Bananas-friend or foe
karenafrn
Posts: 5 Member
Hi
New to the app. Trying to learn as much as possible. Can you all tell me your thoughts on bananas? I was told they are too high on the glycemic index and therefore should be avoided or at least be limited, but so many smoothie recipes call for them. Thoughts? Thanks in advance.
New to the app. Trying to learn as much as possible. Can you all tell me your thoughts on bananas? I was told they are too high on the glycemic index and therefore should be avoided or at least be limited, but so many smoothie recipes call for them. Thoughts? Thanks in advance.
2
Replies
-
For me, foe. But I don't think they're worth the carbs/calories as they don't fill me up. They're like a candy bar to me (except with more micronutrients obviously).
There is nothing wrong with bananas. If they fit into your diet and you like them, go for it. If they leave you feeling unsatisfied or you're short on calories, skip it or eat half.6 -
Bananas are food -- not good, not bad, just food. If you like them in a smoothie, go for it. If you're dealing with a medical condition that requires you to pare down your sugars/carbs, then don't.
I'm diabetic, and I eat bananas in oatmeal, smoothies and sometimes just straight up. Because I like bananas, and they fit my plan.11 -
Are you diabetic or otherwise concerned about your blood sugar? If not, there's nothing specifically wrong with bananas. Even if so, bananas are still OK, they just tend towards higher sugar levels relative to their calories. They're manageable if eaten in moderation.4
-
because I structure my carb intake later in the day, I have a smaller window to fit in my daily grams - bananas are a great carb source for that so for me, we're freinds
3 -
They're just a food. I don't eat them often because I don't really enjoy the taste, but lots of people eat them regularly and still meet their weight loss and/or fitness goals.4
-
One of my favourite pre run foods.
Add a strong coffee or sugar free energy drink and I'm good for 10 miles.6 -
yay but only for desserts like nice-cream. They are a higher calorie fruit when im cutting i just cant bring self to pick a sad little banana over a huge plate of some lower calorie fruits/veg often lol. Plus bananas are only yummy to me frozen xD its a texture thing1
-
A banana has a glycemic index of 51 and is considered a low GI food as it is under 55 and a glycemic load of 13. It's also a whole food.
Foe for me because I'm allergic.9 -
If they fit in your calories, they are friend. If not, you should probably avoid them. No one food has magical powers to cause you to gain weight or lose weight outside of the calories.
Snacking on fruit by itself can be a problem for some people because it doesn't fill them up and they go right back to being hungry. But if fruit fills you up, or if you are eating it as a part of a meal or snack that has other components that fill you up, fruit is yummy and nutritious. I eat a banana pretty much every day - in my oatmeal, in a smoothie, or with lunch.3 -
Are you diabetic or otherwise concerned about your blood sugar? If not, there's nothing specifically wrong with bananas. Even if so, bananas are still OK, they just tend towards higher sugar levels relative to their calories. They're manageable if eaten in moderation.
Not diabetic-I’ve been trying to do little to no sugar and little to no carbs. I’ve lost 60 lbs but have 20 more to go and just can’t maintain a no sugar no carb diet. One of my coworkers recommended this app. Thanks for all the feedback! Seems like a great group!!!3 -
I eat a banana almost every day, and have had no issue losing weight. I just track them as I would any other food and adjust my calories accordingly throughout the day. They are a staple in my smoothies I love them! 5
-
Are you diabetic or otherwise concerned about your blood sugar? If not, there's nothing specifically wrong with bananas. Even if so, bananas are still OK, they just tend towards higher sugar levels relative to their calories. They're manageable if eaten in moderation.
Not diabetic-I’ve been trying to do little to no sugar and little to no carbs. I’ve lost 60 lbs but have 20 more to go and just can’t maintain a no sugar no carb diet. One of my coworkers recommended this app. Thanks for all the feedback! Seems like a great group!!!
If you're doing keto or something, the GI isn't particularly relevant. Most fruits are going to be high in sugar and carbohydrates. I would say that for a very low carb diet, most fruit would be off the table except berries.2 -
Do you like them? Do they fit your calorie/carb goals? Then friend.
If not, foe.
I personally enjoy them.5 -
Great pre-workout, low(er) glycemic index/load snack, and a good source of potassium (although skim milk has more potassium/calorie). I eat a ton of em.3
-
I love them but thought they were high on glycemic index and therefore made a persons sugar spike. Thanks!2
-
Neither. They're just food.3
-
I am a type 1 diabetic...bananas don't affect my blood sugar BUT not all bananas are created equal. I buy the smallest ones I can get my hands on.2
-
We're definitely pals. I wouldn't eat one alone because it wouldn't fill me up, but they fit in nicely in a balanced meal.3
-
I am a type 1 diabetic...bananas don't affect my blood sugar BUT not all bananas are created equal. I buy the smallest ones I can get my hands on.I am a type 1 diabetic...bananas don't affect my blood sugar BUT not all bananas are created equal. I buy the smallest ones I can get my hands on.
0 -
Very good point about size! Thanks0
-
I eat a banana every night for the potassium, they're a pretty dense tasting food (meaning, you KNOW you've eaten something), and they're delicious so...friend.
The peel would be a foe because of the slipping on them. 3 -
Bananas make me nauseated. I don't know why but they do. I like the taste but not the side effects, and in addition they don't satisfy me and are not worthy the calories or carbs.
I used to share (maybe 1/4) or a banana with my husband (potassium) but he used to buy the bigger ones at Costco. Not more; we now drink a low sodium V8 daily to get potassium and bananas are out of our "diet."
If you like them and they fit your calories and macros, go for it.1 -
I eat a banana every night for the potassium, they're a pretty dense tasting food (meaning, you KNOW you've eaten something), and they're delicious so...friend.
The peel would be a foe because of the slipping on them.
Has anybody ever really slipped on a banana peel, or is that just Hollywood? Has Mythbusters done a banana peel episode?4 -
I love them but thought they were high on glycemic index and therefore made a persons sugar spike. Thanks!
Firstly, the glycemic index of a food isn't relevant unless you have a medical issue with blood sugar regulation.
Secondly, the glycemic index of a food is only relevant if you are eating that one particular food in isolation from any/all other foods, while in a fasted state. If you consume any other food with it, or still have those foods being digested in your stomach, they alter the GI of whatever food you're eating.7 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »I eat a banana every night for the potassium, they're a pretty dense tasting food (meaning, you KNOW you've eaten something), and they're delicious so...friend.
The peel would be a foe because of the slipping on them.
Has anybody ever really slipped on a banana peel, or is that just Hollywood? Has Mythbusters done a banana peel episode?
Of course they have
http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/mythbusters-database/slip-and-fall-on-banana-peel/
2 -
Hi
New to the app. Trying to learn as much as possible. Can you all tell me your thoughts on bananas? I was told they are too high on the glycemic index and therefore should be avoided or at least be limited, but so many smoothie recipes call for them. Thoughts? Thanks in advance.
I don't follow a special diet just watch calorie intake. I can eat a banana if I feel like it.
I don't have smoothies because drinking my calories is not satisfying to me.
3 -
I love them but thought they were high on glycemic index and therefore made a persons sugar spike. Thanks!
Firstly, the glycemic index of a food isn't relevant unless you have a medical issue with blood sugar regulation.
Secondly, the glycemic index of a food is only relevant if you are eating that one particular food in isolation from any/all other foods, while in a fasted state. If you consume any other food with it, or still have those foods being digested in your stomach, they alter the GI of whatever food you're eating.
I like it when someone saves me the trouble of typing.1 -
I will occasionally have one. Something about the texture makes a banana a pretty filling option. If I need to eat something quick, I'll grab one because they take way less time to eat than an apple or chicken or hardboiled eggs.1
-
I chop them up and put one in my oatmeal for breakfast ftw!3
-
They're a friend to me--I eat them for the potassium and because they're filling to me in combination with other foods. Or, I'll eat a banana if it's too early for lunch, and it holds me a while longer.
I love them when they're just past the green stage. Brown spots anywhere, and it's no bueno--too sweet.
I do NOT like them in a smoothie. I use mango and/or avocado instead.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions