If every day were like today. You'd weigh X lbs in 5 weeks

kelseymaccombs

Well considering they said I'd lose 9 lbs in the 5 weeks and I'm already down 3.2 in less than 3 days I'm not sure how accurate it is. lol

Weight fluctuates up and down each day, be careful with daily weigh ins. You're not going to lose 9 pounds in 9 days.

mumtoonegirl

not at the point I am with my weight loss, I am nearing the very end. I wish I would loose that but at this point it's not accurate. It was when I first joined but I am at maintenance so the losses aren't coming anymore for the most part.

WinoGelato

I actually find it most interesting and motivational when I've had a day where I've gone significantly over my goal. Seeing that if every day was like today, you'd be very close to your starting weight in 5 weeks, when it has taken me about 5 months to lose what I have is very eye opening and a reminder that a day or two of splurges once in a while isn't going to totally derail you but going back to eating that way all the time will have a fairly quick and negative impact on my progress.

CoffeeNBooze

its pretty true for me. But I always have slip ups after two weeks so its thrown off haha. All part of life.

kylamaries

I've found it's not very correct but I love how it helps me gauge my progress (or lack thereof). When I see the number super low, it makes me feel really proud of my food choices (so I typically eat those again) and when it's high, I decide what food(s) caused that. It helps me understand the difference between eating well and eating anything!

As for the five weeks, I'm guessing it's just because there's approx. 5 weeks in a month (?).

Evilmuffin666

It has me down 20 pounds in 5 weeks. I'm thinking that is not possible.... or healthy.

sarahann513

It's hard to be exact with that, because personally for me, each day is totally different. But it's still fun to see, and a little extra motivation to have good days, I suppose.

aprilco

Seeing that 5 week estimate every day (whether its a lighter or heavier weight) keeps me motivated to at least try to meet my daily goals. I think it keeps me on track and looking for ways to trim a few more calories and exercise just a little more each day.

Mr_Excitement

Finish logging.

Hit button.

boredlimodriver

i bet if you ate the same food and did the same amount of exercise that in 5 weeks it would be correct. Perhaps increasing exercise towards the end to match weight loss

boredlimodriver

It has me down 20 pounds in 5 weeks. I'm thinking that is not possible.... or healthy.

are you eating enough/working out too much?

stealthq

It's never been right for me and never close. For some reason, MFP thinks that if I eat 1600 Cals per day I'm going to maintain. Not likely, since I was losing a pound a week averaging 1450 Cals/day. So, I've been way ahead of the MFP-calc'd curve. It's slowed down now that I'm close to goal, but still I lose faster than the estimate.

gracetillman

I really haven't paid it too much attention, but it does seem to tell me that I will lose on average 1 to 2 pounds per week and that is pretty much the rate I have been going so I think it is probably pretty close.

ClareWantsProgress

I found this the single most discouraging thing about MFP. It always said I should have dropped a lot of weight and it never happened, even though my food intake and exercising is remarkably similar day after day after month after month.

HeidiCooksSupper

If every day were like today, I'd be Bill Murray in Ground Hog Day.

I pay very little attention to it.

__Di__

When you finish your food intake for the day, you push the "complete this entry" button at the bottom of your food list and then you get:

"If every day were like today... You'd weigh ___ lbs in 5 weeks".....From your experience, how close is this prediction?





Extra credit bonus points for answering this question: why 5 weeks? :huh:

Write yourself a little note on your calendar for five weeks time with the predicted weight, see how close it gets.

When I was on MFP before this time around, I found it to be there or thereabouts and I like seeing that little quote, it amuses me, it is cute.

Project9

When you finish your food intake for the day, you push the "complete this entry" button at the bottom of your food list and then you get:

"If every day were like today... You'd weigh ___ lbs in 5 weeks".....From your experience, how close is this prediction?





Extra credit bonus points for answering this question: why 5 weeks? :huh:

Write yourself a little note on your calendar for five weeks time with the predicted weight, see how close it gets.

When I was on MFP before this time around, I found it to be there or thereabouts and I like seeing that little quote, it amuses me, it is cute.

actually I've done this on my note board. predicted a weight for july 30 weighin. I go my brothers prediction and my GF's prediction. my GF's prediction= 215, my prediction = 222, my brother's prediction = 230. Mybrother is a dieter, so maybe he is closest. I like my GF's prediction the best.

The MFP prediction usually has me in the teens (213-219lb) so I added a few lbs to my prediction for error, hence 222 lb prediction.

emilycarr71404

To me to satisfies my need to weigh myself every day. I don't know why but it helps me to pretend that I am already the weight they say I will be in 5 weeks. It keeps me on track. However, I find I lose at a faster rate than they say I will (a least for now I do.)

kenthepainter

I've been at t for 3 days, I've been under my calorie goal. The weight I'd be in 5 weeks has increased at least 1 lb every day. It seems like it should stay the same or even drop a little, I don't think I'm gonna pay attention to it.

salladeve

I tried tracking it for a while, writing down the weight and the date 5 weeks ahead, and I never achieved that goal. I did like seeing it going down though, it may have helped keep me motivated, IDK

Sharon_C

It's never right for me but I consistently hit that button to see what it says and it keeps me motivated.

leanndmary

I've only been onboard for 10 days, but the 5 week prediction is the one thing that really bothers me. Not in and of itself, but if you eat even one calorie less than recommended, you get the 5 week prediction in big letters, while underneath in TINY PRINT is the caution about eating too little being dangerous and counterproductive. I find the font discrepancy to be sending a very poor message about what matters to MFP. As someone who has been both obese and anorexic, I don't think this is healthy or helpful.

_jayciemarie_

The problem I see is the condition, "if every day were like today". I don't know about anyone else, but I don't have five weeks worth of days that are exactly the same. I notice what it says when I close my diary for the day, but I don't keep track of it.

Exactly this!

kimosabe1

it's a BIG FAT LIE!!!

JannAtBeach

The problem I see is the condition, "if every day were like today". I don't know about anyone else, but I don't have five weeks worth of days that are exactly the same. I notice what it says when I close my diary for the day, but I don't keep track of it.

I agree, I never have the same day..... I really don't pay to much attention to it...

willdob3

The problem I see is the condition, "if every day were like today". I don't know about anyone else, but I don't have five weeks worth of days that are exactly the same. I notice what it says when I close my diary for the day, but I don't keep track of it.

Exactly this!

I agree. It is meaningless.

No two days are identical in every way.

RunBrew

It seems like people are missing the point of the statement.

Look at it like this: You're on a 2000 cal plan, you eat 2158 calories one day....that statements gives you an idea what your journey **COULD** look like if you ate 2158 calories every day....Hmmm...do YOU want to do that math every night? 160 calories, times 7 days/week times 5 weeks...thats 5600 calories, divided by 3500 calories/pound... that'd be 1.5-ish pounds UP in 5 weeks....

Or, you touch the button, and it does the math for you.

it goes both ways....2k cal plan, eat 1810....how much weight would I lose eating an additional 190 cal deficit each day?

FWIW, I set my loss at 1 lb/week and according to the line graph, I lost 44 lbs in 42 weeks....Seems accurate to me.

JourneyingJessica

Im the weirdo in the group. I like it. Mainly on days when I'm eating a lot and i see the number barely changing or *gasp* go up. It reminds me that I can't eat all wild.

AlongCame_Molly

In the beginning when I had a substantial amount of weight to lose it was pretty spot-on. But I'm so close to goal now that progress has slowed to a crawl. If it were still accurate I'd have reached my goal back in February!

rypstorm

I only had 7 pounds to lose. I calculated my TDEE based on my BMR from the beachbody website, and I would say it took about three times longer than mfp's estimate. I use it as a gauge to stay on track, but that notice seems like such a tease!