One big meal a day?
Replies
-
Maybe I should clarify what starvation actually looks like
http://johnbarban.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/Starvation-subject-minnesota-experiment.jpg0 -
I dnt know how any1 can think that starving themselves all day and binging at night is ok. Ur a nutrition student, but i'm a nurse and I worked at an eating disorder facility for 2 1/2 yrs. side by side with registered dietician, and my uncle is a certified nutritionist, and non of them would agree, so if ur a student and being taught its ok, maybe u need to look into a new program. anyways, to the OP, u obviously have 2 make the choice, just make sure you research, and make sure to make an informed decision. good luck
Nurses are not food scientists. When did they get their degree? They may need to go back to school for a while if they think it has a metabolic advantage.
My school program is great, one of the best in Iowa. No need for a new program.
Once again. MY metabolism works perfectly. I eat plenty, look great, feel great, and am not starving by any means.0 -
Apparently I am starving myself too:
Frail and unhealthy I know.0 -
I don't think I could do it because I really HATE being hungry. I do eat more than 1/2 my calories at night, but I couldn't go all day with nothing and be happy. But I don't think it would affect my metabolism or weight loss/maintenance as long as it was the same calories overall. It would just affect my mood.
But there seems to be 2 separate discussions in this thread. One is the OP who mentions eating only one meal a day, and the other is restricting by hours (only eating for 5 - 8 hours per day). Those would be very differnt styles of eating.0 -
I dnt know how any1 can think that starving themselves all day and binging at night is ok. Ur a nutrition student, but i'm a nurse and I worked at an eating disorder facility for 2 1/2 yrs. side by side with registered dietician, and my uncle is a certified nutritionist, and non of them would agree, so if ur a student and being taught its ok, maybe u need to look into a new program. anyways, to the OP, u obviously have 2 make the choice, just make sure you research, and make sure to make an informed decision. good luck
In the nicest way possible, you are presenting misinformation. Meal frequency has aboslutely nothing to do with metabolic rate. Thermic effect of food is a function of macronutrient composition (to a small effect) and caloric intake totals. It is not frequency dependent. Fasting periods can reach 48-72 hours without detrimental effect.
^ this and studies have shown an increase to metabolic rate during short term fasts (up to around 72hrs i think) due to i believe the increase in plasma norepinephrine0 -
bump to read later0
-
I don't think I could do it because I really HATE being hungry. I do eat more than 1/2 my calories at night, but I couldn't go all day with nothing and be happy. But I don't think it would affect my metabolism or weight loss/maintenance as long as it was the same calories overall. It would just affect my mood.
But there seems to be 2 separate discussions in this thread. One is the OP who mentions eating only one meal a day, and the other is restricting by hours (only eating for 5 - 8 hours per day). Those would be very differnt styles of eating.
I'm talking about fasting in General. I fast 24 hours 2-3 days a week. Some people do shorter fast. But studies and information I have read is you reap the most benefit from 16-30 hours.0 -
Just started IF about a week ago, it has been amazing. I do find that I am still learning about how to not go totally crazy when I break my fast and eat everything in sight. However, you are right, the large meal and satisfaction that come with it rules.0
-
To clarify I eat a normal meal 5-7 hundred calories when I break the fast. I am assuming that's not binging.0
-
Just started IF about a week ago, it has been amazing. I do find that I am still learning about how to not go totally crazy when I break my fast and eat everything in sight. However, you are right, the large meal and satisfaction that come with it rules.
Have you noticed how much more vividly you can taste the food?0 -
I have done all my cals in a 6-8 hour window and I have had one big meal for the day.
Getting 1300 cals in one meal isnt hard IMO0 -
This is not a good idea, it wll drastically slow your metabolism, which will initially cause you to gain weight, and will causeyu to lose weight at a drastically slower rate. Plus once you start eating normally again, youill gaineight back, bcuz ur of ur slow metabolism, and your body storing fat. also your body needs fuel to run the day. think of your body like a car, you couldn't rip and run all day on an empty tank, with the intention to fill up at the end of the day. you wouldn't make it
This is a great idea, it will drastically increase your metabolism, which will initially cause you to lose weight and will cause you to lose weight at a drastically quicker rate. Plus once you start eating normally again, you'll lose even more because of your supercharged metabolism and all your muscle. Also your body needs 8 cups of water to run daily.Think of your body like a motorcycle. You can speed down the highway doing wheelies but, if a cop sees you; you'll go to jail.
BAM Broscience at it's finest!
Brofist!
………..
……………….__
…………./´¯/‘…’/´¯¯`·¸
………./‘/…/…./……./¨¯\
……..(’(…´…´…. ¯~/‘…’)
………\……………..‘…../
……….’’…\………. _.·´
…………\…………..(0 -
Wow. I love this thread. This is how I prefer to eat and have been forcing myself to eat all day, every day, and feeling crappy at night. I can go back to what my body likes best.0
-
Shenanigans and broscience here.
broscience - I love you! HAHAHA thats awesome0 -
Wow. I love this thread. This is how I prefer to eat and have been forcing myself to eat all day, every day, and feeling crappy at night. I can go back to what my body likes best.
fosho0 -
I really think it is a personal thing - if you want to fast all day and consume all your daily calories in one meal - do it! If it works for you, who are any of us to tell someone they're "wrong"?
For me personally, I do eat every couple hours. I couldn't care less if it helps my metabolism - it a) makes me feel better because my blood sugar is stabilized (I get jittery, nauseous, headachy and completely unreasonable when my blood sugar drops too low) b) it helps to control the desire to binge eat because I am constantly feeding my body food. I don't allow myself to get too hungry anymore - which is what leads to me consume an entire personal cake or whatever.
It is all about calories in/calories out - your body doesn't give a crap WHEN you eat them, as long as you eat them. It is an individual choice.
BTW, I ALWAYS eat my largest meal later at night.0 -
Cliff Richards only eats one meal a day- FACT. And he's not a chunker because I saw him on TV talking about it recently- FACT. And I didn't watch it intentionally, I was just flicking through the channels- FACT.
I say just do what suits you. I don't eat breakfast, but i do eat 2 meals a day usually- brunch and dinner. so i have 2 higher calorie meals rather than 3 smaller calorie ones. and i'm not dying yet (well, i am but only in the sense that we're all dying from the moment we're born, man).0 -
Bump for later. Broscience rocks, lol.0
-
On big meal can work and so can multiple meals.
It's the macros and total energy consumed that matters most.
It's important,however, to realize that your body makes adjustments based upon eating patterns (hormones/gerlin/leptin) . It trigger s responses like hunger and saiety/fullness. In bro terms, f you go with multiple meals your body will tell you hey man you skipped a meal it's time to chow. Likewise for a single/ if approach
From my POV pick something that you can stick with given your schedule.
Be open to other approaches - experiment for yourself after doing sufficient research.
At the leaner levels, a cyclical approach is awesome for shredding down.
Don't diet all of the time!! The more aggressive the caloric deficit the more necessary the refeed
-Grunt0 -
Once a year in March for nineteen days straight, us adult Baha'is fast from sunup to sundown (as long as we're not pregnant, sick or traveling). It's something like the Christian season of lent for us. During this time, I usually eat a very small meal before sunup and the rest of my food in the evening. I find that it's difficult to fit in before bedtime the variety of food and calories I usually eat the rest of the year so I end up eating less the more time goes on. By the end of the nineteen days, I've usually lost an unwanted ten pounds, feel a lot better, and am eating much more conscious of what I really need to eat versus what I feel like eating. I've also asked my doctor about this way of eating and he saw no problem with it. I've been doing this every Spring for 13 years and find I look forward to it as I know how great I'll feel in the end. I've actually been thinking about doing it now to lose weight just as you're doing, if I can maintain it...0
-
Fact: I just learned a hell of a lot with this thread.
Thanks for those of you who actually know what you are talking about. I can go back to eating the way I used to eat and not feel bad about it.0 -
This is not a good idea, it wll drastically slow your metabolism, which will initially cause you to gain weight, and will causeyu to lose weight at a drastically slower rate. Plus once you start eating normally again, youill gaineight back, bcuz ur of ur slow metabolism, and your body storing fat. also your body needs fuel to run the day. think of your body like a car, you couldn't rip and run all day on an empty tank, with the intention to fill up at the end of the day. you wouldn't make it
This is a great idea, it will drastically increase your metabolism, which will initially cause you to lose weight and will cause you to lose weight at a drastically quicker rate. Plus once you start eating normally again, you'll lose even more because of your supercharged metabolism and all your muscle. Also your body needs 8 cups of water to run daily.Think of your body like a motorcycle. You can speed down the highway doing wheelies but, if a cop sees you; you'll go to jail.
BAM Broscience at it's finest!0 -
On big meal can work and so can multiple meals.
It's the macros and total energy consumed that matters most.
It's important,however, to realize that your body makes adjustments based upon eating patterns (hormones/gerlin/leptin) . It trigger s responses like hunger and saiety/fullness. In bro terms, f you go with multiple meals your body will tell you hey man you skipped a meal it's time to chow. Likewise for a single/ if approach
From my POV pick something that you can stick with given your schedule.
Be open to other approaches - experiment for yourself after doing sufficient research.
At the leaner levels, a cyclical approach is awesome for shredding down.
Don't diet all of the time!! The more aggressive the caloric deficit the more necessary the refeed
-Grunt
This...made a lot more sense... Thank you. Things should be explained in bro terms on here more.0 -
Over feeding is anabolic
I'm not very fat and eat in the 4-5,000 cals on a full day of rest / no workouts.
Bro science - I am my own test subject0 -
I have noticed how much better food tastes and I love that I can have heartier portions. Or, if someone asks me to grab dinner with them I'm no longer thinking "Doh, I wish I had known earlier and skipped breakfast". It has given me a lot of freedom. I think I need to work on pre-logging my meals, though to help with my tendency to eat and eat and eat when I break my fast. When I have a meal prepared and set aside I do better. I think it has to do with being able to eat, know I had 5-600 calories, relax for a minute while my body works it all out and then eat again a few hours later.
Does anyone have opinions on BCAAs, or IF while running longer 10+mi distances?
Basically though, I feel better, more in control and I think once my body fully adjusts I will be able to eat reasonably. As a side note I don't think IF has caused me to want to binge, this is an old issue that I am trying to use IF (and therapy) to regulate. I don't think IF promotes binging. Lots of normal, healthy, but hearty ;-) meals can hit 1000+ calories without being a binge.0 -
BCAA is debatable.
The candy versions (extend) are pricey and if you are getting sufficient protien you are ok/not worth it?
However, when I run a large deficit and/or IF -- I use bulk BCAA.
Taste is nasty but from my own experiments I feel less hungry and seem to have better recovery.
Also BCAA triggers a slight insulin response0 -
I too eat 80-90% of my daily calories in a 3 hour window. I love it!!0
-
This thread has convinced me to give IF a try. I already prefer to have one larger meal and I get all panicky when I approach 4PM and I only have 400 calories left. I'd love to experiment with eating my calories between 4-7 in the evening.0
-
I would read the stuff on leangains.com it really spells out the science for you and gives you some tips on how to best approach it, like what to break your fast with and such. It was a lot of info but really helpful.0
-
Well, i guess it already has been said but.. once again it doesn't matter how many meals you eat per day.. 2000 cals are 2000 cals whether you had 5 meals or 1 meal..
It depends on what you prefer and whether or not you can fast during the day.. That's it.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions