intermittent fasting..thinking about it
Replies
-
Really? and why is intermittent fasting so bad if your obese, this interests me?DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Feel free to rip into me
i was wondering the same thing....and i have been counting calories and eating right....i just want to try something different....0 -
DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Regardless of your eating schedule you'll still want to learn to eat sensibly and count cals/macros. They are not mutually exclusive.0 -
DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Regardless of your eating schedule you'll still want to learn to eat sensibly and count cals/macros. They are not mutually exclusive.
i do. i just said that lol0 -
Really? and why is intermittent fasting so bad if your obese, this interests me?DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Feel free to rip into me
The kid here (it's a personal joke between us) and I have had some long discussions about this lol. He's a good guy, and I'm not sure why he hates IF so much. It's clear by his results his methods work for him...but the same can be said of almost every man on this forum (man = apples to apples) who IFs.
chrisdavey
wackyfunster
sidesteal
sniperzzzz
There's more, I just don't have the time to list them all. All very lean, and clearly healthy.
*shrug*0 -
Thats fair enough cris.
Really? and why is intermittent fasting so bad if your obese, this interests me?DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Feel free to rip into me
The kid here (it's a personal joke between us) and I have had some long discussions about this lol. He's a good guy, and I'm not sure why he hates IF so much. It's clear by his results his methods work for him...but the same can be said of almost every man on this forum (man = apples to apples) who IFs.
chrisdavey
wackyfunster
sidesteal
sniperzzzz
There's more, I just don't have the time to list them all. All very lean, and clearly healthy.
*shrug*
I just cant see how if your obese IF wont work for you, quite a strong statement to make if you ask me.0 -
Thats fair enough cris.
Really? and why is intermittent fasting so bad if your obese, this interests me?DONT
yeh... please dont do it. especially if you have obese body fat levels dont even consider it. just learn to eat sensibly and count calories and macros.
Feel free to rip into me
The kid here (it's a personal joke between us) and I have had some long discussions about this lol. He's a good guy, and I'm not sure why he hates IF so much. It's clear by his results his methods work for him...but the same can be said of almost every man on this forum (man = apples to apples) who IFs.
chrisdavey
wackyfunster
sidesteal
sniperzzzz
There's more, I just don't have the time to list them all. All very lean, and clearly healthy.
*shrug*
I just cant see how if your obese IF wont work for you, quite a strong statement to make if you ask me.
I agree...this is a new comment from him. I'm sure he's basing it on self control etc. Everyone seems to think IF is some kind of trigger for eating disorders (whether binging or starving yourself)...when honestly, for everyone I've seen who has tried it, it literally divorces you from emotional eating. Food just doesn't have the control over you that it used to.
Understand, this isn't my personal experience...as I've never had an emotional connection to food, but many people do, and that experience has been relayed by each of them I've talked to about this.0 -
I am a new believer in it. Especially after my results. I wasnt able to get my cals in on the days I work. Now I dont worry about it. I love this. Its so easy and fits into my lifestyle0
-
I am a new believer in it. Especially after my results. I wasnt able to get my cals in on the days I work. Now I dont worry about it. I love this. Its so easy and fits into my lifestyle
Told you it was perfect for you
. I don't push this towards people...not without being asked, but when you told me you were worried about how you were eating during work days...I couldn't help it. I work 8-10hrs a day myself, and rarely have time for lunch. With IF...I don't have to worry about it at all. And as you've seen yourself...it's a HUGE relief.
Eating enough, while trying to lose weight...is just as important as not overeating. This can help ease that burden.0 -
IDK, I think the control and OCD elements of a stricter IF diet like LG could allow ED folks to replace negative behaviors with positive, by channeling these urges into hitting very tight macro targets, eating windows, etc. I think people assume that fasting = calorie deprivation, which it does not. I fast 16+ hours per day, and am carrying a 2000 calorie weekly surplus. The health benefits of fasting are conferred whether or not you are eating at a caloric deficit, and even eating at maintenance you will likely see fat loss and LBM gain due to the way energy partitioning functions in a fasted state. This is not an uncommon result, and is even more pronounced when doing an LG style calorie cycling where post-workout on weight days you eat at a surplus, and at a deficit on rest days.The only thing that was stressed to me was this is not a lifestyle for someone recovering from an ED
It seems like the people condemning IF are doing so completely out of ignorance of what it entails, and the science underlying it.0 -
This^^It seems like the people condemning IF are doing so completely out of ignorance of what it entails, and the science underlying it.0 -
IDK, I think the control and OCD elements of a stricter IF diet like LG could allow ED folks to replace negative behaviors with positive, by channeling these urges into hitting very tight macro targets, eating windows, etc. I think people assume that fasting = calorie deprivation, which it does not. I fast 16+ hours per day, and am carrying a 2000 calorie weekly surplus. The health benefits of fasting are conferred whether or not you are eating at a caloric deficit, and even eating at maintenance you will likely see fat loss and LBM gain due to the way energy partitioning functions in a fasted state. This is not an uncommon result, and is even more pronounced when doing an LG style calorie cycling where post-workout on weight days you eat at a surplus, and at a deficit on rest days.The only thing that was stressed to me was this is not a lifestyle for someone recovering from an ED
It seems like the people condemning IF are doing so completely out of ignorance of what it entails, and the science underlying it.
I definatelt endorse IF. However there is a psychological aspect associated with ED. Let me give a hypothetical. This does not entail all. Most who suffer from anorexia or bulimia have a difficult time controlling triggers. If someone is anorexic and they go 24 hours without eating then their brains revert back to old tapes. Feelings of worthlessness. Or see how good your doing because you didnt eat. An alcoholic cant just go have 1 beer. It creates the phenomenon of craving. Same thing happens in ED. Its an addiction and they stay away from things that create the phenomenon of craving0 -
The people on here who are telling you not to, or saying it won't help with weight loss, most likely haven't tried it at all. Intermittent fasting seems to be helpful in assisting with weight loss, and the reviews I've seen about it are positive. So if you're thinking about doing it, go for it.0
-
IDK, I think the control and OCD elements of a stricter IF diet like LG could allow ED folks to replace negative behaviors with positive, by channeling these urges into hitting very tight macro targets, eating windows, etc. I think people assume that fasting = calorie deprivation, which it does not. I fast 16+ hours per day, and am carrying a 2000 calorie weekly surplus. The health benefits of fasting are conferred whether or not you are eating at a caloric deficit, and even eating at maintenance you will likely see fat loss and LBM gain due to the way energy partitioning functions in a fasted state. This is not an uncommon result, and is even more pronounced when doing an LG style calorie cycling where post-workout on weight days you eat at a surplus, and at a deficit on rest days.The only thing that was stressed to me was this is not a lifestyle for someone recovering from an ED
It seems like the people condemning IF are doing so completely out of ignorance of what it entails, and the science underlying it.
Lean gains is the least strict method I know of.
Not in my opinion...it's the MOST strict of the ones I've used. ESE is simple, you don't eat for a period of time, then eat. What you eat is only moderately relevant to the benefits. Leangains has a whole slew of conditions that you have to meet in order to utilize his protocol as he intended. He's said time and again it's not for weight loss (though it works for that). It's for people who are trying to do something very specific with their bodies, bulk, and cut...simultaneously.0 -
There are definitely a lot of factors to consider, and I wouldn't want to make a generalization for all ED sufferers, just pointing out that saying IF/ED recovery are incompatible is ludicrous... it is going to depend on the individual. I think the problem is most of the people here who are not familiar with ED at all think of them as food-related, which couldn't be further from the truth (Eating Disorder is really a misnomer). Anorexia and Bulimia are both profoundly different disorders, with Bulimia being more centered around a similar pattern of behaviors as OCD, and anorexia is more oriented around feelings of helplessness and a need for control. Obviously these are both very deep subjects, and no short post is going to adequately describe them, but thinking of ED as being driven by food is wrong-headed. The disordered eating is a manifestation of the disorders, not the core symptom, which is why ED are so difficult to overcome for most people. ED are not the opposite of obesity, which seems to be the prevalent view here.I definatelt endorse IF. However there is a psychological aspect associated with ED. Let me give a hypothetical. This does not entail all. Most who suffer from anorexia or bulimia have a difficult time controlling triggers. If someone is anorexic and they go 24 hours without eating then their brains revert back to old tapes. Feelings of worthlessness. Or see how good your doing because you didnt eat. An alcoholic cant just go have 1 beer. It creates the phenomenon of craving. Same thing happens in ED. Its an addiction and they stay away from things that create the phenomenon of craving0 -
Depends on how strict you want to get on macros, meal timing, diet, etc.Lean gains is the least strict method I know of.0 -
This is NOT starving yourself, anymore than 4-6 meals through the day is gluttony. It's changing how you eat. Not how much.
Even snacks? :-(
Actually I wanted to try this but I've been putting it off. I don't want to just jump into without taking the time to research things first.0 -
There are definitely a lot of factors to consider, and I wouldn't want to make a generalization for all ED sufferers, just pointing out that saying IF/ED recovery are incompatible is ludicrous... it is going to depend on the individual. I think the problem is most of the people here who are not familiar with ED at all think of them as food-related, which couldn't be further from the truth (Eating Disorder is really a misnomer). Anorexia and Bulimia are both profoundly different disorders, with Bulimia being more centered around a similar pattern of behaviors as OCD, and anorexia is more oriented around feelings of helplessness and a need for control. Obviously these are both very deep subjects, and no short post is going to adequately describe them, but thinking of ED as being driven by food is wrong-headed. The disordered eating is a manifestation of the disorders, not the core symptom, which is why ED are so difficult to overcome for most people. ED are not the opposite of obesity, which seems to be the prevalent view here.I definatelt endorse IF. However there is a psychological aspect associated with ED. Let me give a hypothetical. This does not entail all. Most who suffer from anorexia or bulimia have a difficult time controlling triggers. If someone is anorexic and they go 24 hours without eating then their brains revert back to old tapes. Feelings of worthlessness. Or see how good your doing because you didnt eat. An alcoholic cant just go have 1 beer. It creates the phenomenon of craving. Same thing happens in ED. Its an addiction and they stay away from things that create the phenomenon of craving
Interesting. I agree that there are alot of factors to consider and are very deep subjects. I dont think the forum is the place to discuss this however I would love to discuss this matter with you further since I have worked with this vast population and would love to hear your insight.0 -
Depends on how strict you want to get on macros, meal timing, diet, etc.Lean gains is the least strict method I know of.
Definitely, but to get the most out of it...it's a very strict protocol.Well in my mind i am comparing it to the warrior diet, 20hr fast, 4hr eating window. That's why i said that.
I've not looked into them much. I've had great results between leangains and ESE, so I never felt the need.0 -
This is NOT starving yourself, anymore than 4-6 meals through the day is gluttony. It's changing how you eat. Not how much.
Even snacks? :-(
Actually I wanted to try this but I've been putting it off. I don't want to just jump into without taking the time to research things first.
No hun, you don't eat snacks lol. That defeats the purpose. PM me your email and I'll send you something interesting to read 0 -
I just starting doing a 16 hour fast with an 8 hour eating window and I LOVE it. I can't believe how easy it is. I would love to do 24 hour fasts but I am not sure I'm ready yet. I think you should try it out.0
-
* The majority of your daily calorie intake is consumed in the post-workout period. Depending on setup, this means that approximately 95-99% (fasted training), 80% (one pre-workout meal) or 60% (two pre-workout meals) of your daily calorie intake is consumed after training.
* The feeding window should be kept somewhat constant due to the hormonal entrainment of meal patterns. We tend to get hungry when we're used to eating and maintaining a regular pattern makes diet adherence easier. If you're used to breaking the fast at 12-2 PM and ending it at 8-10 PM, then try to maintain that pattern every day.
* On rest days, meal one should ideally be the largest meal, as opposed to training days where the post-workout meal is the largest meal. A good rule of thumb is to make meal one on rest days at least 35-40% of your daily calorie intake. This meal should be very high in protein; some of my clients consume more than 100 g of protein in this meal.
Further down on the page, pu!0 -
I just starting doing a 16 hour fast with an 8 hour eating window and I LOVE it. I can't believe how easy it is. I would love to do 24 hour fasts but I am not sure I'm ready yet. I think you should try it out.
Its not that bad. I eat dinner than don't eat till dinner the next day.0 -
[
Actually I wanted to try this but I've been putting it off. I don't want to just jump into without taking the time to research things first.
I am enjoying the results of IF. I am pleasantly surprised how after just the first few days, my hunger was not a problem at all. My fasted workouts are feeling great and I havnt seen any strength loss.
It makes the whole day easier not worrying about getting something ready to eat. Its nice to go out and not having to worry if I will be near a place to get some decent food.
But I agree that you should do your own research before jumping into it. Good luck0 -
For those of you saying 'I don't think'...please, do...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't.
I didn't say no, or I don't think.... how is it harmful to them and others? if they eat or not?
Umm...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't think.
lol very true, but I didn't want to say it wouldn't make a diff, cuz I didn't know. I would starve doing that I feel like. I do high intensity cardio & I an so hungry if I don't eat a certain amount cuz I burn so much.0 -
For those of you saying 'I don't think'...please, do...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't.
I didn't say no, or I don't think.... how is it harmful to them and others? if they eat or not?
Umm...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't think.
lol very true, but I didn't want to say it wouldn't make a diff, cuz I didn't know. I would starve doing that I feel like. I do high intensity cardio & I an so hungry if I don't eat a certain amount cuz I burn so much.
I'm glad you didn't take me teasing you wrong.
Seriously though...you can still eat the same amount. Why couldn't you?0 -
For those of you saying 'I don't think'...please, do...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't.
I didn't say no, or I don't think.... how is it harmful to them and others? if they eat or not?
Umm...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't think.
lol very true, but I didn't want to say it wouldn't make a diff, cuz I didn't know. I would starve doing that I feel like. I do high intensity cardio & I an so hungry if I don't eat a certain amount cuz I burn so much.
I'm glad you didn't take me teasing you wrong.
Seriously though...you can still eat the same amount. Why couldn't you?
You're messed up chris, i was scrolling up and down this thread quickly, kept on seeing a girl's butt, i go to check it out... and it says "crisanderson2". I feel dirty now for some reason.
That is hilarious. You have all sorts of followers. Guess it's a nondiscriminatory butt. lol0 -
For those of you saying 'I don't think'...please, do...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't.
I didn't say no, or I don't think.... how is it harmful to them and others? if they eat or not?
Umm...it's harmful to yourself and others when you don't think.
lol very true, but I didn't want to say it wouldn't make a diff, cuz I didn't know. I would starve doing that I feel like. I do high intensity cardio & I an so hungry if I don't eat a certain amount cuz I burn so much.
I'm glad you didn't take me teasing you wrong.
Seriously though...you can still eat the same amount. Why couldn't you?
You're messed up chris, i was scrolling up and down this thread quickly, kept on seeing a girl's butt, i go to check it out... and it says "crisanderson2". I feel dirty now for some reason.
Lol...that's just wrong man...seriously lol.0 -
i don't agree with the idea of fasting, and neither does my doctor. You need to eat food. Your body requires it. There is a reason why your stomach starts to hurt and grumble after mere hours of not eating. :grumble:0
-
Fasting isn't for everyone. However people that do IF still maintain a healthy caloric intake. It is another form of calorie cycling.0
-
I fast a lot for religious reasons. I feel like it is excellent for that purpose, and, as a bonus I have excellent digestion ;-)
BUT as I get older (have been doing this for 15 years) I notice that some fast days are really tough as far as dizziness and mental confusion. And when we do our annual series of multi-day fasts, I find that I actually GAIN weight, even if I eat very little during the eating part of the week. I think it messes up my metabolism. But the spiritual and self control benefits are worth it, so I do it anyway.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.4K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 440 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.9K MyFitnessPal Information
- 15 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.7K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions