I read an interesting study, whats your opinion.

Grimmerick
Grimmerick Posts: 3,342 Member
edited September 26 in Health and Weight Loss
So I was reading this study where they gave women pictures of the different weights and body types and asked them to pick the one they would most like to be like and they also gave men pictures of womens body types and asked them to pick the ones they were most attracted to. While most women chose a body type that was more boyish and thin around 110lbs , most men chose the curvier women around 140 to 150lbs. This is based on a height of 5'5. It's so weird to me that some women work so hard to become rail thin because they think it is more attractive and they actually end up being less attractive to the opposite sex. Guys whats your input on this? Ladies would you rather be very skinny or have a little oomph in your walk away?
«1

Replies

  • jperrysunlover
    jperrysunlover Posts: 96 Member
    I vote for curvy. Straight and thin is not my goal!
  • alexbowser
    alexbowser Posts: 322
    I would rather be curvy, albeit less curvy than I am now.
  • proverbs31chick
    proverbs31chick Posts: 485 Member
    Wow very interesting, I most def don't want to be rail thin. I want to be thick from the waist down, I love Beyonce's shape, she's got thick thighs and hips. You got to have something to work with and bones well that doesn't work. Just my thoughts.
  • clw_888
    clw_888 Posts: 157 Member
    This study doesn't surprise me. I fall into the same category as most of the women from it...would like to be super thin. Obviously not unhealthfully skinny but with very minimal body fat.
  • jennifer3998
    jennifer3998 Posts: 144 Member
    I'd like to be thin but not super skinny. I like looking like I obviously work out. What I want most is a nice toned stomach and no muffin top - it's bikini time!
  • running_mom
    running_mom Posts: 204 Member
    I'd rather be curvy. It's more sexy ; )
  • mummum2
    mummum2 Posts: 415 Member
    Give me curvy all the way, Beyonce and JO LO bodies come to me!!!
  • HolleeERL
    HolleeERL Posts: 313 Member
    I just want to wear jeans and not have my gut spill over. Don't need to stick thin...I looked like that in high school.
  • ket_the_jet
    ket_the_jet Posts: 1,257 Member
    For the "awwwwws," I'll say that I just want a good personality.

    But in reality, I would say someone healthy, of course. Not fake. I guess it is all based on proportions though.

    Oh, and being interesting is a plus. And having a good personality.
    -wtk

    Edit: To whomever said Beyonce over Kate Moss, definitely.
  • b00b0084
    b00b0084 Posts: 729 Member
    I would love to be a size 12-14, and look healthy. I have been over weight most of my life and I have always wanted to be a plus sized model. I am 5'7'' so wearing a size 12 I will still look thin, I want to be thin, but have meat on my bones.
  • JanerZzz
    JanerZzz Posts: 276
    No rail thin here, curves are more attractive...I just don't want the lumpy lumps and muffin tops and all that unpleasantry. But def Beyonce type body vs. Kate Moss. 100%
  • Christie422
    Christie422 Posts: 120 Member
    Curvy definitely! When I see someone who is rail thin I think they look sickly. I am shooting for still having some "meat on my bones".
  • knittnponder
    knittnponder Posts: 1,953 Member
    I don't want to be super skinny. I want to be shapely and have a fit looking body. One with a little muscle on it that doesn't look like I'll blow away at the first strong breeze! (Of course it would take a hurricane to blow me away at the moment!)
  • __flexylexi
    __flexylexi Posts: 154 Member
    I want to be fit, and lean. I dont know what they mean by curvy, but I am in a size 6, would like to end up in a 4/5, and would like to keep my chest. lol. I want to have visible cuts on my biceps, triceps, back etc... but I don't want people to see my ribs lol. So I guess not stick thin, just very lean -- kinda like the typical runner body... but with boobs.. lol
  • nill4me
    nill4me Posts: 682 Member
    Definitely curvy.
  • Helice
    Helice Posts: 1,075 Member
    I Vote for curvy!
    Altho i try desperately hard to be stick thin.

    Im very close to my goal weight, with only some stubborn thigh flab to get rid of..
    But i must say that as stick like as people think i am im still a very curvy woman.

    My waist is currently 24 inches, but my hips are 32 inches, and my breasts are 32DD.
    Which im sure puts me in the 'hourglass' body shape category.
    And i have an even bigger bum, which unfortunately results in me having legs 2 dress sizes bigger than the rest of my body..

    Which is the reason im on a diet...

    But what im trying to say, is as some people might think im skinny.
    I'd argue with anyone who said i wasn't curvy...
    because i am very curvy.
    im just small curvy.

    But is it even possible to be small curvy naturally?
    I dont no..

    Honestly i still feel very fat.
    But my fionce says that its because of the size of my boobs..
    I don't no.

    But i do no that its NOT possible to feel skinny while being curvy.
  • tashjs21
    tashjs21 Posts: 4,584 Member
    Definitely curvy! :love:

    I've always been curvy in a family of the "sticks" so it took me a long time to get comfortable with that.

    Now that I've gained weight (during and after pregnancy) I am even more comfortable with it. I adjusted my goal to my pre-pregnancy weight instead of the "10 more pounds" that I was striving for at the time. I was perfect for my body type at that time and 10 more pounds probably would have made me look sickly.
  • kevanos
    kevanos Posts: 304 Member
    I don`t think women try to look good so that men think they look good; they want to look a good according to what they think looks good.

    That opinion of what women think is attractive tends to be influence by media a lot and social pressure. Its a vortex. Women are influence by media, then other women are influence by those women.
  • StaceyL76
    StaceyL76 Posts: 711 Member
    I want to be fit and toned - athletic looking, not rail thin. Curves are sexy, I just want my curves to come from my muscles not chub.
    I have been too skinny, too fat, and athletic and out of those, I have always been happiest and felt the sexiest looking athletic.
  • Jenn316
    Jenn316 Posts: 21
    When I lose weight I tend to be boyish rather than curvey. When I was younger I wanted to get fat (wish granted!) and then lose it in hopes of keeping some curves but that is just not my body type. :( I really want to get back down to a size 7 and not have a muffin top at all. My weight can flucuate several pounds in one day and it is very annoying. I tend to weigh myself everyday which I know I shouldn't but I am a little obsessive. LOL I carry most of my weight around my middle . Any suggestions for getting rid of my middle jiggle?
  • Drunkadelic
    Drunkadelic Posts: 948 Member
    I, for one, looove my curves. I'm just trying to get a flatter tummy and thinner arms so I feel better in my own skin
  • TiffanyW1014
    TiffanyW1014 Posts: 599 Member
    I would love to be a size 12-14, and look healthy. I have been over weight most of my life and I have always wanted to be a plus sized model. I am 5'7'' so wearing a size 12 I will still look thin, I want to be thin, but have meat on my bones.

    I'm 5'8 and just got into a size 14. I still think it's to big. (for me). I was thinking like a 6 when I started but now I'm going for a 10 (i think). I want my athletic body back then i will be happy!!
  • Drunkadelic
    Drunkadelic Posts: 948 Member
    I don`t think women try to look good so that men think they look good; they want to look a good according to what they think looks good.

    That opinion of what women think is attractive tends to be influence by media a lot and social pressure. Its a vortex. Women are influence by media, then other women are influence by those women.

    This is sooo true! I've told my bf many times that I don't really dress cute to impress him, I do it to impress other girls. Stupid, but true.
  • greeneyed84
    greeneyed84 Posts: 427 Member
    I like having curves so I wouldn't slim down like that. My husband likes curves to. To me it's about being healthy & not having a lot of excess fat. Heidi Klum & Giselle Buendchen have perfect curves
  • JJBRAY85
    JJBRAY85 Posts: 35 Member
    Sounds like the study is spot on and you all ready have OUR opinion! Pointy shoulders, scarecrow thighs and a snake skelton back... blah... thats why i believe strenth training is SOOO important! Put some muscle over them bones and now we're talking!
  • amberaz
    amberaz Posts: 328 Member
    I am definetly not skinny. I don't think I will ever be skinny. My body type does not lend itself to that look. Even after losing pounds AND inches, I am still athletic looking. I would rather look strong and fit than curvy or skinny. Right now, I am trying to put on some more muscle and take off some more fat, it seems to be working and I am achieving the look that I want.
  • tashjs21
    tashjs21 Posts: 4,584 Member
    As a woman watching celebs in the media, I constantly hear myself say 'she needs to eat a sandwich'.

    The media and Hollywood have come up with this ideal that just is NOT attractive.

    Just look at some of the actresses that were acting in the 90's (like Aniston and Jolie) they were so pretty with a little meat on them...now they try to be so rail thin..it is not attractive at all. :sick:

    I am a HUGE fan of Mad Men and Christina Hendricks on there is the curvy beautiful Joan. Well, there was one season where she had lost weight and her face looked awful, she was obviously MEANT to have meat on her. Luckily the next season she was back to her old self. I can only hope the producers stepped in and said...put the weight back on!
  • tashjs21
    tashjs21 Posts: 4,584 Member
    Jennifer--I much prefer her Then. Now her face is too pointy and manish almost.

    asset-18448.jpg


    Angelina, although still super skinny on the left she looked healthier. Now she is just waaaaaaay too bony and her head seems to big for her body. With her large features she needs the muscle there to support it.

    leatherangie4302.jpg

    Christina Hendricks

    Beautiful full face
    hendricksa.jpg

    Not so much
    ex_christina_hendricks_headshot.jpg


    Okay, I am done pick apart the celebs. :laugh:
  • jeffrodgers1
    jeffrodgers1 Posts: 991 Member
    To be honest... For me it's about a way a person carries themselves. I have in my lifetime had partners of varying shapes and sizes... curvy, sleak, petite and voluptuous.

    Sex appeal is an attitude not a measurement. :bigsmile:
  • myofibril
    myofibril Posts: 4,500 Member
    It's so weird to me that some women work so hard to become rail thin because they think it is more attractive and they actually end up being less attractive to the opposite sex. Guys whats your input on this?

    I think the answer is obvious. Now, before anyone drop kicks me for saying this or puts me in a headlock this is obviously just my opinion.

    It's because the prime motivation isn't to attract men. We're just not that important.

    The prime motivation is to look better than other women. You ladies, not all of you but a serious amount, have this weird competition thing going on where the perception is that being slender elevates you in status above other women.

    Sisters are doing it for themselves? I'm not so sure about that....
This discussion has been closed.