Frustrated
A_Gaddini
Posts: 5 Member
I also do WW on line as well as this. I have gained 2.5 lbs within last 2 weeks. Scale won't budge. I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day but also exercise but don't eat all those extra from workouts. I'm on thyroid meds due to thyroid removal. I don't know why weight won't budge. Tempted to do a detox to jumpstart! Any suggestions
0
Replies
-
Most people suggest that you measure inches, not count lbs on a scale. Fat takes more room then muscle. So if you are working out at all then perhaps a muscles is increasing, you will weigh the same, but your inches will be smaller.
1lb of fat = 1lb of muscle (The muscle is just denser.)
Just a tip
0 -
I think the clue here is your statement "I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day". If you were truly eating only 1200 calories a day, you would be losing weight. Are you measuring/weighing all food and tracking everything you are eating and drinking each day?
2 -
Most people suggest that you measure inches, not count lbs on a scale. Fat takes more room then muscle. So if you are working out at all then perhaps a muscles is increasing, you will weigh the same, but your inches will be smaller.
1lb of fat = 1lb of muscle (The muscle is just denser.)
Just a tip
THIS ISN'T TRUE. You can't create muscle out of nothing (aka a calorie deficit) and you can't transform fat cells into muscle cells. You can only gain muscle on a calorie surplus while working on your muscles through strength training.I also do WW on line as well as this. I have gained 2.5 lbs within last 2 weeks. Scale won't budge. I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day but also exercise but don't eat all those extra from workouts. I'm on thyroid meds due to thyroid removal. I don't know why weight won't budge. Tempted to do a detox to jumpstart! Any suggestions
within last 2 weeks Your weight will fluctuate. My weight can fluctuate up to 5 lbs within a week.
probably almost 1200 calories a day If you aren't using a food scale, your portions are probably more than you realize.
detox to jumpstart Your body isn't toxic. There's no such thing as a jumpstart.3 -
Most people suggest that you measure inches, not count lbs on a scale. Fat takes more room then muscle. So if you are working out at all then perhaps a muscles is increasing, you will weigh the same, but your inches will be smaller.
1lb of fat = 1lb of muscle (The muscle is just denser.)
Just a tip
THIS ISN'T TRUE. You can't create muscle out of nothing (aka a calorie deficit) and you can't transform fat cells into muscle cells. You can only gain muscle on a calorie surplus while working on your muscles through strength training.I also do WW on line as well as this. I have gained 2.5 lbs within last 2 weeks. Scale won't budge. I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day but also exercise but don't eat all those extra from workouts. I'm on thyroid meds due to thyroid removal. I don't know why weight won't budge. Tempted to do a detox to jumpstart! Any suggestions
within last 2 weeks Your weight will fluctuate. My weight can fluctuate up to 5 lbs within a week.
probably almost 1200 calories a day If you aren't using a food scale, your portions are probably more than you realize.
detox to jumpstart Your body isn't toxic. There's no such thing as a jumpstart.
There is something to the concept of body re-composition. Some studies show it is possible to gain muscle while burning fat and being on a slight deficit. its a tricky animal it wrestle.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Most people suggest that you measure inches, not count lbs on a scale. Fat takes more room then muscle. So if you are working out at all then perhaps a muscles is increasing, you will weigh the same, but your inches will be smaller.
1lb of fat = 1lb of muscle (The muscle is just denser.)
Just a tip
THIS ISN'T TRUE. You can't create muscle out of nothing (aka a calorie deficit) and you can't transform fat cells into muscle cells. You can only gain muscle on a calorie surplus while working on your muscles through strength training.I also do WW on line as well as this. I have gained 2.5 lbs within last 2 weeks. Scale won't budge. I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day but also exercise but don't eat all those extra from workouts. I'm on thyroid meds due to thyroid removal. I don't know why weight won't budge. Tempted to do a detox to jumpstart! Any suggestions
within last 2 weeks Your weight will fluctuate. My weight can fluctuate up to 5 lbs within a week.
probably almost 1200 calories a day If you aren't using a food scale, your portions are probably more than you realize.
detox to jumpstart Your body isn't toxic. There's no such thing as a jumpstart.
There is something to the concept of body re-composition. Some studies show it is possible to gain muscle while burning fat and being on a slight deficit. its a tricky animal it wrestle.
Show me the study. To my knowledge, there is no way to create muscle mass while in a calorie deficit. There are many ways to recomp. Some people eat maintenance and lift HEAVY. As a result, they maintain more of their existing muscle mass while burning fat. Boom, recomp. They will also feel stronger, but they will not have bigger physical muscles. Where would the mass come from? This method is most effective for people who are larger who have a lot of fat to lose but may have substantial muscles from carrying around their large bodies. Another way to do a recomp is with cutting and bulking cycles. Bulk (surplus of calories) while lifting heavy, then cut (calorie deficit) while lifting heavy.
None of what she is describing is possibly growing her muscles.0 -
Most people suggest that you measure inches, not count lbs on a scale. Fat takes more room then muscle. So if you are working out at all then perhaps a muscles is increasing, you will weigh the same, but your inches will be smaller.
1lb of fat = 1lb of muscle (The muscle is just denser.)
Just a tip
THIS ISN'T TRUE. You can't create muscle out of nothing (aka a calorie deficit) and you can't transform fat cells into muscle cells. You can only gain muscle on a calorie surplus while working on your muscles through strength training.I also do WW on line as well as this. I have gained 2.5 lbs within last 2 weeks. Scale won't budge. I eat probably almost 1200 calories a day but also exercise but don't eat all those extra from workouts. I'm on thyroid meds due to thyroid removal. I don't know why weight won't budge. Tempted to do a detox to jumpstart! Any suggestions
within last 2 weeks Your weight will fluctuate. My weight can fluctuate up to 5 lbs within a week.
probably almost 1200 calories a day If you aren't using a food scale, your portions are probably more than you realize.
detox to jumpstart Your body isn't toxic. There's no such thing as a jumpstart.
There is something to the concept of body re-composition. Some studies show it is possible to gain muscle while burning fat and being on a slight deficit. its a tricky animal it wrestle.
Show me the study. To my knowledge, there is no way to create muscle mass while in a calorie deficit. There are many ways to recomp. Some people eat maintenance and lift HEAVY. As a result, they maintain more of their existing muscle mass while burning fat. Boom, recomp. They will also feel stronger, but they will not have bigger physical muscles. Where would the mass come from? This method is most effective for people who are larger who have a lot of fat to lose but may have substantial muscles from carrying around their large bodies. Another way to do a recomp is with cutting and bulking cycles. Bulk (surplus of calories) while lifting heavy, then cut (calorie deficit) while lifting heavy.
None of what she is describing is possibly growing her muscles.
I'm not going to argue this point, nor am i going to research the topic to convince you. clearly you are right. but this is an example of what i'm referring too. take it for what its worth.
best wishes. http://scoobysworkshop.com/gain-muscle-lose-fat/ perhaps ......just perhaps...its possible. hmmm0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 433 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.9K MyFitnessPal Information
- 15 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.7K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions