Definitive ranking of Halo Top flavors

leanitup123

forward0backward wrote: »

I was thinking about getting this for my mother. She likes some ice cream

DO IT.

Trilby16

So everybody likes this? I usually like anything remotely sweet but not this. I've only tried Birthday Cake because that's all I could find. It tasted fake. I didn't even finish the pint. Ick. And very expensive. I much prefer mixing a couple of tablespoons of Edy's Slow Churn together with skim milk. Just MHO.

orangegato

^^^This. I also tried Birthday Cake and hated it. Threw it out. Such a bad experience that I never want to try another flavor.

laurabadams

Trilby16 wrote: »

So everybody likes this? I usually like anything remotely sweet but not this. I've only tried Birthday Cake because that's all I could find. It tasted fake. I didn't even finish the pint. Ick. And very expensive. I much prefer mixing a couple of tablespoons of Edy's Slow Churn together with skim milk. Just MHO.

Personally, I thought Birthday Cake was one of the worst flavors of Halo Top. I liked most of the others...peanut butter cup & oatmeal cookie are favorites.

Sp1tfire

I love the birthday cake the best! It tastes just like blue bunny birthday cake flavor to me.

I can't wait to see this list updated with the new flavors (including pumpkin pie!)

t4mommy

Peanut butter cup = YUMMO!!!!