Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Do you say something?
Replies
-
Only if I know them well or they are peddling absolute nonsense, like the guy in my diabetic community who wanted to eat nothing but baked potatoes without butter for a freaking year to lose weight and lower his blood sugar.
But even then when someone doubled down on the assertion that excess carbs make you fat, I didn't say anything else. She's a devout low carber and it wasn't worth the argument.
But the potatoes thing absolutely was worth it.4 -
Family, yes.. Close friends, yes.. friends here or say, at work? No. Not my business. I may post an article on the subject though. In fact, had to do this with my mom who came from the generation of destroyed metabolisms. She kept trying to convince me that that was my issue when I first started and couldn't lose weight.. and it's her excuse for not even trying. She refused to hear what I had to say on the subject. It didn't make sense that she was eating too many calories cause she barely ate.. (She ate BAD foods! Like "all I had today was one slice of Lasagna and some cheesecake!" "How big were the slices?" Then she'd avoid answering the question.. When I wormed it out of her finally and I did a quick mental calculation.. it was over 3k..)
So I posted articles. She never responded to them but diet hasn't come up again since.3 -
I have found that sometimes I enter my exercises and even I don't believe the numbers that it gives me, but I want to keep track of minutes walked,etc so I still enter it into my log as a reference in the future. I just started last week so I am hoping there are ways to modify this to make it more accurate.1
-
It has never come up.
If someone was doing something harmful or telling someone to do harmful things then I'd probably speak up and offer information. Otherwise unless they asked for my opinion or advice I probably would not say anything.
In a situation where a family member liked to say a lot of crazy things I didn't really say anything until they were spamming me with woo cures for cancer.
1 -
Oh, another response that I have used on occasion is, "Hm. I've never considered that." And I just leave off the second half of the statement, which is "... and I'm not going to consider it this time, either."
5 -
I have found that sometimes I enter my exercises and even I don't believe the numbers that it gives me, but I want to keep track of minutes walked,etc so I still enter it into my log as a reference in the future.
I do the same..... my exercise log show's me walking my dog 3 or 4 times a week. I don't have a dog
And it looks like I had one heck of a work out this past weekend ATV'ing. Now we did ride hard... my arms and legs were rubbery when I got off.... but it was more about having it in my history to look back on than the actual calories
since I basically ignore my exercise calories.
.
If a friend on MFP enters what I may consider skewed work out calories and then asks why they aren't losing weight as fast as they think they should.... I might ask if they are eating their exercise calories, otherwise it's not my business.
.
If someone mentions my weight loss and asks me how I've done it I tell them... CICO and that I'm still working on it cause it's amazing the people who think I'm a "Skinny Minnie" after loosing almost 60lbs.... I'm only half way there!
.
If a friend mentions something I feel is incorrect I ask them more about it.... and we usually have a good conversation.
1 -
It totally depends on who it is. If it's a friend or family member whom I care about and they're really off base, then I will try to educate them without seeming preachy. Mostly I'll say something like - "well that's interesting, but I do _______ and it works out well for me". If it's just a random acquaintance or MFP friend, then no. I've had people critique my food diary on here and it's annoying as h3ll! Although I've seen some crazy things I don't feel that it's my place. (Like my one MFP friend early on who logged one burger or sandwich a day and a 12 or 18 pack of Bud-light, every single day.)
He's not around anymore (on MFP that is). Hopefully he's still around somewhere!
I'm actually quite surprised that with the internet people are not better educated about nutrition. They can look up any other thing in the world, but how to eat healthy isn't one of them. I believe it's because they really don't want to know.4 -
Normally I would say...really I've lost weight and didn't have to do that...or that's a new one on me...unless it's someone I know really well...then I'll tell them I think it's total *kitten*.2
-
RaeBeeBaby wrote: »It totally depends on who it is. If it's a friend or family member whom I care about and they're really off base, then I will try to educate them without seeming preachy. Mostly I'll say something like - "well that's interesting, but I do _______ and it works out well for me". If it's just a random acquaintance or MFP friend, then no. I've had people critique my food diary on here and it's annoying as h3ll! Although I've seen some crazy things I don't feel that it's my place. (Like my one MFP friend early on who logged one burger or sandwich a day and a 12 or 18 pack of Bud-light, every single day.) He's not around anymore (on MFP that is). Hopefully he's still around somewhere!
I'm actually quite surprised that with the internet people are not better educated about nutrition. They can look up any other thing in the world, but how to eat healthy isn't one of them. I believe it's because they really don't want to know.
Honestly, I'm not surprised at all. Think of the garbage that comes up when you google "nutrition" or "weight loss".
I rarely correct anyone (even family members) unless they're asking for advice, complaining about not losing weight, or doing something actively harmful. From experience, trying to persuade people that they're doing it wrong never ends well.1 -
RaeBeeBaby wrote: »It totally depends on who it is. If it's a friend or family member whom I care about and they're really off base, then I will try to educate them without seeming preachy. Mostly I'll say something like - "well that's interesting, but I do _______ and it works out well for me". If it's just a random acquaintance or MFP friend, then no. I've had people critique my food diary on here and it's annoying as h3ll! Although I've seen some crazy things I don't feel that it's my place. (Like my one MFP friend early on who logged one burger or sandwich a day and a 12 or 18 pack of Bud-light, every single day.) He's not around anymore (on MFP that is). Hopefully he's still around somewhere!
I'm actually quite surprised that with the internet people are not better educated about nutrition. They can look up any other thing in the world, but how to eat healthy isn't one of them. I believe it's because they really don't want to know.
Honestly, I'm not surprised at all. Think of the garbage that comes up when you google "nutrition" or "weight loss".
I rarely correct anyone (even family members) unless they're asking for advice, complaining about not losing weight, or doing something actively harmful. From experience, trying to persuade people that they're doing it wrong never ends well.
Even when they do ask for advice, they don't always take it. A year ago my sister-in-law (whom I adore) went to the doctor and was told that not only was she morbidly obese, but had high BP, high cholesterol, severe edema and was pre-diabetic. She called me asking for help and I gave her a basic overview of good nutrition and recommended she start with some light exercise. I offered to help her shop, meal prep and go for walks, etc. I repeated that offer several times but she never took me up on it. Now a year has passed and another doctor visit. Nothing has changed except that now she is full blown diabetic and taking medication. <sigh>0 -
If they asked my advice then yes I would. Otherwise, I feel they are going to do what they are going to do and believe what they are going to believe.1
-
Only if they're also complaining about things not working. Most of the time it depends how well I know them. In real life I'll express an opposing opinion to someone I value, but if they are acquaintances I won't bother. One decent friend said something about water and detoxing and I opined on that, but a more acquaintance kinda friend said something about starting keto because she needed a drastic change and I said nothing at all.0
-
It depends on the conversation but if something is said in regards to me and my health I'll definitely say something. Lately I try to stay out of food and weight loss politics, it's like walking into a battlefield. Everyone I know has different perspectives on it and we always harshly disagree.1
-
I try not to. If people ask what i am doing, I will tell them. The issue that I have is that more often than not you can get conflicting views depending on where you research. Perfect example would be there was a debate yesterday whether protein is bad for the liver and 2 people brought up articles/studies that showed completely different evidence. It makes it really hard for people to know if what they are doing is the "right" thing to do. Unless what they are doing is posing an actual threat to their health, I say let people find their own path. It doesnt really matter how people lose weight or get more active, as long as they do. There is more than 1 way to be successful when trying to get healthy.0
-
Dang it, @Bekah7482! I was just going to make that point.
Someone in this thread made the comment about "not sure how there is confusion with the Internet" (I paraphrased, of course).
There are a few problems at play here (maybe more, just my take):
1. Conflicting information is sooooo easily found on just about anything and everything....which do you believe?
2. People - and I am not being ugly - are really lazy and just don't want to put forth much effort
3. People are ignorant (not saying stupid.....specifically saying ignorant)
So, with the Internet and Social Media it is really confusing as there is just so much information available. And, with all of the money to be made (sorry, just being honest) it is possible to find conflicting information on just about any topic of interest. Which do you believe?
And, in today's world (one in which everyone is so freaking busy) no one seems to have the time (read: to make the time) to research anything. Now, naturally "no one" is a gross generalization. Clearly, that is not true. But, "most people" is very very true. It seems - to me, anyway - that most people simply prefer the five-second sound bite instead of the rest of the story.
And, there are a lot of ignorant people out there. I include myself in that category (at times....shoot, whom am I kidding.....most times). They read it on the Internet so it must be true. Another way to put this....there is a strong lack of 'critical thinking' nowadays.
Here is the great thing about all of that: it is easily remedied!
Take my issue with squats (form) and dead lifts (again, form). I was ignorant as to how to properly do them. I did some research, looking for guidelines as to how to do these. There was a ton of information. A ton. Literally, I weighed it! LOL! So, I started doing them. I hurt myself. I recovered and then figured out what I did incorrectly. This time the search was a lot more focused. I found other things, other guides. My form got better. I then found the next problem with my form (read: injury). I healed. I found out what I was doing incorrectly. I finally found some really good guides and now my form is really good. On both.
So, I was clearly ignorant at first. There was so much information and so much seemingly conflicting information out there that I just started. Bad idea. And I found all the error in my ways (a few times). But, eventually we all find the right answer for ourselves.
So, my point.....people who are trying things might be clueless and misguided and ignorant. I would have LOVED it had someone in the gym said "Dude, what on Earth are you doing?". But no one did.
So, to answer the question - I absolutely would say something. Sure, I do not want to be "that guy" in the gym. Surely I do not want to be that guy. Or, "that guy" in the office. But, if you can approach someone with the right "spirit" then most people will listen. If just a little bit....but they will listen. I have had the most interesting conversations in the kitchen at work. And in the grocery store. And at the gas station. With complete strangers (at the grocery store and gas station) and with folks I see every day but don't necessarily know (in the kitchen at work....the 'kitchen' is common space in an office suite). Some just nod their head two or three times and I cut the conversation short.....and they go on their way and sometimes we are still standing there, in full conversation, 45 minutes later (shhh....don't tell my boss!).
Probably not a good idea for everyone, though. I just have an ability to speak with people.0 -
Do you say something if you have friends or people in general say things about weight loss you disagree with
nah. i have to say though that i don't have strong enough opinions about the whole topic in the first place, so my 'disagreement' or not is almost a moot point anyway. i sometimes feel like the agnostic in a room full of different religious sects, around here.
in general (not just weight loss) i try not to get into heated debates about things that people feel strongly about. i'll probably contradict a false statement of fact, regardless of what the theme is. but when it comes to physiology and all that, there don't seem to me to be enough facts for that to even apply. from my outsider's pov there are only opinions.0 -
I keep it simple. "Whatever works for you I'm behind. But no matter what you do, detox or low carb etc. none of it will be worth anything unless you eat fewer calories than you burn." No reason to break the illusion as long as the foundation is CICO. You'll get better results that way. "Yeah, keto! Great! Keep it up! But remember, you still need to eat less than you burn or else all that hard work won't mean a thing..."
"Yeah girl, get on that cleanse! Just remember... you have to etc. etc. etc."
Only intervene beyond that if they are saying something that is genuinely going to hurt them.1 -
I generally don't. Just not my style unless they ask.0
-
I used to but it got exhausting trying to explain basic science and anatomy to people who would rather believe in magic pills than put in the actual effort.
If somebody asks a specific question I still try to reply in a helpful way, especially new vegetarians and vegans who aren't sure what to eat.1 -
If someone seems to be doing something harmful I will speak up. For example, certain fat burners, or "supplements" and the like, starving themselves or getting physical activity in a way that could lead to injury or illness. Otherwise I stick to the "don't start nothin' won't be nothin" rule. If I absolutely cannot bear to see their shenanigans in my news feed I either hide the stuff from my feed or remove them.0
-
If someone seems to be doing something harmful I will speak up. For example, certain fat burners, or "supplements" and the like, starving themselves or getting physical activity in a way that could lead to injury or illness. Otherwise I stick to the "don't start nothin' won't be nothin" rule. If I absolutely cannot bear to see their shenanigans in my news feed I either hide the stuff from my feed or remove them.
even at this point I am not saying anything...these people are adults and I find that regardless of our concern they don't want to hear it...even when asked they don't really want to hear it.0 -
If someone seems to be doing something harmful I will speak up. For example, certain fat burners, or "supplements" and the like, starving themselves or getting physical activity in a way that could lead to injury or illness. Otherwise I stick to the "don't start nothin' won't be nothin" rule. If I absolutely cannot bear to see their shenanigans in my news feed I either hide the stuff from my feed or remove them.
even at this point I am not saying anything...these people are adults and I find that regardless of our concern they don't want to hear it...even when asked they don't really want to hear it.
I can understand that. Lord knows I have seen enough similar attitudes from people. Be it wreckless weightloss or other self destruction. The deaf will never hear.2
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions