Help?! I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong.

jennadiane_

So I've been actively using MFP for almost four weeks now. And my weight is pretty much back at square one and I'm not sure why.

I'm kicking my own *kitten* working out every day for about an hour (Insanity and then a mix up of either treadmill, Jillian Michael's or bike ride). I'm staying under my calorie goal (which is 1200 a day; with my workouts my net is usually 800-900 and I don't feel hungry). Drinking my water (maybe not 8 cups every day - but I'm not drinking anything else if it's not water, or coffee in the AM).

I've lost about an inch and a half on most of my measurements.

Am I doing something wrong? Any suggestions. When I started I was on my period (sorry guys) so I those two extra pounds I chalked up to water weight, but recorded them. Now I'm not on my period and those two pounds are back.

The fact that I have to plan out dinner based on this app is kind of annoying, but it helps, or so I thought. But when the numbers on the scale are going backwards I'm not really seeing the point.

But on the positive. I'm feeling great! My pants aren't SO snug, I'm in a better mood, productive, I'm sleeping better (minus my husband's snoring). I know these are all great things and I shouldn't go by the numbers on the scale but I just can't help it when I work so hard and see "no results".

amyniceneasy

Eat a bit more. Try to not net below 1200.

jennadiane_

Really, don't net below 1200. That seems like a lot.

Robin1109

So I've been actively using MFP for almost four weeks now. And my weight is pretty much back at square one and I'm not sure why.

I'm kicking my own *kitten* working out every day for about an hour (Insanity and then a mix up of either treadmill, Jillian Michael's or bike ride). I'm staying under my calorie goal (which is 1200 a day; with my workouts my net is usually 800-900 and I don't feel hungry).

^^ This. I understand MFP gave you a goal of 1200 calories per day. I'm on the same plan. I'm not going to get in to the debate of whether you eat back your exercise calories or not. I do sometimes and sometimes I don't. That being said, if you are falling under your 1200 BEFORE exercise, that's not good. Your body will not want to let go because it's shocked into thinking it's getting too little fuel and expending too much energy. I know it seems hard to do, but try to work out a daily menu that's at least 1200 calories. I've always found when I stalemate or plateau, increasing my calories with healthy food helps to get the scale moving again.

BackTatJIM

If you lost inches then why does it matter what the scale read? Would you rather the scale say you lost 5 lbs and not lose any inches. What I am saying is you should continue measuring and throw out the scale ;-). I am not sure what you are looking to lose but netting 800-900 calories is really low, If you exercise regularly you need to start eating more, I would try 5-6 small meals a day

MissBee1989

1200 is the very least you should be eating as it's sounds like you are exercising a fair bit, your body has most likely gone into starvation mode. eat at least 1200 a day and I think the weight will come off x

therealangd

Losing inches is better than losing weight. That's great progress for four weeks.

But I also agree. If you are working your butt off with exercise, you need to be netting more than 1200 calories. (unless you are short)

gatorginger

Eat your 1200 and half of your exercise calories back, opening your diary will help us give better advice, for instance maybe your getting too much sodium. After a while you will know what you can eat so it won't be so hard to plan your food out for the day once you do this for a while

ChristineS_51

I'm staying under my calorie goal (which is 1200 a day; with my workouts my net is usually 800-900 and I don't feel hungry).

Eat more.

tweetybaby69

Do not get locked into the scale. Definitely keep track of inches as a lot of times even though you are not losing pounds, you are losing inches. Do not net under 1200, thry to keep your intake to 1200 even after exercise.

Don't be discouraged, it will get better.

tlythgoe

You are gaining muscle, which weighs more than fat. It's normal to see no movement on the scale, or even see weight gain, during the first few weeks of starting intense exercise. The key is to continue to use the tape measure as well as the scale. If you are losing inches but not weight then you are doing it right. Eventually your muscle gains will slow and your weight will drop as you continue to burn fat.

seekingstrengthX2

What you're doing wrong is that you are not eating enough dear. Netting under 1000 is not going to help u reach your goals.

rawfull

What kind of food do you eat? I've learned that all calories are not the same, food matters.

jennadiane_

- I'm 5'2... and before working out I'm usually eating about 1500-1800 calories depending on the day, my work schedule, etc.

- I assumed since I was eating enough calories wise and burning a decent amount my net didn't really matter.

- Yay. I get to eat more I guess... even though I'm not usually too hungry.

- I don't mind planning out my meals for the day. Actually makes life easier but for instance my husband got a pizza last night and before I could even open the box I had to stop and figure out how much I could eat - it was kind of annoying.

silico

I have relevant information to this topic:

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/238282-700-calories-a-day-and-not-losing-redux?hl=700+calories

I seem to be sending more and more people to that link...

Wonderob

You are gaining muscle, which weighs more than fat.

Not a chance when you have such a big calorie deficit - generally you can only build muscle when you have a calorie surplus

Possibly extra water in the muscle due to increased exercise

jennadiane_

I'm eating what I normally would except I'm not indulging in it and eating until I'm stuffed. I started adding more fruits and veggies which aren't so bad. Portion control pretty much is my "diet". If I feel like I'm on a diet per say I'm starving adn I hate it and it sucks.

So I'll increase my net calories and hopefully will see some changes.

Thanks guys!!!

Brizoeller

Your body is not in starvation mode. You are not gaining muscle. Muscle does not weigh more than fat.Sorry, those are all true. Do eat more, you're going for a lifestyle change correct? Not an "i'm going to eat 800 calories for 4 months then eat normal and gain it all back" approach. And be patient. You didn't gain weight overnight, you won't lose it overnight either.

The_New_Christina

From experience, I can tell you that in the beginning I lost 6lbs fairly quickly since starting this on July 2nd. I've maintained those 6lbs lost even though I was going up and down on the scale alot. However, I'm soooo happy cuz I look better. Lost an inch around my arms (upper), lost 2 inches in my stomach, and 3 inches right under my bra area (don't know what that's called.lol). So overall, no one really knows how much I weight, except for my husband, so as long as others can visually see the change, then I know THIS is working! Chin up and never give up!

RitaSantoss

Maybe you're in plateau mode. Your metabolism froze. You should try to eat a bit more to ingest more calories and work out less. Instead of working out for 1 hour everyday. Try to just do it like 3/4 days a week untill your metabolism restarts and you start losing weight again.

MoveTheMountain

Honestly, you might want to exercise a bit less, and give yourself a little more time to recover between workouts. Rest and recovery is at least as important as the exercise itself. (And yes, there's a good chance you need a little more food...)

slappymcgee

as backwards as it sounds, you are not eating enough. Make sure you get your 1200 in at minimum. When you dont eat enough, your body will start to fight you and you wont lose anything.

vim_n_vigor

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/390145-should-i-eat-my-exercise-calories

You should be eating more.

ekane23

Is it possible that you aren't calculating the correct calories burned either? I found that based on my info I had entered, MFP, Edomondo and others like it would give me a crazy amount of calories for excercise. Then I purchased a Heart Rate Monitor and wow, there was a big difference! I was giving myself credit for TOO MANY calories burned.


Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter

allywood90

If you eat below 1200 net calories, it will be very difficult for you to lose weight. Especially if you are not accounting for all of the calories you are burning during exercise. This is because when your body does not receive enough calories, it goes into starvation mode, your metabolism slows down, and it hangs on to the fat cells that are stored in your body instead of burning them off during exercise. Another thing is that because you are doing exercise like insanity, you are probably gaining muscle mass, which is why you are losing inches but not pounds. Muscle weighs more, but it has less mass than fat. Eat a few more hundred calories, and a lot of protein, and you will be good.

ErinBeth7

Really, don't net below 1200. That seems like a lot.

Thats not a lot. The minimum suggested for anyone is 1200. If you eat the right foods, even 1500 is not too much. You are losing inches and thats great. The number on the scale does not reflect all the hard work you've done and changes your body is going through. Its a very basic number and only measures one thing. I would go by measurements because you've had success there, its obviously working. Like everyone has been saying, you need to eat more. Try 1300-1400.

brandyla78

I can't go by the scale...I have a medium size frame and more muscle than lots of people my height...so I weigh more than someone who "looks" bigger than me. You need to think in terms of building muscle means losing fat; you may be losing a pound of fat but also gaining a pound of muscle...the muscle looks much better I PROMISE and in the long run the extra muscle will burn more calories. Give it some time and keep up with your measurements. If you are eating the RIGHT foods and working out you are on the right track!

RuthSweetTooth

Open your diary and we'll take a look.

mamamc03

From your cal intake you described (1500-1800) you are fine!! You are working on fat loss and you NEED a deficit to lose. Once you get closer to maintenance, you can focus on that net. Unless you are burning 1000-1500 a day...i wouldn't stress.

http://www.livestrong.com/article/295395-how-many-calories-does-my-body-need-to-survive-at-rest/

amy1612

You are gaining muscle, which weighs more than fat. It's normal to see no movement on the scale, or even see weight gain, during the first few weeks of starting intense exercise. The key is to continue to use the tape measure as well as the scale. If you are losing inches but not weight then you are doing it right. Eventually your muscle gains will slow and your weight will drop as you continue to burn fat.

Muscle DOES NOT WEIGH MORE THAN FAT!!!!!!

It takes up less space then fat, but it doesnt 'weigh more'. A lb of feathers is the same as a lb of rocks.

AND you are unlikely to gain muscle in a calorie deficit. Inches are a great loss, dont worry about the scale

RuthSweetTooth

I have a suspicion that you have gained more muscle, which weighs more. Be patient. Soon it will start coming off. Your metabolism will increase and turn you into a lean machine. Just stick with it!!!!