I'm 5'7" and my goal weight is _____________

smithiekat
smithiekat Posts: 112 Member
edited September 19 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi.

I'm 5'7" (female!) and my first goal was 149. I'm close to that goal (about 4-5 more pounds). I picked that goal because (a) it would put my in healthy BMI range and (b) because then I could say i weigh "in the 140s." Shallow I know but I'm being honest.

Anyways, as I get closer to my goal I'm wanting to set it a little lower. I'm not worried about the number so much anymore, I just know what I want my stomach and legs to look like, so I'll switch to maintain when I'm happy with those areas. In high school I weighed 135, so I may shoot for 135-140. In any event, I'm curious what other women of my same height are shooting for (or even better what women my same height have already achieved).

Thanks! :flowerforyou:

Kat
«1

Replies

  • dewdrop
    dewdrop Posts: 1,715 Member
    OK, don't get mad at me for posting, but this is such a good question. I'm somewhere around 132lbs now (maybe 1lb lighter, dunno for sure). I was thinking of trying to get around 125, maybe a little lower, but I might be skinny there - just gotta try, to see how it looks like. I am just annoyed by looking at me in pictures and getting my eyes stuck on my tights and thinking "hmm... still plumpy". Dunno, seriously, it bugs me. Why can't I just be OK with the way I am and am I objective when looking at pictures? Or is it that much a matter of body constitution?
  • demezat
    demezat Posts: 158
    I'm 5'7 also, and my goal weight is 140
  • 3babybeans
    3babybeans Posts: 8,268 Member
    Dew - I think 125 might be pushing it. At my lowest weight at 5'-7, I was 118 & that was just sickly looking, kwim? Try doing some extra toning on your legs & you might just feel better about how you look as opposed to getting that number lower on the scale. :flowerforyou:

    Personally, I'm 5'-7" & I'm sitting at 148 right now & would really like to see in the low 140s, if not 140. I still have some areas where there is too much plump, kwim?
  • AnneElise
    AnneElise Posts: 4,206 Member
    I am 5'6" and my current weight is 141, my ultimate goal is 130 but i would be very satisfied at 135
  • Iceprincessk25
    Iceprincessk25 Posts: 1,888 Member
    I'm 5'7 and my goal weight is around 133-135 pounds. When I go below 130 it looks too skinny for my frame.
  • GIGINATOR
    GIGINATOR Posts: 355 Member
    I'm 5'8" and my goal weight is 145-150lbs!
  • dclarsh
    dclarsh Posts: 364
    I'm 5'8" and my goal weight is 130 pounds. I'm at about 135 right now. When I get to 130, I plan on maintaining it for another two months and focusing on toning, and then I'll re-evaluate if I want to go a little lower or a little higher.

    I have a pretty light frame though, with really no curves... even when I weighed an extra 30 pounds, I didn't have curves, it all just sat around my tummy and made me look like I was wearing a flotation device under my clothes... you know, in case of an emergency water landing.
  • kerrilucko
    kerrilucko Posts: 3,852 Member
    I am 5'6" and my current weight is 141, my ultimate goal is 130 but i would be very satisfied at 135

    SAMEZIES! I'm also 5'6" and am currently 141 lbs. I'd like to get down another 5-10 lbs but I've decided to hold off on getting below 140 until after the wedding, for fears that my gown won't fit.
  • mommybug77
    mommybug77 Posts: 19
    Mine is 150. I will revaluate it once I hit that point. I have had 3 c-sections so I am realistic with myself as to what I would like my stomach to look like
  • HannahRoo
    HannahRoo Posts: 48 Member
    I'm 5'7" and my goal weight is 145.

    I was 135 lbs at one point but now that I look at pictures from back then I think that may have been too low for my frame.

    I will reevaluate when I reach my current goal.
  • sassekel
    sassekel Posts: 114 Member
    I am 5'7" also. I set my goal for 150, I might change it when I see how I feel at that weight. my lowest was 125 in the 90's that was too thin for me I think. I am top heavy so I'll just go by how I feel at goal weight and lower it if I am uncomfortable at 150.
  • idobepity
    idobepity Posts: 4
    I'm 5'8" and my goal weight is 170!
    I'm very happy with my upper body and overall shape at this weight.. I feel very "womanly" and have always had a huge rear! It seems no matter how many leg lifts or stairs I climb, it has always been the same size...

    Good luck to you and remember: any size is beautiful, as long as you're healthy!

    211409.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Food Diary
  • SHBoss1673
    SHBoss1673 Posts: 7,161 Member
    So here's the thing ladies. FORGET YOUR WEIGHT!

    Once you get close to healthy BMI can you PLEASE just forget about how much you weigh!

    Focus on your body fat %, and maybe definition and size. But weight is arbitrary. Some of you can weigh more because you have slightly denser organs, you'll never know, some of you may have longer bones, or more muscle mass in an area that's not near the surface of the skin, you'd never know besides weighing more.

    Body fat % will let you know that you are healthy, regardless of weight, someone with a low BF% will be healthy, and look good to boot! Who cares if you weigh 142 or 135? Nobody but you would ever be able to tell the difference if your muscle mass is the same anyway!

    Break the mind game, force yourself to stop thinking in terms of weight! Think in terms of health and maybe even in how you look! Weight has nothing to do with it once you are in a healthy range!
  • 3babybeans
    3babybeans Posts: 8,268 Member
    So here's the thing ladies. FORGET YOUR WEIGHT!

    Once you get close to healthy BMI can you PLEASE just forget about how much you weigh!

    Focus on your body fat %, and maybe definition and size. But weight is arbitrary. Some of you can weigh more because you have slightly denser organs, you'll never know, some of you may have longer bones, or more muscle mass in an area that's not near the surface of the skin, you'd never know besides weighing more.

    Body fat % will let you know that you are healthy, regardless of weight, someone with a low BF% will be healthy, and look good to boot! Who cares if you weigh 142 or 135? Nobody but you would ever be able to tell the difference if your muscle mass is the same anyway!

    Break the mind game, force yourself to stop thinking in terms of weight! Think in terms of health and maybe even in how you look! Weight has nothing to do with it once you are in a healthy range!

    NEVAH! :laugh:

    Seriously, though...Thanks, Banks! :flowerforyou:
  • kerrilucko
    kerrilucko Posts: 3,852 Member
    So here's the thing ladies. FORGET YOUR WEIGHT!

    Once you get close to healthy BMI can you PLEASE just forget about how much you weigh!

    Focus on your body fat %, and maybe definition and size. But weight is arbitrary. Some of you can weigh more because you have slightly denser organs, you'll never know, some of you may have longer bones, or more muscle mass in an area that's not near the surface of the skin, you'd never know besides weighing more.

    Body fat % will let you know that you are healthy, regardless of weight, someone with a low BF% will be healthy, and look good to boot! Who cares if you weigh 142 or 135? Nobody but you would ever be able to tell the difference if your muscle mass is the same anyway!

    Break the mind game, force yourself to stop thinking in terms of weight! Think in terms of health and maybe even in how you look! Weight has nothing to do with it once you are in a healthy range!

    NEVAH! :laugh:

    Seriously, though...Thanks, Banks! :flowerforyou:

    I agree with everything you said Banks, and I suppose I am thinking more of my size and shape than the number on the scale. I'm just using the numbers to guesstimate my goal. As in I feel that 5-10 more lbs lost will result in the shape I'm looking for. :flowerforyou:
  • smithiekat
    smithiekat Posts: 112 Member
    So here's the thing ladies. FORGET YOUR WEIGHT!

    Once you get close to healthy BMI can you PLEASE just forget about how much you weigh!

    Focus on your body fat %, and maybe definition and size. But weight is arbitrary. Some of you can weigh more because you have slightly denser organs, you'll never know, some of you may have longer bones, or more muscle mass in an area that's not near the surface of the skin, you'd never know besides weighing more.

    Body fat % will let you know that you are healthy, regardless of weight, someone with a low BF% will be healthy, and look good to boot! Who cares if you weigh 142 or 135? Nobody but you would ever be able to tell the difference if your muscle mass is the same anyway!

    Break the mind game, force yourself to stop thinking in terms of weight! Think in terms of health and maybe even in how you look! Weight has nothing to do with it once you are in a healthy range!

    NEVAH! :laugh:

    Seriously, though...Thanks, Banks! :flowerforyou:

    I agree with everything you said Banks, and I suppose I am thinking more of my size and shape than the number on the scale. I'm just using the numbers to guesstimate my goal. As in I feel that 5-10 more lbs lost will result in the shape I'm looking for. :flowerforyou:

    yea! what she said!
  • GIBride01
    GIBride01 Posts: 328 Member
    My goal weight was 155 and I am almost 5'8". Once I hit 155, I stopped worrying about getting the scale to go down, and more toning and improving my fitness. I think the number on the scale really depends on your body type also. I can't remeber ever being below 145...and that was when I was doing athletics in high school and college. I would look bad at anything below 140..We ladies do focus on the scale too much, but I am as guilty as the rest as wanting that number to go down! I am still working out and weighing myself weekly, but just to make sure the number doesn't go up!
  • beckyi88
    beckyi88 Posts: 604
    I'm 5'6" and my goal is 137 - 141. I'd love to go by the old rule of thumb: 100 pounds for 5' plus 5 pounds for every inch over 5', but don't think I can maintain that. Even in high school dropping below 132 was almost impossible.
    And, those weights do put me in a normal BMI, nowhere close to underweight! :happy:
    Becky
  • literydr
    literydr Posts: 1
    I'm 5'7'' currently at 167.0 and would like to downsize and keep it under 150. Years ago I became a Weight Watcher Lifer at 140 and didn't stay there very long....maybe if I had more time to exercise.

    Anybody else look at vacation photos and remember exactly how much you weighed?

    Sue
  • JDHINAZ
    JDHINAZ Posts: 641 Member
    I :heart: Banks. You know, not like I :heart: my husband, but still, I :heart: you, man!!!!
  • SHBoss1673
    SHBoss1673 Posts: 7,161 Member
    I :heart: Banks. You know, not like I :heart: my husband, but still, I :heart: you, man!!!!

    LOL!

    I do what I can lady!
  • iRun4wine
    iRun4wine Posts: 5,126
    I'm 5'7 and my goal weight is around 133-135 pounds. When I go below 130 it looks too skinny for my frame.

    I'm the same height and have the same goal. I've never gone below that, but I would imagine (like you said) that 130 would just be too skinny! :noway:
  • jlbay
    jlbay Posts: 473 Member
    Well, it depends on your body structure.

    I am exactly 5' 7" and my goal is 140. When I ran every day - I weighed 135 and was a size 4/6. My mom is 5' 8" and she is a size 6 at 125 lbs - but she is built totally different than I. She has no hips and very slender legs. Somehow, I got these monster hips and much more 'curvy' legs.
  • kimber607
    kimber607 Posts: 7,128 Member
    Hi

    I can tell you everyone REALLY is different
    I am 5'7+ and recently went out for a GNO and of course, weight came up
    I weigh typically 129-131....my gf guessed my weight as 118 :noway:
    My friend is almost the same size as me and weighs 123 (she is pretty darn skinny)

    Anyway, I came here weighing 157 in Jan 08....holding on to baby weight from #2 (my dd was 3 yrs old!)
    My initial goal was 138-140 but I continues to loose until I hit 128-129
    Now my goal is to look healthy strong and maintain that lose

    I wanted to add, since lots of people have been asking/curious about a full length pic of me..I took a pic recently and added it to my profile

    good luck!
    kim
  • Cindysunshine
    Cindysunshine Posts: 1,188 Member
    Banks is so very smart !! I'm 5' 8 " . When I weigh 160 I wear a size 8. I would love to get back to 160 but I have no way of knowing if 160 is right for me now. I might get to 175 and be in a good body fat percentile and wear a size 8. Just keep eating right and exercising girls. It is about way more than what the scale says. :smile: Cindy :heart:
  • fiftyandfit
    fiftyandfit Posts: 349 Member
    I'm 5'7",but I'm one of the OG's (old gals).......I would like to see my numbers
    go down to 160, but more importantly I want to be healthy. Would just like to
    get rid of my "muffin top" and the puckery thighs!! I'd probably look anorexic
    if I was down in the 130's!

    209964.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter
  • lizbeth787
    lizbeth787 Posts: 101 Member
    I'm 5'8 and 130-132 pounds... honestly if I weighed any less, I would look like a skeleton!!!!
  • LisaZaugg1976
    LisaZaugg1976 Posts: 1,144 Member
    I weigh 123.6 right now my goal is 120 I am 5'3" and I also shooting for 20% body fat
  • rosabella
    rosabella Posts: 194 Member
    Just so we know we are all different, I am also 5'7" and my goal is 125, but I have a lot less muscle than some of you ladies! If I reach the measurements I want before that, I will switch to maintaining... it's all about the measurements and how YOUR body looks! :happy: :heart:
  • denmother46
    denmother46 Posts: 272 Member
    Echo the everyone if different. My original goal was 140, then I adjusted to 135. I am also 5' 7". Final goal was based on what would be reasonable for me to maintain - cos whats the point if you have to starve or deprive yourself to stay at any give number. After I got got 135 I concentrated on gaining muscle. Stayed at the same weight for several months but was able to eat pretty much whatever I wanted due to the amount of exercise. I have been at 128 for over 6 months now and have added a good amount of muscle. The number isnt as important as how you feel - and I feel great. Full of energy and I look better in my clothes than I have in years. I could never give up food - so I decided I just have to work out enough to offset what I eat.
This discussion has been closed.