Low calorie/cardio vs keto/weights
fitjam00
Posts: 9 Member
Hi everyone, so when I was younger low cal & cardio ( 1hr 4-5x per week), allowed me to lose weight fairly quickly. Well fast forward 20 years, low cal & cardio didn't work ( quickly enough for me to feel it was worth the stress if it). So a co-worker, a Physical thearpist, suggested I try keto and weight lifting instead. Boom! The weight started coming off fairly quickly.
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
2
Replies
-
Weight loss comes from a calorie deficit. You will always drop some water weight when you start low carb.9
-
I did low cal/ cardio for 2 months without a lot of progress , now I'm 5 months in and 50lbs down from keto6
-
I understand water weight but I really don't get why my 1500 low cal vs 1500 keto progress
I'd like to know if anyone else experienced this or knows the science behind it?3 -
Regardless of the food choices and macro balance you choose, it's a calorie deficit that causes weight loss.
When you describe low cal/cardio - how low cal? Were you logging? Using a food scale? How did you estimate calorie burn from cardio? Did you eat those cals back? How long did you use this approach?
You mentioned that it wasn't working quickly enough... what is your expectation? Is it a reasonable one? How much weight are you trying to lose?7 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
2 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
Weight training doesnt burn much calories. More likely, you are more accurate on this diet than the other diet. It doesn't seem like the other diet was sustainable for you, which could have led to inaccuracies in tracking and compliance issues.7 -
I am just reading Fat For Fuel, by Dr. Mercola and he fully explains the science behind why keto works. Great book! I actually borrowed it from my library via ebook download onto my phone.17
-
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!25 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
If you lost weight, it was via a caloric deficit, by whatever means you created it. Congratulations on the weight loss.8 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
Who's anti keto? The science is very clear, if you control for calories and protein there is no difference. What is more important is dietary adherence.
I generally eat high carb and higher protein and all my numbers are outstanding. Also, since inflammation is the new buzz word, it should noted that weight training causes inflammation. Inflammation isnt a problem, chronic inflammation is. And that is generally cause by obesity.15 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
Who's anti keto? The science is very clear, if you control for calories and protein there is no difference. What is more important is dietary adherence.
I generally eat high carb and higher protein and all my numbers are outstanding. Also, since inflammation is the new buzz word, it should noted that weight training causes inflammation. Inflammation isnt a problem, chronic inflammation is. And that is generally cause by obesity.
I don't care about you or your numbers. AGAIN, the original poster asked SPECIFIC questions that no one other than me answered.16 -
It's not a "narrative. It's reality. Many fad diet proponents try to downplay CICO because they feel it distracts from the dogma of their fad of choice. Others even outright deny it. But none of these rhetorical gymnastics changes said reality.
As an individual that toiled for months at the onset of my journey with these fad diets, I understand fully the cult personality around many of them. However, one thing I can report to folks new to this is that once they accept CICO the easier their journey (and life in general) will become.8 -
Hi everyone, so when I was younger low cal & cardio ( 1hr 4-5x per week), allowed me to lose weight fairly quickly. Well fast forward 20 years, low cal & cardio didn't work ( quickly enough for me to feel it was worth the stress if it). So a co-worker, a Physical thearpist, suggested I try keto and weight lifting instead. Boom! The weight started coming off fairly quickly.
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
Possibly as you are older you aren't able to put the same effort into the cardio you did when you were younger. Or your tastes have changed and the low-cal diet you did didn't psychologically satisfy you now the way it did then.
It's really hard to say for sure though, since you are dealing with multiple variables and personal recollection. I mean, maybe keto was the key for you and it would have worked even if you stuck with cardio. Or maybe the cardio took too much out of you and staying with the same diet but working in some weightlifting would have done the trick. The important thing is you found what works for you - congrats!4 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
I don't think most posters here are anti-"keto". They are anti-"keto works better for everyone".12 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
Who's anti keto? The science is very clear, if you control for calories and protein there is no difference. What is more important is dietary adherence.
I generally eat high carb and higher protein and all my numbers are outstanding. Also, since inflammation is the new buzz word, it should noted that weight training causes inflammation. Inflammation isnt a problem, chronic inflammation is. And that is generally cause by obesity.
I don't care about you or your numbers. AGAIN, the original poster asked SPECIFIC questions that no one other than me answered.
Lol.6 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
I don't think most posters here are anti-"keto". They are anti-"keto works better for everyone".
THAT WASNT THE QUESTION OP ASKED.4 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
I don't think most posters here are anti-"keto". They are anti-"keto works better for everyone".
THAT WASNT THE QUESTION OP ASKED.
I was responding to you calling out the other replies, not the OP. I already responded to the OP.4 -
I was calorie counting for 2 months 1500 kcal and walking on treadmill min 30 3-4x per week
But i felt like I was killing myself for the 4lbs after 2 months I was done
I think my expectations where too high in retrospect cuz that 1 lb a week, is a safe amount ( I know now)
I didn't eat the calories back, I measured my food, but was never sure what my calories deficit was from the exercise as the calorie counter on the treadmill is not accurate
The keto is the same 1500 kcal and weight training 3-4x week
Maybe its the weight lifting?
I've experienced the same thing. These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative. I train hard with weights 3-4 times a week on keto and I've not only dropped weight faster than ever in my life, I also don't have inflammation anymore. I do light cardio like walking my dogs or biking with my wife but nothing like steady state cardio on machines. Keep up the great work!
I don't think most posters here are anti-"keto". They are anti-"keto works better for everyone".
THAT WASNT THE QUESTION OP ASKED.
I was responding to you calling out the other replies, not the OP. I already responded to the OP.
I didn't call anyone out. They felt the burning desire to attempt to correct someone on MFP...again. THEY gave their speeches about something not even remotely close to what OP asked. I answered the question.12 -
Sounds like you found the diet that works best for you... right now.
Keto can work really well for some. It often reduces appetite, stabilizes energy, reduces cravings, and improves health - especially if there is insulin resistance to consider. LCHF has been found to work slightly better for those with metabolic syndrome/IR. It is not a huge difference - averages out to about 6 lbs in a year - but it is there for some of us.
For those without metabolic syndrome/IR they lose just as well on a higher carb diet.
I'm one who experienced a situation like yours. During the 90's and early 00's, I was low fat and higher carb, and ran half marathons on the weekends ... and steadily gained weight. Faster when I had to cut back on exercise. Losing weight was a struggle and slow.
Now I am in my 40's and can't do a lot of exercise due to injuries and arthritis, but doing keto I could lose weight fairly easily. I set my macros to lose about 1-1.5 lbs per week at just over 1400 kcals. I ate 1500 and lost 2-3 lbs per week. I maintain at about 2000 kcal a week, unless I go higher carb for a while, at which time I gain.
Keto really works well for some.
ETA Weight lifting often results in some water gain and a slowing of the scale for a while. In my n=1, I was lifting quite heavy for a few months then had to stop all activity due to an injury. Within 2 weeks of stopping activity I lost 10 lbs. All I could guess was water weight.7 -
I consider this calling people out
These anti-keto hawks dive down whenever something doesn't fit their "calories in calories out" narrative.
And this is what OP asked for
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
<shrug> I feel like she got a lot of other's experience and insights. And she hasn't complained about the responses she got. Luckily, it doesn't matter because she is having success and was just looking for more info, I'm sure she'll be fine one way or the other.6 -
Hi everyone, so when I was younger low cal & cardio ( 1hr 4-5x per week), allowed me to lose weight fairly quickly. Well fast forward 20 years, low cal & cardio didn't work ( quickly enough for me to feel it was worth the stress if it). So a co-worker, a Physical thearpist, suggested I try keto and weight lifting instead. Boom! The weight started coming off fairly quickly.
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
Possibly as you are older you aren't able to put the same effort into the cardio you did when you were younger.
That's a really good point
I think it was just easier for me in my 20s to tear up the treadmill and function on a lower calorie count
At this stage in my life it wasn't sustainable
It's nice to read about others who've had a similar journey in this community3 -
wildhorsewendy wrote: »I am just reading Fat For Fuel, by Dr. Mercola and he fully explains the science behind why keto works. Great book! I actually borrowed it from my library via ebook download onto my phone.
Please don't put Mecola and science in the same sentence. That is an insult to all the scientists out there.For the love of God shut up about the *kitten* calorie deficit!
I am glad you have found what works for you, as has the op. That is awesome. However, please be respectful that keto will not work for everyone.
Psst, the reason it has worked for you is because it easily keeps you in a calorie deficit as you find a diet high in fats filling. On the other hand I need a good balance of fibre, fat and protein in my diet to give the same results.12 -
Lillymoo01 wrote: »wildhorsewendy wrote: »I am just reading Fat For Fuel, by Dr. Mercola and he fully explains the science behind why keto works. Great book! I actually borrowed it from my library via ebook download onto my phone.
Please don't put Mecola and science in the same sentence. That is an insult to all the scientists out there.For the love of God shut up about the *kitten* calorie deficit!
I am glad you have found what works for you, as has the op. That is awesome. However, please be respectful that keto will not work for everyone.
Psst, the reason it has worked for you is because it easily keeps you in a calorie deficit as you find a diet high in fats filling. On the other hand I need a good balance of fibre, fat and protein in my diet to give the same results.
This isn't about me or OP choosing to do keto. The question was whether anyone else experienced the same results as he/she did while on keto and only weight training. Neither of us ONCE mentioned keto was the only way or the right way to do a thing. The only thing we're "guilty" of is having the same experience.15 -
Lillymoo01 wrote: »wildhorsewendy wrote: »I am just reading Fat For Fuel, by Dr. Mercola and he fully explains the science behind why keto works. Great book! I actually borrowed it from my library via ebook download onto my phone.
Please don't put Mecola and science in the same sentence. That is an insult to all the scientists out there.For the love of God shut up about the *kitten* calorie deficit!
I am glad you have found what works for you, as has the op. That is awesome. However, please be respectful that keto will not work for everyone.
Psst, the reason it has worked for you is because it easily keeps you in a calorie deficit as you find a diet high in fats filling. On the other hand I need a good balance of fibre, fat and protein in my diet to give the same results.
[insult removed by MFP mods] This isn't about me or OP choosing to do keto. The question was whether anyone else experienced the same results as he/she did while on keto and only weight training. Neither of us ONCE mentioned keto was the only way or the right way to do a thing. The only thing we're "guilty" of is having the same experience.
Is it possible to express your opinions without the insults?7 -
Hi everyone, so when I was younger low cal & cardio ( 1hr 4-5x per week), allowed me to lose weight fairly quickly. Well fast forward 20 years, low cal & cardio didn't work ( quickly enough for me to feel it was worth the stress if it). So a co-worker, a Physical thearpist, suggested I try keto and weight lifting instead. Boom! The weight started coming off fairly quickly.
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
Possibly as you are older you aren't able to put the same effort into the cardio you did when you were younger.
That's a really good point
I think it was just easier for me in my 20s to tear up the treadmill and function on a lower calorie count
At this stage in my life it wasn't sustainable
It's nice to read about others who've had a similar journey in this community
It's really easy to get to thinking that there is something wrong with you, isn't it?
When I was in my 20s I ate like crap and I ate a lot, but I stayed thin even though I didn't do much purposeful exercise. But in hindsight, I was generally more active - a more physical job, I would go out and do more active stuff rather than sitting at a restaurant table, I had energy even if I only slept 5 hours. Ahhh, the good old days!4 -
Hi everyone, so when I was younger low cal & cardio ( 1hr 4-5x per week), allowed me to lose weight fairly quickly. Well fast forward 20 years, low cal & cardio didn't work ( quickly enough for me to feel it was worth the stress if it). So a co-worker, a Physical thearpist, suggested I try keto and weight lifting instead. Boom! The weight started coming off fairly quickly.
Is this because I'm old or my metabolism is changed ?
I would love to hear the experience of other
Or just any insight you may have
Possibly as you are older you aren't able to put the same effort into the cardio you did when you were younger.
That's a really good point
I think it was just easier for me in my 20s to tear up the treadmill and function on a lower calorie count
At this stage in my life it wasn't sustainable
It's nice to read about others who've had a similar journey in this community
It's really easy to get to thinking that there is something wrong with you, isn't it?
When I was in my 20s I ate like crap and I ate a lot, but I stayed thin even though I didn't do much purposeful exercise. But in hindsight, I was generally more active - a more physical job, I would go out and do more active stuff rather than sitting at a restaurant table, I had energy even if I only slept 5 hours. Ahhh, the good old days!
Excellent point. Add to this the fact that your metabolism slows as you age and you probably have the answer of why it was easier then. I am glad you have found something that works.2 -
Great. Once again I don't care. You don't have the will power to do keto so you blah blah blah about how wonderful your "journey" has been by just reducing calories. Great.
It has nothing to do with willpower. Some people enjoy keto, and thus find it easy to stick to and lose weight. That's excellent. Other people enjoy other ways of eating at a deficit that they find easy to stick to and lose weight. Again, excellent. Why white knuckle it through something that is going to have the exact same result when you can do it in a far more pleasant way? I starved myself in my younger days. Should I go back to that just because it took willpower (because believe me, it did)?12 -
This thread has taught me that keto makes you angry.37
-
Alatariel75 wrote: »This thread has taught me that keto makes you angry.
That is actually a side effect of keto apparently.5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions