getting teary eyed... 30 days in and now gaining.

DANCERPURPLE

bump

katcod1522

I would cut the alcohol! And no processed anything. ALL whole foods. I have maybe one beer a month...But Im a runner..and just cant drink like I used too Stay strong! Head up!

NB_Lady

Hang in there- you've done a awesome for such a short time and your body could be adjusting to the changes. From my personal experience, sodium is a big issue and like others have mentioned could be part of the problem.
Remember this is a lifestyle choice, so I'd try to stay within my calories and exercise but not totally give up the foods you enjoy. I personally enjoy a glass of wine with my meal at the end of a long hectic day, and in order for ME to succeed at this life time choice, I don't want to feel like I'm in denial mode.

Good luck!

Maryfullofgrace

I agree with everyone here. Cut out all your alcohol. Lower your sodium. Watch the magic happen.

TripleJ3

I agree, 600 seems like its way to high, even at 4mph. You don't weigh too much more than I do and in 30 min I probably burn 200. People do Zumba or Spinning and burn 600 or less in an hour.

Weigh your food.

Be honest with yourself. I know when my weight was creeping or stalling, I wasn't being 100% honest with myself. Small bites here and there turned into lots of bigger bites.

Try eating just half of your exercise calories. Stick with it. I would be on track for a few days, a week then not see the changes I felt I should, then blow it. I weigh/measure about once a month. My losses are small but now I see them. My hardest road block is my mind. I feel like I work so hard at this and I eat so healthy that I should look better and be farther along then I am. I get frustrated and think screw it.

My losses may be slow and small, but I was on a plateau for over a year. I ate more like everyone suggested and gained 5lbs in August. Finally I have lost that and hopefully I will continue to see my small yet huge to me changes by continuing doing what I'm doing.

Good luck!

sheltielover

Thanks again.
Also, is there a balance b/t sodium and potassium? my husband tells me that basically the potassium should extract some water. do you all watch potassium?

also, i just read out loud all your comments to my 178 lb husband who is a marathon runner and is in amazing shape.
he wants me to post that he's been telling me the same things- cut out the sodium and limit alcohol and up the protein-- but that I didnt listen to him

he's sitting here smirking! i guess its easier to hear from strangers

sheltielover

Sheltie,
Hang in there, the goal is not to give up, this happens to all of us at some point or another. Sometimes sooner than others. There are a few bits of advice that I can offer however that might help you.

1) Change your workout routine. Everyone has the same problem, our body are designed to adapt and overcome adversity. If you have been putting all of your effort into your workout and you do the same or similar exercises everyday your body will identify what you are doing and it will find a way to work around it. I try to change my exercises up as often as I can. For example, if you are using walking as your exercise, instead of walking for 30 minutes try increasing the speed (even if slowly) for part of the time. Every 10 minutes you walk try to jog for 2 - 3 of those minutes. If you work out at the gym you can try my personal favorite, the elliptical. A lot of people tell me they "hate" the elliptical, but I have learned to call it my friend because of how many variables it offers and because I can use it to push myself. Try a different programmed pattern every day. To get around my issues, I did Manual settings on Monday (30 minutes of Level 17.. try it lower than that to start with, I started at level 8 and worked my way up to 17 over a course of 3 months, keeping my heart rate at 165 - 170 the entire time) Tuesday I did the Hill setting (again 30 minutes and do what you can to keep your heart rate up at about 165 , but don't try to go much above 170) Wednesday "Personal Trainer Mode" It makes you change directions and tells you to use your arms to push or pull or just use your legs. Thursday, back to manual mode, Friday "Around the world" Various hill settings. Saturday & Sunday rest. (5 days a week isn't for everyone, but it has helped me tremendously... find what works for you and go with that). No matter what kind of exercise you do, by the end of 30 minutes you should have broken enough of a sweat that it looks like you took a quick sprint outside in a downpour and back again.

2) Change your tracking info on your diary. I see that you use the default settings. Try going to Setting > Diary Info and changing what you are tracking. For me I changed mine to reflect Calories / Carbs / Protein / Sugar / Sodium. This helps because While everything looked great for a while as soon as I added "Sugar" to mine, I realized that there were days when I was going way overboard on sugars even though everything else looked good.

3) Take a multi-vitamin. It sounds like a strange suggestion, but sometimes your body resists change because it is not getting enough of one kind of vitamin, it will resist you in an effort to protect itself if its not getting something that it needs. Adding vitamins to your diet will increase the odds that your body will burn off everything that you put in and expunge everything that is excess. If you give it more nutritional suppliments than it needs it won't hang on to things that it doesn't need.

4) Sleep. The hardest thing to acquire is enough sleep. Once you change your workout routine, set yourself some goals. The first kinds of goals that I find make things better are "pleasure goals" I don't know anyone that doesn't like getting extra rest. So make a plan, chart everything out so that you can accomplish the things that you need to get done, and set yourself a goal even if its only 1 night a week to start to get a full 8 - 9 hours of sleep. While this is difficult (I know I have a 3 year old that wakes up at 5:30am everyday) you can make this happen by planning it out ahead of time. No matter what find one day that you can tell yourself "I'll be in bed by 9pm and awake by 7am". Its hard to do, but if you can get at least one day of rest your body will recover better.

5) Keep in touch with MFP friends. We all have our own experiences and we are all in the same boat here. Having a strong support group to keep things going is the best motivator and help you will find. Just like you did when you posted this topic, ask for help. Ask for suggestions. Those of us that have been where you are will not hesitate to offer whatever support we can to make your journey a successful one.

Good luck, keep up the hard work. You can do this!

-Ryan

thank you for taking all the time to type this Ryan. I appreciate your insight.

AlsDonkBoxSquat

Thanks again.
Also, is there a balance b/t sodium and potassium? my husband tells me that basically the potassium should extract some water. do you all watch potassium?

also, i just read out loud all your comments to my 178 lb husband who is a marathon runner and is in amazing shape.
he wants me to post that he's been telling me the same things- cut out the sodium and limit alcohol and up the protein-- but that I didnt listen to him

he's sitting here smirking! i guess its easier to hear from strangers

I don't track potassium, for potassium I just listen to my body. When my legs start to cramp I eat sweet potatoes for 2 days and they loosen back up again. Drinking a crap ton of water will actually help with sodium water weight, but really the trick is to keep it at a healthier level over all. Not saying that soup every once in a while is going to kill you on water weight, but high sodium processed foods on a regular basis will. As far as a correlation between sodium and potassium and water . . . I have no clue.

psuLemon

Everyone, I just spent 20 minutes reading thru all of your knowledgeable comments.
Now I am crying- not from being frustrated, but b/c I feel so supported.

Thank you--- I am going to make some slight changes, as all of you suggested.
I can't tell you how much I appreciate you taking the time out of your lives to help a stranger.

Here's just part of the changes I'm going to make
1. cut the alcohol to once a week (I've noticed it has creeped up again)
2. cut the processed/high carb/high sodium foods-- get back to more REAL food
3. change up my workouts- push myself a bit more than just walking at 4.0
4. Start taking a multivitamin

And yes-- I do own a food scale- I've weighed everything religiously in the last month.
I may even adjust MFP to only lose 1 lb a week and up my calories.

It was hard for me to open my diary to "the world"- but I needed other sets of eyes to see what I hadnt been seeing!

Its all experimenting and finding out what works best for my body, right ?

Thank you all again- I've taken notes and am going to follow your advice!

And increase your calories!

sheltielover

A BIG THANK YOU TO ALL OF YOU FOR YOUR HONESTY THIS WEEK. IVE MADE SOME SERIOUS CHANGES- THE BIGGEST HAS BEEN UPPING MY CALORIES TO STRIVE FOR A 1 LB LOSS INSTEAD OF 2, REMOVING THE ALCOHOL, REMOVING THE HIGH SODIUM AND PROCESSED FOODS.

DUE TO THIS-- IM IN SHOCK- THE WEIGHT HAS MELTED OFF THIS WEEK!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH AGAIN- THIS IS SUCH A SUPPORTIVE AND NON JUDGEMENTAL PLACE AND I AM SO GRATEFUL TO HAVE FOUND IT!!

AIMEE

any advice is appreciated:

ive been on mfp since mid sept and had lost a total of 15 lbs - down to 185... this past week the weight's been slowly creeping up- and today I weighed in at 188. I'm dumbfounded.
--- I'm eating my calories--- have gone over 1 time by like 80 cals
---I'm working out - not daily, but about 3 times a week - on sunday I walked for an hour and burned 600 cals-
---I'm drinking my water- even somedays getting 10 glasses in
---It's not "that time of the month"... even when that happened I only gained like 1 lb and then lost it quickly

i've made my diary public b/c I'd like some frank honest comments to get me thru this.
I refuse to throw in the towel, but it gets hard to stay on plan and then see this type of gain for no reason.

here is my diary:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/food/diary/sheltielover

Aimee

lacroyx

yay! congrats! :drinker:

DavidRuthstrom

I KNOW THE FEELING - and it sucks. Here's what turned me around so I've lost almost 50 pounds in 3+ months:

The Paleo Solution by Robb Wolf

Fixed more than my weight problem, too. Go to Amazon.com and less than $10 for the Kindle version you can read on your PC, you'll be amazed at the science of finally knowing what we're supposed to eat, and why eating other things makes us sick and fat. Email me at wdww99@yahoo.com if you have questions. Good luck.

psuLemon

Congrats Aimee.

Maryfullofgrace

Congratulations!!! I hope that your weight loss continues!

onewhodiets

I'm so glad you wrote this, because I just started a few weeks ago and I lost five pounds and then was compelled to search using the unhappy term "gaining for no reason". I really don't get why this is happening to me, but it is reassuring to read about others and the responses you got were insightful. There is no way I'm giving up (although I'm not going to updata my weight until it goes down again!) and I assume you've been bolstered too, by others on the site.