Fatorexia: Is it a thing?
Hungry_Shopgirl
Posts: 329 Member
So I just came across the term in a blog post and had never heard of it before. A google search brought this up: dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1267883/Fatorexia-In-mirror-Sara-saw-slim-woman-Just-problem-17st-So-deluded.html
In a nutshell, she describes it as "Though still fat, you think you are slim and exhibit all the reverse traits of anorexia."
Have you guys heard of it before? Do you think it's a real thing?
In a nutshell, she describes it as "Though still fat, you think you are slim and exhibit all the reverse traits of anorexia."
Have you guys heard of it before? Do you think it's a real thing?
13
Replies
-
Its in the daily mail... enough said...35
-
TavistockToad wrote: »Its in the daily mail... enough said...
Yep pretty much my response.
I won't click on your link because I don't want to give them revenue. The daily mail especially the 'femail' pages is notorious for making stuff up to make women feel alternatingly good and bad about themselves.
I believe body dysmorphia is a thing and can represent itself in different ways. If you worry you have body dysmorphia you should go see a professional,14 -
Apparently a made up word in the title of a book:
http://www.cosmopolitan.co.za/health-fitness/body-health/fatorexia0 -
I get what it's saying - I would just call it "denial" to be honest. Even "body dysmorphia" is too strong.
A lot of people 'have' this - they think they're a fine weight but candid photos etc. tell a different story.
Also, urgh, Daily Fail. Love how they're calling her "deluded" in the URL too... lovely.
20 -
That was a painful read, woman avoids mirrors and pretends she doesn't know she is fat, woman is forced to face reality and then compares her denial to people with a mental health issue.
I'm sure there are many of us who have not noticed just how much weight we have allowed ourselves to put on. I know even now the person in the mirror doesn't look too fat to me, but the camera never lies so I know full well I still have work to do!
Do I think this amounts to 'fatorexia'? No, I think it's a positive thing, I think it means we don't dislike ourselves so much that all we see is our fatness.
To compare that to anorexia seems like a massive insult to people with a genuine condition.8 -
Sounds like delusion and narcissism.
And i agree with @Loug1983 here, it's insulting and attention mongering at it's finest. Anorexia is the most deadly mental illness in the world and needs to be taken seriously.7 -
Positive self image? Probably
Denial? Certainly
A mental disorder? No!
4 -
yea but surely your clothes size tells you , you are fat. I don't know any world where a size UK 18 upwards is a skinny. You may not have scales or mirrors but i assume one still wears clothes, so when your clothes no longer fits you and you find yourself buying size 16, then 18, then 22 you should have the intelligence to know you are putting on too much weight and you have a problem. I'm not fat shaming anyone, i'm just saying be the size you want to be, and if you're not, do something about it, make healthier choices. And if your brain is telling you troublesome things about your body , weight, looks etc then its time to seek professional help to deal with it.5
-
People with anorexia generally don't think of themselves as being okay despite being abnormally thin, but rather believe they are too fat, they are not simply in denial...
So I would say, if this lady believes she is too thin and is constantly eating trying to gain weight, it's a mental disorder...
A mental disorder has to cause you distress, if you believe you are okay, there's really no distress, so I don't think it can qualify.
5 -
Hungry_Shopgirl wrote: »So I just came across the term in a blog post and had never heard of it before. A google search brought this up: dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1267883/Fatorexia-In-mirror-Sara-saw-slim-woman-Just-problem-17st-So-deluded.html
In a nutshell, she describes it as "Though still fat, you think you are slim and exhibit all the reverse traits of anorexia."
Have you guys heard of it before? Do you think it's a real thing?
I don't know if this is actually the same thing, because it sounds like the article is a mental health issue and not a conscious choice, but it kinda reminds me of the death fatty movement. There are a lot of obese people out there (calling themselves "deathfats", apparently to poke fun at the term "morbidly obese") who take the whole "health at any size" concept entirely too far by claiming that being severely overweight doesn't come with health complications and that all the studies that show otherwise are the works of biased "fatphobic" health professionals who have deeply internalized fat hate.
I once had a "friend" who was a proud self-described death fatty. She was so large she needed mobility aids to get around because her knees were starting to give up. She absolutely denied the possibility that the weight was the issue and said it was just "bad knees and fibro". We aren't friends anymore.4 -
I think this minimises the seriousness of anorexia. So she cut the tags out of clothes and never looked in a mirror. Denialist and potentially a bit delusional. She's just trying to sell books.3
-
I think fatorexia is nonsense. I did do exactly this: after losing 90 pounds in about a year I felt much thinner and more attractive - but I knew I still weighed 290 pounds, so that kept the fantasy in a convenient box for storage and occasional use when I needed the boost.5
-
1) Daily Fail
2) Clearly promotion for her book
I'm just proud I resisted the sidebar of shame today!2 -
Daily Fail as mentioned often already Not worth even reading
Their business model is built on making women feel embarassed about their body harassing women and lying0 -
She's not looked in a full length mirror for years...?
That's ignorance. Not fatorexia, not body dismorphia, just plain ignorance.
I actually find it rather distasteful that she (mis)uses those strong mental health terms to describe herself.4 -
Alatariel75 wrote: »I think this minimises the seriousness of anorexia. So she cut the tags out of clothes and never looked in a mirror. Denialist and potentially a bit delusional. She's just trying to sell books.
This.
I do think some people are in denial or have bizarrely inflated egos or the like, but not that it's an ED akin to anorexia.
And yeah, Daily Mail.0 -
Um..... what.1
-
Body dysmorphia is pretty prevalent in the fitness/bodybuilding world. Heck, I may have it myself, according to my dear wife. I'm 225# at 6'1 and I still see nothing but a skinny dude in the mirror. I still feel like people look at me and are thinking "damn, that dude is too skinny". I'm not kidding.
I intellectually "know" that I'm not small but what I see in the mirror is something different. It's part of what keeps me going to the gym and lifting.
This just sounds like some variant - I wonder how many formerly overly "skinny" people, especially men suffer from this.1 -
I think calling it fatorexia is insensitive, but body dysmorphia absolutely goes both ways. I believe I experience a mild form. If I didn't own a scale and know my BMI chart by heart I would believe I am much thinner than I really am. I have to take my measurements before buying clothes because I'll buy clothes a couple sizes too small and think they look fine. I've always had a full length mirror and have never been able to see the gains unless they were very large and sudden. I think I'm struggling to stick to my diet after losing 60 pounds, I'm still 80 overweight, because I honestly can't see where I need to lose more weight from.
That lady in the story sounds a little different though. Like she is cutting out tags and avoiding mirrors because she just doesn't want to believe she is obese. Sounds more like denial to me.3 -
kristikitter wrote: »I get what it's saying - I would just call it "denial" to be honest. Even "body dysmorphia" is too strong.
A lot of people 'have' this - they think they're a fine weight but candid photos etc. tell a different story.
This is me to a 'T', I was in severe denial of my size and if I looked in my mirror I was fine but when I looked in the mirror with someone next to me (eg. at work my co-workers and I were all walking past floor to ceiling mirrors) I am shocked at how much bigger I was compared to them. I just thought I was the same size as them. It was/is total denial. I figured since I went to the gym everyday that the scale was lying - nope it was me lying to myself. I'm getting better now - over 40 pounds lost but still 50 to go.0 -
That was a painful read, woman avoids mirrors and pretends she doesn't know she is fat, woman is forced to face reality and then compares her denial to people with a mental health issue.
I'm sure there are many of us who have not noticed just how much weight we have allowed ourselves to put on. I know even now the person in the mirror doesn't look too fat to me, but the camera never lies so I know full well I still have work to do!
This. Seeing myself in the mirror, I always thought I looked 'okay'. Sure, I could lose a few pounds, but it wasn't so obvious.
And then there was this:
Yeah, truth hurts. That doesn't make not noticing it a mental health issue. (I guess a case can be made for not being depressed about my previous appearance because I didn't notice how heavy I was, but it sort of got obvious when I went clothes shopping. And I sure as heck didn't walk into a place like Victoria's Secret or Lulu Lemon and wonder why nothing fit.)
8 -
Exactly that, estherdragon.0
-
In 1996 When I was 25 years I experienced that! I was gaining weight but did see in the mirror how fat I was. The only way that I could tell that I was gaining weight was the scale.0
-
Honestly, I think a lot of us can relate to this a little bit. I know I can.
But it's just denial and not a mental disorder for the majority. I'm just glad I've always reigned it in before getting too out of control.
1 -
normally when I pass a mirror, I take a moment to flex.4
-
normally when I pass a mirror, I take a moment to flex.
You flex your fat?
Flatorexia makes me think of flatulence but that's another topic clearly. Seems a little ridiculous really. And an attempt to make a name for acceptance. Although I never saw myself as fat as I was, oddly I don't see myself as the shape I currently am.0 -
Wow! I had no idea that posting something from the Daily Mail would make people not click on it! Pardon my ignorance, I'm originally South American so I don't even know what kind of reputation that site has.
I ran across the term in this article in a Spanish-speaking newspaper: http://tn.com.ar/salud/lo-ultimo/megarexia-el-mal-de-ser-feliz-con-sobrepeso-afecta-8-de-cada-10-obesos_805490
But I figured not many would be able to read it. So I just google searched the term and copy pasted the first English-language article I found on the topic.
I guess now I know better eh?3 -
@estherdragonbat I have had the exact same moment - "yeah I could probably lose a bit of weight" - and then there was THAT photo that just hit me and it really, really hit home.
Thank you for sharing, I am still not brave enough to share mine!!!4 -
estherdragonbat wrote: »That was a painful read, woman avoids mirrors and pretends she doesn't know she is fat, woman is forced to face reality and then compares her denial to people with a mental health issue.
I'm sure there are many of us who have not noticed just how much weight we have allowed ourselves to put on. I know even now the person in the mirror doesn't look too fat to me, but the camera never lies so I know full well I still have work to do!
This. Seeing myself in the mirror, I always thought I looked 'okay'. Sure, I could lose a few pounds, but it wasn't so obvious.
And then there was this:
Yeah, truth hurts. That doesn't make not noticing it a mental health issue. (I guess a case can be made for not being depressed about my previous appearance because I didn't notice how heavy I was, but it sort of got obvious when I went clothes shopping. And I sure as heck didn't walk into a place like Victoria's Secret or Lulu Lemon and wonder why nothing fit.)
As a frequent con goer, I want to know who is cut out!8 -
As others have said - Its the Daily Mail enough said. It, along with that other joke paper "The Sun" wouldn't know a fact if it came up and slapped them across the face. Check somewhere else and see if this is the case - you'll not get anyting useful from The Daily Mail.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions