The best pb&j sammich EVER!

CallMeCupcakeDammit

So simple! Here are the ingredients, and you can NOT stray from them or you just ruin it. No arguing, dammit!

2 slices of Martin's potato bread (whole wheat is acceptable)
2 T Trader Joe's natural peanut butter (because perfect)
2 T Welch's grape jelly

Put your two pieces of bread on your plate (separate them first), then using a knife you spread the peanut butter on one slice of bread, and the jelly on the other. Put the two together, and voila! Make sure the jelly is on the bottom slice. Don't ask questions. You can add a glass of cold milk, too. Or whatever you like, really. I'm easy like that. If you don't have Martin's available in your area, then I will shed a tear for you.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

WhatMeRunning

I have been looking for a PB&J recipe for years. My mom used to make the best PB&J. Oh, how I have longed to taste them again!

CallMeCupcakeDammit

Byn, you made me think of this, even though it's not raspberries.



ETA that I have just recently expanded my jelly horizons and used elderberry and strawberry recently, not raspberry yet.

cmcollins001

Seriously, Strawberry or go home!

Strange_magic

Sorry it's either Orange Marmalade and extra crunchy on oatnut

Or nothing!

04hoopsgal73

Well dear, I left my PBJ/Concord Grape Jelly school hood sandwich life behind me. I'm all grown up and converted to Raspberry Jam, preferably homemade. So that's PBRJ to you!

Unknown

This content has been removed.

k8blujay2

Just peanut butter for me thanks... unless you substitute the jelly with a dark chocolate spread (or nutella if you wish, but that's not my choice)...

Erin_goBrahScience

So simple! Here are the ingredients, and you can NOT stray from them or you just ruin it. No arguing, dammit!

2 slices of Martin's potato bread (whole wheat is acceptable)
2 T Trader Joe's natural peanut butter (because perfect)
2 T Welch's grape jelly

Put your two pieces of bread on your plate (separate them first), then using a knife you spread the peanut butter on one slice of bread, and the jelly on the other. Put the two together, and voila! Make sure the jelly is on the bottom slice. Don't ask questions. You can add a glass of cold milk, too. Or whatever you like, really. I'm easy like that. If you don't have Martin's available in your area, then I will shed a tear for you.

I hate grape jelly!

CallMeCupcakeDammit

Sorry it's either Orange Marmalade and extra crunchy on oatnut

Or nothing!

Oh poop! I forgot to say creamy or crunchy! I knew I'd screw it up. Either, really. I was always a creamy girl, but I bought crunchy by accident once and it was good! But orange marmalade? Hmmmmm, maybe I'll go to my mom's and make one at her house and check that out.

BombshellPhoenix

For the visual learners. I like to make mine with more p than j.

_crafty_

Seriously, Strawberry or go home!

we can't be friends anymore.

RASPBERRY or BLACKBERRY are the only acceptable jellies for PB&J

shutyourpieholeandsquat

ho-made plum jelly or GTFO

KameHameHaaaa

I make the best pb&j, but i use my mama's strawberry freezer jam grape jam is good too tho'

CallMeCupcakeDammit

For the visual learners. I like to make mine with more p than j.

Yeah, baby, I'd eat your sammich! Darn this whole logging and weighing stuff. I don't do the "whatever I can spread on dat bread" method anymore.

Sarauk2sf

Can I substitute the bread for cauliflower?

BombshellPhoenix

For the visual learners. I like to make mine with more p than j.

Yeah, baby, I'd eat your sammich! Darn this whole logging and weighing stuff. I don't do the "whatever I can spread on dat bread" method anymore.

I put it on the scale and start smothering it ♡.♡

JTick

Sorry, I'm a little unclear on how much salt to use.

2bassets

This was my supper last night, but the sugar free strawberry jam. Oh, and Extra Crunchy Skippy!!

CallMeCupcakeDammit

Can I substitute the bread for cauliflower?

Only if you're cutting. Then I will allow it. Wait, what am I saying?! :sick:

Alluminati

Is it Paleo?

CallMeCupcakeDammit

Sorry, I'm a little unclear on how much salt to use.

The salt is already in the peanut butter. :drinker:

pleasurelittletreasure

I gotta say: It's actually not even peanut butter. It's the ABM - Justin's Almond Butter and Smucker's Simply Fruit Orange Marmalade.

Candi_land

Is this vegetarian?

LeonCX

A peanut butter and jelly sandwich. How original.

Angimom

blackberry or blueberry! And toast the bread first! YUMMYNESS

CallMeCupcakeDammit

Is it Paleo?

Sadly, no. I'm sorry for the Paleoans.

CallMeCupcakeDammit

A peanut butter and jelly sandwich. How original.

This isn't just any peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

pleasurelittletreasure

screw the jelly, I want pickles instead!

Pregnant?

ETA: For some reason, I immediately pictured Sandra Dee, ordering "Mixed pickles and strawberries, please." Was very cute, because her mom had ordered the exact same thing when SHE had been pregnant, so the cat was out of the bag.