Splenda...Good or Bad?
Options
Replies
-
I use splenda as its sucrolose based, rather than aspartame, which my bf doesnt like. I think its been great for me as I used to have alot of sugar, but now ive swapped to splenda.
im sick of all these reports - everything is bad for you these days.
I like it and haven't had any side effects.0 -
Must watch: http://www.foodista.com/blog/2011/06/20/how-splenda-is-deceving-you.
Do Not trust the FDA- most of the members also work for the same corporations that sell the products. True Fact. Most products Do Not get enough testing and get passed. They only see dollar signs, not caring about our health. We have to look out for ourselves.
Splenda, and all artificial sweeteners (including, gasp, aspartame!) have been shown to be fine in humans.0 -
Must watch: http://www.foodista.com/blog/2011/06/20/how-splenda-is-deceving-you.
Do Not trust the FDA- most of the members also work for the same corporations that sell the products. True Fact. Most products Do Not get enough testing and get passed. They only see dollar signs, not caring about our health. We have to look out for ourselves.
Splenda, and all artificial sweeteners (including, gasp, aspartame!) have been shown to be fine in humans.
One of the previous posters mentioned the FDA. They are the ones that allow these products on the market and they are the ones selling the products as well. Just watch the video clip. http://www.foodista.com/blog/2011/06/20/how-splenda-is-deceving-you. I don't believe everything I see on the net, but this is NO hype! Dr Mercola has done A LOT of research on this and also wrote a book on it- Sweet Deception.
Sure, it's fine for humans if you want to chance getting cancer or gaining, YES gaining weight. We all have the right to make our own choices. Watch the video- make your own decision after you've viewed facts from all viewpoints.
I did a post on this a couple days ago: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/269384-how-splenda-is-deceiving-you0 -
One of the previous posters mentioned the FDA. They are the ones that allow these products on the market and they are the ones selling the products as well. Just watch the video clip. http://www.foodista.com/blog/2011/06/20/how-splenda-is-deceving-you. I don't believe everything I see on the net, but Dr Mercola has done A LOT of research on this and also wrote a book on it- Sweet Deception.
Sure, it's fine for humans if you want to chance getting cancer or gaining, YES gaining weight. We all have the right to make our own choices. Watch the video- make your own decision.
Again regarding the FDA - the facts which the FDA uses has been provided by multiple institutions, INCLUDING international institutions across the globe, which have no connection to the FDA. It's a silly justification to blame the FDA when the world of research is at a general consensus on this.
I don't have to watch a video because no scientific research exists that would lead me to believe artificial sweeteners cause cancer or weight gain. If there were sufficient evidence to make that claim, then I'd watch your video. But that evidence doesn't exist, while counter evidence to that claim does exist, making the video baseless in terms of its sources and foundation.
I don't have to watch a video that tells me unicorns are real to tell you the video is wrong. This is no different as there is no proof that exists.0 -
One of the previous posters mentioned the FDA. They are the ones that allow these products on the market and they are the ones selling the products as well. Just watch the video clip. http://www.foodista.com/blog/2011/06/20/how-splenda-is-deceving-you. I don't believe everything I see on the net, but Dr Mercola has done A LOT of research on this and also wrote a book on it- Sweet Deception.
Sure, it's fine for humans if you want to chance getting cancer or gaining, YES gaining weight. We all have the right to make our own choices. Watch the video- make your own decision.
Again regarding the FDA - the facts which the FDA uses has been provided by multiple institutions, INCLUDING international institutions across the globe, which have no connection to the FDA. It's a silly justification to blame the FDA when the world of research is at a general consensus on this.
I don't have to watch a video because no scientific research exists that would lead me to believe artificial sweeteners cause cancer or weight gain. If there were sufficient evidence to make that claim, then I'd watch your video. But that evidence doesn't exist, while counter evidence to that claim does exist, making the video baseless in terms of its sources and foundation.
I don't have to watch a video that tells me unicorns are real to tell you the video is wrong. This is no different as there is no proof that exists.
Continue drinking your kool-aid. Have a nice day0 -
The last time I lost a lot of weight, I followed Dr. Perricone's book. He recommended using Splenda because it has been found to be the safest artificial sweetener on the market. Unless you're eating 100 packets a day, does anybody actually think it's going to harm you in a significant way? If you put a couple packets a day in your oatmeal and coffee, I really don't think you have anything to worry about. It's like with anything...MODERATION.
I don't put a lot of faith in the people who try to scare us from consuming certain things. They all like to claim these companies 'are out to get you and your money' but aren't they doing the same? Shrill books trying to frighten people from foods are looking to make a profit from those books, just as the makers of Splenda are looking to make a profit from their product.
As for Splenda being expensive...just watch out for coupons and sales. Two months ago they put out $3/1 coupons. The very next week Walgreens put the Splenda 100 ct. on sale for 2.99...so guess who got 20 boxes of FREE Splenda???? Me0 -
Continue drinking your kool-aid. Have a nice day
If you want to patronize me, then I'll say I'm willing to bet you have zero understanding of the scientific method, and thus your opinion is completely meaningless when it comes to understanding proper sources. But keep believing your internet videos and doctors who have been suspended for malpractice. Great sources you've got there!0 -
t
Splenda contains chlorine according to "Excitotoxins: The Taste That Kills"
It does, the chlorine replaces hydroxides in the bond. However, the electronegativity of that bond is the reason that we cannot digest it for calories. As such, the chlorine passes out of the body, intact with the molecule, without ever becoming a free chloride ion.
Finally, someone who understands chemistry!0 -
t
Splenda contains chlorine according to "Excitotoxins: The Taste That Kills"
It does, the chlorine replaces hydroxides in the bond. However, the electronegativity of that bond is the reason that we cannot digest it for calories. As such, the chlorine passes out of the body, intact with the molecule, without ever becoming a free chloride ion.
Finally, someone who understands chemistry!
Yeah if you solely focus on the biomechanics of lots of things, it'll sound terrible. But what's the implications of those biomechanics when applied to the realistic intake of those foods? Nothing. That applies to artificial sweeteners, HFCS, saturated/trans fat, etc.
Missing the forest for the trees - whenever someone tells you what the biochemical process is of <food>, ALWAYS ask what the practical implications are of that process for your everyday consumer.0 -
It's really such a personal choice. I'm on a diabetic diet so me adding sugar to my tea or coffee is out. Most of the time I don't use anything in them But sometimes I want it sweetened and I find I like the taste of stevia better for that. I have nothing against Splenda since it's used in so many products. It doesn't bother me. I have a friend who couldn't use Equal because it gave her bladder pains. She switched to Splenda and also uses stevia with no problem. But you have to understand that she puts 7 packets of Splenda in one cup of tea!! Everything in moderation.0
-
I love Splenda. I tried Stevia in the Raw...YUCK! I can't do it. Anything that makes 0% greek yogurt taste worst is not happening for me :noway:0
-
t
Splenda contains chlorine according to "Excitotoxins: The Taste That Kills"
It does, the chlorine replaces hydroxides in the bond. However, the electronegativity of that bond is the reason that we cannot digest it for calories. As such, the chlorine passes out of the body, intact with the molecule, without ever becoming a free chloride ion.
Finally, someone who understands chemistry!
Yeah if you solely focus on the biomechanics of lots of things, it'll sound terrible. But what's the implications of those biomechanics when applied to the realistic intake of those foods? Nothing. That applies to artificial sweeteners, HFCS, saturated/trans fat, etc.
Missing the forest for the trees - whenever someone tells you what the biochemical process is of <food>, ALWAYS ask what the practical implications are of that process for your everyday consumer.
The hard part is when scare tactics are used, from a position of authority, on an audience that is not (nor should required to be) immediately prepared to deal with the data. Chlorine, for example, sounds terrifying (bleach, gas), when it is, in fact, a vital element that appears naturally in cocoa, cheese, beer, etc. Not a danger at all, and is even necessary. Ah well.0 -
The hard part is when scare tactics are used, from a position of authority, on an audience that is not (nor should required to be) immediately prepared to deal with the data. Chlorine, for example, sounds terrifying (bleach, gas), when it is, in fact, a vital element that appears naturally in cocoa, cheese, beer, etc. Not a danger at all, and is even necessary. Ah well.
Also this is the main reason why I think basic research/stats/scientific method courses should be a requirement in high school. EVERYONE in this country would benefit from understanding how to approach claims with a skeptical and empirical thought process. It would be much more difficult to dupe the masses, at very least.0 -
The hard part is when scare tactics are used, from a position of authority, on an audience that is not (nor should required to be) immediately prepared to deal with the data. Chlorine, for example, sounds terrifying (bleach, gas), when it is, in fact, a vital element that appears naturally in cocoa, cheese, beer, etc. Not a danger at all, and is even necessary. Ah well.
Also this is the main reason why I think basic research/stats/scientific method courses should be a requirement in high school. EVERYONE in this country would benefit from understanding how to approach claims with a skeptical and empirical thought process. It would be much more difficult to dupe the masses, at very least.
It would be a different industry if, indeed, everytime someone makes some incredible claim, the target population starts asking for P values and confidence intervals, rather than going for their credit card. It would, at least, be amusing.0 -
AAAgh man, I still use Sweet an Low.:blushing:0
-
It would be a different industry if, indeed, everytime someone makes some incredible claim, the target population starts asking for P values and confidence intervals, rather than going for their credit card. It would, at least, be amusing.0
-
I stay away from refined sugars and fake sugars. Splenda, in particular, caused me to have horrific kidney troubles. My doctor said that he sees that all the time in people that regularly use Splenda.
I use small amounts of honey and whatever sweetness that is naturally found in fruits. BUT---I'm also pretty paleo. It's changed my entire life and my body.0 -
Stevia is what I have started using, it's natural and tastes just fine.0
-
If it's made with chemicals it's not from nature. Truvia is made from the stevia plant and has no chemical additives. Splenda is chemical city! Might as well have Aspartame...0
-
If it's made with chemicals it's not from nature. Truvia is made from the stevia plant and has no chemical additives. Splenda is chemical city! Might as well have Aspartame...
Truvia is highly refined, and has large amounts of added erythritol.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.4K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions