Water/Tea confusion

Options
1356

Replies

  • chicklidell
    chicklidell Posts: 275
    Options
    Personally....to me:
    If we are counting it as "hydration"
    And caffeine "dehydrates"

    This is a no brainer........don't cheat by using tea, coffee, and soda as a "hydrating" count.
    Drink WATER!


    This is what I learned going to school as an EMT.

    If you went to school as an EMT and they taught you this, you should ask for a refund. This is wrong. Caffeine does not dehydrate.
  • fteale
    fteale Posts: 5,310 Member
    Options
    Personally....to me:
    If we are counting it as "hydration"
    And caffeine "dehydrates"

    This is a no brainer........don't cheat by using tea, coffee, and soda as a "hydrating" count.
    Drink WATER!


    This is what I learned going to school as an EMT.

    It isn't cheating. Coffee tea etc doesn't dehydrate. They hydrate you. They are mostly water. CAFFEINE dehydrates you, but the amount in tea, coffee and coke isn't enough to achieve that.
  • Fit_Canuck
    Fit_Canuck Posts: 788 Member
    Options
    Personally....to me:
    If we are counting it as "hydration"
    And caffeine "dehydrates"

    This is a no brainer........don't cheat by using tea, coffee, and soda as a "hydrating" count.
    Drink WATER!


    This is what I learned going to school as an EMT.

    You are absolutely correct, it won't dehydrate you per say, it's a diuretic and will cause minimal fluid loss and then your body will kick in and retain fluid to compensate. You'd have to basically overdose on caffeine to cause massive fluid loss.

    If you went to school as an EMT and they taught you this, you should ask for a refund. This is wrong. Caffeine does not dehydrate.
  • StacySkinny
    StacySkinny Posts: 984 Member
    Options
    I'm sorry but I just can't see counting soda pop as water. Drinking 8 cups of Pepsi or Coca-Cola does not equal 8 cups of water and shouldn't be treated at such. That's just IMO though.
  • ginnylee74
    ginnylee74 Posts: 398 Member
    Options
    [This has probably been asked before, but I didn't see it.]

    I've heard it both ways... no, tea (hot or iced) is not the same as water, and yes, tea (hot or iced) is exactly the same as water. I've never been much of a water drinker, but I do drink a lot of tea - unsweetened, throughout the day. Since all I'm doing is flavoring the water without sweetening it, can I count it as part of the recommended daily 8 cups of water?

    Thanks!

    I'll bet you didn't realize this would cause such a discussion. It's kinda funny. It's almost like the saying (parapharsing) If you want to keep your friends as friends, Never talk religion or politics. So I guess never talk about What Counts as Water and What Doesn't.
  • staceyb2003
    staceyb2003 Posts: 203 Member
    Options
    My three rules:
    1) Drink whatever you want. Whether it is caffeinated or not.
    2) Track the liquids, both in the water count and the food diary (if drinking something other than water that has calories, sodium, etc).
    3) Drink enough of anything to make sure your pee is close to clear.

    Boom.
    Life simplified.

    I like this!
  • fteale
    fteale Posts: 5,310 Member
    Options
    I'm sorry but I just can't see counting soda pop as water. Drinking 8 cups of Pepsi or Coca-Cola does not equal 8 cups of water and shouldn't be treated at such. That's just IMO though.

    In the case of coke, perhaps not as they add a ton of stuff to have a really strong diuretic effect and make you drink more. But in general, it really does count, you just have to add in the massive whack of extra calories you get with those kind of drinks.
  • MercuryBlue
    MercuryBlue Posts: 886 Member
    Options
    My three rules:
    1) Drink whatever you want. Whether it is caffeinated or not.
    2) Track the liquids, both in the water count and the food diary (if drinking something other than water that has calories, sodium, etc).
    3) Drink enough of anything to make sure your pee is close to clear.

    Boom.
    Life simplified.

    Boom. Lawyered. ;)
  • ScatteredThoughts
    ScatteredThoughts Posts: 3,562 Member
    Options

    "Eight 8-ounce glasses of water a day. Another approach to water intake is the "8 x 8 rule" — drink eight 8-ounce glasses of water a day (about 1.9 liters). The rule could also be stated, "Drink eight 8-ounce glasses of fluid a day," as all fluids count toward the daily total. Although the approach really isn't supported by scientific evidence, many people use this easy-to-remember rule as a guideline for how much water and other fluids to drink."

    I see that is from the Mayo Clinic article for which you gave a link. It should be also noted that the same article has this bit of information.

    "Beyond the tap: Other sources of water

    Although it's a great idea to keep water within reach at all times, you don't need to rely only on what you drink to meet your fluid needs. What you eat also provides a significant portion of your fluid needs. On average, food provides about 20 percent of total water intake. For example, many fruits and vegetables, such as watermelon and tomatoes, are 90 percent or more water by weight.

    In addition, beverages such as milk and juice are composed mostly of water. Even beer, wine and caffeinated beverages — such as coffee, tea or soda — can contribute, but these should not be a major portion of your daily total fluid intake. Water is still your best bet because it's calorie-free, inexpensive and readily available. "
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member
    Options
    Caffeine does not dehydrate. If it started as water, adding something to it does not make it not water.

    You should do your own research on this to get an accurate, unbiased, medically-based opinion.
    Absolutely agree, because there are very few people on here who don't spout pseudo science that they cannot back up with good evidence. By which I do not mean magazine articles!

    Educate yourself on the issue, or believe any old rubbish that strangers on a forum tell you - I've even heard people claim in all seriousness that adding sugar to herbal teas means they don't "count" as water! :bigsmile:
  • skywa
    skywa Posts: 901 Member
    Options
    i wouldnt count tea. because its a diaretic, and actually dehydrates you. :3
  • JennieAL
    JennieAL Posts: 1,726 Member
    Options
    I count any liquid. Just not alcohol.
  • karinaes
    karinaes Posts: 570 Member
    Options
    [This has probably been asked before, but I didn't see it.]

    I've heard it both ways... no, tea (hot or iced) is not the same as water, and yes, tea (hot or iced) is exactly the same as water. I've never been much of a water drinker, but I do drink a lot of tea - unsweetened, throughout the day. Since all I'm doing is flavoring the water without sweetening it, can I count it as part of the recommended daily 8 cups of water?

    Thanks!
    i count water and decaffeinated, unsweetened tea as water.. nothing else. we don't get enough water anyway, so i'm not going to count EVERYTHING that contains H2O and just drink plenty water and and decaf herbal tea :smile:
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member
    Options
    Unless my 4 year degree was a waste of my time, coffee is not a proven diuretic, it also counts toward fluid intake.
    Your degree was not a waste of time, but trying to give a lot of the people on here the benefit of your education is absolutely a waste of time.

    People would rather believe ill informed opinions in a magazine or advice from complete strangers on forums than take the trouble to lean about their bodies.

    To be honest I'm pretty disgusted that this site does not have an FAQ setting out some of the basic knowledge about this stuff. The discussions are absolutely endless and tedious. Maybe if the site stated it in black and white, people would believe it. Because, yanno, it's on the internet so it must be true... *rolls eyes*
  • appleseeds
    appleseeds Posts: 212 Member
    Options
    Caffeine does not dehydrate. If it started as water, adding something to it does not make it not water.

    You should do your own research on this to get an accurate, unbiased, medically-based opinion.



    You would have to drink like 30 cups of tea for the caffine level to dehydrate you, and then you've had so much water it couldn't possibly do so.
  • Hysiq
    Hysiq Posts: 12
    Options
    If it has caffeine it DOES NOT count as water. Everything else does.


    Source: Nephrologist (kidney specialist)
  • MercuryBlue
    MercuryBlue Posts: 886 Member
    Options
    Unless my 4 year degree was a waste of my time, coffee is not a proven diuretic, it also counts toward fluid intake.
    Your degree was not a waste of time, but trying to give a lot of the people on here the benefit of your education is absolutely a waste of time.

    People would rather believe ill informed opinions in a magazine or advice from complete strangers on forums than take the trouble to lean about their bodies.

    To be honest I'm pretty disgusted that this site does not have an FAQ setting out some of the basic knowledge about this stuff. The discussions are absolutely endless and tedious. Maybe if the site stated it in black and white, people would believe it. Because, yanno, it's on the internet so it must be true... *rolls eyes*

    It's funny because I used to be fairly active on the boards for a while, then went away for a bit to deal with some personal/life stuff. Came back to the boards today only to see the exact same things being discussed that were being discussed one and two years ago. Same questions- same misinformation as responses. My head is asploding right now.
  • Fit_Canuck
    Fit_Canuck Posts: 788 Member
    Options
    Unless my 4 year degree was a waste of my time, coffee is not a proven diuretic, it also counts toward fluid intake.
    Your degree was not a waste of time, but trying to give a lot of the people on here the benefit of your education is absolutely a waste of time.

    People would rather believe ill informed opinions in a magazine or advice from complete strangers on forums than take the trouble to lean about their bodies.

    To be honest I'm pretty disgusted that this site does not have an FAQ setting out some of the basic knowledge about this stuff. The discussions are absolutely endless and tedious. Maybe if the site stated it in black and white, people would believe it. Because, yanno, it's on the internet so it must be true... *rolls eyes*

    It's funny because I used to be fairly active on the boards for a while, then went away for a bit to deal with some personal/life stuff. Came back to the boards today only to see the exact same things being discussed that were being discussed one and two years ago. Same questions- same misinformation as responses. My head is asploding right now.

    Noo don't asplode!! :) It'll be ok, trust me
  • fteale
    fteale Posts: 5,310 Member
    Options
    My son's nephrologist (he only has one functional kidney, so I have learned a lot about this!) says the only things he has to avoid in later life are coca cola and tobacco. No mention of tea. I suspect it's not the caffeine in the coke that is the issue.
  • StacySkinny
    StacySkinny Posts: 984 Member
    Options
    Ok, some of you say that ALL liquids count towards your water intake, but from what I've read researches clearly demonstrated that large quantities of cola result in enhanced kidney stone formation due to their acidity and radical mineral imbalances. Your body must buffer the acidity of soft drinks with calcium from your own bones. As this calcium is eliminated through your urine, it slowly forms kidney stones. So why on earth would someone count cola as water intake?


    Sources:
    Weiss GH, Sluss PM, Linke CA. Changes in urinary magnesium, citrate, and oxalate levels due to cola consumption. Urology. 1992 Apr;39(4):331-3.
    and
    Rodgers A. Effect of cola consumption on urinary biochemical and physicochemical risk factors associated with calcium oxalate urolithiasis. Urol Res. 1999;27(1):77-81.

Categories