So I went to a nutritionist
Replies
-
I personally find that sitting at work all day is rough for a good night's sleep. I work till 4:30ish, head to the gym at my school from about 5 - 5:45, then walk to class at 6. It's only 45 minutes in between things. On those days, I always sleep so much better! If you can squeeze in a half hour somewhere a few times a week I think you'll notice a difference in falling asleep at night.
I also agree with everyone saying you might not be logging accurately. Be careful of things that are generic like "sandwich" or "slice of" because a lot of them are wrong. You need to break down everything in the sandwich, and actually weigh things like slices of cake.
Otherwise I have no idea about the supplement she recommended so I don't have an opinion! good luck
0 -
A few questions about your fatigue/exhaustion:
- do you feel miserable in the morning even when you got 7-9 hours of sleep?
- are you tired all day but then have a hard time falling/staying asleep at night?
9 is usually a sweet spot for me, but I can only get 9 hours on the weekends. Otherwise, yes, I'm miserable in the mornings.
To the second question, yes.
This is 100% normal for teenagers.0 -
Hmm. I didn't think of this. My doctor referred me to a nutritionist for hypertension and the insurance company ended up saying it was education and refused to pay for it. Very expensive diet info.0
-
Ugh! Trying to maintain or lose weight in college is tough- especially if you are on the meal plan. I found the only way for me to truly lose weight was by lowering my carbohydrate/sugar intake. I read the South Beach Diet years ago, and it really opened my eyes to how your body metabolizes different foods. Once I hit a healthier weight I added back complex carbs like steel cut oats, but I find I still have to keep the sugar intake as low as possible.
As far as you being lethargic- welcome to college! I think that happens to most students, so you're not alone. A high protein/healthy fat diet should help. Also, I know you said you don't have time to exercise- but even 1/2 an hour walking each day could help with your energy levels. I find it might take a couple of weeks to kick in, but I swear it works!
Your school probably has a gym and they might even offer classes, which could be fun! You should look into it and get your friends to join you!
You will feel a lot busier post-graduation, so it's best to start exercising and practicing a healthy lifestyle now. Learn how to balance your time, make your health your priority, go to class, and don't forget to have fun! They don't call college "The Glory Years," for nothing!0 -
Dining hall/cafeteria food sucks, period. That's like judging American cuisine by the food at McDonald's--processed, salty and flavorless.
It may be worth researching economic ways to eat fresher food next year away from the meal plan, or figure out how to supplement it here and there. Many adults have challenging schedules, and it does take some effort and planning to make fitness and food a part of your daily life.0 -
Herbal supplements can help with energy but I wouldn't take one without checking with a dr. Lowering carbs and especially sugars has helped my energy levels a lot. So that may help you too.
You say that you have to get used to bland American vegetables. Are you away from your family? Is this your first time away from home? Are you from another country? Could you be depressed?
I agree with you on the carbs/sugar. I'm from the US but I'm of Indian origin and eat almost exclusively Indian food at home. I live relatively close to home but can only go home once a month. I am depressed, yes.
Are you doing anything for the depression, that can make you feel exhausted. Have you had a physical?0 -
Don't know if this has been mentioned: have your Vitamin D level checked. I was chronically fatigued (not necessarily chronic fatigue). My D level was low, and I supplement with D3 and feel much better.0
-
A few questions about your fatigue/exhaustion:
- do you feel miserable in the morning even when you got 7-9 hours of sleep?
- are you tired all day but then have a hard time falling/staying asleep at night?
Actually, I was just reading and that is ME
And it sucks...
Back to the real topic!0 -
have not read all the responses...
here's my two cents...
reducing carbs helped boost my energy.
b12 is also a good idea
how's your iron levels? I'm anemic & that causes drowsiness.
have you had a sleep study? turns out i have sleep apnea and need a CPAP machine
how's your thyroid levels?
yes, increase veggies.
good luck! :drinker:0 -
I do not really have time to exercise either but I do. Be careful here at MFP at claiming that as you will get people's schedules and get told that there is no excuse. Some days are harder than others believe me, but if you think exercise will help your energy you can do it...you do not have to exercise though to be healthy and lose weight so don't exercise if you don't want to.0
-
Everybody has time to exercise. If you think you are busy as a student, wait until real life, it gets worse. People that work and have kids and all that, look at students that say they don't have time, and die laughing. Carve out 30 minutes and exercise. It will be the best investment of your time. The President of the United States takes time to exercise, you certainly can to. You just are not putting it up there on your list of priorities. One solution to this is schedule it into your day. I don't fit in exercise, I actually schedule it in with everything else.
As far as your diet, it is my opinion that you are eating more than you think you are. That's not a huge problem, but you are not able to weigh and measure because it is being served to you. So, that's probably where you are failing in your attempts. I would prioritize feeling more energetic, rather than trying to lose weight. I do believe that exercise will do that for you. Schedule it in. It is important. If you don't take care of your body, it will fail you when you need it.
Gonna have to agree with guitarharry on this one. May I just add that the amount of time that you spent writing this and reading and responding to ALL of the kind people who are trying to help you...you coulda exercised!
Maybe I'm the only tough love guy here...but try exercising for a few weeks...I have a feeling that it may help with many of your issues. This is how life works...try something for a short time and see if it works for you. If it doesn't then move onto the next thing to try. Eventually you will find what works for you. The only problem then is being honest with yourself and not being lazy or making excuses and just do it! No one here can tell you 100% what the solution is...so give one a try!
Good luck!0 -
Everybody has time to exercise. If you think you are busy as a student, wait until real life, it gets worse. People that work and have kids and all that, look at students that say they don't have time, and die laughing. Carve out 30 minutes and exercise. It will be the best investment of your time. The President of the United States takes time to exercise, you certainly can to. You just are not putting it up there on your list of priorities. One solution to this is schedule it into your day. I don't fit in exercise, I actually schedule it in with everything else.
As far as your diet, it is my opinion that you are eating more than you think you are. That's not a huge problem, but you are not able to weigh and measure because it is being served to you. So, that's probably where you are failing in your attempts. I would prioritize feeling more energetic, rather than trying to lose weight. I do believe that exercise will do that for you. Schedule it in. It is important. If you don't take care of your body, it will fail you when you need it.
Gonna have to agree with guitarharry on this one. May I just add that the amount of time that you spent writing this and reading and responding to ALL of the kind people who are trying to help you...you coulda exercised!
Maybe I'm the only tough love guy here...but try exercising for a few weeks...I have a feeling that it may help with many of your issues. This is how life works...try something for a short time and see if it works for you. If it doesn't then move onto the next thing to try. Eventually you will find what works for you. The only problem then is being honest with yourself and not being lazy or making excuses and just do it! No one here can tell you 100% what the solution is...so give one a try!
Good luck!
I was responding to these messages in my transition minutes between classes and such, I couldn't have exercised. At this point, whenever I have free time, I'm too darn tired to exercise. Plus, I'm so out of shape that I can only last a few minutes anyway. At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you. You don't need to exercise to lose weight anyway, and losing weight is my number one goal right now.0 -
Everybody has time to exercise. If you think you are busy as a student, wait until real life, it gets worse. People that work and have kids and all that, look at students that say they don't have time, and die laughing. Carve out 30 minutes and exercise. It will be the best investment of your time. The President of the United States takes time to exercise, you certainly can to. You just are not putting it up there on your list of priorities. One solution to this is schedule it into your day. I don't fit in exercise, I actually schedule it in with everything else.
As far as your diet, it is my opinion that you are eating more than you think you are. That's not a huge problem, but you are not able to weigh and measure because it is being served to you. So, that's probably where you are failing in your attempts. I would prioritize feeling more energetic, rather than trying to lose weight. I do believe that exercise will do that for you. Schedule it in. It is important. If you don't take care of your body, it will fail you when you need it.
Gonna have to agree with guitarharry on this one. May I just add that the amount of time that you spent writing this and reading and responding to ALL of the kind people who are trying to help you...you coulda exercised!
Maybe I'm the only tough love guy here...but try exercising for a few weeks...I have a feeling that it may help with many of your issues. This is how life works...try something for a short time and see if it works for you. If it doesn't then move onto the next thing to try. Eventually you will find what works for you. The only problem then is being honest with yourself and not being lazy or making excuses and just do it! No one here can tell you 100% what the solution is...so give one a try!
Good luck!
I was responding to these messages in my transition minutes between classes and such, I couldn't have exercised. At this point, whenever I have free time, I'm too darn tired to exercise. Plus, I'm so out of shape that I can only last a few minutes anyway. At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you. You don't need to exercise to lose weight anyway, and losing weight is my number one goal right now.
Exercise doesn't have to be a 1-2 hour go to the gym sort of pursuit (though that's great when your schedule permits). Just getting in more walking will do wonders. It only take 15 mins or so to walk a mile. Get that in 3-4 times per day and you've got some decent time in there. Walking between classes or taking the long way, use the stairs rather than the escalator/elevator, etc. It adds up before you know it.
Trust me, I used to work a full-time job and went to undergrad classes full time at a pretty solid university, I know how hectic it can be. I used to study on the bus when commuting in from my cheaper apt. 3 cities away, slept on the floor of my office when my shift ended at 6 am and my first lab wasn't until 8 am. Trust me, I really do get it. But, just having breaks in between classes is a HUGE plus compared to getting out in the world where you're stuck at a desk for 8-14 hours a day. Sometimes, you can just get it in little bits here and there but those little bits add up if you're willing to get a little creative. Plus, you'll sleep a lot better with consistent physical movement, so you may find that more time will free up that way.0 -
I understand too tired.
I understand crazy tiny windows of opportunity to make a workout happen.
I understand being out of shape.
BUT, you can't get in shape if you don't exercise and every tiny window of time that you do have free offers something...a walk, dancing in your dorm room/apartment with no one watching, a few pushups or situps when you need a mental break...shoot when I do laundry, if the day has been too busy to fit a real work out in, I will fold ten things then do 20 jumping jacks and some burpees and repeat.
Excuses for not doing something can always be shot down...it would be better to say..."I am not ready to prioritize exercise right now"than it is to offer reasons why you cannot do what others can do. You CAN find time to exercise but you have to want to...but it sounds to me like you are not ready to make that a priority. That is ok..prioritize other parts of being a healthy person, like your diet and your sleep and your mood/depression.0 -
First of all.... too many carbs?? Obviously don't trust her, your carb intake is fine and you can go a lot higher if you want. Definitely watch the sodium though!!! That is a lot of sodium and can hold on to extra water which can in result make you look fluffier then you probably are.
I eat 300 carbs a day...
I eat -/+2000 calories a day....
It is not the carbs that are the problem and it is not the calorie intake that you "might be going slightly over because you count inaccurately"...... wooooww.... really people?
just keep up the good work, drink plenty of water, have lots of fruit, hehe... and vegetables
but honestly.... fruit is more important lol
best of luck!!!
xoxo~Becky0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I went to see a nutritionist last week to discuss my lack of weight loss and my constant fatigue/exhaustion. She told me to send her my food diary for a week, so I did.
Today, she told me the following things
--my calorie level was fine (which surprised me, since I haven't lost any weight since placing my calories at 1740)
--my protein level was fine (I eat on average 50g per day, sometimes more sometimes less. I rarely meet my goal for protein as suggested by MFP)
--I eat too many carbs (understandable)
--I don't eat enough vegetables/fruits (also understandable, I guess I'll have to get used to bland, American-style vegetables)
Instead of suggesting exercise to help with my tiredness (she understood that I don't really have time) she told me to take an herbal supplement called Rhodiola. I've never heard of this herb and I'm a little skeptical.
What do you think? Should I go by what the nutritionist is saying?
You may also want to look into whether or not the Rhodiola with interfere with any meds you may be taking.0 -
First of all.... too many carbs?? Obviously don't trust her, your carb intake is fine and you can go a lot higher if you want. Definitely watch the sodium though!!! That is a lot of sodium and can hold on to extra water which can in result make you look fluffier then you probably are.
I eat 300 carbs a day...
I eat -/+2000 calories a day....
It is not the carbs that are the problem and it is not the calorie intake that you "might be going slightly over because you count inaccurately"...... wooooww.... really people?
just keep up the good work, drink plenty of water, have lots of fruit, hehe... and vegetables
but honestly.... fruit is more important lol
best of luck!!!
xoxo~Becky
I have no idea what your point is.
I agree with you on carbs. It's not about any specific macro nutrient, but rather about the total calories in versus out.
Well, if she's eating 1740 cals on average and is still experiencing constant fatigue, then there is probably something else going on. It could be a thyroid problem, a deficiency in iron/Vitamin D/something else, etc., or something like insulin resistance. If it is something like insulin resistance, the amount of carbs may make a big difference and be contributing to the fatigue, which is probably why some suggested cutting them back to see if she noticed a difference in such things as that's easier to address with diet without a full blood panel being drawn.
When everything is firing on all cylinders, the macro levels can be much more variable. But, when someone is experiencing something out of the ordinary like inexplicable fatigue, macro levels MAY be very important.0 -
Herbal supplements can help with energy but I wouldn't take one without checking with a dr. Lowering carbs and especially sugars has helped my energy levels a lot. So that may help you too.
You say that you have to get used to bland American vegetables. Are you away from your family? Is this your first time away from home? Are you from another country? Could you be depressed?
I agree with you on the carbs/sugar. I'm from the US but I'm of Indian origin and eat almost exclusively Indian food at home. I live relatively close to home but can only go home once a month. I am depressed, yes.
Depression can cause fatigue. I know you are busy and stressed, but exercise can help with all of the problems you are having. My first advice though, is to get to a Dr. or campus counselor. Don't let the depression get out of hand.0 -
Usana vitamins helped me tremendously! Within a month I had energy again and within 5 years my allergies were gone! I've always taken store bought vitamins, and they didn't do much. These are amazing!0
-
Getting off sugar, white flour and high GI foods and adding in lots of green vegetables will help your depression, and walk more!
I've been down that road too!0 -
Hello OP,
First off let me say you are beautiful! Secondly I am s university student who attended college before.
A couple of things id like to address;:
Do you study/do homework in your room where you sleep? If so stop! For me in college this was the main reason I couldn't ever sleep! I was in such close proximity to my bed (as most rez's are) I mentally couldn't separate from it
Second try and make the time to workout, it does so much good for you mentally! It reduces my stress, depression and helps me sleep better than anything out there. Someone already said fitness blender, another workout I truly love is waysofgray, search her up on instagram or Google, her eBook is 10$ and workouts can be done in 30 or less normally less .
Third do yourself a favour, next time go home get a ride to the grocery store and pick up a small bottle of franks hot sauce + individual spice packets. Walmart has them and its cheap.
I wouldn't try the herb if I was you, id increase the hell outta the protein and reduce your sugar! More energy in no time. If you keep feeling down try a vitamin d pill and if its really bad try tryptophan, a depression drug that's plant based and no side effects of attachment issues, Really helped my first year away.
Don't be a stranger feel free to add me if you need clarification, or a buddy. Remember grades get you a job but you need health and confidence to even get in the door of a job. 0 -
I'm having trouble with the math here in that your calories are fine, protein is fine, and fat is fine but you need to maintain your calorie level but decrease carbs without increasing anything else. I didn't notice if you provided a full macro breakdown but if you're at 1700 calories and 50 grams of protein then your day might look something like...
pro: 50gm's = 200 calories
fat: 57gm's = 510 calories (I'm guessing based on 30% of your total calories which is about max recommended)
cho: 248gm's = 990 calories
Total = 1700 calories
So if protein and fat remain constant and you reduce your daily carb in-take and let's assume it's 100gm's for example purposes, your day would now look like...
pro: 50gm's = 200 cal's
fat: 57 gm's = 510 cal's
cho: 148gm's = 592 cal's
Total = 1,302 cal's
That's a difference of 400 calories and rather dramatic. If you calories are good and your dietitian wants you to maintain your calories but cut your carbs, then you must add the deficit left from the reduced carbs in the form of fat or protein, it's just simple math. Nothing wrong with replacing some carbs with green veggies by any means, but you're still at a net-net reduction in total calories and if you're not feeling great now then you're going to feel even worse.0 -
Everybody has time to exercise. If you think you are busy as a student, wait until real life, it gets worse. People that work and have kids and all that, look at students that say they don't have time, and die laughing. Carve out 30 minutes and exercise. It will be the best investment of your time. The President of the United States takes time to exercise, you certainly can to. You just are not putting it up there on your list of priorities. One solution to this is schedule it into your day. I don't fit in exercise, I actually schedule it in with everything else.
As far as your diet, it is my opinion that you are eating more than you think you are. That's not a huge problem, but you are not able to weigh and measure because it is being served to you. So, that's probably where you are failing in your attempts. I would prioritize feeling more energetic, rather than trying to lose weight. I do believe that exercise will do that for you. Schedule it in. It is important. If you don't take care of your body, it will fail you when you need it.
Gonna have to agree with guitarharry on this one. May I just add that the amount of time that you spent writing this and reading and responding to ALL of the kind people who are trying to help you...you coulda exercised!
Ha! I always say, "If Beyonce has time to exercise, so do I!!"
To the point of scheduling it-- this is a huge tool that keeps my butt in that gym. I'm sure you have a phone/computer/old school journal with a calendar function. Use it! I schedule time for the gym like I schedule work meetings and I do *NOT* move them. Not for work or social functions. I find it also helps to commit to the same time each day. We all like a routine, no?0 -
At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you.
When I was 19, I was a single mother and full-time student with a job and a boyfriend and I had time to exercise. What is going on in your life that you have less time than I did?
As for energy, exercise GIVES you energy. Just start walking. Trust me.0 -
At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you.
When I was 19, I was a single mother and full-time student with a job and a boyfriend and I had time to exercise. What is going on in your life that you have less time than I did?
As for energy, exercise GIVES you energy. Just start walking. Trust me.
I've looked at everyone's advice--thank you for your input. I understand people have busier lives than I do and still find the time. But right now it's not just time, it's energy. I'm mentally and physically drained at the end of the day. After a full day of classes, work, studying, clubs, whatever social time I have--I'm drained. I don't get to do a lot of the things my friends do because of how out of shape I am. I wilt if I exert myself too much. I just want to be thinner at this point. Exercise can wait.0 -
And, again, exercise gives you energy. It also makes you stronger (I couldn't do five minutes the first time I was on an elliptical. Now I can go for as long as I want/have time for).At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you.
When I was 19, I was a single mother and full-time student with a job and a boyfriend and I had time to exercise. What is going on in your life that you have less time than I did?
As for energy, exercise GIVES you energy. Just start walking. Trust me.
I've looked at everyone's advice--thank you for your input. I understand people have busier lives than I do and still find the time. But right now it's not just time, it's energy. I'm mentally and physically drained at the end of the day. After a full day of classes, work, studying, clubs, whatever social time I have--I'm drained. I don't get to do a lot of the things my friends do because of how out of shape I am. I wilt if I exert myself too much. I just want to be thinner at this point. Exercise can wait.
If it were important to you, you would do it. You don't need to make excuses. Just say you don't want to. But, also, don't complain about not being able to do things with your friends because that is your fault.
I will say, if it is THAT bad at your age, you should see a doctor because that isn't normal.0 -
At this point I'm shelving exercise until I have the time and energy, but thank you.
When I was 19, I was a single mother and full-time student with a job and a boyfriend and I had time to exercise. What is going on in your life that you have less time than I did?
As for energy, exercise GIVES you energy. Just start walking. Trust me.
I've looked at everyone's advice--thank you for your input. I understand people have busier lives than I do and still find the time. But right now it's not just time, it's energy. I'm mentally and physically drained at the end of the day. After a full day of classes, work, studying, clubs, whatever social time I have--I'm drained. I don't get to do a lot of the things my friends do because of how out of shape I am. I wilt if I exert myself too much. I just want to be thinner at this point. Exercise can wait.
I am there, too. People tell me I will have more energy if I exercise more, but I am so tired. if only I wasn't so tired I would be able to exercise to give me energy ugh! I am told it helps with mood and sleep and weight and energy and health. When you find some time you may want to consider it. You may have resources to exercise on campus.
I am in a very different situation than you. I am much older and do see a doctor for depression. Like was stated above it isn't normal to be that tired0 -
You may have resources to exercise on campus.
If you have feet and a surface, you can walk. That's all you need to do to start. Walk, swim if you have access to a pool, maybe some yoga if you can get to a class. You don't start with the marathon. You start with a quarter-mile walk and work your way up.
The first time the strongest man in the world picked up a barbell, it was probably 20 pounds.0 -
If it were important to you, you would do it. You don't need to make excuses. Just say you don't want to. But, also, don't complain about not being able to do things with your friends because that is your fault.
I will say, if it is THAT bad at your age, you should see a doctor because that isn't normal.
I'm not saying this to be mean, but this poster is kind of right. I'm 37 working 50+ hours a week with 24/7 on-call support, I'm working on my Masters degree, and I'm married but I still train hard 3x / week.
You very well could be wiped out, but you should strongly consider getting a blood panel drawn to evaluate your blood sugar, thyroid, iron, etc, etc. There might be something else going on with you right now, you shouldn't be so tired all the time.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions