Keto

magnusthenerd

tezzmakk wrote: »

lemurcat2 wrote: »

tezzmakk wrote: »

Are you? Thats nice. But every cell in your body is two thirds water so every time you burn a fat cell you burn two times the water so in terms of long term weight loss its quite important. Stop trying to be clever

Not really, water weight fluctuations are easy. And no, that's not how fat loss works.

But if you are super excited about dropping some water weight, that's cool. Makes one wonder why you claimed to be concerned/shocked by it, however.

Show me where i mentioned fat loss please

Well presumably, since you haven't mentioned taking hacking limbs off into consideration, you aren't interested in a change in body weight simpliciter, since that would be faster, and potentially more permanent.
Are you just interested in losing weight, period, like someone looking to make a cut for a sport or something? Or is the weight loss motivated by something like health outcomes, or achieving an ascetic? It seems losing fat is generally what you want with both of those.

tezzmakk

magnusthenerd wrote: »

tezzmakk wrote: »

Are you? Thats nice. But every cell in your body is two thirds water so every time you burn a fat cell you burn two times the water so in terms of long term weight loss its quite important. Stop trying to be clever

Fallacy of division - what is true for the whole (your body) is not necessarily true for individual parts (cells). Muscle cells contain more water than average. Fat cells contain a lot less water than average - their percent water will depend, in fact, on if you've been losing weight, particularly in a way the reduces carbohydrate stores.
The whole difference in the water content is what allows for the analysis of human body fat without people being dead - testing the density or water content of the body.

So if i eat lots of carbs that would make my body store lots ofwater causing me to put on weight if i continue to do that i will continue to put on weight. Dods that water weight count?