Is it necessarily bad to have running as your sole source of exercise?

MeanderingMammal

kami3006 wrote: »

RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: »

dewd2 wrote: »

I'm curious who is marking all the recommendations for cross training / lifting as 'woo' and why? If you disagree with the suggestions you should at least offer an alternative and state your reasons for it.

I'm curious to.

There is a reason almost all running plans incorporate cross training of some kind.

I'm seeing this all over the forums and at first I thought troll but now I wonder if it's also some new or newish folks thinking it's short for "woohoo."

To be fair, when it was introduced the guidance note said it could be used for either "woo" or some variant of user-group, because for variants of like weren't enough.

dutchandkiwi

My husband was only focussing on running. In the end that is what caused his long term injury he is still suffering from He totally neglected his core muscles and over time all his other (bottom) muscles tried to compensate. As it turns out over compensate. On medical specialist order he is now doing pilates and morning workouts for his core and slowly his injury is healing.
So my take on it would be not long term no. Do some core work as well.

Bluebell2325

Completely going off on a tangent, but just interested in what woo means (it wasn't me pressing it) but to me (UK if that makes a diff) woo means great, very happy, more than just "like". Does it have a different meaning in US??! Always been confused why there's an awesome AND a woo which to me mean we thing. Well that's my stupid question of the day out the way, back to topic!! Mx

Okiludy

Bluebell2325 wrote: »

Completely going off on a tangent, but just interested in what woo means (it wasn't me pressing it) but to me (UK if that makes a diff) woo means great, very happy, more than just "like". Does it have a different meaning in US??! Always been confused why there's an awesome AND a woo which to me mean we thing. Well that's my stupid question of the day out the way, back to topic!! Mx

I think it means you think the statement has no truth to it.

CoueCoue

dewd2 wrote: »

I'm curious who is marking all the recommendations for cross training / lifting as 'woo' and why? If you disagree with the suggestions you should at least offer an alternative and state your reasons for it.

It's not me (promise)...but one suggestion is that this fairly new addition of "woo" by MFP is pretty confusing...as some take it to mean "woo-woo crazy talk" whereas some take it to mean a "punch in the air" kind of "YES!" whoop of agreement.

Maybe this person means the latter??? Dunno.

Bluebell2325

Thanks Oki, I'll think of it as the "twaddle" button in future! Though why you would use it without comment??!

JustRobby1

"Woo" is used a bunch in scientific circles to basically describe conspiracy theory, new age, or other unfounded or ludicrous beliefs. I think the main reason it is also used here at MFP is that people holding ridiculous beliefs is pretty common in the fitness world.

girlgroves

CoueCoue wrote: »

dewd2 wrote: »

I'm curious who is marking all the recommendations for cross training / lifting as 'woo' and why? If you disagree with the suggestions you should at least offer an alternative and state your reasons for it.

It's not me (promise)...but one suggestion is that this fairly new addition of "woo" by MFP is pretty confusing...as some take it to mean "woo-woo crazy talk" whereas some take it to mean a "punch in the air" kind of "YES!" whoop of agreement.

Maybe this person means the latter??? Dunno.

I've never personally used the Woo button, but isn't that a smiley face next to it? - in which case wouldn't the positive 'punch-the-air-YES-whoop' meaning would make more sense??

Penthesilea514

girlgroves wrote: »

CoueCoue wrote: »

dewd2 wrote: »

I'm curious who is marking all the recommendations for cross training / lifting as 'woo' and why? If you disagree with the suggestions you should at least offer an alternative and state your reasons for it.

It's not me (promise)...but one suggestion is that this fairly new addition of "woo" by MFP is pretty confusing...as some take it to mean "woo-woo crazy talk" whereas some take it to mean a "punch in the air" kind of "YES!" whoop of agreement.

Maybe this person means the latter??? Dunno.

I've never personally used the Woo button, but isn't that a smiley face next to it? - in which case wouldn't the positive 'punch-the-air-YES-whoop' meaning would make more sense??

MFP claims it can be dual use, for both positive and negative reasons, which is confusing. I don't see that as a smiling face honestly- I see it as someone cocking their head to the side, like in confusion. The smile seems more like how I handle hearing "woo" in real life- smiling and backing away slowly...

Penthesilea514

http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10570889/new-community-reaction-woo#latest

sijomial

Bluebell2325 wrote: »

Completely going off on a tangent, but just interested in what woo means (it wasn't me pressing it) but to me (UK if that makes a diff) woo means great, very happy, more than just "like". Does it have a different meaning in US??! Always been confused why there's an awesome AND a woo which to me mean we thing. Well that's my stupid question of the day out the way, back to topic!! Mx

@Bluebell2325

I'm in the UK too and would interpret woo as "what a load of cobblers".
Woo-hoo I would see as encouragement or happy / over-excited.



As for the only running aspect. I'm a cyclist rather than a runner and tend to do strength training for the vast majority of the time in addition to my riding. But in the run up to a big cycling event I may well prioritise my cycling to the exclusion of strength training for a few weeks to help my training recovery.

I don't see solely running as "bad" but would say sub-optimal for most people. Still a lot better than sofa surfing whichever way you look at it.

WickedPineapple

woo = BS, nonsense, quackery, codswallop, balderdash

On MFP, it's used as a response to unsubstantiated claims.

To the OP - I agree with what's been said above. Only running for exercise isn't necessarily a bad thing, but as others have mentioned, cross training will compliment your running and help with injury prevention. Personally, I was running with very little strength training while training for a 10k over a year ago. I ended up with ITBS and couldn't run for the better part of a month, which was miserable. Now I do regular strength training with a focus on hips/glutes once a week in addition to other cross-training (more often if the side of my knee is twinging).

youngcaseyr

GemstoneofHeart wrote: »

I only run and walk and have for a year. I occasionally do body weight training or intervals but I just don't really like them. The best exercise is the one you do.

^^^This. I've lost weight and maintained weight (aside from pregnancy) for the last 6 years from ONLY running, with some yoga here and there, because it's what I enjoy and I'm happy with the results from it. So so so many people stick to one kind of work out because it's the one they'll do. Which is totally okay. It all depends on your goals. I've recently started incorporating bodyweight training into my regimen because my goals have changed, but if you only want to run and you are proactive about preventing injuries and maintaining your health while running, then I think you're fine with just running while you're training, and in the foreseeable future.

BigNorthernBear

Running gets so much BS bad press its shocking. If you enjoy it, do it, eventually you will want to supplement in order to improve faster or just to change things up. "bad" is relative to what you want to achieve.