Apple cider vinegar
Replies
-
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!4 -
This content has been removed.
-
Maybe the "results" some folks claim is because it makes you too sick to eat???
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23979220
2 -
The BBC programme " Trust me I'm a Doctor,"at the start of the year did identify one aspect which was not present on ordinary vinegars. Fermented foods are fine for those who are able to eat them, no everyone has a system which is able to conform to the regularly accepted Norm.
To address the above comment. I have absolutely no idea how it worked scientifically, only that something had improved and was observed by a third party and reported. The first person was seen to be breathing more easily! I know because I was providing the meals for that person that this was the only change in their diet.
If someone finds a grannies remedy reference, tries it and for them it addresses the issue for which they were looking for a resolution of, then that is sufficient in my view for that person. The use of ACV was recommended to be tried dilute in that specific circumstance. It may work for one but not others. There are many contributory causes to asthma, one is infectious so it may have worked as an antimicrobial, speculation as the reference takn up suggested. I'm well aware of the hay fever/asthma genetic predisposition.
I'm not saying for everyone to go out and try this, obviously a person knows their own body best, for you it would be the height of, the word escapes me. One does one's own thinking.
asthma can be aggravated by infections but its not caused by it. it can trigger it just like heat,cold,pollen.allergies and even acid reflux can aggravate asthma. The thing is you cannot get rid of asthma, you dont outgrow it like it used to be thought, you can be symptom free for many years and sure some foods could trigger an asthmatic response as well. hay fever is also an allergy. it has nothing to do with asthma but can trigger it.
I have had asthma all my life. I have to be on meds to control mine,others may be able to go symptom free by change in diet or by losing weight. But once you have asthma you always have it,one day out of the blue a person can have an asthma attack and die. ACV for asthma would be possibly a placebo effect for some. it can also improve on its own in some. so the ACV was most likely not a contributing factor.0 -
moosmum1972 wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
IN RATS.....not humans we aren't rats.
Since the studies didn't prove it doesn't help and showed that it looks like it does help with certain things, there is no need to be so dismissive (not just you but others also). It does mean that it should probably be investigated more. For those interested, try it, rinse your teeth and see what you think. I'm done here.5 -
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
Nobody has proven that my method, leaving a saucer of cream outside my doorstep to gain the favor of the weight loss pixies, doesn't work either.
If they're making definitive claims for humans in the summaries for the studies after doing research on rats, they're way overstepping what their evidence shows.6 -
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
Nobody has proven that my method, leaving a saucer of cream outside my doorstep to gain the favor of the weight loss pixies, doesn't work either.
If they're making definitive claims for humans in the summaries for the studies after doing research on rats, they're way overstepping what their evidence shows.
Some of the references were for rat studies and some were for human studies!5 -
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
Nobody has proven that my method, leaving a saucer of cream outside my doorstep to gain the favor of the weight loss pixies, doesn't work either.
If they're making definitive claims for humans in the summaries for the studies after doing research on rats, they're way overstepping what their evidence shows.
Some of the references were for rat studies and some were for human studies!
Which human studies establishing or potentially establishing a benefit to weight loss are you referring to?4 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
Proof it doesn't work should not be the criteria though............this is backwards.
Because I can't find the "study" that proves marshmallow Peeps (or whatever) are not good for weight loss, is not a reason to force myself to eat them 3 times a day.6 -
One thing I do know, it help with regularity0
-
janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »
The references I gave said it helped reduce hunger, helped with insulin sensitivity, and also reduced post meal blood glucose spikes.
I'm missing the part in that article where it says it does any of that for humans. It cites a couple of studies that it says "could" do or "suggests" it might do so for rats. Is that what you're referring to?
The references in the article talk about those things.
Yes, I read it. That's how I know you're talking about what the results "could show" or "suggest" for rats. It's not even definite for them, let alone humans.
They did make some definitive claims in the studies. I didn't download the whole study to read, I just read the summary that was given. They should state the uncertainties in their studies. Nothing I read said that they proved that it didn't work!
Proof it doesn't work should not be the criteria though............this is backwards.
Because I can't find the "study" that proves marshmallow Peeps (or whatever) are not good for weight loss, is not a reason to force myself to eat them 3 times a day.
Please look harder! I would have no trouble eating Peeps however many times a day required
0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »What are your thoughts? Anyone taking this daily? Has it helped in overall health, weight loss, etc?
No, it doesn't generically help with health or cause weight loss. Some have specific issues where it might be helpful, or worth a try, but I never had any of those issues so haven't tried it for that.
It's one of many fermented foods that could be helpful to the gut biome (eating a healthful diet overall is more significant, focusing on having a bit of ACV is definitely missing the forest for the trees if one does not have a good diet and make sure calories are on point and so on). I would never personally consume ACV on its own, as if it were medicine, but I love fermented foods and vinegars and use it in my cooking.
There's nothing special about ACV, for the record -- the benefit (as a fermented food) is the presence of the live culture, which could exist in any vinegar (although ACV is more often sold that way). You can make your own, too.
That's not what the studies I referenced said. I don't think it has to be ACV either and other vinegars would be similar.
What's not what the studies you referenced said?1 -
Great in salad dressing, and useful in concentrate form as a weed killer....I would bet the overwhelming majority of claims about it's miracle powers are apocryphal.0
-
I’ve been using them for 2 weeks now and it’s definitely helping with digestive issues.1
-
The only thing that drinking ACV makes you lose is your will to live.
6 -
During my weight loss (around 1/3 of my body weight), I drank it daily for weeks at a time, and I didn't drink it at all for other weeks at a time.
I noticed zip-zero-no-nada effect on my very predictable weight loss rate, on my appetite, or any other related thing.
Why did I drink it? Because (1) I like it, (2) I believe personally but cannot defend scientifically that eating probiotic/fermented foods is good for me, and (3) there's some sign it can help older folks among whom stomach acid insufficiency is more common, so as a 62-year-old with slight IBS-C tendencies, it seemed worth trying, as long as I like the stuff anyway.
Why, then, did I not drink it for weeks at a time? Because it seemed to aggravate the first-ever-in-my-life horrific heartburn that was the chief symptom of my gallbladder adenomyomatosis, a symptom that ended totally when the gallbladder came out.1 -
TenderBlender667 wrote: »Based on personal experience, apple cider vinegar did nothing for my health or weight loss. The one time I tried it as an "acid reflux remedy," the heartburn became 10x worse.
May have had something to do with adding acid to your acid reflux.
2 -
I have insomnia and 1Tb ACV with honey in a cup of water (via straw) at night let me sleep all through the night! I did it several nights in a row and it was fantastic!! Then I started having extra digestive problems, and more research led me to conclude it is not good for people who have had their gallbladder out. I was so bummed. I really loved all the sleep I was getting. Sleep can help with weight loss so I'd continue as long as it kept working.
*Always rinse your mouth out after, and wait 30mins before brushing teeth.4 -
I drink kombucha almost every day!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions