Re-thinking my position on eggs...

124»

Replies

  • mnlght535
    mnlght535 Posts: 84
    Here's a good article talking about the reality of eggs, high cholesterol, and heart disease:
    http://www.wellnessletter.com/ucberkeley/feature/the-sunny-side-of-eggs/#

    Great article. Thanks for sharing. It appears, with the amount of studies done with hundreds of thousands of people, that there is no significant increase in bad cholesterol correlated with the consumption of eating 3 eggs per day (as that article suggests). However, the culprits that could be responsible would be how the eggs are prepared or what they are served with. Lots of great information in there.

    Again, thanks for the share :)
  • jofjltncb6
    jofjltncb6 Posts: 34,415 Member
    Don't dump the yolk because it builds muscles and most of the egg protein is in the yolk. I use to toss my yolk away, not anymore (well not as often, because I really prefer the white only.) Also the yolk boost brain and muscle power.The yolk also fends off sore muscles, because of the choline. Plus have 1 or 2 eggs a day keeps the pounds away.


    Egg White Egg Yolk
    Calories 17 59
    Fat (g) .06 4.51
    Saturated Fat (g )0 1.6
    Carbs (g) .24 .61
    Protein (g ) 3.6 2.7
    Cholesterol (mg) 0 210
    Sodium (mg) 55 8
    Calcium (mg) 2.3 21.9
    Vitamin D (IU) 0 18
    Folate (mcg) 1.3 24.8

    Most of the protein is not in the yolk - but the WHOLE egg on the whole is a pretty darn perfect food.

    Yeah, yeah, lots of numbers...

    ...but that doesn't change the fact that almost all of the "awesome" in an egg is in the yolk.
  • jofjltncb6
    jofjltncb6 Posts: 34,415 Member
    Here's a good article talking about the reality of eggs, high cholesterol, and heart disease:
    http://www.wellnessletter.com/ucberkeley/feature/the-sunny-side-of-eggs/#

    Great article. Thanks for sharing. It appears, with the amount of studies done with hundreds of thousands of people, that there is no significant increase in bad cholesterol correlated with the consumption of eating 3 eggs per day (as that article suggests). However, the culprits that could be responsible would be how the eggs are prepared or what they are served with. Lots of great information in there.

    Again, thanks for the share :)

    The real question is, is high cholesterol even causative to heart disease?

    ...(but I guess that's a discussion for another topic).

    So, what were we talking about here? Oh yeah...eggs...(and bacon).
  • mnlght535
    mnlght535 Posts: 84
    Gotta love people when they go on about organic eggs etc. They are still fed with the same junk feed in the same way and they even get rained on with the same polluted rain etc. No better or worse in reality unless your chicken producing eggs are fed seeds rather than feed.

    Reality of eggs and cholesterol can be found on the British Heart Foundation website (e.g. the UK's premier website on heart health!) - http://www.bhf.org.uk/default.aspx?page=12920

    Some more good information on eggs. Thanks for the share. These articles allow us to make informed choices. Thanks a bunch :)
  • AuddAlise
    AuddAlise Posts: 723 Member
    Of course! Disney's cartoon version of Beauty & the beast.
  • EyeLikeTacos
    EyeLikeTacos Posts: 324 Member
    I disagree with everyone here that say don't sweat how much eggs yolks you eat or they have no effect on your cholesterol.

    One egg Yolk has nearly 2/3's the daily cholesterol intake. If you have a family history of high cholesterol..WATCH your yolk count...

    I suggest having your choleterol checked at least 4 times a year..(IF) you have cholesterol issues and see how your diet effects those numbers...if you are averaging 2 or more egg yolks a day and it has no negative effects on your cholesterol numbers...then continue...but if your LDL is going up....Cut back to one egg yolk a day or none depending on other Cholesterol intakes....I am 162 lbs, 8.2% body fat...and I don't eat fast food or fried foods...but My LDL is 138...its genetics...and if I eat over 2 or 3 egg yolks a day ...my LDL goes up almost 30 points.


    JUST wanted to ADD: Genetics is the key component here...MOST people can get away with eating as many egg yolks as they want....but I am not one of those...and I am sure there are other people that have same issues with cholesterol that I do.

    What is your HDL number? And your HDL:LDL ratio? And your LDL size? Triglycerides? How do those change when you eat more than 2-3 yolks a day? Eggs are known to raise LDL levels, but they also proportionately raise HDL numbers, and studies show (some of the articles linked here already explain this) that the LDL particles are larger than what is considered to be "harmful." They've also found that the HDL:LDL and triglyceride numbers that matter more than just LDL numbers.

    Also, the recommended cholesterol number is based on the flawed idea that dietary cholesterol affects blood cholesterol, which has been debunked.

    Here are my total numbers:

    Total = 238, HDL = 89, LDL = 134, Triglycerides = 76

    HDL/LDL ratio is 66%, Anything above 40% is GOOD.

    Total Cholesterol to HDL ratio is 2.7, BELOW 5 is good.
  • lorib75
    lorib75 Posts: 490 Member
    I have my own chickens. They get fresh grass and bugs on a regular basis and their eggs are healthier than what you get in the store. Yay eggs!

    This. We raise chickens for eggs and for meat. I wouldn't know what to do if I didn't have farm fresh eggs. Store eggs stink to me and taste weird... FRESH IS BEST!! lol:laugh:
  • Dragonwolf
    Dragonwolf Posts: 5,600 Member
    I disagree with everyone here that say don't sweat how much eggs yolks you eat or they have no effect on your cholesterol.

    One egg Yolk has nearly 2/3's the daily cholesterol intake. If you have a family history of high cholesterol..WATCH your yolk count...

    I suggest having your choleterol checked at least 4 times a year..(IF) you have cholesterol issues and see how your diet effects those numbers...if you are averaging 2 or more egg yolks a day and it has no negative effects on your cholesterol numbers...then continue...but if your LDL is going up....Cut back to one egg yolk a day or none depending on other Cholesterol intakes....I am 162 lbs, 8.2% body fat...and I don't eat fast food or fried foods...but My LDL is 138...its genetics...and if I eat over 2 or 3 egg yolks a day ...my LDL goes up almost 30 points.


    JUST wanted to ADD: Genetics is the key component here...MOST people can get away with eating as many egg yolks as they want....but I am not one of those...and I am sure there are other people that have same issues with cholesterol that I do.

    What is your HDL number? And your HDL:LDL ratio? And your LDL size? Triglycerides? How do those change when you eat more than 2-3 yolks a day? Eggs are known to raise LDL levels, but they also proportionately raise HDL numbers, and studies show (some of the articles linked here already explain this) that the LDL particles are larger than what is considered to be "harmful." They've also found that the HDL:LDL and triglyceride numbers that matter more than just LDL numbers.

    Also, the recommended cholesterol number is based on the flawed idea that dietary cholesterol affects blood cholesterol, which has been debunked.

    Here are my total numbers:

    Total = 238, HDL = 89, LDL = 134, Triglycerides = 76

    HDL/LDL ratio is 66%, Anything above 40% is GOOD.

    Total Cholesterol to HDL ratio is 2.7, BELOW 5 is good.

    And what are your numbers when you eat more than 3 eggs per day? Assuming it was just the eggs doing it, and your LDL goes up 30 points, your HDL should go up 30 points, too (negating the effect of the rise in LDL). That's my point.
  • peachyxoxoxo
    peachyxoxoxo Posts: 1,178 Member
    The real question is, is high cholesterol even causative to heart disease?

    ...(but I guess that's a discussion for another topic).

    So, what were we talking about here? Oh yeah...eggs...(and bacon).

    To briefly answer your question, cholesterol in the body becomes elevated in response to stress. Chronic stress can increase blood pressure and manifest in other ways that contribute to heart disease. Oxidized (damaged) cholesterol IS indeed one of the substances that can build up plaque in the blood vessels, but the way it becomes oxidized is again a result of free radicals and other forms of stress (low physical activity, smoking, poorly controlled blood glucose, etc). High cholesterol is merely an indictor of someone developing heart disease, but it doesn't cause it.
  • raystark
    raystark Posts: 403 Member
    Eggs are fine for you. Those old studies are crap :) I say eat as many as you want, You don't have to limit yourself to 3 a week. They are a great source of protein and keep you full. Plus the good stuff is in the yolk. GO EGGS!!

    +1. I generally eat four poached eggs for breakfast to fuel my pre-work morning trail hike. They are yummy and have a great combination of protein and fat.
  • EyeLikeTacos
    EyeLikeTacos Posts: 324 Member
    answered in pm
  • caraiselite
    caraiselite Posts: 2,631 Member
    i love eggs. perfect low carb food.
  • kiminikimkim
    kiminikimkim Posts: 746 Member
    Before the new bakery came on my block, I used to eat one egg a day for breakfast.
This discussion has been closed.