No fanfare for achieving weight loss goal?
suelfong
Posts: 4 Member
Does MyFitnessPal really NOT give any fanfare or congratulations for achieving your weight loss goal? Fitbit said, "Goal met. Woohoo!" Nothing from MFP? MFP got me there more than my Fitbit did! Thanks, MFP! :-)
0
Replies
-
No but if you post pics and a success story people will come out of the woodwork to congratulate you. :happy:0
-
Huh, I thought there might be a little something too. Like on Wii Fit when you reach a goal, there's a little fireworks show. Might be a good website suggestion. Reminds me of the whole Mario series. Months of work to rescue the princess and she never even acknowledges you when she's rescued. :grumble: :laugh:Does MyFitnessPal really NOT give any fanfare or congratulations for achieving your weight loss goal? Fitbit said, "Goal met. Woohoo!" Nothing from MFP? MFP got me there more than my Fitbit did! Thanks, MFP! :-)0 -
Does MyFitnessPal really NOT give any fanfare or congratulations for achieving your weight loss goal? Fitbit said, "Goal met. Woohoo!" Nothing from MFP? MFP got me there more than my Fitbit did! Thanks, MFP! :-)
Hummm........MFP peoples should think about it seriously ! Nice Idea !!0 -
Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.0
-
Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
But then again it "cheers" when you've logged for 5 days straight, when you lost 0.1 lbs, when you did a 5 minute walk....
In that light I wouldn't mind a bit of fireworks 20 pounds in, really!1 -
Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
LOL exactly I wouldn't expect this to happen... ha ha!0 -
0 -
So if it congratulated you for reaching your goal weight, should it also chastise you for being over on subsequent log-ins? I can just see it: "Ooooo, you gained a pound! Well isn't that just too bad. Looks like you shouldn't have switched your goal to maintenance so soon". :laugh:0
-
Just wanted to say, Congratulations! It is a big deal0
-
That's actually a neat idea. Like if confetti showered down the webpage or something, lol. Nothin' wrong with a little slap on the back!
Congrats on reaching goal! Like another poster said, maybe share your success on the Success Stories board as motivation for others!0 -
It's like the kids who get trophies just for showing up.
Who needs that?
MFP has that little thing that says it you eat like this for five weeks:
That's their version of an "attaboy" IMO0 -
Is it my imagination or do some people just reply to a post to be argumentative ?0
-
Not just you... Maybe some are a little jealouss.... Congrats on your loss! Nothing wrong with wanting a little cheer at the end.Is it my imagination or do some people just reply to a post to be argumentative ?0 -
Just wanted to say, Congratulations! It is a big deal
This!0 -
It's like the kids who get trophies just for showing up.
Who needs that?
MFP has that little thing that says it you eat like this for five weeks:
That's their version of an "attaboy" IMO
Huh? But.. it's not just participating, it's putting in hard work and achieving a goal. I don't understand how a participation trophy is the same thing as a website congratulating you on losing the amount of weight you set out to lose. Totally think it's a good idea and couldn't hurt. The people against it implying that MFP would somehow coddle people for a virtual slap on the back upon reaching goal cracks me up. Seems like a harmless and positive idea, maybe OP should put this in the suggestion forum.0 -
my, bad, I thought the OP was asking a question. (I thought I saw a question mark)0
-
Congratulations!!!
Maybe a bunch of us should report this to get the moderators' attention about something good.0 -
I second that motion. It would a fun addition.It's like the kids who get trophies just for showing up.
Who needs that?
MFP has that little thing that says it you eat like this for five weeks:
That's their version of an "attaboy" IMO
Huh? But.. it's not just participating, it's putting in hard work and achieving a goal. I don't understand how a participation trophy is the same thing as a website congratulating you on losing the amount of weight you set out to lose. Totally think it's a good idea and couldn't hurt. The people against it implying that MFP would somehow coddle people for a virtual slap on the back upon reaching goal cracks me up. Seems like a harmless and positive idea, maybe OP should put this in the suggestion forum.0 -
Love the idea, at least a posting on your feed like you get when you log so many days or finish your daily food diary.
FYI, this would be best posted under Website Suggestions (see lower topics on message board home page)
ETA: Nevermind, I see it's already there.
0 -
Forget MFP, from me CONGRATULATIONS!!! You did it!!! you rock, you worked hard and did what you needed too.. how much more awesome can it be!Does MyFitnessPal really NOT give any fanfare or congratulations for achieving your weight loss goal? Fitbit said, "Goal met. Woohoo!" Nothing from MFP? MFP got me there more than my Fitbit did! Thanks, MFP! :-)0
-
I just dumped a link to here on there.Love the idea, at least a posting on your feed like you get when you log so many days or finish your daily food diary.
FYI, this would be best posted under Website Suggestions (see lower topics on message board home page)
ETA: Nevermind, I see it's already there.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1092426-fanfare-for-goal-achieved0 -
Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
But then again it "cheers" when you've logged for 5 days straight, when you lost 0.1 lbs, when you did a 5 minute walk....
In that light I wouldn't mind a bit of fireworks 20 pounds in, really!
This is true - I agree. At least a "whooo! you did it!" or something.
They hype everything else up "okolo completed her food diary for today and was UNDER HER CALORIE GOAL!" -
or OKOLO LOST ALL HER WEIGHT AND IS NO LONGER A FATTIE - YEAAAYYY FREAKING YEAAYYY WHOHOOO!.
that may be a bit much, but you get the idea 0 -
Nah, that's exactly what I plan to post on FB when I reach goal.Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
But then again it "cheers" when you've logged for 5 days straight, when you lost 0.1 lbs, when you did a 5 minute walk....
In that light I wouldn't mind a bit of fireworks 20 pounds in, really!
This is true - I agree. At least a "whooo! you did it!" or something.
They hype everything else up "okolo completed her food diary for today and was UNDER HER CALORIE GOAL!" -
or OKOLO LOST ALL HER WEIGHT AND IS NO LONGER A FATTIE - YEAAAYYY FREAKING YEAAYYY WHOHOOO!.
that may be a bit much, but you get the idea
:laugh: 0 -
Congratulations on reaching goal! You rock and since you've been here long enough you know that the posts that matter the most aren't the auto posts but those that you shout yourself from the roof top! Hurray for you! 31.7 more pounds and I'll be posting my self praising boast too!0
-
Is it my imagination or do some people just reply to a post to be argumentative ?
Maybe you haven't been here long enough to notice that there are certain MFPers who will reply to EVERY post just to argue. You'll get used to it.
OP ...*FIREWORKS*
0 -
Huh, I thought there might be a little something too. Like on Wii Fit when you reach a goal, there's a little fireworks show. Might be a good website suggestion. Reminds me of the whole Mario series. Months of work to rescue the princess and she never even acknowledges you when she's rescued. :grumble: :laugh:Does MyFitnessPal really NOT give any fanfare or congratulations for achieving your weight loss goal? Fitbit said, "Goal met. Woohoo!" Nothing from MFP? MFP got me there more than my Fitbit did! Thanks, MFP! :-)
Hehehehehehehe0 -
That's actually a neat idea. Like if confetti showered down the webpage or something, lol.
OMG that would be SO cute! :happy:0 -
Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
Yes. I am the Lisa Simpson of the Weightloss World.0 -
Nah, that's exactly what I plan to post on FB when I reach goal.Do you really need a website to slap you on the back and shout "Congratulations" for achieving a personal goal? Seems silly to me. The site is a tool for meeting and maintaining your goals, not a cheerleader.
But then again it "cheers" when you've logged for 5 days straight, when you lost 0.1 lbs, when you did a 5 minute walk....
In that light I wouldn't mind a bit of fireworks 20 pounds in, really!
This is true - I agree. At least a "whooo! you did it!" or something.
They hype everything else up "okolo completed her food diary for today and was UNDER HER CALORIE GOAL!" -
or OKOLO LOST ALL HER WEIGHT AND IS NO LONGER A FATTIE - YEAAAYYY FREAKING YEAAYYY WHOHOOO!.
that may be a bit much, but you get the idea :laugh:
ME TOO!0 -
Well i will tell ya way to go!! 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions