Going to bed hungry

lovelylovebug

Whenever I have a "good day" more often than not I go to bed hungry. Not STARVING, though, just a little tummy rumbles and a higher urge to eat things. This is sometimes a battle: not to snack before bed. My question is this: how many of you go to bed hungry in order to achieve your calorie intake for the day? What do you think about going to bed hungry and how do you feel when it happens to you? Sometimes I think the only way I see weight loss is when I am hungry at night. I read somewhere that it is good to go to bed hungry because it means your body is using your fat stores.

I'm curious to see everyone's opinion on this.

coolchick03270

I have had the exact same thoughts! I have been going to bed hungry every night for the past week- since I joined MFP, really started eating healthy/low cals/etc. I'm hungry right now. I have no idea if it's the right thing to do, but I actually feel better going to bed hungry. I try my best to not eat after 7pm too.

TaraTLC83

Sometimes the body mistakes thirst for hungry... you could try drinking a glass of milk, or tea or something. Or, you could just eat something like a grapefruit or an orange. Something that isn't too heavy. I love sitting on the couch peeling a grapefruit to nibble on in the evenings.

smbyrd13

I agree with you, when I have a "good" day...i.e. within or below my calorie limit, I almost always go to bed hungry. I just know what I have a nice, healthy, and filling breakfast to look forward to in the morning. I figure that I don't notice hunger when I'm sleeping so it's not a big deal for me and it's just less calories I'm consuming. It's hard because my husband always has a soda and snack sometime around 9pm....but I've gotten to the point where snacking after dinner isn't an option for me.

michelledyan

I didn't know the body confused thirst with hunger. Thanks for the post!

Shyloh1

I've never gone to bed hungry.

I always try and eat all my calories and get enough protein in my diet to keep me full. If I'm hungry,I eat and have always had a bedtime snack. I just make sure it's healthy and it fits into my macros for the day.

Edit: If you go over your macros...don't worry about it! You can make up for it later...

Semperfione

Hi lovelylovebug, first I am not so sure you should go to bed early hungry. Your body does need to be tricked into thinking your starving it again, but if you kept an even amount of calories, then the next day drop on calories, stagger them and it will happen.

I too do what you do. Go to bed early hungry. I don't think its healthy. But then I think if it works for us tonight then we need to fess up and let each other know if it worked. Just be careful to not get it back..

Wishng you the best, keep us posted...

Rob

Cslicemarie

Ooooh. I hate that feeling! I've tried drinking water to help curb the hunger but then I always have to pee in the middle of the night.

stephabef

I usually try to go to bed at least slightly hungry... or rather, not full. I get awful nightmares if I eat before I go to sleep

amh1974

I feel the same way! I hate going to bed hungry but I do it. I hate being hungry at all, ever! I get cranky. :grumble: Last night I was hungry and ate 2 saltine crackers and 5 baby carrots in an attempt to settle the grumbling. When that didn't work I drank a bottle of water. That didn't really help either because I was up running to the bathroom all night! Honestly, I just give in many times and then I feel like crap that I did. If you have any earth shattering answers please let me know. I'm always looking for friends to keep me on track!


Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Weight Loss Tools

lovelylovebug

Sometimes the body mistakes thirst for hungry... you could try drinking a glass of milk, or tea or something. Or, you could just eat something like a grapefruit or an orange. Something that isn't too heavy. I love sitting on the couch peeling a grapefruit to nibble on in the evenings.

Yeah, I knew about that. But I can usually tell the difference between my body wanting to eat because it's thirsty (I will crave things like apples or cold things), hunger because of boredom and actual hunger. It's always good to drink a full glass of water before actually eating anything and waiting ten minutes to see if it goes away, because if it isn't real hunger then the urge should subside. Another way to test real hunger is to gauge what you want to eat... if a bowl of steamed veggies and chicken doesn't appeal to you (or any other healthy thing), then you aren't "really" hungry.

Spazbme

ah hahaha! I kept reading thinking that and then saw your post. Same problem I have. I worked out this morning and didn't drink enough water today. That's probably why I have a headache and literally don't feel good I'm so hungry. I hate going to bed on a full stomach though and there is nothing satisfying in the house anyway. All I can think is that staggering my calories might be better for my glucose levels... I seem to be very sensitive to my blood-sugar levels, I get nauseated although I'm not diabetic. weird, but thanks for all the posts, it's helpful to read.

lookpretty

I know people say not to eat after some time or another but I emotionally cant do it, if I go to bed hungry I cry, I need to eat before I go to sleep, I dont eat carbs in the day but I do before bed, I feel like my body has all nite to digest it, I feel like I sleep better if Ive eaten and wake up feeling better, I tend to not eat breakfast but if I dont eat before I go to sleep I wake up moody and craving

Pebble321

If you are actually hungry and not just craving chocolate (maybe that's just me!) then I find that a few almonds is a good snack before bed. I find that having just 4 or 5 almonds is enough to quieten down my tummy and I go to sleep feeling better. If this takes me a few cals over for the day, I don't think it's a problem.

Elizabeth_C34

It takes a while to get your eating habits in your calorie range AND fulfilling. Don't be afraid to go over by 100-200 calories if you are hungry.

girllimberlost

Having something to eat before bed is the best way to keep your blood sugar stable through the night. Putting your body into starvation mode will be the best way to GAIN weight. Keeping your blood sugar stable will help you burn extra fat.

You should be eating 6 meals a day, and one of them should be within a couple of hours of going to bed. The meal before bed should be complete, protein, healthy fat, and complex carbohydrate. It should also be low calorie, around 100-120.

Dunkirk

Would having your evening meal later help?

Crystal_Pistol

Whenever I am hungry, I eat something. To hell with calories- I can make that up later. I have actually woke up in the middle of the night (sometimes like 2am), felt hungry, and eaten rice cakes and almond butter. When I had a 12am to 4am diary category, all kinds of strange things appeared there.

In summary- I'm not doing anything hungry, definitely not trying to sleep with a rumbling stomach.

Shyloh1

Whenever I am hungry, I eat something. To hell with calories- I can make that up later. I have actually woke up in the middle of the night (sometimes like 2am), felt hungry, and eaten rice cakes and almond butter. When I had a 12am to 4am diary category, all kinds of strange things appeared there.

In summary- I'm not doing anything hungry, definitely not trying to sleep with a rumbling stomach.

I like your way of thinking!

princesspeach577

If I'm hungry late at night, I try to drink something warm like tea. It's pretty filling and helps you not go over your calories.

LeanerBeef

I don't think there is any need to go to bed hungry. Try to have a healthy snack an hour or 2 before going to bed.

One healthy snack that someone suggested to me & I love = cut up an apple, a teaspoon of peanut butter, and a half cup of low fat/calorie ice cream. It's pretty awesome, fills ya up, and makes you feel like you had a pretty awesome snack.

Guaranteed to conquer bed time hunger pains. :bigsmile:

lovelylovebug

Whenever I am hungry, I eat something. To hell with calories- I can make that up later. I have actually woke up in the middle of the night (sometimes like 2am), felt hungry, and eaten rice cakes and almond butter. When I had a 12am to 4am diary category, all kinds of strange things appeared there.

In summary- I'm not doing anything hungry, definitely not trying to sleep with a rumbling stomach.

Lol so what day did you post your middle of the night snacks to? The day prior or the next day? Technically it would be the next day, but I'm just curious...

Crystal_Pistol

I have actually woke up in the middle of the night

Is it strange that my grammar disturbs me? I find that I try to speak more "loosely" in the forum and then hate reading my posts.
Random thought I felt like sharing.

hatravers

at the start of everyday i have a bowl of oatmeal made with water and add a 35 cal yogurt into it (to make it creamier) and 1 tsp of honey, i register it in my diary and add another bowl for supper that way i know i wont go to bed hungary

BluenoserChick

I've discovered if I eat past 7pm, because of my poor metabolism, I end up with indigestion and end up chewing antacids before bed. Coupled with that discovery and the new calorie monitoring, I find I'm going to bed hungry more often than not. I just drink a Coke Zero as a 'snack/treat' and deal with it. Better hungry than suffering indigestion and waking up through the night. To each his own though.

GreatSetOfBrains

I tend to be wy under one day related to only god knows. But I am often 100 cals or so over from the midnight snack pack. That's I need to simmer the tummy. Of half a PB&J. My fav, yummy!

hrharris70

I don't know if this will help but, I usually eat a protien and veggie dinner about 3 hours before bedtime then fit a short workout in there somewhere. By the time it wears off I'm already asleep. I prefer to wake up hungry than go to bed hungry. That sounds like a punishment, " Going to bed hungry". : )

bdur76

Going to bed hungry for me is a reminder of my victory and strength over food for the day. I'm not famished at bedtime, but I do get some stomach grumbles and feel hungry. I go to bed most days feeling totally strong and empowered that I am in control of my eating decisions and that food no longer controls or dictates itself to me. Sounds lame I'm sure, but I love it!

dovesgate

When I first started on MFP I had a few nights that I went to bed hungry or I'd be waiting for midnight to roll around so I could sneak off to the kitchen for a snack that wouldn't put me over my calories. I don't do that anymore. I had to learn the hard way to leave myself enough calories for a good, filling dinner or an after-dinner snack because I dislike feeling hungry. It isn't very relaxing when my tummy is rumbling.

lovelylovebug

Would having your evening meal later help?

Probably yeah, but the only issue with that is I eat lunch 1-2pm most days and I can't wait past 6 to eat dinner! Then I go to bed at around 10 without snacking (most nights).

significance

I save a lot of my calories for the evening and have dinner fairly late so I have a good dinner to look forward to all day and don't go to bed hungry. I don't mind being a little hungry during the day - there's still something to look forward to later - but if I find it really demoralising to finish the day hungry.