calories between 4:30-8:30PM and am never hungry and have lost 24 pounds so far.0 -
arditarose wrote: »arditarose wrote: »This thread is going to be the death of me. I should have finished my coffee before reading the forums.
I'm surprised starvation mode hasn't been mentioned yet.
Don't get me started. My heart just skipped a beat lol.
But seriously, not to derail. Meal timing doesn't matter, shakes don't rev up your metabolism. Eat in a deficit, weigh your food, lose weight. It's that "simple". Also eat when you want-I eat 800 calories right before bed.
I do love setting aside a significant number of calories for one big meal a day.
lol that's sometimes just my dessert....I'm definitely not someone to look up to diet wise but at least I know what I'm getting myself into ha.0 -
May be because I do not have a thyroid, but I find that if I eat my main meal before 6:00 p.m., the weight comes off a lot easier. Eating my main meal later (after 6:00 p.m.) leaves my body feeling very sluggish. Yes, I do weigh my foods and I eat healthy.0
-
PrincessxSoph wrote: »Before I Started Work, I Was Losing General 1-2 Pounds Overnight, And All Of A Sudden It's Stop, I'm Seriously Considering To Have Less Calories Than What My Intake Is And Very Small Portions?
Are you saying here that you would weigh yourself at night and then be 1-2 lbs lighter in the morning? If that's the case, that's a normal weight fluctuation. Other things that contribute to fluctuations are salt, TOM, and exercise. You need time and patience. Lockdown your logging. Make sure you have that right. Make sure that your expectations are realistic, and keep at it.0 -
This thread is hurting my head, between all the caps and the answers full of old wives tales.
OP, if you were ever losing 1-2 lbs overnight, it was water weight. Actual weight loss will be more like 1-2 lbs per week, and even if you are perfect there will be some weeks you don't lose.
Meal timing is irrelevant. Metabolism changes throughout the day based on activity or specific foods eaten is not enough to make a noticeable change in weight loss.
Get a food scale and weigh your portions. Eat your calories at whatever times work for you.
Aim for a more realistic weekly goal.
Weigh yourself at the same time of day, no more than once a day. Considering you seem really emotional about normal weight fluctuations, I would strongly suggest you weigh once a week.0 -
This thread is hurting my head, between all the caps and the answers full of old wives tales.
OP, if you were ever losing 1-2 lbs overnight, it was water weight. Actual weight loss will be more like 1-2 lbs per week, and even if you are perfect there will be some weeks you don't lose.
Meal timing is irrelevant. Metabolism changes throughout the day based on activity or specific foods eaten is not enough to make a noticeable change in weight loss.
Get a food scale and weigh your portions. Eat your calories at whatever times work for you.
Aim for a more realistic weekly goal.
Weigh yourself at the same time of day, no more than once a day. Considering you seem really emotional about normal weight fluctuations, I would strongly suggest you weigh once a week.
/thread.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions