Is it bad to take in more Protein than fat?
Tonyrebuilt
Posts: 43 Member
Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
0
Replies
-
If you stick to your calorie requirement you will probably lose weight2
-
Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week2
-
Nothing facilitates more than remaining within a calorie deficit. More protein is fine.1
-
Thanks for clearing that up. Reason I asked is because I was told my body would start using the extra protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle.0
-
Michael190lbs wrote: »Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week
You need to be in a 3500 calorie deficit per week to lose one pound per week, which is about 500 calories deficit per day.1 -
CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Michael190lbs wrote: »Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week
You need to be in a 3500 calorie deficit per week to lose one pound per week, which is about 500 calories deficit per day.
his calorie intake is 1900 I said 2400 burn which is neg 500 per day:) We just looked at it different-lol0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Thanks for clearing that up. Reason I asked is because I was told my body would start using the extra protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle.
Most people lose lean muscle at the same time as losing fat. You can minimize it by eating adequate protein and exercising.1 -
CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Michael190lbs wrote: »Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week
You need to be in a 3500 calorie deficit per week to lose one pound per week, which is about 500 calories deficit per day.
Well considering my estimated BMR is 2600 I should be losing 1 pound every 5 days.0 -
Michael190lbs wrote: »CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Michael190lbs wrote: »Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week
You need to be in a 3500 calorie deficit per week to lose one pound per week, which is about 500 calories deficit per day.
his calorie intake is 1900 I said 2400 burn which is neg 500 per day:) We just looked at it different-lol
I see where you are coming from, but I think it could be misinterpreted by some to mean that they have to exercise until they burn off 2400 calories. If 1900 is already a deficit set by MFP, no extra burn is needed. You don't have to exercise at all to lose weight if you eat within your calorie limit. MFP will already give you a 500 per day deficit in the goal they give you for 1 lb per week loss.0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?0 -
Not if you are hitting a sensible fat minimum goal - I like 0.4g of fat / lb of bodyweight for example when I'm tracking macros.Is it bad to take in more Protein than fat?
1 -
CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Michael190lbs wrote: »CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Michael190lbs wrote: »Never!!!! - Depends on your activity level if you burn 2400 calories a day you will lose a pound a week
You need to be in a 3500 calorie deficit per week to lose one pound per week, which is about 500 calories deficit per day.
his calorie intake is 1900 I said 2400 burn which is neg 500 per day:) We just looked at it different-lol
I see where you are coming from, but I think it could be misinterpreted by some to mean that they have to exercise until they burn off 2400 calories. If 1900 is already a deficit set by MFP, no extra burn is needed. You don't have to exercise at all to lose weight if you eat within your calorie limit. MFP will already give you a 500 per day deficit in the goal they give you for 1 lb per week loss.
I can understand that and we are on MFP so makes sense your way.0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
Yeeeees...? It's the calorie limit aligned with your TDEE that's going to facilitate the healthy weight loss- not necessarily your macros (which are in place to align with your nutritional/training goals).
As per the right foods... eat whatever you want within your macro/calorie ranges (fat loss) with an eye toward nutritionally well rounded (health).1 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently0 -
CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Thanks for clearing that up. Reason I asked is because I was told my body would start using the extra protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle.
Most people lose lean muscle at the same time as losing fat. You can minimize it by eating adequate protein and exercising.
So if I work out like I plan to do I should be good?0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
Yeeeees...? It's the calorie limit aligned with your TDEE that's going to facilitate the healthy weight loss- not necessarily your macros (which are in place to align with your nutritional/training goals).
As per the right foods... eat whatever you want within your macro/calorie ranges (fat loss) with an eye toward nutritionally well rounded (health).
I was told that my body would burn protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle. That's what I meant about healthy weight loss. I don't want to lose lean muscle just the fat. I do my standard push ups and sit ups everyday .0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Thanks for clearing that up. Reason I asked is because I was told my body would start using the extra protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle.
No. You were told wrong. The extra protein will help preserve lean muscle as you lose weight. Those are excellent macros as long as you limit your calories to 1900. If you start working out you can eat most of the calories you earn from exercise and still lose weight. I've lost over 100 pounds with similar macros and still have decent muscles.Tonyrebuilt wrote: »CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Thanks for clearing that up. Reason I asked is because I was told my body would start using the extra protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle.
Most people lose lean muscle at the same time as losing fat. You can minimize it by eating adequate protein and exercising.
So if I work out like I plan to do I should be good?
Yes.3 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
Yeeeees...? It's the calorie limit aligned with your TDEE that's going to facilitate the healthy weight loss- not necessarily your macros (which are in place to align with your nutritional/training goals).
As per the right foods... eat whatever you want within your macro/calorie ranges (fat loss) with an eye toward nutritionally well rounded (health).
I was told that my body would burn protein for fuel instead of fat and I would lose lean muscle. That's what I meant about healthy weight loss. I don't want to lose lean muscle just the fat. I do my standard push ups and sit ups everyday .
Whoever told you that is an idiot, and you should probably disregard any other advice they give you as well because it will probably be equally garbage.
Adequate protein intake helps preserve lean body mass. Read this thread for help on setting up your macros properly and why you should do it that way:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/819055/setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets/p11 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.0 -
Use the values below for the recommended ranges;
Protein = 0.8-1.2g/lb (lean body mass)
Fat = 0.4g/lbs (lean body mass)
Carbs = remainder
Weight loss is caused by a caloric deficit. Adequate protein is muscle sparing. Adequate fats are for hormonal health.2 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
I did not say your top healthy weight is 175. I used that number as an example. If 235 is goal, your fat would be 94 grams, which is an even bigger increase from your current settings.
How tall are you? Have you trained to build muscle in the past? That is a high ideal weight for most people. It would be unusual to see a 22 yo with the kind of muscle base to support that as a lean weight. Even if your goal was 15% bf, the LBM you'd have would be 200 lbs. Lower bf would mean LBM would be even higher.0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
Three years ago I was heavier than you and (Power lifter in the 1400 lb club) now weigh 178 look at my pictures Hardly skin and Bones you are going to lose a lot of Muscle and Fat its all part of the game. Big bulky muscles carry a lot of Fat when you lean out and drop body fat your muscles lose size due to fat loss.
1 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
How are you determining your muscle mass? There are very few people I know at 235 that are leaned out.1 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
I did not say your top healthy weight is 175. I used that number as an example. If 235 is goal, your fat would be 94 grams, which is an even bigger increase from your current settings.
How tall are you? Have you trained to build muscle in the past? That is a high ideal weight for most people. It would be unusual to see a 22 yo with the kind of muscle base to support that as a lean weight. Even if your goal was 15% bf, the LBM you'd have would be 200 lbs. Lower bf would mean LBM would be even higher.
6'2" I used to play college football. I went from weightlifting 3 times a day to not having done a push up in 4 years. I'm not necessarily trying to get a six pack and be totally ripped. Even when I could see my abs a little bit I was about 225lbs.0 -
Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
How are you determining your muscle mass? There are very few people I know at 235 that are leaned out.
I'm not saying I was leaned out, but that was a very natural weight for me to maintain with regular exercise and eating relatively poorly. I could have definitely have shed some more fat. I just felt good at that weight is all
0 -
Michael190lbs wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Tonyrebuilt wrote: »Currently my split goes as follows:
Carbs: 50%
Fat: 20%
Protein: 30%
Calorie limit: 1900
Will this facilitate healthy weight loss given I eat the right foods and hit my calorie goals?
That's about 42 grams of fat per day, which is not much. What is your weight?
I weigh 279lbs currently
That is way too little fat. Multiply the top "healthy weight" for your height by .4 and use that as your fat goal in grams. So if the top weight is 175, it would be 70 grams per day, for example. Dietary fat is important for hormone function and to aid in vitamin absorption. It's not a macro to whack down to poverty levels.
Only thing is, if I weighed 175lbs I would be literally skin and bone. My ideal healthy weight is 235lbs. I'm not 279lbs of fluff. I got a lot of muscle that been covered up over thepast 5 years.
Three years ago I was heavier than you and (Power lifter in the 1400 lb club) now weigh 178 look at my pictures Hardly skin and Bones you are going to lose a lot of Muscle and Fat its all part of the game. Big bulky muscles carry a lot of Fat when you lean out and drop body fat your muscles lose size due to fat loss.
You are right, I just haven't been under 200lbs since the 7th grade. It's just hard to picture myself at that weight.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions