Biochemistry answers for common weight loss questions: Sodium. (warning, long and nerdy)
Replies
-
jasondjulian wrote: »newheavensearth wrote: »I remember when my parents went on a low sodium diet for hypertension. They cut out huge types of processed foods and of course lost weight (less food). So they chalked up their weight problems to sodium. When they discovered low or no sodium substitutes they added the foods back in and gained most, if not all of the weight back. But they still believe that sodium causes obesity and refuse to believe excess food intake has anything to do with it. Their doctor only told them to watch the salt, nothing else.
My wife's grandmother's doctor told her the same, watch the salt- so she pretty much cut it out completely. Put herself in the hospital a few weeks later hooked up to IV electrolytes... too little salt intake and she was confused, dazes, lethargic and cognitively impaired.
As with all things, it is about balance and moderation.
I fear that the health establishment dumbs down advice to the point where people can draw mistaken conclusions from what they are being told like in your example. Doctor notices a persons blood pressure is through the roof, measures sodium levels and finds them to be very high. Doctor can either spend 30 minutes explaining to patient the effects of sodium on the body or they could just spend 30 seconds telling the patient to avoid sodium because for the immediate future that would benefit them. Practically speaking they are going to go with option 2. I get it with Doctors but what annoys me is if you try to look up information on sodium on websites that should be credible like the american heart association they end up just telling you to avoid sodium and they don't really elaborate either. There I don't think they are saving time I think they are just dumbing it down because they figure the general public won't get it or will ignore it if they complicate it with information so they just hash tag it into a tweetable "avoid sodium" and call it a day.2 -
I think they are also going with normal response to advice given - semi-followed. If that much.
So by saying cut it out - they are expecting vast majority to just watch it a little - like eating only half that bag of chips watching TV, or small fries with hamburger.
They probably rarely expect anyone to really get serious about it and lower it that much.
But that's a failure knowing your patient then - so bigger issue highlighted I think.
Which wouldn't surprise me either, if you give a range, that now means needing to log things, and that is successful for how long?
And even if you do a few days to get an idea, the mere act of logging changes decisions during that time, which may change when logging stops.1 -
I think they are also going with normal response to advice given - semi-followed. If that much.
So by saying cut it out - they are expecting vast majority to just watch it a little - like eating only half that bag of chips watching TV, or small fries with hamburger.
They probably rarely expect anyone to really get serious about it and lower it that much.
But that's a failure knowing your patient then - so bigger issue highlighted I think.
Which wouldn't surprise me either, if you give a range, that now means needing to log things, and that is successful for how long?
And even if you do a few days to get an idea, the mere act of logging changes decisions during that time, which may change when logging stops.
Well its always a balance between getting the message out to the widest amount of people to do the most good versus the damage it might cause a few people who take the advice blindly even though it doesn't apply to them and may do them more harm than good.
I just feel like the actual information should be more easily accessed by those who wish to seek it out.0 -
Bumping this because it deserves to be seen
5 -
rabbit trail warning! Tuberculosis!
I work in records myself and sometimes I end up diving deep in to history. I once had to arrange for the disposal of abandoned documents from a tuberculosis sanatorium. Which led me to read up about the history of this disease. Which led me to understand the whole dynamics of contagion, quarantine, and the absolute terror the old diseases had over society.
From what I read the best "treatment" for tuberculosis before antibiotics was a 3,000 calorie a day diet. Forget the ice baths and fresh air. What worked best was to feed the patient enough calories to allow the body to naturally fight off the disease. They engendered a few cures that way. A few.
Modern medicine; what a miracle.
cause i love rabbit trails! I was watching an old Audrey Hepburn movie the other week (Nun's Story) and she ends up in the Congo as a nurse and develops Tb...the treatment the doctor gives her is basically 6-12 months rest, with lots of good food in a loft type room where she can see the sun/trees1 -
deannalfisher wrote: »rabbit trail warning! Tuberculosis!
I work in records myself and sometimes I end up diving deep in to history. I once had to arrange for the disposal of abandoned documents from a tuberculosis sanatorium. Which led me to read up about the history of this disease. Which led me to understand the whole dynamics of contagion, quarantine, and the absolute terror the old diseases had over society.
From what I read the best "treatment" for tuberculosis before antibiotics was a 3,000 calorie a day diet. Forget the ice baths and fresh air. What worked best was to feed the patient enough calories to allow the body to naturally fight off the disease. They engendered a few cures that way. A few.
Modern medicine; what a miracle.
cause i love rabbit trails! I was watching an old Audrey Hepburn movie the other week (Nun's Story) and she ends up in the Congo as a nurse and develops Tb...the treatment the doctor gives her is basically 6-12 months rest, with lots of good food in a loft type room where she can see the sun/trees
Yeah before the development of anti-mycobacterial antibiotics the "treatment" for TB was rest and plenty of food and sun. Basically because there wasn't an actual treatment and your immune system, if healthy, can often contain the disease (although you will never be rid of it that way). There were massive treatment facilities called sanitariums dedicated to this purpose.
With the development of antibiotics that is no longer the treatment, but the current antibiotic regime for TB sucks and there is a problem with resistance as well. Current treatment for drug sensitive TB is 4 drugs daily for 3 months followed by 2 of those 4 drugs daily for an additional 3 months. Some of those drugs are a bit toxic and can give you issues such as nausea. Not surprisingly it is difficult to get patients to stick with a 6 month antibiotic course especially when those antibiotics make them feel fatigue and illness in and of themselves. So there has been a rise in MDR (multidrug resistant) and XDR (extremely drug resistant) TB that requires 1-2 years of treatment with a larger cocktail daily including injectables. Treatment cost for XDR TB is something like $500k and outcomes aren't great.
Need new drugs and an effective vaccine for treatment pretty desperately. People in the developed world seem to view TB as a disease from a bygone era but the truth is TB kills more people than any other infectious disease to this day with millions of deaths a year and it has a huge base of infection with about 2 billion people infected worldwide.
....and this has nothing to do with sodium 5 -
Really interesting and informative thread. Thank you! 0
-
-
Superb thread! More please!0
-
-
Aaron_K123 wrote: »
I like the idea of a thread explaining what actually happens to fat cells when you lose weight.
Also what calories actually are and how they work.
(I mean, I’ve read up about both, but you have a way of explaining things that are scientific and easy to understand!)1 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »
Did you end up doing the "where weight actually goes" one? I *think* I remember seeing that but I'm not sure if it was just you answering the thread asking about it or if it was a stand alone.1 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »
Did you end up doing the "where weight actually goes" one? I *think* I remember seeing that but I'm not sure if it was just you answering the thread asking about it or if it was a stand alone.
Second on this. I know it's expiration based, but I've never dug into the science beyond that.0 -
@Aaron_K123 : Great information! I appreciate the detail...or maybe miss the nerd-speak from college bio-chem? LOL! Either way, thanks!1
-
Aaron_K123 wrote: »
Did you end up doing the "where weight actually goes" one? I *think* I remember seeing that but I'm not sure if it was just you answering the thread asking about it or if it was a stand alone.
Gave it a shot:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10650701/biochemistry-answers-to-weight-loss-questions-where-does-the-weight-go/p1?new=14 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »So lately I've seen a lot of posts about sudden weight gain or sudden weight loss and what does it mean or something about whether or not I should care about sodium in my diet. There seems to be a lot of misunderstanding or misinformation out there. This is an attempt to address what is actually going on in your body when you take in sodium (or other ions) which I think if understood will help answer any questions one might have about sodium intake. I realize this sort of explanation is definitely not for everyone, but for those who would like to know I thought I'd try to explain. I'm not going to try to cover everything sodium does, just the main thing I think people care about. If I misrepresent something in here please do provide a correction in the comments.
Why is Sodium important, what does it do to our body?
When people talk about sodium they are typically talking about sodium chloride or table salt, NaCl. In water NaCl dissociates into Na+ and Cl+, ions if you are a chemist…or electrolytes if you are a wellness blogger. Ions in solution are kept at a constant concentration by diffusion. If you had two 1 liter pools of water separated by a barrier that was permeable to ions like sodium but not water and you put 10 grams of salt in one side and 20 grams of salt in the other the sodium ions would migrate through the barrier from the high concentration to the low concentration until there was 15 grams per liter on both sides. The amount of water on either side would remain the same at 1 liter. If the barrier was instead permeable to water but not sodium what would happen is that water would transfer from the low sodium side to the high sodium side until there was the same amount of sodium per unit water on both sides thus coming to equilibrium just like in the first example. What this effectively would mean though is that one side would lose water down to 0.66 liters and the other side would gain water to 1.33 liters so that on both sides there were 15 grams per liter of ions on both sides. Same result, different thing traveling between the barrier.
Cells in your body are like the latter example, they are permeable to water but impermeable to ions. If the ion or dissolved solute concentration is the same outside and inside the cell then the solutions are isotonic and nothing happens. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much higher than inside the cell (hypertonic) the water will get sucked out of the cell to equalize the concentrations. That is bad. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much lower than inside the cell (hypotonic) then water will rush into the cell making it swell until potentially it pops and kills the cell. Which is really bad. This is why if you need hydration in a hospital they hook you up to a saline IV (that has salt at a concentration similar to your blood) rather than pure water.
Your cells naturally have a specific ion concentration within them that allows them to carry out the functions necessary for life. One of the critical regulatory parts of your body is to make sure that the liquid outside of your cells has the same concentration of ions as what is inside to avoid water either rushing into or out of cells. This is called ion homeostasis.
Okay with all that said what does it mean for you and what does it mean when you take in sodium in the form of salt. Basically it means your body needs to keep the sodium levels in your blood in equilibrium with that of your cells. If the amount of sodium you take in plus the amount of water you take in adds up to a solution that has a higher concentration of sodium than your blood your body will do what it can to pull water into your bloodstream to dilute the concentration so that it returns to equilibrium. When you drink more water your body will try to hold onto it to help lower the overall concentration of sodium. Since there is only so much physical room in your blood vessels the result is your blood pressure goes up…more water, same space, more pressure. Your bodyweight will also increase with the retained water.
If instead you take in more water and less sodium leading to a concentration that is overall lower than what is present in your blood your body will respond by flushing water out of your system to raise the concentration of ions within your blood back to equilibrium. This results in water leaving your blood and there being less volume of water in your vessels causing a drop in blood pressure. Your body flushing the water out will also drop your overall body weight.
Your body has a lot of water to work with, much of your bodyweight is water….so it is very good at keeping this equilibrium. Unless your consumption of sodium is extreme (either extremely low or extremely high) over a long period of time it is probably not something you really need to worry about. If you are concerned you can always have your sodium levels checked by a doctor. An easier way to have some idea of where you are at is the color of your urine. If you have a lot of sodium intake relative to water consumption your body is likely holding onto the water and your urine will appear much darker. If on the other hand you are drinking a lot of water and taking in very little sodium your body is likely trying to flush out the water as fast as it can and your urine will appear almost the color of water. A light straw colored urine is what to expect if you are close to balanced.
One thing to keep in mind is it is not how much sodium you take in it is how much sodium relative to how much water you take in that actually matters. What that means is high sodium foods (which have very little water in them) tend to raise your sodium levels while beverages that contain sodium (like soda or milk) tend to overall lower your sodium levels because they have a lot more water in them than they do sodium. Your blood and the contents of your cells are a lot “saltier” than a can of soda is so drinking soda is if anything going to lower the concentration of sodium in your blood. If you don’t believe that try drinking an IV saline solution.
Fad diets of the “Lose weight in just two weeks!” variety tend to “work” by having you do things that effectively drop your sodium concentration enough that your body responds by flushing water out of your system. They will do something like have you switch to a diet of fruit and veg or other low sodium foods while drinking lots and lots of water (to dilute sodium). The end result is that your body weight goes down rapidly as your body expels the water not only that you took in but also just the water retained naturally in your body. But you haven’t lost fat, you’ve just put yourself into a condition where your body is desperately trying to return the ion concentration in your blood into equilibrium which is not a particularly healthy state. You won’t be able to sustain this, eventually you will need to take in sodium and when you do your body will retain water and you will put the weight back on.
Honestly unless you have a heart condition or high blood pressure at a level where your doctor has specifically told you to monitor and limit your sodium intake you probably shouldn’t care about sodium in your diet. A normal diet is going to be close enough in sodium and water that your body is perfectly capable of sorting it out and you can just pay attention to the color of your urine. If it is too dark then drink more water. If it is too light then either drink less water or add more salt into your diet. Sodium and hydration are two sides of the same coin. Lots of health advice websites tout lowering sodium or drinking more water because they assume the average person looking to lose weight is consuming too much sodium relative to the amount of water they are taking in...but that isn't necessarily true.
MFP defaults to setting a sodium target for you to “hit” that turns red if you go over it. I think this is unfortunate that it is a default setting and you’d be better off turning that particular feature off. If during the course of your diet your weight suddenly goes up 3 pounds or suddenly drops three pounds in the course of a day most likely this is related to how much sodium/water you have taken in and not anything to do with fat. That sort of thing is safe to ignore, it has nothing to do with fat loss or your health...its normal.
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.5 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »So lately I've seen a lot of posts about sudden weight gain or sudden weight loss and what does it mean or something about whether or not I should care about sodium in my diet. There seems to be a lot of misunderstanding or misinformation out there. This is an attempt to address what is actually going on in your body when you take in sodium (or other ions) which I think if understood will help answer any questions one might have about sodium intake. I realize this sort of explanation is definitely not for everyone, but for those who would like to know I thought I'd try to explain. I'm not going to try to cover everything sodium does, just the main thing I think people care about. If I misrepresent something in here please do provide a correction in the comments.
Why is Sodium important, what does it do to our body?
When people talk about sodium they are typically talking about sodium chloride or table salt, NaCl. In water NaCl dissociates into Na+ and Cl+, ions if you are a chemist…or electrolytes if you are a wellness blogger. Ions in solution are kept at a constant concentration by diffusion. If you had two 1 liter pools of water separated by a barrier that was permeable to ions like sodium but not water and you put 10 grams of salt in one side and 20 grams of salt in the other the sodium ions would migrate through the barrier from the high concentration to the low concentration until there was 15 grams per liter on both sides. The amount of water on either side would remain the same at 1 liter. If the barrier was instead permeable to water but not sodium what would happen is that water would transfer from the low sodium side to the high sodium side until there was the same amount of sodium per unit water on both sides thus coming to equilibrium just like in the first example. What this effectively would mean though is that one side would lose water down to 0.66 liters and the other side would gain water to 1.33 liters so that on both sides there were 15 grams per liter of ions on both sides. Same result, different thing traveling between the barrier.
Cells in your body are like the latter example, they are permeable to water but impermeable to ions. If the ion or dissolved solute concentration is the same outside and inside the cell then the solutions are isotonic and nothing happens. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much higher than inside the cell (hypertonic) the water will get sucked out of the cell to equalize the concentrations. That is bad. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much lower than inside the cell (hypotonic) then water will rush into the cell making it swell until potentially it pops and kills the cell. Which is really bad. This is why if you need hydration in a hospital they hook you up to a saline IV (that has salt at a concentration similar to your blood) rather than pure water.
Your cells naturally have a specific ion concentration within them that allows them to carry out the functions necessary for life. One of the critical regulatory parts of your body is to make sure that the liquid outside of your cells has the same concentration of ions as what is inside to avoid water either rushing into or out of cells. This is called ion homeostasis.
Okay with all that said what does it mean for you and what does it mean when you take in sodium in the form of salt. Basically it means your body needs to keep the sodium levels in your blood in equilibrium with that of your cells. If the amount of sodium you take in plus the amount of water you take in adds up to a solution that has a higher concentration of sodium than your blood your body will do what it can to pull water into your bloodstream to dilute the concentration so that it returns to equilibrium. When you drink more water your body will try to hold onto it to help lower the overall concentration of sodium. Since there is only so much physical room in your blood vessels the result is your blood pressure goes up…more water, same space, more pressure. Your bodyweight will also increase with the retained water.
If instead you take in more water and less sodium leading to a concentration that is overall lower than what is present in your blood your body will respond by flushing water out of your system to raise the concentration of ions within your blood back to equilibrium. This results in water leaving your blood and there being less volume of water in your vessels causing a drop in blood pressure. Your body flushing the water out will also drop your overall body weight.
Your body has a lot of water to work with, much of your bodyweight is water….so it is very good at keeping this equilibrium. Unless your consumption of sodium is extreme (either extremely low or extremely high) over a long period of time it is probably not something you really need to worry about. If you are concerned you can always have your sodium levels checked by a doctor. An easier way to have some idea of where you are at is the color of your urine. If you have a lot of sodium intake relative to water consumption your body is likely holding onto the water and your urine will appear much darker. If on the other hand you are drinking a lot of water and taking in very little sodium your body is likely trying to flush out the water as fast as it can and your urine will appear almost the color of water. A light straw colored urine is what to expect if you are close to balanced.
One thing to keep in mind is it is not how much sodium you take in it is how much sodium relative to how much water you take in that actually matters. What that means is high sodium foods (which have very little water in them) tend to raise your sodium levels while beverages that contain sodium (like soda or milk) tend to overall lower your sodium levels because they have a lot more water in them than they do sodium. Your blood and the contents of your cells are a lot “saltier” than a can of soda is so drinking soda is if anything going to lower the concentration of sodium in your blood. If you don’t believe that try drinking an IV saline solution.
Fad diets of the “Lose weight in just two weeks!” variety tend to “work” by having you do things that effectively drop your sodium concentration enough that your body responds by flushing water out of your system. They will do something like have you switch to a diet of fruit and veg or other low sodium foods while drinking lots and lots of water (to dilute sodium). The end result is that your body weight goes down rapidly as your body expels the water not only that you took in but also just the water retained naturally in your body. But you haven’t lost fat, you’ve just put yourself into a condition where your body is desperately trying to return the ion concentration in your blood into equilibrium which is not a particularly healthy state. You won’t be able to sustain this, eventually you will need to take in sodium and when you do your body will retain water and you will put the weight back on.
Honestly unless you have a heart condition or high blood pressure at a level where your doctor has specifically told you to monitor and limit your sodium intake you probably shouldn’t care about sodium in your diet. A normal diet is going to be close enough in sodium and water that your body is perfectly capable of sorting it out and you can just pay attention to the color of your urine. If it is too dark then drink more water. If it is too light then either drink less water or add more salt into your diet. Sodium and hydration are two sides of the same coin. Lots of health advice websites tout lowering sodium or drinking more water because they assume the average person looking to lose weight is consuming too much sodium relative to the amount of water they are taking in...but that isn't necessarily true.
MFP defaults to setting a sodium target for you to “hit” that turns red if you go over it. I think this is unfortunate that it is a default setting and you’d be better off turning that particular feature off. If during the course of your diet your weight suddenly goes up 3 pounds or suddenly drops three pounds in the course of a day most likely this is related to how much sodium/water you have taken in and not anything to do with fat. That sort of thing is safe to ignore, it has nothing to do with fat loss or your health...its normal.
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.
It reads very easy to me, with paragraph breaks in the appropriate places.
Maybe Aaron could do some science haiku as a change of pace.
4 -
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.
copy/paste into your favorite text editor and add your paragraph breaks to make it easier to read.
You can randomly pick where - because they are in correct places right now.
Those aren't long actually, shorter than science text book.
What's great about written word though - can reread when needed.
And wait for appropriate time to focus on it.4 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »So lately I've seen a lot of posts about sudden weight gain or sudden weight loss and what does it mean or something about whether or not I should care about sodium in my diet. There seems to be a lot of misunderstanding or misinformation out there. This is an attempt to address what is actually going on in your body when you take in sodium (or other ions) which I think if understood will help answer any questions one might have about sodium intake. I realize this sort of explanation is definitely not for everyone, but for those who would like to know I thought I'd try to explain. I'm not going to try to cover everything sodium does, just the main thing I think people care about. If I misrepresent something in here please do provide a correction in the comments.
Why is Sodium important, what does it do to our body?
When people talk about sodium they are typically talking about sodium chloride or table salt, NaCl. In water NaCl dissociates into Na+ and Cl+, ions if you are a chemist…or electrolytes if you are a wellness blogger. Ions in solution are kept at a constant concentration by diffusion. If you had two 1 liter pools of water separated by a barrier that was permeable to ions like sodium but not water and you put 10 grams of salt in one side and 20 grams of salt in the other the sodium ions would migrate through the barrier from the high concentration to the low concentration until there was 15 grams per liter on both sides. The amount of water on either side would remain the same at 1 liter. If the barrier was instead permeable to water but not sodium what would happen is that water would transfer from the low sodium side to the high sodium side until there was the same amount of sodium per unit water on both sides thus coming to equilibrium just like in the first example. What this effectively would mean though is that one side would lose water down to 0.66 liters and the other side would gain water to 1.33 liters so that on both sides there were 15 grams per liter of ions on both sides. Same result, different thing traveling between the barrier.
Cells in your body are like the latter example, they are permeable to water but impermeable to ions. If the ion or dissolved solute concentration is the same outside and inside the cell then the solutions are isotonic and nothing happens. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much higher than inside the cell (hypertonic) the water will get sucked out of the cell to equalize the concentrations. That is bad. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much lower than inside the cell (hypotonic) then water will rush into the cell making it swell until potentially it pops and kills the cell. Which is really bad. This is why if you need hydration in a hospital they hook you up to a saline IV (that has salt at a concentration similar to your blood) rather than pure water.
Your cells naturally have a specific ion concentration within them that allows them to carry out the functions necessary for life. One of the critical regulatory parts of your body is to make sure that the liquid outside of your cells has the same concentration of ions as what is inside to avoid water either rushing into or out of cells. This is called ion homeostasis.
Okay with all that said what does it mean for you and what does it mean when you take in sodium in the form of salt. Basically it means your body needs to keep the sodium levels in your blood in equilibrium with that of your cells. If the amount of sodium you take in plus the amount of water you take in adds up to a solution that has a higher concentration of sodium than your blood your body will do what it can to pull water into your bloodstream to dilute the concentration so that it returns to equilibrium. When you drink more water your body will try to hold onto it to help lower the overall concentration of sodium. Since there is only so much physical room in your blood vessels the result is your blood pressure goes up…more water, same space, more pressure. Your bodyweight will also increase with the retained water.
If instead you take in more water and less sodium leading to a concentration that is overall lower than what is present in your blood your body will respond by flushing water out of your system to raise the concentration of ions within your blood back to equilibrium. This results in water leaving your blood and there being less volume of water in your vessels causing a drop in blood pressure. Your body flushing the water out will also drop your overall body weight.
Your body has a lot of water to work with, much of your bodyweight is water….so it is very good at keeping this equilibrium. Unless your consumption of sodium is extreme (either extremely low or extremely high) over a long period of time it is probably not something you really need to worry about. If you are concerned you can always have your sodium levels checked by a doctor. An easier way to have some idea of where you are at is the color of your urine. If you have a lot of sodium intake relative to water consumption your body is likely holding onto the water and your urine will appear much darker. If on the other hand you are drinking a lot of water and taking in very little sodium your body is likely trying to flush out the water as fast as it can and your urine will appear almost the color of water. A light straw colored urine is what to expect if you are close to balanced.
One thing to keep in mind is it is not how much sodium you take in it is how much sodium relative to how much water you take in that actually matters. What that means is high sodium foods (which have very little water in them) tend to raise your sodium levels while beverages that contain sodium (like soda or milk) tend to overall lower your sodium levels because they have a lot more water in them than they do sodium. Your blood and the contents of your cells are a lot “saltier” than a can of soda is so drinking soda is if anything going to lower the concentration of sodium in your blood. If you don’t believe that try drinking an IV saline solution.
Fad diets of the “Lose weight in just two weeks!” variety tend to “work” by having you do things that effectively drop your sodium concentration enough that your body responds by flushing water out of your system. They will do something like have you switch to a diet of fruit and veg or other low sodium foods while drinking lots and lots of water (to dilute sodium). The end result is that your body weight goes down rapidly as your body expels the water not only that you took in but also just the water retained naturally in your body. But you haven’t lost fat, you’ve just put yourself into a condition where your body is desperately trying to return the ion concentration in your blood into equilibrium which is not a particularly healthy state. You won’t be able to sustain this, eventually you will need to take in sodium and when you do your body will retain water and you will put the weight back on.
Honestly unless you have a heart condition or high blood pressure at a level where your doctor has specifically told you to monitor and limit your sodium intake you probably shouldn’t care about sodium in your diet. A normal diet is going to be close enough in sodium and water that your body is perfectly capable of sorting it out and you can just pay attention to the color of your urine. If it is too dark then drink more water. If it is too light then either drink less water or add more salt into your diet. Sodium and hydration are two sides of the same coin. Lots of health advice websites tout lowering sodium or drinking more water because they assume the average person looking to lose weight is consuming too much sodium relative to the amount of water they are taking in...but that isn't necessarily true.
MFP defaults to setting a sodium target for you to “hit” that turns red if you go over it. I think this is unfortunate that it is a default setting and you’d be better off turning that particular feature off. If during the course of your diet your weight suddenly goes up 3 pounds or suddenly drops three pounds in the course of a day most likely this is related to how much sodium/water you have taken in and not anything to do with fat. That sort of thing is safe to ignore, it has nothing to do with fat loss or your health...its normal.
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.
3-7 sentences is not too many sentences per paragraph. If you're on the app, try switching to desktop, @houndgal. If that's still a struggle, copy into a word document and divide as you see fit/for ease of legibility.3 -
[/quote]
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.[/quote]
The paragraphs are structured correctly. It may just be an attention span problem. You see a long post and decide it's just too long to read.3 -
musicfan68 wrote: »The paragraphs are structured correctly. It may just be an attention span problem. You see a long post and decide it's just too long to read.
I think people have gotten too used to Twitter/Instagram/text messages and regard them as the standard rather than properly written/punctuated/formatted composition. Anything more than 160 characters (and not written in txtspk) becomes tl;dr for some.1 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »So lately I've seen a lot of posts about sudden weight gain or sudden weight loss and what does it mean or something about whether or not I should care about sodium in my diet. There seems to be a lot of misunderstanding or misinformation out there. This is an attempt to address what is actually going on in your body when you take in sodium (or other ions) which I think if understood will help answer any questions one might have about sodium intake. I realize this sort of explanation is definitely not for everyone, but for those who would like to know I thought I'd try to explain. I'm not going to try to cover everything sodium does, just the main thing I think people care about. If I misrepresent something in here please do provide a correction in the comments.
Why is Sodium important, what does it do to our body?
When people talk about sodium they are typically talking about sodium chloride or table salt, NaCl. In water NaCl dissociates into Na+ and Cl+, ions if you are a chemist…or electrolytes if you are a wellness blogger. Ions in solution are kept at a constant concentration by diffusion. If you had two 1 liter pools of water separated by a barrier that was permeable to ions like sodium but not water and you put 10 grams of salt in one side and 20 grams of salt in the other the sodium ions would migrate through the barrier from the high concentration to the low concentration until there was 15 grams per liter on both sides. The amount of water on either side would remain the same at 1 liter. If the barrier was instead permeable to water but not sodium what would happen is that water would transfer from the low sodium side to the high sodium side until there was the same amount of sodium per unit water on both sides thus coming to equilibrium just like in the first example. What this effectively would mean though is that one side would lose water down to 0.66 liters and the other side would gain water to 1.33 liters so that on both sides there were 15 grams per liter of ions on both sides. Same result, different thing traveling between the barrier.
Cells in your body are like the latter example, they are permeable to water but impermeable to ions. If the ion or dissolved solute concentration is the same outside and inside the cell then the solutions are isotonic and nothing happens. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much higher than inside the cell (hypertonic) the water will get sucked out of the cell to equalize the concentrations. That is bad. If the ion concentration outside the cell is much lower than inside the cell (hypotonic) then water will rush into the cell making it swell until potentially it pops and kills the cell. Which is really bad. This is why if you need hydration in a hospital they hook you up to a saline IV (that has salt at a concentration similar to your blood) rather than pure water.
Your cells naturally have a specific ion concentration within them that allows them to carry out the functions necessary for life. One of the critical regulatory parts of your body is to make sure that the liquid outside of your cells has the same concentration of ions as what is inside to avoid water either rushing into or out of cells. This is called ion homeostasis.
Okay with all that said what does it mean for you and what does it mean when you take in sodium in the form of salt. Basically it means your body needs to keep the sodium levels in your blood in equilibrium with that of your cells. If the amount of sodium you take in plus the amount of water you take in adds up to a solution that has a higher concentration of sodium than your blood your body will do what it can to pull water into your bloodstream to dilute the concentration so that it returns to equilibrium. When you drink more water your body will try to hold onto it to help lower the overall concentration of sodium. Since there is only so much physical room in your blood vessels the result is your blood pressure goes up…more water, same space, more pressure. Your bodyweight will also increase with the retained water.
If instead you take in more water and less sodium leading to a concentration that is overall lower than what is present in your blood your body will respond by flushing water out of your system to raise the concentration of ions within your blood back to equilibrium. This results in water leaving your blood and there being less volume of water in your vessels causing a drop in blood pressure. Your body flushing the water out will also drop your overall body weight.
Your body has a lot of water to work with, much of your bodyweight is water….so it is very good at keeping this equilibrium. Unless your consumption of sodium is extreme (either extremely low or extremely high) over a long period of time it is probably not something you really need to worry about. If you are concerned you can always have your sodium levels checked by a doctor. An easier way to have some idea of where you are at is the color of your urine. If you have a lot of sodium intake relative to water consumption your body is likely holding onto the water and your urine will appear much darker. If on the other hand you are drinking a lot of water and taking in very little sodium your body is likely trying to flush out the water as fast as it can and your urine will appear almost the color of water. A light straw colored urine is what to expect if you are close to balanced.
One thing to keep in mind is it is not how much sodium you take in it is how much sodium relative to how much water you take in that actually matters. What that means is high sodium foods (which have very little water in them) tend to raise your sodium levels while beverages that contain sodium (like soda or milk) tend to overall lower your sodium levels because they have a lot more water in them than they do sodium. Your blood and the contents of your cells are a lot “saltier” than a can of soda is so drinking soda is if anything going to lower the concentration of sodium in your blood. If you don’t believe that try drinking an IV saline solution.
Fad diets of the “Lose weight in just two weeks!” variety tend to “work” by having you do things that effectively drop your sodium concentration enough that your body responds by flushing water out of your system. They will do something like have you switch to a diet of fruit and veg or other low sodium foods while drinking lots and lots of water (to dilute sodium). The end result is that your body weight goes down rapidly as your body expels the water not only that you took in but also just the water retained naturally in your body. But you haven’t lost fat, you’ve just put yourself into a condition where your body is desperately trying to return the ion concentration in your blood into equilibrium which is not a particularly healthy state. You won’t be able to sustain this, eventually you will need to take in sodium and when you do your body will retain water and you will put the weight back on.
Honestly unless you have a heart condition or high blood pressure at a level where your doctor has specifically told you to monitor and limit your sodium intake you probably shouldn’t care about sodium in your diet. A normal diet is going to be close enough in sodium and water that your body is perfectly capable of sorting it out and you can just pay attention to the color of your urine. If it is too dark then drink more water. If it is too light then either drink less water or add more salt into your diet. Sodium and hydration are two sides of the same coin. Lots of health advice websites tout lowering sodium or drinking more water because they assume the average person looking to lose weight is consuming too much sodium relative to the amount of water they are taking in...but that isn't necessarily true.
MFP defaults to setting a sodium target for you to “hit” that turns red if you go over it. I think this is unfortunate that it is a default setting and you’d be better off turning that particular feature off. If during the course of your diet your weight suddenly goes up 3 pounds or suddenly drops three pounds in the course of a day most likely this is related to how much sodium/water you have taken in and not anything to do with fat. That sort of thing is safe to ignore, it has nothing to do with fat loss or your health...its normal.
I cant get through these long paragraphs. Can you please edit and break down the long sections of texts?
Paragraphs are breaks for the readers ease. I want to read these posts, but simply can't make it through this informative essay. Sorry.
It reads very easy to me, with paragraph breaks in the appropriate places.
Maybe Aaron could do some science haiku as a change of pace.
Eating sodium?
Salt isn't complicated,
just drink more water.8 -
Aaron_K123 wrote: »
I like the idea of a thread explaining what actually happens to fat cells when you lose weight.
Also what calories actually are and how they work.
(I mean, I’ve read up about both, but you have a way of explaining things that are scientific and easy to understand!)
@mazcor536 What calories actually are and how they work I already wrote a post on:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10616633/biochemistry-answers-for-common-weight-loss-questions-what-are-calories/p1
I titled all of these "Biochemistry answers...." so could search for that I guess for ones I've covered.1 -
Bump.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions