Lara bars protein bars quest bars Lenny and Larry?
anmille8
Posts: 49 Member
I feel like these are marketed as health food but at 200 calories plus they really put a dent in the caloric in take. Do you guys eat any of these regularly are they more of a treat? What’s your go to quick easy snack I use to grab bars but now I look at the calories and put me right back down
1
Replies
-
I eat a quest bar 3 times a week for breakfast0
-
I don't think they're marketed as health food so much as they are protein bars or snack bars... but at the same time being higher in calories doesn't make something unhealthy. I'd hardly consider something that's 200 calories to be a meal and any protein bar with 200 or less is pretty low calorie. If you want quick low calorie snacks then fruit, popcorn and low fat yogurt would be even lower. Special K bars are lower at 130 calories but still have 12g of protein if I remember correctly.8
-
I feel like these are marketed as health food but at 200 calories plus they really put a dent in the caloric in take. Do you guys eat any of these regularly are they more of a treat? What’s your go to quick easy snack I use to grab bars but now I look at the calories and put me right back down
'healthy' doesn't automatically = low calorie9 -
And “healthy” is a relative term, open to different interpretations.2
-
I eat them daily. Not because I think they are healthy, but because I like them. I used to eat 4 quest bars a day before they changed the formula. Now I eat one every once in awhile. I go through lenny and larry periods where I eat 1-3 of the 2oz cookies a day as well, lol. If they fit in your calories, there is nothing wrong with eating them daily, just as there is nothing wrong with eating oreos daily if they fit in your calories.2
-
Teabythesea_ wrote: »I don't think they're marketed as health food so much as they are protein bars or snack bars... but at the same time being higher in calories doesn't make something unhealthy. I'd hardly consider something that's 200 calories to be a meal and any protein bar with 200 or less is pretty low calorie. If you want quick low calorie snacks then fruit, popcorn and low fat yogurt would be even lower. Special K bars are lower at 130 calories but still have 12g of protein if I remember correctly.
The only Special K bars with 12g of protein that I know of are 170-180 calories.0 -
Teabythesea_ wrote: »I don't think they're marketed as health food so much as they are protein bars or snack bars... but at the same time being higher in calories doesn't make something unhealthy. I'd hardly consider something that's 200 calories to be a meal and any protein bar with 200 or less is pretty low calorie. If you want quick low calorie snacks then fruit, popcorn and low fat yogurt would be even lower. Special K bars are lower at 130 calories but still have 12g of protein if I remember correctly.
The only Special K bars with 12g of protein that I know of are 170-180 calories.
Oh okay, thanks for the correction. It's been a long time since I've had one of those.2 -
I can lose weight on 2000 calories per day. I have a protein bar for afternoon snack pretty much every day. Usually Combat Crunch at ~230 calories for 20 grams of protein.
Lenny and Larry's are harder to fit in at ~400 calories for 16 grams of protein. I only have those very occasionally.1 -
Beats a candy bar if you still need to get some protein in. And can stash in a bag/car for infinity for when you need a meal on the go. I usually only have a small dinner pre-cardio at work, and then have a protein/food bar (or half a bar dipped in peanut butter) in the car after running/cycling before heading to dancing venue. Or for breakfast while walking to the car heading out to the gym.3
-
Beats a candy bar if you still need to get some protein in. And can stash in a bag/car for infinity for when you need a meal on the go. I usually only have a small dinner pre-cardio at work, and then have a protein/food bar (or half a bar dipped in peanut butter) in the car after running/cycling before heading to dancing venue. Or for breakfast while walking to the car heading out to the gym.
Good point. I always have one protein bar stashed in my purse, one in my gym bag, and a couple in my office desk drawer, just in case.2 -
"healthy" and calorie count don't always go hand-in-hand. Something can be high calorie and healthy, and low calorie can be relatively unhealthy (though, those terms are all subjective, so there is a lot of variance in what someone might consider high vs low calorie, healthy vs unhealthy).
That said, I eat both quest bars and clif builder bars several times per week. I'm on about 1900 cals per day, so I have a bit more room than some, though not as much room as others. It's hard to beat the convenience of them, and if you pair it with a yogurt or something, it makes for a reasonable "meal". Not so great for people who prefer high volume foods/eating, though.2 -
Any of the quest bars I do. also costco has a very good one as well kirkland signature is the brand.0
-
I eat protein bars daily as a snack and a way to get my protein in, but not the ones you mentioned. Lara Bars are good but not enough protein for the calories. If I'm going to eat 200 calories as a snack then the protein needs to be high enough to balance it out.
Right now my go-to protein bar is the Costco brand. My daughter really likes the GNC brand0 -
yea that makes since I struggle grocery shopping so much now that i'm counting because everything i normally go for i tell myself its not worth it especially when you can see the calories but then realized i'm not really grabbing anything but protein and veggies0
-
"Healthy" doesn't mean low calorie. I eat a Clif bar just about every weekday as part of my lunch because I enjoy the taste and they fit easily into my goals. I will have a Larabar sometimes as a treat, but they're a bit too low in protein to be a regular choice for me.
If you feel like they're not worth the calories, then I think that is sufficient reason to avoid them.3 -
I eat protein bars daily as a snack and a way to get my protein in, but not the ones you mentioned. Lara Bars are good but not enough protein for the calories. If I'm going to eat 200 calories as a snack then the protein needs to be high enough to balance it out.
Right now my go-to protein bar is the Costco brand. My daughter really likes the GNC brand
Exactly. Quest has spoiled me on the protein per calories ratio so I have more of a problem considering the lara bars or the lenny and larry cookies that good a source of protein. Well, the cookie wasn't bad and I coincidentally ate one yesterday when I don't normally but consider the 8 g protein a bonus.
0 -
ditto on the Larabars - I know I've checked the nutritional info at least a few times and put them back on the shelf. I usually have Clif, Balance, Nature Valley chewy protein, or Pure Protein bars (or the Aldi knockoffs of the first 3)(<$1.20/bar with decent enough macros).0
-
I have a Larry and Lenny's cookie for breakfast and a larabar as a dessert. The larabars have no processed sugars.0
-
I eat a quest bar every day after work - I find it's a nice treat, helps get my protein up and keeps me full for a reasonable period of time. Good happiness to calorie ratio IMO...1
-
The Quest bar seems to be a love or hate thing. I've had 2 and reaction for me is... oof. Strange aftertaste and consistency. I guess there was some lawsuit about misrepresenting calories or fiber content, not sure about the outcome. Personally I like Kind bars for a 200 calorie treat. Kinda pricey though at $1.50 a piece.0
-
dwayneb2020 wrote: »The Quest bar seems to be a love or hate thing. I've had 2 and reaction for me is... oof. Strange aftertaste and consistency. I guess there was some lawsuit about misrepresenting calories or fiber content, not sure about the outcome. Personally I like Kind bars for a 200 calorie treat. Kinda pricey though at $1.50 a piece.
Nothing came of it. Quest uses IMOs (certain type of fiber) which are partially digestible and therefore counted as 1.5 calories per gram rather than the full 4. A lab tested IMOs and found the full 4 to be digested, but performed the experiment using conditions that didn't accurately mimic the way that humans digest food, so the results were skewed. The calorie count is accurate, just in case you were wondering.
They're way better heated up but all the fruity ones taste chemically to me.1 -
Pure protein bars! I did see Sinfit has a snack size (100 cal) version out, and I think Metrx may, as well. I like Protein One (Fiber One) bars, but I've found they are a bit much on my stomach. 0
-
Teabythesea_ wrote: »dwayneb2020 wrote: »The Quest bar seems to be a love or hate thing. I've had 2 and reaction for me is... oof. Strange aftertaste and consistency. I guess there was some lawsuit about misrepresenting calories or fiber content, not sure about the outcome. Personally I like Kind bars for a 200 calorie treat. Kinda pricey though at $1.50 a piece.
Nothing came of it. Quest uses IMOs (certain type of fiber) which are partially digestible and therefore counted as 1.5 calories per gram rather than the full 4. A lab tested IMOs and found the full 4 to be digested, but performed the experiment using conditions that didn't accurately mimic the way that humans digest food, so the results were skewed. The calorie count is accurate, just in case you were wondering.
They're way better heated up but all the fruity ones taste chemically to me.
Sadly quest doesn't use IMOs anymore.
I wish they did because they were amazing back then.
dwayneb2020 wrote: »The Quest bar seems to be a love or hate thing. I've had 2 and reaction for me is... oof. Strange aftertaste and consistency. I guess there was some lawsuit about misrepresenting calories or fiber content, not sure about the outcome. Personally I like Kind bars for a 200 calorie treat. Kinda pricey though at $1.50 a piece.
They used to be really good back when they used iso-IMOs. The original recipe was awesome and is what made them so popular. Once they changed, they have never been the same. I used to eat 4-5 a day but now just eat one a month maybe.1 -
I keep mini Kind bars in my desk for emergencies. I can take the 100 calorie hit more easily than a 200 calorie hit0
-
I hate Kind bars. They taste like soap to me - not sure which ingredient it is.0
-
I come and go with snacks like that. I do use Larabars quite a bit for my long runs as fuel. I do like a good protein smoothie, so I use protein powder and mix with greek yogurt and a banana. There's a few Quest bars I really like. I notice when I buy them, hubby treats them more like snacks (like a granola) rather than fuel, so I'll stash them in my running pack. When it comes to protein, I try to hit my protein goal with food before I'll consider a protein bar.0
-
Clif bars, which include Luna bars and Builder's bars, aren't marketed as diet or health foods. They're intended for people who are doing physical activities such as hiking, kayaking, or outdoor work. That's why the form factor is: fairly high calories, no low-calorie fillers, easily digestible ingredients, a good balance of macros including carbs, can be eaten on the go or with dirty hands, stays good for a long time in a variety of weather conditions, and has a wrapper that prevents the aroma of the food from attracting wildlife. I wish there was a bar out there like Clif bars but with no refined sugar though, maybe substituting date paste. The closest thing is Larabars but a lot of people have trouble digesting whole raw nuts. I used to like the ONE/Quest type of protein bars but lately I have been finding them gross and fake tasting.0
-
dwayneb2020 wrote: »The Quest bar seems to be a love or hate thing. I've had 2 and reaction for me is... oof. Strange aftertaste and consistency. I guess there was some lawsuit about misrepresenting calories or fiber content, not sure about the outcome. Personally I like Kind bars for a 200 calorie treat. Kinda pricey though at $1.50 a piece.
Ya, I had a Quest S'Mores bar a few years back and experienced a nasty aftertaste. I blame the sucralose. I do experience it as sweet, but nasty.
https://www.phillymag.com/be-well-philly/2013/08/22/study-fake-sweeteners-taste-disgusting-people/0 -
I have the occasional protein bar, but usually more of an after workout protein kick (which is my afternoon snack) or sometimes as dessert if I'm still hungry and have the calories. I just hate the ingredients of most of them. I don't "Eat clean" ( hate that phrase) but maltitol and sorbitol bother my stomach, and it's in a LOT of them.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions